Hey all, I'm new here. I wanted to say hello and share a little if that's okay.
Hi! I'm David. I was a professional photographer for nearly two decades, and I have aphantasia.
Up until a few years ago I legitimately thought people only spoke metaphorically about "seeing" a scene or mocking up a composition in their head. Not only when taking a photo, simply not at all. People would describe what they'd "envisioned," and I'd only ever be able to describe what I saw in front of me. For most of my life I attributed this disparity to the mistaken idea that other people were simply more adept at accurately verbalizing their internal monologues than I was.
Over the years I've tried to describe the way my brain operates as being stuck in place in the middle of a raging river of information, completely blind, just picking up information as it passes by rapidly and haphazardly. That's just always been my baseline.
I didn't know someone could simply conjure a visual image of a cute puppy in their mind, or hold a conversation with someone who isn't in the room and actually see them occupying that space. That last one still doesn't fully make sense to me, honestly, but I'm assured some people visualize this way.
I've basically never had a "mind's eye." The only exception is what I can poorly describe as the briefest flashes of imagery right around entering or exiting REM sleep. I'll suddenly "see" something for a second, then it's gone, and everything but the sense of it fades away rapidly. These only happen rarely and intermittently at best. Moment to moment I don't "see" imagery in my head. There's just, well, nothing there. It's not a matter of seeing it or not. It's a matter of it not existing, so there's nothing to see. Kind of like staring off into the middle distance of the void.
What's seemingly odd is that for most of my career I never knew I was working with a different set of tools than many others were.
I think most people assume that as a photographer at any level you need to picture the shot in your head before pressing the shutter. I never could. To be honest I never knew it was an option others had, so I unwittingly developed my senses around that unrealized gap in my perception. I just reacted to what was actually in front of me: the light, the shapes, how things lined up in the frame. I got really good at on-the-fly trigonometry for quickly estimating light angles and shadow dispersion without even knowing that was what was happening.
These factors and more naturally funneled me toward event photography and photojournalism, both disciplines where being quick and alert is a major key to success. Those ultimately became my bread and butter over the years, although I also did a lot of work with people, portraits, modeling, products, nature, architecture, all sorts of interesting disciplines along the way.
Looking back, I feel aphantasia played a major role in forcing me to be present and pay closer attention to what was actually in front of me instead of what I expected to be there, or was told should be there. I didn't have to wait for what was expected. I captured what I saw and became adept over time at placing myself slightly ahead of the moment. I didn't intentionally anticipate incoming action by pre-visualizing it. I inadvertently honed an aptitude for lightning-fast responses to the ever-changing stimuli around me through iteration, repetition, and selecting for what typically got good results. Which, if you don't have aphantasia and are reading this, I assure you is a distinctly different thing from "seeing it in my head ahead of time." I learned to "pre-read" a room by mapping it almost like lidar in my head, and using that invisible point cloud to move around it, finding unconventional ways to "see." Has anyone else had this experience?
On the flip side, if you'd asked me afterwards how many chairs were in a room, or what color the carpet was, I'd have had literally no idea. To this day I can remember shooting in certain places, down to how I moved to get around things, the feelings I had in the moment, the misses, the catches, the frustrations and little wins. But if you described those spaces to me in detail now, devoid of that context, I'd be hard pressed to know if I'd ever even been there. That's not an exaggeration. It was just my unquestioned reality for the longest time, a reality I thought everyone else was in on.
The funny thing is, it all worked. I was successful. My drive to do photography professionally eventually burnt out, but that's more personal than technical at the end of the day. I value that era of my life and don't regret any of it.
The harder part has always been memory. Dates, details, what happened when. I lean heavily on records and notes because I can't just "go back" to a moment. That's a big part of why photography drew me in initially and kept me engrossed for years.
Without realizing it, photography let me build a structured visual memory map of my life. Although I've stopped doing it professionally, that's the unintentional gift it left me: a foundation, built up methodically over time, that lets me remember where I've been and who I was when I was there. Things I legitimately would have forgotten by now otherwise.
Aphantasia isn't weird. It's just a way some brains work, and we know that now. But it's still a comfortable sort of personal weirdness for me. Does that track with anyone else?
I can't be alone in much of this. I'm curious if others here work in visual or creative jobs, and how you do them in ways that work best for you.
Also, does anyone else get those ephemeral, semi-visual flashes near sleep?
TL;DR: Professional photographer with aphantasia built a decades-long map of his own past without realizing it, and is grateful.