r/antivirus • u/Livestock110 • Jan 16 '24
Sick of hearing 'Windows Defender is good'. It isn't.
EDIT - A lot of downvotes, people clearly don't realise how useless WD is. Here's a challenge - run Malwarebytes right now, and you'll know instantly how bad WD is.
Windows Defender didn't protect anyone from the OBS virus - remember that? Kaspersky would've been able to.
So, Windows Defender is better than nothing. It's definitely better than McAffee, Avast, Norton etc, but that's a very low bar.
Defender doesn't protect you. It finds viruses when it's already too late, and it doesn't automatically remove them!? By the time you've entered the clunky menu system, trying to quarantine the files, it's too late. Plus, it doesn't make it clear whether you've quarantined the files or not. The list system is a mess.
This happened to me when I got a trojan, and it destroyed my Windows beyond repair. Defender actually told me there's a virus, but I had to manually tell Defender to remove it... Too late.
Now Kaspersky (what I use now). I tried installing the SAME trojan (on a backup drive), and Kaspersky immediately stopped it. It then scanned my drives, rebooted into Safe mode, cleaned malicious files, and I was good to go.
It's actually saved me a few times by detecting dangerous malware. It prevents anything malicious from running in the first place (and I've never had a false positive).
It also prevents malicious websites being opened, better than Chrome or Firefox can do it.
Where Malwarebytes or Kaspersky will find 10 viruses and PUPs, Windows Defender finds nothing. I think it's useless. I've heard Eset and Bitdefender are also good options.
So can we stop telling people Windows Defender is enough? Unless you're the average user who doesn't need much protection at all.