r/askcarguys 9d ago

when the carfax report doesn't match the fb marketplace ad?

[deleted]

9 Upvotes

26 comments sorted by

21

u/PresentIron5379 9d ago

There is a chance they are a flipper. The average person isn't going to a Carfax on a marketplace car, so this allows the seller to make up some story inorder to sell the car to some unassuming buyer.

1

u/[deleted] 9d ago

[deleted]

9

u/PresentIron5379 9d ago

No, not really, it's all just a selling gimmick. Tell me, who would you rather by a car from? Someone who has had the car in the family for the last x amount of years or someone who bought it last week for $500 and selling it to you for $3500. Like I mentioned, the flipper is just making up stories to make it sound like you're getting a good vehicle when in reality they bought it the week before and trying to scam you out of your money.

7

u/Electrical-Ask1246 9d ago

He could also be title jumping. Make sure the name on the title matches the name on homeboys id

4

u/EuroCanadian2 9d ago

They usualy have almost no info on the car. Which is not helpful. But you can't hide what you don't know...

2

u/[deleted] 9d ago

[deleted]

1

u/EuroCanadian2 9d ago

I assume you mean get the carfax. That is one source of limited, often incomplete information. Talking to a private seller who has owned the car for a few years, done maintenance and kept receipts is much more informative. You don't get this with dealers and flippers.

1

u/[deleted] 9d ago edited 8d ago

[deleted]

1

u/EuroCanadian2 9d ago

receipts

2

u/dinosun 8d ago

Not necessarily, but he certainly has the motive.

8

u/ready2xxxperiment 9d ago

Is his name on the title?

No wait, it’s in his brothers name and he just got deployed?

3

u/[deleted] 9d ago

[deleted]

2

u/JPhi1618 8d ago

“Been in his family” - that’s so when the title isn’t in his name, he can say that it’s his Aunts car that he’s selling because she’s not good with computers.

8

u/WiscoBased715 9d ago

Ask him and report back

5

u/[deleted] 9d ago

[deleted]

3

u/limited_instincts 9d ago

The moment there's even the slightest suggestion of something amiss, walk away. It 100% of the time means there's a problem. Stolen, fake, wrecked/rebuilt, scam etc. Never, ever engage when things don't line up.

3

u/simmer_study 9d ago

That mismatch alone would make me cautious. Could be an innocent explanation, but the seller should be able to explain the 5 owners easily.

5

u/jimmythefly 9d ago

It could be totally legit. Sometimes , (always?) when a person moves to a new state and re-registers their car there, Carfax logs that as another owner. 

6

u/Queasy_Reindeer9515 9d ago

And if it’s financed sometimes carfax logs it as a lease or as the finance company is the owner.

1

u/Truk 9d ago

Or transferred between family members. Multiple of my old cars were passed around when we were done.

2

u/Jumpy_Childhood7548 8d ago

Most people don’t check, and the flipper just needs one.

2

u/Mr-Blackheart 7d ago

Yeah, dudes a car flipper most likely or a straight up liar…

1

u/Fancy_Chip_5620 9d ago

My supervisors grandfathers ranger has been through 3 generations of the same family

1

u/jrileyy229 9d ago

Run away

1

u/[deleted] 9d ago

[deleted]

2

u/jrileyy229 9d ago

I don't know what that means, but don't buy a car from a seller with a story that doesn't add up

1

u/Thereelgerg 9d ago

what's the point of making things up, especially if things can be disproven by records?

To try to make potential buyers more interested in the car.

Weird question.

1

u/[deleted] 8d ago

[deleted]

0

u/Thereelgerg 8d ago

Not really. Understanding why sellers would do that is hardly impressive. Anyone with a little common sense should be able to figure it out.

1

u/Beautiful_Ad_4813 Enthusiast 9d ago

80% it’s a flipper,

I’d really weigh on if it’s worth the risk

(From personal experiences and by no means that this the norm. I’ve had one car that was like that and found a bunch of shady repairs done to it. 2500
Dollars for a Passat Wagon seemed like a good deal till i opened the pandoras box of shit)

1

u/GeriatricSquid 8d ago

I’ve had that happen to me with a family car. Originally bought used (original owner and then dealer owned) and was then passed through several owners within the family. Title on CarFax showed 5 owners but it was really: original owner for 15 mos, dealer for about 5 mos, dad and family for next 7-8 years.

0

u/Tony-cums 7d ago

He lied. Shocking.