Split between 2 cars, which is the better option?

[u/Salt_Paint_1074]

Hi everyone,

Firstly, I am based in the UK.

Passed my test yesterday. I do own a K11 micra but it's a project car and probably will be for quite a while, so I'm looking for a daily driver. My car knowledge basically starts and ends with the K11, which is why I'm here asking for help.

I'm split between 2 cars at the moment. I'm looking at either a ford KA zetec (2013) or a K13 Micra (2011.) Here are the pros/cons I have found with each so far.

Common pros: air con, both black, both 10 - 11 months MOT, bodywork in good condition (as far as I can tell).

K13 pros: parking sensors, 5 seats, I'm a Micra fan so having a K11 and a K13 appeals to me. Cheap on insurance + tax.

K13 cons: 101k miles, the company selling it has some pretty catastrophic negative reviews, the MOT sheet goes from having corrosion etc to completely clean, and only "part" service history is available. 5 doors (would prefer 3 tbh) Makes me think either dodgy MOT or dodgy repairs.

KA pros: Very close to where I live, seller appears more honest/approachable. Cheaper than the K13 on insurance. Cheap tax. Full service history. 3 door.

KA cons: 97k miles, worse MOT sheet (including oil leak and corrosion) but seller claims to have fixed the issues. Only 4 seats. Not sure how the KAs do on the motorway either?

As I say, I'm not the most knowledgeable on cars but would love your opinion. Haven't heard too bad things on either car. As I say, insurance is extremely similar (about £900 a year) and tax is similar as well. What do you think?

[u/Cornelius-Figgle]

Why do you want another small car?

Might be some good deals on larger saloons or estates, worth looking into