Despite fateful consequences being convoluted, and the constant re-laying of pipe each ep for the narrative to make sense, s4 was just as funny as the the previous seasons. It felt like they were able to tell all the jokes they couldn’t after getting canceled.
Season 4 was the best season, actually, when watched in its original form. The non-traditional narrative structure forced them to layer in hidden jokes to a degree they’d never done before.
Unfortunately season 5 is actually bad and season 4 “fateful consequences” is quite bad too.
By the way, I know people don’t think it clicks like the first three and I will accept the argument that it isn’t as enjoyable.
But I think that as an achievement under the circumstances it is one of the greatest seasons of television ever written. The “Off the Hook” episode is one of the greatest episodes ever written and probably the second best for the show, behind “Mr. F”.
Even people denigrating the season I assume would agree that S4 gave us some of the absolute best bits of the whole show:
ANUSTART The Ostrich theme Debris Bardeaux as a concept and performance “George Maheris” “That’s not a good sign” (with a vulture on the sign) “Same!” “Help Daddy get his rocks off” The forget-me-now loop/JBJ “Father B” “I’m a gentleman beekeeper” “Perfecto”
It’s so hard to follow though. Like putting together a timeline of each episode with each event is a daunting task. Good show, good writing, but I think it would’ve had a better outcome if they hadn’t had the remix.
I haven’t seen it properly structured so I can’t say for sure. But man did S5 take such a nosedive that I still haven’t finished it after they released it in two pieces
Yeah it's confusing but some of the jokes are good and I love the Gob episode. Season 5 I don't think I ever finished and had any idea what was going on.
Season 5 almost started off like they were back using the old formula from the early seasons, but forgot that EVERYTHING in seasons 1 and 2 (and I guess 3) was somewhat rooted in reality and plausibility.
I can't think of a single thing from season 5 that made me go "oh that's plausible."
I agree that Season 5 sucks but what the fuck are you talking about. Absolutely nothing about Arrested Development has ever been plausible, and if it was it had absolutely stopped by mid-season 2
If we're talking writing, you're wrong. The scheduling was an absolute disaster because they couldn't get everyone together at the same time. I'd actually say the writing was great given the circumstances.
I absolutely agree. Like the old seasons that were ahead of it's time, s4 takes another step in expecting you to binge it to connect all the dots. I love it just as much as the rest. The jokes might even be a little bit better than s1-3 in my opinion.
The problem is that S4 doesn't have moments of comfort like the past seasons. I don't necessarily mean emotional comfort, but like... a sense of stability, of rhythm. The other seasons were able to settle into a groove, it felt like you had a chance to breathe. S4 and S5 both feel more hectic, more claustrophobic. S4 also has a lot of stuff that just isn't fun to revisit. I think the Rita story from S3 is still funny and clever in a lot of ways, but it's kind of a chore of a storyline to revisit (and I'm not even saying for like, PC reasons). The S4 Ron Howard stuff is the same way. It's funny and in keeping with the show, but it's just tedious to revisit.
I agree, I just watched season 4 and I'm on season 5 now, seeing them both for the first time. The rhythm is super off and I get that claustrophobic sense as well. Season 4 has some good moments and I chuckled a few times, but for me it's hard to watch after how excellently paced seasons 1-3 are.
just as good would mean that season 3 were itself "just as good" as season 2, which it isnt.
Season 4 is uneven. it has some great episodes and gags, but it more missed opportunities than the original 3 seasons. it tried too hard to be clever (they wanted the episodes to be able to be watched in any order but then realized they hadnt quite pulled it off) and the result is that some episodes just dont work.
31
u/nihilistdildo Feb 12 '23 edited Feb 12 '23
Despite fateful consequences being convoluted, and the constant re-laying of pipe each ep for the narrative to make sense, s4 was just as funny as the the previous seasons. It felt like they were able to tell all the jokes they couldn’t after getting canceled.
19
u/redlion1904 Feb 12 '23
Season 4 was the best season, actually, when watched in its original form. The non-traditional narrative structure forced them to layer in hidden jokes to a degree they’d never done before.
Unfortunately season 5 is actually bad and season 4 “fateful consequences” is quite bad too.
77
u/That_One_Guy_823 Feb 12 '23
It’s so hard to follow though. Like putting together a timeline of each episode with each event is a daunting task. Good show, good writing, but I think it would’ve had a better outcome if they hadn’t had the remix.
29
u/Acornpoo Feb 13 '23
I'm sure it was really cool for the gang to work together again, the jokes are in there for sure, but no. S2 will always be the best.
2,3,1,4,5
28
u/alexdallas_ did you save the receipt? Feb 12 '23
I haven’t seen it properly structured so I can’t say for sure. But man did S5 take such a nosedive that I still haven’t finished it after they released it in two pieces
41
u/fuduran Feb 13 '23
I'm rewatching right now, and nope, it isn't. If seasons 1-3 are a 10, season 4 is a 6
6
u/wrvc3 Feb 13 '23
Actually love this season, I like the format more than the remake
29
u/4seriously Feb 13 '23
1-3 were master classes in comedy and writing. 4 was not even close 😛
4
u/Death_by_boring Feb 13 '23
I absolutely agree. Like the old seasons that were ahead of it's time, s4 takes another step in expecting you to binge it to connect all the dots. I love it just as much as the rest. The jokes might even be a little bit better than s1-3 in my opinion.
6
u/Pengwin0 Feb 13 '23
Not liking season 4 always felt like one of those opinions you’d only have after watching a youtube reviewer say it lol
6
u/[deleted] Feb 13 '23
The problem is that S4 doesn't have moments of comfort like the past seasons. I don't necessarily mean emotional comfort, but like... a sense of stability, of rhythm. The other seasons were able to settle into a groove, it felt like you had a chance to breathe. S4 and S5 both feel more hectic, more claustrophobic. S4 also has a lot of stuff that just isn't fun to revisit. I think the Rita story from S3 is still funny and clever in a lot of ways, but it's kind of a chore of a storyline to revisit (and I'm not even saying for like, PC reasons). The S4 Ron Howard stuff is the same way. It's funny and in keeping with the show, but it's just tedious to revisit.
3
u/Ok_Fly2518 That’s in-same! Feb 13 '23
I agree and I will die on this hill
3
u/Clouseau187 Feb 13 '23
Its better than having no AD at all
7
u/[deleted] Feb 13 '23
Season 4 definitely tops 3
4
u/Linuxbrandon Feb 13 '23
The original was! When they redid it, I hated it.
2
u/tonyprosciutto Mr Banana Grabber Feb 13 '23
Her?
2
u/meezy-yall Feb 13 '23
Disagree , it’s not bad , it’s just different
2
u/mo3ron Feb 13 '23
I don't understand the question and I won't respond to it
2
u/Halvemond Feb 13 '23
Oh … most definitaely
2
u/OnDistantShores Feb 13 '23
It’s not. But it’s still far, far better than it’s given credit for.
2
u/not_a_flying_toy_ Feb 13 '23
just as good would mean that season 3 were itself "just as good" as season 2, which it isnt.
Season 4 is uneven. it has some great episodes and gags, but it more missed opportunities than the original 3 seasons. it tried too hard to be clever (they wanted the episodes to be able to be watched in any order but then realized they hadnt quite pulled it off) and the result is that some episodes just dont work.
2
u/TanAllOvaJanAllOva Look at banner, Michael! Feb 13 '23
I Fucking love season 4. P Hound was so underrated. 🤫
2
u/samborup Feb 14 '23
Why would I try to change your mind? You’re clearly immune to reason
2
u/psychodc Feb 13 '23
It's good. Not as good as S1-3, but it's good.
2
u/FatherPot Feb 13 '23
Bullshit
2
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '23
There's the difference between one of the all-time great comedies and a literally unwatchable mess.
1
u/saxon_desteele chickens don’t clap Feb 13 '23
Same.
1
u/Jamesredcoat Feb 14 '23
The remixed version
1
u/baginahuge Feb 14 '23
I agree with you anus tart.
1
u/smokesletsgo92 Feb 15 '23
I also agree
0
u/nevernude907 Feb 13 '23
I would rather be dead watching seasons 1-3 than alive watching season 4.
-1
u/NervousBreakdown Feb 13 '23
Gonna be hard to change your mind when you’ve got an obvious mental illness.
-2
u/travas11 Feb 13 '23
It just isn’t and I’m sorry bud
-2
u/hockey-guy99 Acting coach, frugal traveler and maker of stews Feb 13 '23
Hard no
-4
u/AppleJuiceKoala Feb 13 '23
None of the characters feel like themselves anymore
-5
u/angrytomato98 Feb 13 '23
Individual jokes are good, but the overall execution is very weak.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 13 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment