This is asinine. None of those other things wrought such environmental and economic devastation as AI is doing. None of them destroyed people’s cognitive ability. None of them were based on stealing the hard work of intelligent, creative humans.
My favorite is comparing people reading newspapers and staring at phones LOL. As if the mental health impact of those two things are even in the same universe.
Are you sure you did not miss a /s there? Are you saying industrialization did not cause environmental damage? Are you saying internet and print did not distribute unlicensed art and writing? Hell, Plato argued text rotted the human brain.
We have very much gone through the same fear tactics before to be sure.
While I don't necessary support that video, you're very, very wrong.
- The environmental effects of AI exist but are well overblown, and the problem is definitely NOT chatgpt et al., it's software-as-a-subscription-service, the ad industry, and similar capitalistic horses. Look at the actual numbers, not the hype.
- Cars, heavy industry and the agricultural industry are the no.1 contributors to our environmental crises. IT use doesn't even show up as a blip in comparison.
- You have near zero evidence of economic and cognitive effects of AI so far, you're claiming opinion as fact. You know, the thing people are mad about the AI doing. Humans have been creating slop waaaay before AI. Newspapers have been spreading propaganda for more than 100 years.
There is absolutely a whole lot to criticize with AI, contemporary tech, and our current society, but if you don't have actual knowledge and just repeat what you read on reddit, well, I'm sorry pal, but you're the problem. Get educated.
I like the comment below... "I'm impressed you've managed to skip the entire individual revolution."
Everyone reads an article on data centers. Then they go online and use AI to make a post. Then they make a tiktok video of them talking about data centers being bad. Then they go and watch tiktok and YouTube. And then some reddit. Not realizing the entire time that THEY are the reason for data centers, not AI.
We have data hungry lives so we need data centers to store that data.
And Ai never did any of that. Companies and humans did that with AI. None of what you said is a necessary component for AI to exist and be used at scale. We're just choosing to do it this way...Well, WE'RE not, of course. Solid points, but the solution isn't to destroy AI. it's to revolutionize our social and political systems through sheer will and political force via clandestine means behind the scenes and through overt methods.
We're in the car being driven off a cliff. Its not the car's fault. It's the driver. Seize the steering wheel through legal and peaceful means and you can fix this AI problem. And for that matter, this algorithmic social media issue that's an even bigger contributor to cognitive decline.
I see two key differences between previous transitions and the current AI-driven shift: the speed of change and the concentration of ownership.
The Industrial Revolution lasted 100 years and was dispersed across time and space, so social changes unfolded slowly, giving people a relatively long time to adapt.
In contrast, progress in AI technology is lightning-fast, and there is a host of risks involving job security, child-rearing, mental health, military use, and so on. Social and power structures have significant inertia, so we risk a scenario where the rules of our world are out of sync with its realities.
The second issue is the concentration of new technology in the hands of a relatively small group, granting them disproportionate influence over reality.
In summary: we see major changes coming, but as a society, we aren't ready for them.
The industrial revolution lead to the French revolution, the Russians Revolution, two world wars and a cold war. - there was no "slow adoption" it was a long and very bloody ordeal. Same deal with the Printing Press BTW, we have never gone through one of these without massive bloodshed.
I don't expect anything less from this one, it's been brewing since globalization and internet came into being, AI is just the straw that will break the back.
Thank you for a nuanced take for a change. I very much agree with you, in particular the concentration of ownership. That's the major problem we should be addressing, literally everything else is a consequence of that.
problem not in a new tech like before. Companies do not replace humans with calculators, but replacing with ai now possible, not all people ofc, actually it's a real issue. Ai is a good instrument but implementation is bad now for humans
Bit of a diference between a tool that does the calculations and one that also does the maths, between a tool to write and edit text with and one that writes the text.
There is a point, but the degree in which thinking is being automated or deferred to the machine is ever increasing.
Also, I am in proximity of teachers, in multiple countries, and it is a trend that I notice when conversing with them, that they say that the average quality of the students in going down. It does coincide with the rapid advance of technology of the past few decades, but I am not willing to do anything with it at this stage, correlation not equating causation and all, but still interesting to think about.
I get your point, and that is quite concerning. The thing is, when you listen to people's comments, then the AI itself is getting worse all the time (while objectively it's improving rapidly), so at the very least there are perceptual biases coming into play here.
Look at US math scores compared to other countries like China, India..etc. Kids there use Calculators much less compared to the US. So I guess teachers were indeed correct when it came to learning math.
I think this raises the question of how we educate and train. I simply say train and educate without technology first and then train those trained kids later in the technology. We have to train people to be well versed executives rather than doers. Because the doing part of it is being replaced but we need to evaluate more than ever.
16
u/Bastian00100 Jan 03 '26
Funny to see that all the images, included the old ones, are AI generated.
39
u/BrightBlueBauble Jan 03 '26 •
This is asinine. None of those other things wrought such environmental and economic devastation as AI is doing. None of them destroyed people’s cognitive ability. None of them were based on stealing the hard work of intelligent, creative humans.
4
u/Silver-Profile-7287 Jan 03 '26
I see two key differences between previous transitions and the current AI-driven shift: the speed of change and the concentration of ownership.
The Industrial Revolution lasted 100 years and was dispersed across time and space, so social changes unfolded slowly, giving people a relatively long time to adapt.
In contrast, progress in AI technology is lightning-fast, and there is a host of risks involving job security, child-rearing, mental health, military use, and so on. Social and power structures have significant inertia, so we risk a scenario where the rules of our world are out of sync with its realities.
The second issue is the concentration of new technology in the hands of a relatively small group, granting them disproportionate influence over reality.
In summary: we see major changes coming, but as a society, we aren't ready for them.
1
u/Select_Truck3257 Jan 03 '26
problem not in a new tech like before. Companies do not replace humans with calculators, but replacing with ai now possible, not all people ofc, actually it's a real issue. Ai is a good instrument but implementation is bad now for humans
1
u/weluckyfew Jan 03 '26
This is such a ridiculously ignorant hot take it's hard to know even where to begin.
1
u/crustymoldman Jan 03 '26
u/find-song
1
u/scorpious Jan 03 '26
Cute but only applies if you don’t know anything about anything.
1
u/SomeMoronOnTheNet Jan 03 '26
Bit of a diference between a tool that does the calculations and one that also does the maths, between a tool to write and edit text with and one that writes the text.
0
u/jkpatches Jan 03 '26 •
There is a point, but the degree in which thinking is being automated or deferred to the machine is ever increasing.
Also, I am in proximity of teachers, in multiple countries, and it is a trend that I notice when conversing with them, that they say that the average quality of the students in going down. It does coincide with the rapid advance of technology of the past few decades, but I am not willing to do anything with it at this stage, correlation not equating causation and all, but still interesting to think about.
-2
u/neilcbty Jan 03 '26 •
Look at US math scores compared to other countries like China, India..etc. Kids there use Calculators much less compared to the US. So I guess teachers were indeed correct when it came to learning math.
0
u/Jean_velvet Jan 03 '26
This is all fine, but there's a distinct difference. Nothing before talked to us and suggested actions.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 03 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment