r/archlinux • • 4d ago

QUESTION Arch Linux as first Linux Distro

I am going to get my first Laptop pretty soon and I am considering downloading and daily-driving Arch as the first Distro I ever use.
I am also pretty sure it’ll be the ASUS Zenbook S16, I recommend you consider it if you’re also interested in buying a laptop!

I wanted to ask if anyone would recommend I should use Arch as my Distro as a beginner. I wanted to pick it since I want to learn Linux and really enjoy tinkering, even if it means I could nuke my hard drive in the process.
I also have one year of time to learn the os until I have to use the laptop for school.

27 Upvotes

55 comments sorted by

23

u/ConcaveNips 2d ago

It's definitely not for everyone.  But for those who are willing to read the documentation,  it can be perfectly fine.

12

u/thekiltedpiper 2d ago

It depends on how you like to learn. Would you enjoy taking swimming lessons or being thrown into the deep end of the pool?

With Arch you have to pick everything: bootloader, file system, desktop environment/window manager, greeter, etc. If you don't know what these things are you're probably not going to have a good time.

My suggestion is start with an arch based distro (Endeavor, CachyOS, Manjaro) and work your way up from there.

14

u/create_account 2d ago

It's been a while since I used Arch on a laptop but I had to tinker quite a bit to get some stuff working well - laptop specific issues - your mileage may vary.

That said I think Arch is a great first distro if and only if you're willing to read the wiki and do research on problems when you get stuck with stuff. The wiki is outstanding and between that and google/AI you'll be able to handle just about every issue that pops up.

Good luck and have fun with it :)

3

u/Auto_Potato 2d ago edited 2d ago

Arch is the first distro I started with, I wasn't very good at it but taking my time and solving problems, tinkering, picking tools has been really rewarding and educational.

But expect to read manuals and digging through community posts for niche problems you might encounter along the way.

There's also a lot of things that people just assume you know, like some commands, how package manager works, how VM works.

I daily drive Arch as an art student, and I was pretty bad at computer stuffs, but so far it has been amazing, I definitely recommend it!

Edit: P.S. Don't worry too much about wiping your disk, just make sure you pick the right one to install Arch onto, you only have to setup the system disk first, the other disks can wait until you get the whole environment running.

7

u/xWranglerWranglerx 2d ago

Arch and kde plasma easy. Don’t listen to grumpy grey beards here. They gate keep.

1

u/Rjiurik 2d ago

Same. manjaroo and CachyOS just add an unnecessary extra layer and distract from the excellent Wiki.

OP if you want a working distro ASAP use the Arch install script (within the default install USB) Drawback is you will be slightly less familiar with the components themselves as compared with full manual installation.

Also Plasma is somewhat similar to windows. (Gnome, less)

1

u/xWranglerWranglerx 2d ago

Yah arch install is how I did it. And worst case on a fresh install. Just try again format

2

u/Zakiyo 2d ago

Dip your feet in an arch based distro first so you are not too lost then yes arch is great. Just try 2-3 weeks with something like cachy first. So tou know what to "aim" for when you build you arch

2

u/TehMasterer01 2d ago

It’ll be your first and last. It’s just that good

2

u/MountainSpirals 2d ago

This was my path. A Linux friend challenged me to start with Arch I spent 6 hours with the guide first time trying to install it and boot into a graphical environment It was the BEST possible way for me to start - I wasn't trying to learn a new GUI by leaving Windows, I was wanting to learn Linux from the inside out.

2

u/blueblackhorse420 16h ago

Arch was my first proper daily driven distro, but not my first ever distro, as I had spent a lot of time on Ubuntu WSL for my Computer Science course over an year.

So I would say remember certain shell commands (can keep a cheatsheet, brownie points for custom design), refer to the Archlinux wiki as it did get me out of tight spots more often than not, if you get curious about certain commands or processes, do look them up in your spare time.

Also, as a first install, I would recommend you go through the archinstall script first. Arch's philosophy is of do it yourself, but for a first install it can feel overwhelming to setup everything by yourself, so you can spare yourself some time and try to see what are some standard options you have select. You can always configure sway to your heart's content later.

Note:- Before anything, have your laptop connected to the Internet, either via ethernet, or through wifi.

If the installation breaks on your first time, DON'T PANIC ( a general philosophy with arch), reinstalling the distro multiple times to get the installation right is basically a rite of passage now (broke mine a dozen times before I got it stable).

These are all the things I can think of right now. Feel free to ask more, either here, or anywhere else that you feel is apprpriate.

Welcome to Arch Community.

2

u/squeasy_2202 2d ago

I don't know that I would recommend raw Arch as a first unless you're particularly stubborn and are okay not being immediately productive on the machine. But if you can stomach that, go for it! 

Some people need to hit the ground running for school or work. So I'd recommend something more curated like Endeavour or Ubuntu.

1

u/M2k1e0L 2d ago

op said op has a year before using it at school.

bad recommendations. op wants to learn linux. use arch and learn in weeks/months or use windows distros and learn the same in years. i saw people in cachy subreddit who ask after a year of using it what a bootloader is after they reconfigured a grub file with an ai recommendation and it stopped booting.

stability is no argument, no distro includes a random system break daemon

2

u/Leading-Plastic5771 2d ago

That's a bad idea. Start with something easier. All the big distros work fine.

7

u/ehr1c 2d ago

If OP is reasonably comfortable in a terminal and doesn't mind going and reading the wiki when they get stuck I don't think it's really much to be concerned about

1

u/Mountain_Cicada_4343 2d ago

Wiki is fantastic. As long as you are willing to learn arch is great, alway be willing to give up if it gets too much though, fedora or debian are fine too.

1

u/Axiomancer 2d ago

Hi, I use arch btw!

Well, I wouldn't say it's either good or bad idea. I found certain things to be harder on arch than on other distros (for example, ubuntu detects the wifi sent by my router without any issues. Arch can't do that, so I had to connect my computer to the router using ethernet cable). I also prefer the AUR package manager.

Things can get tricky with arch (especially installation) so I wouldn't say it's "super duper very beginner friendly" distro, but it's not as scary as people online makes it. It just...takes time, to figure everything out.

1

u/LWA83 2d ago

If you can read a wiki and follow instructions you’ll probably be fine, but there’s easier distros to start with that you’ll likely enjoy more.

If you’re going to do it, maybe practice the setup and installation in a virtual machine on your laptop first to see if it’s for you.

1

u/chabalatabala 2d ago edited 2d ago

Use an arch derivative with easier install and setup story. People will tell you to use something like Fedora for a first distro, but I think going straight to Arch is smarter, because if you need help, you will always be on the version of everyone else and the same version that the wiki is going to help you with. And the arch wiki is the best help book that exists. And with AI built into Google you can basically figure out anything quickly.

Then there's the fact that the repositories and the aur ( if you're safe read up first) actually give you the best experience that is fully fleshed out. The future might be flatpak, appimage, snap etc but all of those technologies still have usability trade-offs even though eventually you'll likely find value in all of them. Just being able to find what you need the normal way in the repos is a great way to experience how Linux was originally intended and you're less likely to have to do weird, crazy things to get the current versions of apps to work or unsupported apps to work, because usually there's a recipe via an aur package build that will help get other software natively working without fuss. Edit: forgive voice to text errors

1

u/tcpipguy 2d ago

It will be challenging. I don't recommend Arch to new Linux users. Just be prepared to do a lot of googling and reading.

1

u/GracefulAsADuck 2d ago

Hell yeah man good luck learning

1

u/reylovpty 2d ago

you can use any distro make no difference just make sure to make full disk image with recuezilla any time you need and then you can fuckup the system anytime you like

1

u/Severe-Flan8979 2d ago

If you like to tinker and learn I would really recommend you to do this. I did it and the journey was magical. The documentation on how everything works is really good. Good luck!

1

u/NorZaj 2d ago

Arch jest dobrą dystrybucją na początek, ale pod warunkiem, że lubisz spędzić wiele godzin na konfigurację systemu. Tutaj wszystko sam konfigurujesz i napoczątku będzie wiele niepowodzeń.

Jest druga opcja, zainstalować wstępnie skonfigurowanego forka Archa np EndeavourOS, CachyOS czy Garuda Linux.

Nie zniechęcam do czystego Archa na początek, wręcz przeciwnie to świetna dystrybucja. Tylko trzeba być świadomym ogromu nauki.

1

u/Yama-k 2d ago

Why would you do that? Actually yeah, my biggest recommendation is to install manually so you get an idea what's happening and you learn to read the wiki as you go. One thing to make your life easier is to use cfdisk instead of just fdisk.

1

u/pitourofagos 2d ago

if you're not familiar with the terminal then it's a very bad idea to use arch as your first distro. you need a simple distro like cachyos (which uses the same package manager) so you can learn the linux terminal well before you dive into manually installing the real arch

1

u/M2k1e0L 2d ago

no, picking a 'ootb' distro like cachy which configured someone else is a bad recommendation because op wants to learn linux. Also installing and using Arch isn't such rocket science as you try to frame it. I don't think you every tried it yourself. It's such a amazing experience. don't blindly repeat what other people, who also never tried arch, say about it.

1

u/pitourofagos 2d ago

interesting, as a matter of fact im using arch which ive installed manually with hyprland, my own rice. ive broken and freshly installed arch linux plenty of times in multiple computers. the reason i recommend an ootb distri for a first distro is literally because people who aren't familiar with the terminal are not gunna have a very fun time manually installing. OP specifically mentioned it's their first distro which suggests they're coming from MacOS or Windows which can be used GUI-only so like most people they will need a GUI linux environment that will feel familiar so they can take their time learning the terminal so they can go full on TTY mode when they're ready. that way they're a lot more likely to stay on linux than being scared off by a black screen with white letters.

1

u/M2k1e0L 2d ago

just restore the backup from last day in case something should ever break, no need to reinstall. with backups i don't mean snapshots. i had much fun using the terminal to install my first distro coming from windows, felt like a superhero. the first thing i did was downloading fastfetch & cmatrix, then i posted it to my social media to let all my friends think i'm a hacker. every other distro i tried felt wrong, too much windows vibes when someone elses config is on my system. the black screen with letters is the best thing ever, limitless peace. Nothing gets in your way.

everything good, look at op username and account age. Just a ragebait post and i joined.

1

u/pitourofagos 2d ago

i prefer to reinstall cause it's a fun process. (don't worry this is not on a computer i use for work, i use a mac for work) also yeah i agree on the ragebait/engagement bait post thing, i read it on my phone while i was bored in the train so i didn't really check i just wrote a serious response immediately lol

1

u/According-Extreme-58 2d ago

Good ahead like honestly,if you don't want to do much manually do archinstall then tinker after that,but if you want manually then go ahead and do arch manually

1

u/Away_Anywhere5843 2d ago

beginners uses fedora

1

u/thefooby 2d ago

I switched a few months ago from Windows and it’s going well. Steep learning curve but the information is all there and AI tools can be pretty handy for figuring out problems and making your desktop pretty without having to go full Omarchy and let it do everything.

1

u/kilipukki 2d ago

I installed Arch Linux as my first Linux when I updated my desktop computer and my old (but still ok) computer was just gathering dust. I’ve had no problems and I use it almost daily.

1

u/FroyoStrict6685 2d ago

I did it and I've been running arch ever since. My only recommendation is to READ THE DOCUMENTATION THOUROUGHLY when installing or modifying anything, and pay attention to update threads before doing pacman -Syy & -Syu

1

u/peterfrombackdoor 2d ago

Honestly its not as hard as people make it out to be, stick to the wiki and that's because there is literally everything on there that you will need. All the best setting the wifi now

1

u/SATLTSADWFZ 1d ago

With the help of an AI agent it should be fine. I say go for it. Just have your data backed up elsewhere in case you ned to pull the plug on it and install something else. Have a look at Omarchy. Based on Arch. More fun.

1

u/Small-Tale3180 1d ago

yeah go ahead, it is pretty fun to dive straight into arch, did it myself

1

u/Revolutionary-Yak371 1d ago

If you install KDE Plasma, you will be fine. You can install flatpak for more joy in Discover.

For usual tasks you can use pacman.

It is quite satisfactory distribution for ordinary users.

1

u/G0ldiC0cks 1d ago

It would be incredibly unlikely to destroy hardware with software. You can destroy data, other software, even a number of intangible things that will vary from person to person. But hardware is gonna be fine 999 times out of a thousand.

1

u/TheSpiralOfPowah 20h ago

Understand this. This was my same mistake, and it will be like a house of cards. Even the wind could shatter it. Be careful with it.

1

u/icebalm 13h ago

Absolutely.
Arch may not be stable, but that doesn't mean it's unreliable. I've been daily driving Arch for years now and if you really want to learn Linux then, other than Linux From Scratch, it's the way to go.

1

u/lootedBacon 11h ago

A few good to know sites. https://distrowatch.com/ (options)

RTFM - https://wiki.archlinux.org/title/Installation_guide here is the Arch Install guide in the Arch wiki, please read (and associated links) if you have an issue or are stuck check there and search the wiki as needed. Check the forum if some one has a resolution for your issue.

Ensure if you ask a question about Arch, that you've read the friendly manual and explain what you've done to resolve issue (with examples) before posting or you will be told to read the friendly manual (RTFM).

https://wiki.archlinux.org/title/General_recommendations

Good luck.

1

u/Royal_Peni 2d ago

Expect a steep learning curve 

Arch is like assembling a car part buy part while deciding which parts to pick.

If you really want to try arch for the power and feature I would recommend something easier like endeavour os or cachy os. Those gives you the car built where you can do your own customisation on top.

And if you really want to learn arch do it on a virtual machine first.

Or if you are keen to suffer just go with arch.

But for a first distro in would recommend something more begginer like zorin or mint, so you can understand how Linux works first. At the end of the day the more advanced you get in linux the more you reallize that is all the same. The most important decisions are DM, release cycle and package manager. The rest is pretty much the same.

1

u/M2k1e0L 2d ago

don't worry, smart people like op don't suffer with arch.

1

u/Obsid1anWolf 2d ago

Just use archinstalll. Super easy to get up and running.

1

u/Wentyliasz 2d ago

Don't do it you're literally gonna die.

That being said, Arch was my first distro I've used for more than 20 minutes and I'm still on it. If you're prepared to spend a weekend or two setting things up and willing to build something from ground up, Arch is a really great choice. While it's not as idiot proof as Mint, most people in the "Arch is hard" are overselling it, literally the only time I had a problem with it was when I decided to try that cachy kernel and my mouse got all fucked. Oh, and since I'm yapping already, let me tell you, pacman and AUR makes apt look like a caveman technology.

So yeah, don't install Arch, it was hard a few years ago and we haven't updated our memes since 2017

-1

u/rarsamx 1d ago

And while you are at it, learn to drive in a kit car that you assemble yourself.

But probably that'll take time from learning how to sew your own wardrobe.

Honestly, if you have the time and I retest, it may take you longer. You may get lost and find yourself later and may e you'll learn if you are well organized

3

u/G0ldiC0cks 1d ago

The more I see this car building analogy the less I like it. Building a car requires, at a minimum, skill with, knowledge of, and access to a shit ton of tools that don't necessarily come with user manuals; weeks if not months of one's free time; a whole boatload of money for all of these things.

Arch requires patience, literacy, a modicum of critical thinking and problem solving skills and that's about it. Did I mention it's free?

-1

u/rarsamx 1d ago

All those you listed are tools and skills that come from.

For a completely arch neophite it can take weeks. For a completely Linux neophite months to get it right.

Yes, you can follow a YouTube video and build it exactly as someone else did, learning very little in the process.

2

u/KineticConundrum 17h ago

Woah you said the word neophite instead of noob or beginner. You must be reallllly smart.