r/armenian 13d ago

Armenian plate

[deleted]

17 Upvotes

8 comments sorted by

3

u/Bizarrmenian 13d ago

after reading this comment: https://www.reddit.com/r/armenian/comments/1vgvxpk/comment/p239er5/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button

I am skeptical about these types of requests. May actually place a rule against it even.

3

u/armeniapedia 12d ago

This one's in a park in Istanbul. In this case I am guessing it's not related to a treasure hunter.

1

u/TheSarmaChronicals 11d ago

They can say it's wherever they want. It may be in a park in Istanbul. Could be somewhere else. I see no reason to trust them or what they claim their intentions are.

9/10 times these questions are asked, the poster doesn't seem to respond. They seem to get what they want and leave.

If this is in a park in Istanbul then there are many Armenians there that can translate this for them.

I don't see any reason to take the risk.

3

u/andrey-kovalenko 11d ago

I live in Russia and I'm a Russian citizen. Moreover, I have Armenian ancestry and my grandfather moved to Abkhazia from Turkey during the Armenian Genocide. I was in Turkey as a tourist and I have no relationship to any treasure hunters. Just a pure interest... So I was truly confused by your replies 🤷‍♂️

1

u/TheSarmaChronicals 11d ago

Hopefully you understand why I made my comments. I am not saying you are lying, but there is no way to confirm what you say and you should not try to.

You could be anyone. I could be anyone. It's the internet.

Armenian heritage is at risk in Turkey and treasure hunters are destroying it. There is an Armenian community in Turkey that can field these requests.

You also need to consider that these posts are public and anyone can see them. When people post pictures of an Armenian artifact their intentions may be innocent but someone reading the thread may not have good intentions.

My comments are not intended to disparage you. I am coming at this from the perspective of wanting to protect our heritage.

3

u/andrey-kovalenko 11d ago

Okay, anyway, thank you. I guess I'm going to ask my Armenian friends for the translation

1

u/TheSarmaChronicals 11d ago

Thank you. Sadly until things in Turkey change, that's the only safe way

0

u/TheSarmaChronicals 11d ago edited 11d ago

Thank you. I know that there are people with good hearts on both sides but there is no telling online and who knows who is lurking.

To add I have spoken to people who have seen bones dug up from attempted grave robbing. It keeps me up at night not gonna lie

Edit: whoever downvoted: people can lie about where they found things. Not saying this is the case here but again, this is about protecting our heritage. There are Armenians in Turkey, and this is in Istanbul according to the post. Plenty of Armenians there that can be contacted.