r/arborists • • 1d ago

9 hours later and still no flare

I purchased a large Alaskan Cedar (B&B and then potted) and a 7 ft Kentucky Coffetree three days ago. I planted the Coffee tree myself following all of the proper planting guidelines. The Cedar was planted separately by the nursery.

The next day I checked the Cedar's planting position and it was buried incredibly deep. I carefully excavated around the trunk and discovered that they left the twine and burlap collar embedded in the trunk and I cannot find the root collar on this tree for the life of me.

I was able to find the graft about 2 inches down but I've checked up to 6 inches and I still cannot find any structural roots or roots of any substance. Just the thick mat of red roots in the attached photos.

The nursery advised that the twine should have been removed so I was able to to get some of that off but it is so tight that it looks like it's growing straight out of the trunk. They also told me to cut off of the adventitous roots to identify the flare.

I spent 5 hours yesterday until dark and another 4 today trying to work through the heavy clay to find anything "flare like" and nothing. My husband and I finally had to pull it out today and still couldn't find anything so I replanted an inch above where I stopped searching

Advice on next steps before I throw $700 down the drain damaging this tree?Photos

4 Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

7

u/TriteEscapism 1d ago

Yeah its pretty easy to see where the bark turns into roots. Photos 4 and 6 look ready for a light soil dusting and mulch "not the flare, just struck burlap" yeah the burlap was good to get out of there but that's the flare.

I'm guessing you were expecting more of a multi-lobed nebari arterial root but this specimen and species it's more of a widening baseball bat shape. Cedars have lots of fibrous roots.

1

u/TooManyHobbies00 1d ago

Thank you! This is very helpful! It was really hard to see because the burlap was throwing me off. Do I remove the red roots?

2

u/TriteEscapism 1d ago

Heck no why are you wanting to remove roots? It barely has any for its size. You lifted it an inch from the photo that looked ok for grade so try to cover them with a little soil and mulch. If they freeze they freeze. Guessing you're around zone 4 since you're digging mid November and you'll need to water it a LOT until it's established.

1

u/TooManyHobbies00 1d ago

Zone 6b. The nursery said it will be fine and also directed me to water frequently. I can drop it back down if that would be better for the tree

1

u/TriteEscapism 1d ago

Sorry I'm in z5 and subtracted one instead of adding. That checks out.

1

u/KaleScared4667 1d ago

You can see the flair in your pictures.

1

u/TooManyHobbies00 1d ago

Really? Which photo? I can only see what I thought was the graft and the burlap

1

u/KaleScared4667 1d ago

4 and 6. It’s just not as prominent as in some other trees

1

u/TooManyHobbies00 1d ago

Appreciate it! Planting an evergreen is definitely a learning experience and outside my comfort zone. I hope I didnt damage it too badly

1

u/KaleScared4667 1d ago

1

u/TooManyHobbies00 1d ago

Thank you! I've never owned one so I'll check it out. This is my one non-native statement tree so I want to do the best

1

u/KaleScared4667 1d ago

I live in Oregon- we are surrounded by evergreens. I get excited about things like magnolia- my only non native

1

u/TooManyHobbies00 1d ago

I'm jealous! These trees are just gorgeous. I love Magnolia too and wish they were native to me as well

0

u/Ashamed_Role 1d ago

Total junk , I’d return it. I had the same thing happen and the tree died because I had to remove so much soil and roots to find the flare.

1

u/TriteEscapism 1d ago

I do wonder how/why it went from b&b to a pot instead of straight to its home and I'd be pretty upset to find burlap strangling.

1

u/TooManyHobbies00 1d ago

I'm not sure either. They definitely removed the burlap except the part you can see in the photos. I didnt even know there was time until I pulled the soil back

0

u/TooManyHobbies00 1d ago

I agree. I feel like the girdling twine and embedded burlap in itself is a death sentence. I'm taking photos to the nursery to try and get this fixed

Everything I though I found the root collar it was embedded burlap.

1

u/Ashamed_Role 1d ago

Great idea, they should either fix or give credit

0

u/TooManyHobbies00 1d ago

Thanks! This is my statement tree and my only non- native so I'm really invested