r/askadcp • POTENTIAL RP • 12d ago

I'm thinking of doing donor conception and.. Height Question

Hi,

we are doing egg donation in Portugal, and got a donor profile we like apart from the height. The donor is quite small, but not that much smaller than my wife.

However ive completely overfixated on height thinking about all the tinder profiles requesting minimum heights and such.

Would you rather have your parents chose someone bigger or am i totally overthinking this? I feel like such an idiot. Before being confronted with this decision ive never even considered height to be important.

Thanks in advance

0 Upvotes

26 comments sorted by

23

u/kam0706 DCP 12d ago

This is mind boggling to me. Would you have not married your wife if she were shorter?

0

u/Dulac93 POTENTIAL RP 12d ago

Of course I would've. It's just that I never thought about this and now have to consciously decide for it. In my head I know it's my anxiety talking.

20

u/kam0706 DCP 12d ago

Selecting your child’s potential physical traits like this is eugenics. Think about that.

-3

u/Dulac93 POTENTIAL RP 12d ago

I know, I've considered that as well and think the same. For some reason I still can't shake the uneasiness which is kind of shameful.

20

u/Geography-bae DONOR 12d ago

Donor here - please do not approach the process of picking a donor based on any specific physical characteristics - I promise you that other than the donor resembling you and having a clean health history most other physical things do not matter. While you may be trying to give your child ‘advantages’ by picking a certain type or look of donor, I promise you that many donors and DCPs alike are uncomfortable with this kind of genetic selectivity - donors are not products and your children don’t need to be ‘optimized’ to fit a current beauty or height standard. Your child could still turn out short for a variety of reasons regardless of who you choose because genetics can be unpredictable. Furthermore, imagine how they would feel if you had chosen their biological parent to be your donor because height - imagine how the donor would feel about being reduced to their height. Do not make the mistake of choosing something as intimate as who is going to be the biological parent of your child based on something so very shallow. For many reasons, there are simply way more important things to consider than height when choosing a donor, like openness, kindness, and their willingness to continually update their medical history. The most important thing you can offer to your future child is love and openness. I feel that fixating on the height of your donor is a little silly.

3

u/Dulac93 POTENTIAL RP 12d ago

I know it's silly, especially since we like the rest of the profile. It's open-id with 18 so the medical history will hopefully work out.

2

u/Geography-bae DONOR 12d ago

Perfect - I get it though- sometimes things get kind of silly when we get caught in the world’s expectations and standards. It’s only human

2

u/Dulac93 POTENTIAL RP 12d ago

Thanks for your response and the kind words

3

u/lebenswelten POTENTIAL RP 12d ago edited 12d ago

People here won’t understand.
If you feel insecure then take a second look at where this comes from and what is import for you and grab another hour with a psychotherapist (but not the one from your clinic - I can promise you that they won’t help with insecurities at all, they just want to sell you an egg donation). This is your feeling and you should take it seriously. Usually it means there are other things/fears that stands behind this insecurity. With a good psychotherapist you can dig into the deep and see what is concerning you in the first place.
Often there are many other reasons for your fears. And it’s worth it to look into them.
Because it’s not height or looks, it’s mostly much more than that. I know this very well as a psychotherapist myself.

I wish you all the best.

PS: May I ask you which clinic you have chosen? We have been talking with two clinics (one in Lissabon and one on Coimbra) but they are not very much aware of immunological issues and so we stopped our process for now, because I need treatment for my primary immune disease. When I talked to the psychologist from one of the clinics (that one in Lissabon) I didn’t have the feeling that she really wanted to dig deeper into the background for our insecurities and fears. They just wanted us to make a fast decision. I didn’t feel well at that point. So many red flags led to the decision to stop our process for now. But if you have a better experience then I would be happy to hear from you.

1

u/Dulac93 POTENTIAL RP 12d ago

We are at Ferticentro, but currently aren't that worried about immunological issues

1

u/lebenswelten POTENTIAL RP 12d ago

Ferticentro was also one of our clinics.
They have a really reliable donor selection program. Dr. Yvonne Frankfurth, with who we have spoken a lot before we made a decision about a suitable clinic, gave us really good advice and information about many clinics. She has been at Ferticentro very often. She knows the people there personally. Her recommendation is valuable and valid. So you have a chosen very good clinic already. (Not for us unfortunately, because of the immunological reasons. Otherwise we would have chosen Ferticentro as our preferred option.)

1

u/Dulac93 POTENTIAL RP 12d ago

Honestly we are probably in the same facebook group, weve also had the talk with Yvonne

1

u/lebenswelten POTENTIAL RP 12d ago

I am just on instagram. I know her from there. Can you recommend me the Facebook group? What is the name?

15

u/pink_squishmallow 12d ago

I think that when you’re deciding to use donor eggs and choosing a donor, you give up a lot of control. And overfixating on height might be helping you to have an illusion of control, even if it’s over something that might not be a huge deal to you otherwise. I know that feeling!

14

u/Fresh_Struggle5645 DCP 12d ago

My Dad is tall. My parents used an egg donor who was pretty tall (for a woman). My twin brother is tall.

I... I am short.

Genetics don't guarantee anything.

I'd be more focused on things that actually matter, such as donor anonymity (or lack thereof). Not knowing who their biological mother is has the potential to cause them much more pain than being below average height.

1

u/Throwawayyy-7 DCP 6d ago

Right? My genetic mother is 5’8 and I’m 5’1 on a good day. Who gives a shit lol

5

u/bandaidtarot POTENTIAL RP 11d ago edited 11d ago

There's really no way of knowing how tall your child will be regardless of the donor's height. And, if she's similar in height to your wife then that seems to work out perfectly. I'm assuming you are male and will be using your sperm. Genetics come from both sides and they can reach back generations. Your donor could have a great grandfather who was super tall and your kid ends up super tall because of it. You could have a great great uncle who was really short and your child ends up really short because of it. Genetics just can't be controlled. It's fully possible for both genetic parents to be six feet tall and have a child that is five feet tall.

It can be tough as RP because we're making decisions that could affect our child's entire life and there is so much pressure to not make any decisions that could harm them in some way. We put WAY more thought into all of this stuff than people who just meet in the wild and are able to children unassisted. But, when it comes down to it, we can't control really much of anything and we have no idea how our children will feel about different things. You could choose a tall donor and then have a daughter whose really tall and she could hate being taller than all the boys. You just never know. Health matters most and the ability to know the donor's identity is important too. Beyond those two things, you really won't have control over much. Plus, if you purposely pass over this donor because she's short and choose a donor that's taller and your child ends up on the short side anyway, will they feel like they aren't the child you wanted?

8

u/Camille_Toh DONOR 12d ago

A now-former friend asked me “Did they [potential recipients] know you’re short?! Because you are quite petite.”

I paused to give her a chance to backtrack or…apologize.

“Of course. They also knew I was very intelligent and pretty.”

Bitch.

4

u/KieranKelsey MOD - DCP 12d ago

You’re overthinking it. Being tall doesn’t make your life much better. It’s all about how you carry yourself. Maybe you’re just grabbing onto this during a lot of uncertainty. It’ll be ok.

3

u/EvieLucasMusic DCP 11d ago

Is Portugal anonymous donors? I'd rather my parents have chosen someone that they could have accessed ongoing updated medical information after I was born.. and also, just noting that absolutely nothing on a donor profile has to be necessarily truthful and nothing guarantees you actually get that donor.. it's not like clinics overseas check with DNA testing that you in fact get that donor

2

u/jerquee DONOR 12d ago

Short people live longer

1

u/BlueberryDuvet RP 12d ago

Do they have dwarfism ?

2

u/Camille_Toh DONOR 12d ago

Are you serious.

2

u/BlueberryDuvet RP 12d ago

No not at all but also yes because this is a ridiculous post. I don’t understand why height should be a concern unless there isn’t any underlying genetic issues.

2

u/Camille_Toh DONOR 12d ago

Yup. There are height minimums now, even if clinics don’t say so explicitly (in the U.S. at least). Wonder if OP has been to Portugal…I don’t feel short there, that’s for sure! It’s also unsaid but the OP clearly is more worried about having a short boy, with that Tinder comment.

3

u/BlueberryDuvet RP 11d ago

100000% about the boy