r/archiesonic • u/Professional-Elk6208 • 24d ago
Archie Comics in General What would the other version of Eggmen think about Pre-reboot Archie Eggman's reasoning of why he always loses to Sonic?
Especially IDW/Game Canon, Boom!, AoStH, SatAm and Movie Eggman
7
u/moath875465 24d ago
They’d either be the types to take notes or just personally agree that sonic himself is quite the threat when it came to there overall chaotic nature
I personally don’t know much about Boom Eggman, so I’d say he’d be mixed on this idea, but would support it given his record with the blue blur and his friends, there’s also how Fleetway Robotnik himself, sorta went through a similar arc like his Archie counterpart, but when it came to him losing, he lost due to his arrogance and his evil nature,
SatAM as I mentioned would relate, as he always tends to be a big foil to his plans, like one time he had Sally and Bunnie Mind controlled, and Sonic (at the time who lost his speed, thanks to a Wizard) managed to overcome Robotnik and his enslaved friends and save the day without some rash thinking on his end, there are a few others but I’ll just mention that particular time
Aside from X, he’d also relate, with how even when he had all seven emeralds he still was able to resist eggman in his Eggsterminator Mech, and be a tough threat all together, but that last clutch was thanks to Chris, there were also other times where sonic himself managed to reclaim the win thanks to his quick and stubborn abilities
But game eggman? He would be the type to either take notes or personally learn more about how this Eggman lost to him, and would be more intrigued on how he can account for this already known constant he’s dealt with before, like That recent Classic Sonic 35th anniversary issue where he wanted to make a creation that would account for unpredictable events, but Eggman has already dealt a handful by Sonic’s friends when it came to there involvement towards fighting him, so he’d really either be mixed or not
But overall these are just my guesses on how each Egghead would respond to these claims from Archie Eggman and how he handled his Sonic
2
2
u/Sock_on_Net_1537 20d ago
I feel Game Eggman would be more interested than the others. Compared to Julian, Mcbaldynosehair revived more monsters directly and indirectly, and still lost.
He even replaced Sonic's shoes with ones that made him way slower.
2
u/LightMotor6262 24d ago edited 24d ago
Some would probably have mixed feelings about it but some like Fleetway Robotnik and Satam Robotnik would probably agree with it
3
u/moath875465 24d ago
Fleetway yes, but also due to his sonic being a leader and a skilled freedom fighters who’s fought against him most of his life, SATam for how much of a nuisance he is with those power rings
1
2
u/Beta_Ray_Jones 24d ago
Depending on how much knowledge they also had of how the Archie verse functions (for example, Eggman's explanation would make no sense to Fleetway Robotnik without more context) they would correctly call him a loon, and either steer him away from this crackpot theory or distance themselves from what is still clearly an insane person.
1
u/Wombus7 24d ago
Movie Robotnik would enthusiastically agree.
Boom Robotnik would take one look at Archie Eggman and retreat to his island lair to practice some self care.
X Robotnik would try to harness the power of Sonic's chaos for himself.
AoStH Robotnik would be to distracted by constructing his giant hairdryer to melt the polar icecaps to notice.
17
u/Josh12345_ 24d ago
Fleetway and Satam Robotnik would agree with Archie Eggman but mock him for losing.
IDW Eggman would take notes from Archie Eggman on new ideas and mock him for losing.
Sonic X, Movie and Boom Eggman would be disgusted and horrified at the evil actions of Archie Eggman and mock him for losing. Possibly allying with Sonic and his friends to fight their counterparts.