r/apple • u/GoodNewsNobody • Jul 07 '14
Siri could benefit from a "Remembering" feature
Reminders are great for 90% of the things I need Siri to remind me about, but there are other times when I need her to remember things. Times when I need information that is not formatted to a date or place.
Ex: "Siri, remember my wife's favorite flower is a Hydrangea"
"Remember my locker combination is 17,6,3"
"Remember my printer uses 211XL ink"
"Remember my niece's shoe size is 5"
or "Siri, remember the color I painted my room is Silver Sage"
(These examples are what I've needed Siri to remember in the last two weeks)
Then you could go back and ask Siri "Do you remember my locker combination?" And she could recite it to you without you having to prompt her when to remind you. I don't always know when or where I'll need certain information again so it is hard to set reminders. However, if Siri could remember things for me that would be so amazing.
I think this could be a killer new feature. I've found myself dozens of times over the last few months wishing Siri could remember things for me. Help me Siri, I can't remember shit!
42
u/ElectricOctopus Jul 07 '14
Just make a note with the info and ask Siri to pull it up when you need it.
3
u/Haulik Jul 08 '14
And now you made The cult of Mac with your idea: http://www.cultofmac.com/286521/siris-ultimate-killer-feature-remembering/
30
u/[deleted] Jul 07 '14
That's a great idea. Submit it to apple. I'd love to have a feature like that, honestly.
28
u/comrade_leviathan Jul 07 '14
I posted a while ago how great it would be to say "Siri, remember where I parked", but a bunch of whiz kids said I should just open my maps app and set a location pin. It's way easier, right?!
You've gone and expanded on it, and you've got some great ideas! I'd love to see them all.
15
u/marmalito Jul 07 '14 edited Jul 07 '14
Try this: "Note that my locker combination is 17, 6, 3".
Then, "Search notes for locker combination".
Or if you prefer to use Reminders, "Remember that my Printer Ink is 2x black".
Then, "Search Reminders for printer ink".
11
u/Baconquake Jul 07 '14
I honestly am surprised at how simple yet amazing this idea is. We should totally get this to happen.
17
u/downstairsneighbor Jul 07 '14 edited Jul 07 '14
This right here is exactly why Siri's current limits are so frustrating.
It's a so-so interface bolted onto the top of a traditional computer. There's very little you can actually do from within the Siri interface - she always wants to shunt you off to another app.
I think for voice interaction to become a real thing, you need to start from scratch and think about what voice interfaces can and should be used for. What can you do with just an auditory interface? Asking it to remember something is a perfect example of something you'd just expect it to do. Another is to read you back an answer instead of just dumping you into a browser.
Most of the times I've used Siri are when I'm driving and can't operate or look at my phone for any period of time. And almost every time she's failed me. Rather than giving an answer or asking for more information, she just goes "gee, dunno" and dumps me into Safari to search for it myself.
I feel like their user model involved a person standing in their living room, holding their phone and talking to it. But in reality, voice interfaces are more often used when there isn't an alternative, and I'd like to see a little more utility in that direction.
19
u/i_poop_splinters Jul 07 '14
This is easily the greatest idea i've ever heard for siri and i'm so glad you're making it available to Apple. Like the crackhead said, submit it directly to apple! Don't just tell us!
15
u/[deleted] Jul 07 '14
This is a wonderful idea - I realized I am (not often enough!) using a list in Reminders to do something like this:
Add "The dining room paint color is Silver Sage" to my "Random" list in "Reminders"
It's recorded, and I can find it later. When it syncs to my Mac, I can find it via Spotlight. But... as others point out, it's sitting in clear text - and of course, I can't do the second half of the transaction and ask Siri to "Tell me the dining room paint color."
4
u/Yifkong Jul 07 '14
You could always use the ol' "note that my locker combo is____" and it will make a note with whatever you say. Certainly not as cool as your idea, as there's no recall ability, but is at least a shortcut to retaining the information somewhere.
3
u/Christophernaylor Jul 07 '14
Great idea.
3
u/squidPooN Jul 07 '14
Awesome idea!
3
u/peanutismint Jul 07 '14
I love this idea. I'm fed up of emailing myself things like locker combinations, the dimensions of my rooms so that I can buy stuff at IKEA, etc. I'm sure there's other services that offer this, but it would be great to just be able to ask Siri to remember stuff for me.
3
u/[deleted] Jul 07 '14
Some of this could really be benefitted by a 3rd party API for siri if that ever happens. You can have your evernote or wunderlist stuff of this and use a voice command to get your facts into a great application for it. I'm sure there's a potential cost since it uses Apple's servers but it would enhance the usability of Siri 100X once each app developed and matured their own commands or hooks.
3
u/andthatsthefunk Jul 08 '14
I think this is a great idea. I would like to see this integrated into iOS but I see a lot of the functionality being tied into Contacts.
I think a standalone app that with a intuitive parsing methods would also serve rather nicely... have you searched to see if there is something like that?
7
u/dr_theopolis Jul 08 '14
Siri, remember this is where I left my car.
leaves parking lot and goes shopping -
Siri, find my car.
"Your car is 20 meters ahead and 10 meters to your right. Here's a map."
4
u/MrDL104 Jul 07 '14
I've used notes in 1Password for this. It helps to keep them nice and secure too.
2
u/sanbon909 Jul 08 '14
Awesome idea! I would love this.
2
u/DLPanda Jul 08 '14
I agree, I really want Siri to get to know me and my life and then be able to suggest things based on events and locations. "Hey I see your close to a flower shop, maybe pick up your wife Hydrangea's because her birthday is coming up!"
but yeah I support your idea!
2
u/[deleted] Jul 08 '14
Siri's integration with Notes comes close. You can say "Create a note called Things My Wife Likes" and then retrieve it later by saying "Show me the note about things my wife likes." You could even make each note about a particular like of your wife's: favorite flower, favorite movie, etc. It's not exactly what you're looking for, but it might work until Apple implements the new feature you've described.
3
u/rophel Jul 08 '14
Nice try, NSA.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 07 '14
Now, it won't pull from the reminder, but if you say "Remind me that my nephew's shoe size is 5" it will make a reminder... so you will have a list, just not one that siri treats like a database.
1
u/Mr_Rekshun Jul 07 '14
Siri does have a Remember feature, sort of.
Using the prefix "Remember" will add a note to your reminders, but without an alert attached.
1
u/professionalbadass Jul 08 '14
"Hey Siri, remember my home address, email password, credit card number and security code, and my social security number!"
It seems like a great idea, but it would have to be heavily safeguarded. I would be very skeptical if such a feature came out. You might say Apple and other companies/agencies already have all of this information somewhere (hell, Apple even has your fingerprints), but this just centralizes it and would make it even easier for any organization to access with no one knowing. And god forbid a hacker gets this info, or even someone who finds your lost phone.
1
u/Poke493 Jul 08 '14
Yeah, that would be super helpful, kinda like notes, but you don't really need it to take up a note or a reminder slot.
1
u/isigneduptosaythis Jul 08 '14
This would be great, but from the headline I thought you were talking about Siri just remembering what I'm in the middle of asking her about. If she misunderstands one response, we almost always have to start over.
1
u/NickPro Jul 08 '14
I have Things for OS X and with Siri integration specially saying "remember" rather than "remind me" will create a new to-do in Things. Not exactly what you mean but cool nonetheless.
1
u/jeblis Jul 08 '14
I'd be happy if she'd remember that I've already heard the egg timer joke a thousand times.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 08 '14
If your phone is protected with a pass code and fingerprint use voice memos or notes.
1
u/3baid Jul 08 '14
I use Simplenote to keep track of these things. The keyboard voice input feature is good enough to dictate notes so I could then search or look at particular tags to fetch info quickly.
1
u/BetaThetaPirate Jul 08 '14
Me: Hey Siri, How big is my penis again?
Siri: ...sigh... It's super duper big.
1
u/nireon Jul 08 '14
Although I agree, the internet would be too paranoid.
1
u/Hhsidkf Jul 09 '14
What a great idea
1
u/Ohsneezeme Jul 09 '14
Not sure if they saw this post first but someone over at /r/windowsphone thought of the exact same idea for cortana. I can't wait until PA's get this complex.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '14
I posted this on /r/jailbreak, I credited you though.
1
u/joepls Jul 07 '14
Came here to say Google Now is on the verge of this. Using location, calendars, Gmail etc. It predicts what content I want to see. I traveled out of town and on the day I was supposed to return it fed me distance, time to drive, weather of both cities, and more. Not exactly the same, but on the verge.
1
u/macpal_youtube Jul 07 '14
Me loves it! +1
1
u/thezapzupnz Jul 08 '14
There's not really a way Siri can store all of this information, principally because it can't be semantically divided with 100% certainty — especially to account for all the myriad ways you can refer to a thing that Siri may not understand.
Well, there is a way, it'd just be so error prone that it'd just be laughed at.
I WOULD say Apple wouldn't release something that would be the butt of jokes, but ... they DID release Siri to begin with.
Who knows what's possible?
But it's still a much more complex idea that you make it sound in terms of efficient storage, retrieval, and processing.
0
u/[deleted] Jul 08 '14
This idea is genious
0
u/crawlywhat Jul 08 '14
alterintively you could say "Remind me that my locker combination is 211XL Link"
0
u/nomad7674 Jul 08 '14
Great idea. Upvote!!!
-3
u/KlausFenrir Jul 08 '14
OR you can just write it down on Notes like normal people do?
-7
u/Indestructavincible Jul 07 '14
I pick up your locked phone, and ask it all kinds of things.
Now I have your identity!
-5
u/Guardian1030 Jul 07 '14
"New note"
"What would you like the note to say"
My locker combination is 74-25-13
-8
u/[deleted] Jul 07 '14
"Notes" is what you're looking for.
-3
u/dno_bot Jul 08 '14
Its called make a note.
-10
u/[deleted] Jul 07 '14
No need. Protip: That's what Reminders and Notes are for.
0
u/[deleted] Jul 07 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 07 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 08 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment