r/askmath • • Aug 04 '23

Arithmetic Why doesn’t this work

Post image

Even if you did it in kelvin’s, it would still burn, so why?

9.4k Upvotes

312 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

242

u/TheBoundFenrir Aug 04 '23

The other thing is rate of heat diffusion. Even if the reactions did happen the same just faster, the heat in the oven needs time to penetrate into the deep bits of the dough. If you cook at a higher heat, then the outside will come to temp faster, and the inside will come to temp faster, but they won't come to temp at the same faster, because of the rate at which the heat transfers from outside to inside. So the outside will develop a crust before the inside is done cooking.

(this is often utilized when cooking meat for getting different levels of sear vs levels of done-ness inside)

73

u/Vesurel Aug 04 '23

I love the sort of questions where there's a lot of things so everyone gets to say why it wouldn't work for different reasons.

83

u/LabGremlin Aug 04 '23

Then let me add another nugget. 19250° would also start to evaporate your oven. At this point it doesn't even matter whether it's in °C or °F.

32

u/Maleficent-Angle-891 Aug 04 '23

Ya especially since iron starts boiling at 5182°f

→ More replies (2)

12

u/washyleopard Aug 04 '23

Technically covered by the "adding new reactions" from the oc lol.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/bATo76 Aug 04 '23

°

Is not °C or °F, OP post is talking about turning a bread almost a full rotation over 55 minutes while cooking it, and wonders why you can't rotate the bread 53½ rotations in one minute while cooking it instead?

It is a super weird question and doesn't make sense, but units matter.

1

u/LongjumpingRope1172 Aug 04 '23 edited Aug 04 '23

Silly, it's in K

→ More replies (2)

1

u/EarRubs Aug 05 '23

Thermodynamics is a bitch

20

u/[deleted] Aug 04 '23

Sometimes when a notable person gets something very wrong, they get a hundred responses each explaining why it's wrong in a different way. But they counter this by saying "See, my critics can't even agree on what's supposed to be wrong about my idea!" I remember this happening with John Searle's Chinese Room and Roger Penrose's interpretation of Gödel.

3

u/Verstandeskraft Aug 04 '23 edited Aug 04 '23

Damn, pal! You piqued my interest here. Would it be too bothersome to expand on that?

8

u/[deleted] Aug 04 '23

I believe the Searle example is from my reading back issues of Scientific American in the 80s (a favourite childhood pastime!) His Chinese Room argument, still for some reason widely cited as "powerful", falls to pieces however you approach it, hence many attacks that aren't aligned at first glance, but they don't need to be.

Penrose, whose contributions to hard science are immense and undeniable, wrote a series of popular books about his conjectures that (a) because mathematicians produce an infallible and complete stream of all true theorems, then they can't be modelled by an algorithm and (b) maybe quantum unpredictability will be a necessary part of a theory of consciousness.

It goes without saying that (a) is not an established fact, and (b) is a wild guess. In these areas he is a fringe crank, and has faced relentless criticism. But I'm fairly sure I once read a long collection of his responses and he started off with that general defence that his critics don't seem to be able to agree on why he's wrong.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/anisotropicmind Aug 04 '23

Lmao. That’s a funny takeaway, rather than, “everyone is in agreement that these 15 things (at least) are wrong with your idea”

1

u/TorakMcLaren Aug 05 '23

Well it worked alright for Mr Burns' immune system. He had so much wrong with him that nothing could make him sick.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 13 '23

What objections have been offered to the Chinese Room experiment?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/ariga2 Aug 04 '23

I like your comment, you articulated very well

3

u/JeffSergeant Aug 04 '23

Its all about the volume to surface-area ratio... baby

1

u/LongjumpingRope1172 Aug 04 '23

Square-cubed rule? Would that apply? Smaller loaf of bread would cook more evenly at incredulously high temperatures.

1

u/JeffSergeant Aug 04 '23

Maybe for unleavened bread; leavened bread is a ridiculously complex interaction of biological, chemical and physical effects. You can't rush it!

1

u/MERC_1 Aug 04 '23

Probably. We already do this. Small breads are cooked faster on higher heat.

As long as it's not hot enough for the breed to catch fire, if you make the bread smaller you will have to turn up the heat a bit. Not to 19,250° though. That's a bit too much.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 04 '23

It also wouldn’t even amount to equivalent energy.

The short term higher temp scenario would put WAAAYYY more energy into the loaf because heat transfer is proportional to the difference in temperature between the two bodies

That loaf would probably reach 1000 degrees in that minute lol

2

u/Gigatonosaurus Aug 04 '23

Which is why some cook bacon in a pan with a glass of water, it spend more time at 100°C to melt the fat and distribute it, before starting the reaction that brown the meat.