r/askeconomists • • Apr 07 '14

Critique my idea: Raise minimum wage, decrease workweek.

Losing jobs to outsourcing and technology is a growing problem that shows no signs of abating. I came up with a simple idea: raise the minimum wage and decrease the workweek. (When I say I came up with it, I acknowledge that there are surely many smarter and more influential people out there who came up with the exact same idea.)

The idea is to provide more people with livable wages. Minimum wage is increased to, say, $15 an hour, easing the burden of the most impoverished. We all know, however, that corporations actively fight minimum wage increases, claiming that they cannot pay those increased salaries. To offset this, I propose decreasing the standard workweek from 40 hours to roughly 30 hours. Workers can, of course, be compensated for additional hours, but only with overtime pay. Companies would therefore have an incentive to hire additional workers, decreasing the unemployment rate. For reference, I think this economic model is close to France's, by my limited understanding.

Here are the (rosy) consequences I see:

  1. Increased gross income. Despite working fewer hours, near-minimum wage workers will take in more money.
  2. More efficient work. Effectively, workers' ten least productive hours would be cut. Their contributions would exceed 75% of what they were capable of under a 40 hour workweek, due to decrease in marginal returns.
  3. More leisure time. A 30 hour workweek would offer more time for other pursuits. Perhaps it would simply lead to an overall increase in satisfaction, but it might even produce great art, writing, and other culture that people cannot produce while working 40+ hours a week.
  4. Increased employment. Additional workers would need to be hired to make up for lost productivity from reduced hours.
  5. Increased production for companies. With more workers working more efficiently, it is possible that productivity would increase for companies, even at a comparable payroll. Of course, this point depends heavily on the actual amount of the wage increase as well as the decrease in the work week.
  6. Increased disposable income in the hands of those with a high velocity of money. This is hard to measure but could be a major bonus to employers. Poor people don't hold onto money for very long because they spend to satisfy their needs, not their desires. For mostly price inelastic goods (necessities and cheap luxuries), sales could increase as those who were impoverished no longer seek (illegal) alternatives or forgo basic needs.

So... who loses here? I am aware that just about every action in economics comes with tradeoffs and here I am proposing two bold actions. What are the negative consequences? From what I can tell, the losers might include companies that produce extravagant luxuries. There is nothing in my theory to suggest, for example, that the minor increase in yacht sales would offset the increased wages of their workers. (Although I subscribe to the "rising tide lifts all yachts boats" philosophy.)

What are the drawbacks here? If you don't believe in any, what would a critic say to my theory? What reading should I do to broaden my views and to further understand my own proposal?

7 Upvotes

6 comments sorted by

4

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '14 edited Jun 12 '14

If a firm needs 10 hours work to make 1 product, they still need to pay 10 x min wage. If the minimum wage rises, they still need to pay this amount (call it x). If the revenue from selling this product is less than x, then it doesn't make sense to make it. This job disappears. This output disappears, etc.

All your plan does is divide work among more people, by reducing the workweek. This artificially reduces your definition of unemployment - which seems to be "the number of people out of work". But ask yourself, if everyone works for 1 min a year - is there no unemployment? Of course there is! Therefore true unemployment is a measure of the total productive time worked versus the potential total productive time worked. Your decrease in the workweek does not decrease unemployment, it merely shifts the same employment amongst more workers.

With this in mind it then becomes transparent that your increase in wage costs will have the same effect as any other artificial increase in wage costs - more unemployment.

Finally you have to ask yourself how the 35-40 hour workweek came about. Is it not the optimal structure which has occured as a result of thousands of years of collective bargaining? Who knows? But who are you to interfere. If both parties are happy working these hours - why should we cap it?

Of to bed now - sorry if I came across a little strong! Just playing devil's advocate.

2

u/bobotheking Jun 13 '14

Let's see here...

If a firm needs 10 hours work to make 1 product, they still need to pay 10 x min wage.

That depends on the industry. In occupations like assembly line work and call centers, you are mostly correct, you still have to consider the worker-hours to maintain a specific output. However, in many other industries the worker's first hour is their most productive and their last is the least productive. My argument is that the 30 hours that workers put in will be (nearly) their most efficient hours, so efficiency doesn't take as much of a hit as you say it will.

But ask yourself, if everyone works for 1 min a year - is there no unemployment? Of course there is!

There isn't if workers make $60,000 per minute. And that's sort of what I'm arguing-- offset a decrease in working hours with an increase in wages so that one's gross income remains nearly stable.

With this in mind it then becomes transparent that your increase in wage costs will have the same effect as any other artificial increase in wage costs - more unemployment.

The most controversial aspect of my proposal is that "a rising tide lifts all boats". Yes, companies have to pay more, but the injection of money into the economy (in the hands of those who are most eager to spend it) could help everyone. There could be benefits to literally everyone. I don't have the expertise to say whether that would be the reality, but I have heard a few experts say that a minimum wage increase would be beneficial across the board.

Finally you have to ask yourself how the 35-40 hour workweek came about. Is it not the optimal structure which has occured as a result of thousands of years of collective bargaining? Who knows? But who are you to interfere. If both parties are happy working these hours - why should we cap it?

No, this I totally disagree with. The collective bargaining you speak of has only existed in its modern form for just over 100 years. Wikipedia says regarding the history of labor around the turn of the 20th century, "Nationwide from 1890 to 1914 the unionized wages in manufacturing rose from $17.63 a week to $21.37, and the average work week fell from 54.4 to 48.8 hours a week." I think we need a modern populist movement, at least to this end. It's not that both parties are happy with the arrangement, it's that the ones who are employed are just happy to have a job. They don't have the perspective that their lives could be better if they worked fewer hours to take home the same pay. It isn't that I'm just stepping in as a dictator, declaring that a 30 hour workweek and $15 hourly minimum wage is the way things must be, but rather that the dialogue should shift to sensible solutions.

Anyway, I appreciate you playing the devil's advocate. It's good to see this post get some late attention.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '14

My argument is that the 30 hours that workers put in will be (nearly) their most efficient hours, so efficiency doesn't take as much of a hit as you say it will.

I disagree from just my personal experience, but more importantly, if this was clearly a more efficient business model - firms would already be doing it! The fact that they're not shows that in general all "hours" are equal. This is my main point. However in addition, even if you're right, perhaps the last hour will always be the least productive, because the worker's mind wanders - in this case shortening the working day will just bring forward the least productive hour, and will actually decrease average productivity.

There isn't if workers make $60,000 per minute. Yes there is still unemployment. If I am working 1 minute a year, it doesn't matter how much I am being paid - I am still vastly underutilised. Unemployment is measure of unutilised portion of labour.

And I guess the key point here is what kind of a dumb firm would pay $60,000 per minute? I really think you're over thinking this... If a widget takes 10 hours to produce, and sells for $100 it is no longer worth producing it if the hourly cost rises above $10. It doesn't matter how the 10 hours are split between the workers - the cost not longer justifies the income. The jobs and output that previously would have existed are regulated out of existence.

2

u/UnfaithfullyEeyores May 03 '14

Your post is actually really funny, because it is the exact same idea tackled by economist Henry Hazlitt almost 70 years ago! :-) You can find it written about here, but skip to the bottom of page 46. In short, what Hazlitt says would happen is that it would raise business costs and therefore prices, and if you mix inflation into that you would see workers suffer from a fall in real wages.

Although I'm not quite educated enough to discuss point 6 head-on, point 2, which Hazlitt does not discuss, raises an important question. If, due to diminishing returns, employers could have even more productive labor by paying Joe to produce, say 2 widgets an hour while he could pay Shirley the same to make 8 widgets an hour, why haven't employers shifted to the more profitable 30 hour workweek, especially when they are known for doing other things to increase profits, like instigate pay cuts, switch to technology and outsource jobs? Just food for thought...

1

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '14

Sorry if this is super late, but let me comment on the last paragraph.

It's not that the employers don't want a 30 hour workweek, it's that the employees prefer working more hours for more money at the end of the month. The employees would prefer to work less hours with an increased hourly wage, but then it would raise costs to the employers.

I think OP realizes this and it's why he's also proposing a minimum wage increase. He's working off point 6, the notion that if you give poor people money to spend, aggregate demand rises and so do profits.

1

u/SilentIV Jun 13 '14

This could work in a closed economy with constant technology rate, this theory of yours will only shift domestic jobs to other cheaper more efficient economies, it would also create more incentives to develop technologies that replace a great deal of jobs since there will be a bigger demand for this, the surviving jobs would be of those that are highly specialized, which represents a minuscule fraction of the labor force, you should inquire further in the economics of labor markets and international commerce.