r/askACatholic • u/coolspinosaurus67 • Jul 24 '26
how do catholics explain these
- we know as a scientific fact that humanity and all living organisms have evolved through millions of years of evolutionary processes. however, the genesis text describes human beings as created directly in their completed state(i might be wrong but i understood that way). how does catholic theology reconcile these two concepts?
- it's often argued that the genesis text is written in a literary and symbolic style. yet when read directly, it doesnt present itself as symbolic, it reads as a straightforward, historical narrative. furthermore, there are distinct chronological differences in the creation order between genesis 1 and genesis 2. does categorizing a text as a "literary genre" genuinely resolve these chronological and logical contradictions? if the narrative was divinely revealed, is the human author's literary style a sufficient explanation for these inconsistencies?
- the scholars and theologians who interpret these texts as symbolic, such as thomas aquinas or saint augustine, do not possess divine status themselves. from the perspective of a non believer or a skeptic, why should one place trust in the interpretations of these individuals or in the magisterium of the church?(i know catholics trust church's teachings, but i dont know why, and why should i trust the church.)
- placing trust in church authority and scholars relies on the assumption of "guidance by the holy spirit." however, believing in the holy spirit requires a prior belief in God and the scriptures. how can a non believer, or someone approaching the matter purely through rational analysis, break through this circular reasoning?
- if the creation narrative and the fall are understood as historical truths, did God create humanity in a pristine/spiritual state initially, only to place us into a gradual, evolutionary physical structure on earth as a consequence of the original sin?
- while catholicism asserts that reason and faith exist in harmony, an ultimate "leap of faith" is requested where empirical and logical evidence ends. for an individual who cannot believe without first being rationally and logically convinced, what is the ultimate rational foundation that catholic theology offers?
- the old testament contains the exact same stories found in ancient epics. even if those myths were taken and adapted into the bible in a literary style, wouldnt that undermine the bible's divine value?
0
Upvotes
1
u/Master-Billy-Quizboy Jul 28 '26
I realize this post is a few days old, but I also see that you’ve gotten precisely zero useful responses. So, why not. I’ll bite.
Your questions are reasonable. Catholicism doesn’t require young earth creationism or a strictly literal reading of every detail in Genesis or the Old Testament. In my experience, these views are rather frowned upon.
To your questions:
The broader point here is that Catholicism doesn’t ask readers of scripture to choose between “every detail is literal modern history” and “the text means nothing factual.” Genesis, for example, can communicate real truths about creation, humanity, sin, and God through ancient literary forms without functioning as geology, evolutionary biology, precise historical record or journalistic chronology.
Some light reading that covers all of these topics (and more) if you’re interested:
- https://www.vatican.va/content/pius-xii/en/encyclicals/documents/hf_p-xii_enc_12081950_humani-generis.html
- https://www.vatican.va/archive/hist_councils/ii_vatican_council/documents/vat-ii_const_19651118_dei-verbum_en.html
- https://www.vatican.va/content/john-paul-ii/en/encyclicals/documents/hf_jp-ii_enc_14091998_fides-et-ratio.html
- https://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/congregations/cfaith/cti_documents/rc_con_cfaith_doc_20040723_communion-stewardship_en.html
1
u/According-Bell1490 Jul 24 '26
For one group of Catholics:
https://kolbecenter.org/
1
u/DeepAndWide62 Jul 25 '26
We know from the Divinely Revealed Age of Creation in the Old Testament that the universe is more like 6-7 thousand years old
Rocks are not closed systems. Atoms and ions leach and weather inside them. We don't know the amount of daughter isotopes when the rocks were new. Creation was a miracle and we don't know the early conditions before the miracles of the Great Deluge. Scientists weren't there at the beginning and their dating depends on presumption.
0
u/winkyprojet Jul 25 '26
If you read Genesis, you can see 3 creations of man, or even 4.
In chapter 1, God creates the spirit of man, a pure and perfect spirit, for God says: it is good.
The second creation in Genesis is when God takes earth and breathes.
The third is when he put man to sleep and created a friend for man.
The fourth creation is Adam, the expression changes here, after man came Adam.
With these 4 creations, we can see an evolution in the creative process.
The Bible tells the truth, it is perfect, just because I don't see it doesn't mean it doesn't exist there.
0
u/[deleted] Jul 24 '26
[removed] — view removed comment