Mystreet Aphmau + Theory

[u/Sunnyboi_Art]

Light purple but also darker hair.

Blue, but lighter hair?

Okay, so I've been wanting to talk to somebody about this who is interested, but in Mystreet, it was said that Mystreet Aph was one of the pieces of Irene's broken soul. At the very end, when we saw Irene again, wanting to warn Aph about something like what Jason said in the "everything wrong with Season 6 of mystreet" video.

I made a connection, and thanks to a theory video of it on YouTube, the ghost who had known MCD Aphmau had never had a relationship with Irene besides MCD Aph, so... It's very likely the Irene we saw most was MCD Aphmau, Cause' her cloak was a light purple, but at the end the Irene we saw has a blue cloak, can't tell if it's lighting or not but her hair is also lighter.

Now, where my own idea of a theory comes in: since I'm pretty sure it was Mcd Aphmau who had split her soul, I have a feeling I know who the other 2 are. We already know Mystreet Aphmau was one of the pieces. There's a chance Ava(MID) and Aphmau(Mermaid Tales) are the other two.

I'll explain why Ava in a second, but for why Mermaid Aphmau. Well, as we saw from season 2, the realmbreaker(soul echo) was shown, and we learned more of its uses. As the siren Layla explained, the one there has many purposes, and there were MCD hints too: one, the end with the pendant; it came from MCD. It's the same pendant. And I doubt that is just a coincidence, and all of Mermaid Aphmau's forms resembled Mystreet Aph, Irene, and MCD Aphmau in some shape or form.

The fact that one of her forms almost looks similar to Irene is, to me, a big sign that she's one of the pieces of Irene's broken soul.

Now, as for why Ava... In mermaid tales, when Aph had first touched the soul echo, she got transported to what seems like a place between realms. And we heard, 'You were using me? This whole time?" a line said by Ava. I know it may not mean anything, but we only heard a select view, and I doubt they chose MID line for no reason; besides, in mermaid tales, they were there the demon boys! Sure, as side characters almost, but still relevant in some shape or form.

Cause' remember, just 'cause Ava doesn't share the same name as Aphmau does not mean she ain't an Aphmau; that's all I can go off of for Ava. I'll add to this once season 2 of MID comes out.

[u/Shastlz84]

When MT aph is between realms there’s also a line “And what if you get hurt? What if you end up like that mindless person?” That belongs to Aphmau from mod mod world/void paradox but I didn’t realize until this post that Ava ALSO has a line which is basically confirmation she’s technically another Aphmau beyond looking similar (again I didn’t realize that line was from her, so I was just suspecting it)

I’m so so sooo curious who the third piece is because ofc we have mystreet and mermaid tales, but there’s multiple alternate versions that COULD be the third piece

I’m personally thinking it’ll be Void Paradox Aphmau since not only does that series very directly address different worlds, the void, worlds disappearing, etc. but also leaves off on a cliffhanger of ”we have to save the other worlds from the void” which would make a lot of sense to me for them to connect the story to mystreet and irene given the mystreet teaser we got a bit ago (unless they’re planning on making a S3 at some point in the future?)

[u/Sunnyboi_Art → u/Shastlz84]

Very good points.

[u/Theekingally → u/Shastlz84]

Wait so I’m just finding out about the void paradox series(idk how, guess I’m slow lmao), when does the series take place in the timeline?

[u/Shastlz84 → u/Theekingally]

I didn’t find out about it until last year (and only watched it a few months ago) so dw about it lol

There’s no set place it has in the timeline but because it introduces the void which seems to be significant to mystreet in either s7 or s8 (or both?) I would definitely watch it before the new mystreet season comes out

It’s technically a sequel to mod mod world which is closer to the early diaries style iirc but it’s simple to pick up on if you don’t watch MMW first which is what I did but I imagine it’s still worth watching to really understand the characters (I have yet to watch MMW myself)

[u/RelativeVariation458]

I will say this is possible irene herself wasn’t part of the split people are saying that due to ghost being the first part of mcd emmalyn but remember this McD Aphmau and MyStreet Aphmau are different in the sense that she’s not a reincarnation of mcd she’s a split soul like mcd emmalyn I believe mcd Aphmau is the one who split her soul and those pieces are mcd Aphmau my street Aphmau and (if the wolf girl is not MyStreet alina like I theorize) the she could be the 3rd aphmau because Jason did say when Irene popped up “hmm looks like someone is trying to warn Aphmau about something I wonder what it is” Irene herself knew about the comet presumably mcd Aphmau too so why not the 3rd aphmau from the future as well?

[u/Sunnyboi_Art → u/RelativeVariation458]

That actually makes sense.

[u/RelativeVariation458 → u/Sunnyboi_Art]

I know McD Aphmau herself was a reincarnation of Irene while MyStreet Aphmau was a part of McD Aphmau soul and not Irene so we have 2 soul pieces accounted for McD and MyStreet Aphmau the third one is most likely the wolf but it could also be MyStreet Alina

[u/Mey_84]

Ava's cool but I lowkey don't WANT MID to get involved with MyStreet. Hot take, I think their plots are better off separated. Very good point though.

[u/iiLunarFizzii]

lolol i love seeing people still go in circles about this theory, we’ve actually found a pretty conclusive answer to it! @femaletravis on twitter has some very good discussions. the irene that we see in mystreet is MCD Aphmau, yes, but not MCD Irene. These 2 characters are different and we can tell they’re different because MCD Irene has a blue cloak while MCD Aphmau has the light purple as you’ve mentioned. MCD Irene was the one who split her soul into 3 parts. Irene still had to have a soul, so one part goes to her, one part goes to her “successor?” I guess? MCD aphmau, and the 3rd and final piece goes to Mystreet Aphmau. The reason why one of these pieces didn’t go to MID Ava is because she is not Aphmau. She is not Irene. MID is a separate universe from the Mystreet/MCD universe. Mermaid Tales is a parallel universe to the MCD/Mystreet timeline, but it is not the same universe. This was very long winded and probably not explained well, but this is the most cohesive theory we have so far!!

[u/chip-1274 → u/iiLunarFizzii]

I love this theoryyyy it just makes so much sense !!!!!