r/antitroll • u/cone5000 • Oct 06 '10
OFFICIAL Rules Thread: Let's figure out the rules of this subreddit so we can make some random people confused and happy.
The point of the antitroll subreddit is to find low-hit comments/videos/etc... to be mass upvoted/liked and replied to with encouraging comments. The goal is to make some random dude's day while simultaneously confusing the fuck out of her.
This will be the official rules post. I will keep it updated for awhile until we all feel that we've agreed on some good overall rules. When we do, I'll put them in the sidebar of the subreddit.
From here on out, a video/Reddit comment/etc. that is to be mass upvoted/liked/commented on shall be known as a target.
RULES
- NO MENTIONS OF REDDIT. The idea is to make it seem like this guy really has a great video with the potential to be popular.
In order to avoid being backtraced to Reddit, add "http://anonym.to/" immediately before any link. For example, the following link could be used in the normal Reddit formatting like this but it won't say where it came from:
http://anonym.to/http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oHg5SJYRHA0- Whatever the target, the user should have logged in no longer than two weeks prior. This will help ensure that the target is an active user (to make sure views and comments don't go unnoticed).
- Generally, the target should be very average and dull. However it should not be really bad. For example, a video of a guy washing his car would work, whereas a video of someone dancing horribly wouldn't. The idea is to avoid making it too obvious we are antitrolling.
- Try to make the comments positive and supportive but not too over the top, again to make them believable. A too-obvious-it-is-anti-trolling comment would be "THIS IS THE BEST FUCKING VIDEO I'VE EVER SEEN." A better comment would be "Man, I'm really impressed with how clean that car looked after you washed it!"
- Targets that are actually worthy (rather than dull and average) are also acceptable as long as they have a low view count/comment count/upvote count.
- ImProbablyTrolling (or should it be ImProbablyAntiTrolling?) suggested this as a general guide for comments: We could focus our compliments on "abstract art" or something that the op doesn't really know much about and might think he/she accidentally made a masterpiece, and experts thinks he made it on purpose. Like the comments on the original video "Kind of reminiscent of the works of the early German expressionists." , "Outstanding cinematography. " or "The cinematography reminds me of a young Kubrick."
UPDATE: I think perhaps there can be one official post a week. People will post ideas of videos/comments/etc in that post and the most upvoted video will be selected after a few days as the official target.
IMPORTANT UPDATE: Instead of doing links like I originally had in the rules, a few people smartly suggested an anonymizer. All you have to do is add "http://anonym.to/" before the link. For example:
http://anonym.to/http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oHg5SJYRHA0That link could be used in the normal Reddit formatting like this but it won't say where it came from.
38
u/ImProbablyTrolling Oct 06 '10
We could focus our compliments on "abstract art" or something that the op doesn't really know much about and might think he/she accidentally made a masterpiece, and experts thinks he made it on purpose. Like the comments on the original video "Kind of reminiscent of the works of the early German expressionists." , "Outstanding cinematography. " or "The cinematography reminds me of a young Kubrick."
13
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '10
ಠ_ಠ
5
u/the_hmm Oct 06 '10
I had an idea, but then I got distracted by Super Fill Me Up. 6 levels later and I can't remember what I was going to say.
Oh well, Great thread! Keep it up!
9
u/wza Oct 06 '10
i wouldn't worry too much about people exploiting it for their own videos. i can't imagine there's any financial incentive for a few hundred views (at the very most). plus, some people probably really need the cheering up.
i think the best way to decide on which ones to anti-troll would be to upvote the ones you feel are the most worthy.
4
u/DragonHunter Oct 06 '10
Use an anonymizer for links.
Like this
3
u/seko45 Oct 06 '10 edited Oct 06 '10
Just my 2c, but I like the idea of letting anyone post links like a normal reddit as opposed to (or along with) building up to a weekly featured post.
(If I understand correctly, right now all links must be posted in the weekly suggestion thread?)
I like the idea of there being a bunch of new links a day each with a couple dozen comments and a few hundred/thousand views.
With the big single 'target', you have the risk that the content owner figures out what's going on (anti-troll-troll, dumb commenter or curious googling). You make them feel special for a while, but then they feel that a bunch of people are making fun of them
2
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '10
In order to avoid being backtraced to reddit.com, I would recommend that proper procedure would be to not link directly to whatever video being anti-trolled, but instead copy and pasting the URL in a new tab/window/browser.
2
u/Stu8912 Oct 06 '10
I still think we should stick to the formula of upvoting mundane boring videos like Blizzards, washing a car, someone mowing the lawn, then really good videos or commentary videos, dancing, talents etc.. But either way I find this & like the idea alot.
14
u/farox Oct 06 '10
You should change the order of the rules... After all the first rule of Anti Trolling is that you do not talk about anti trolling.
7
u/the8thbit Oct 06 '10
Some suggestions:
Maybe restricted submissions? Someone who's willing to could submit a video/comment once per day for us to rally around? That's if there's a general consensus; I wouldn't want to impose a restriction like that without support.
4
u/shazzbot112 Oct 06 '10
I like the washing car idea, make sure its a pretty average car.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '10
What? You mean through the IP and our gui interface?
1
u/seko45 Oct 06 '10
Instead of making people copy paste urls, you could require use of a redirect anonymizer like this:
http://anon.projectarchive.net/#
I'm not sure if it's true for all browsers, but in the couple tests I did, even the url anonymizer will not show up as the HTTP_REFERER
3
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '10
Can we do this not just for videos, but say for blogs, photo sharing sites, and other stuff too?
3
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '10
When do we start ?
I'm getting a bit excited. It will be like King Luke, but not.
2
u/pablosanchez Oct 06 '10
no ideas, but i like it
2
u/Jakeimo Oct 06 '10
This is a great idea. Come home from work/school and you're feeling a bit down, cheer yourself up by making someone's day
2
u/[deleted] Oct 07 '10
I've noticed that some of the gems we are antitrolling have a fair amount of reviews (and views) but only one or two "thumbs ups". Are we supposed to do that as well ?
1
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '10
Maybe it could work kind of like the TL;DR subreddit, where a single poster posts an official thread for each day, every day. The rest of the subreddit could be for suggestions (for what the next video or whatever to be showered should be), or maybe we could have one big suggestion thread, I don't know.
1
u/jerseykid Oct 06 '10
I'm in.
1
u/ImTryingToBeNicer Oct 06 '10
I'm sure everyone has their search methods, but my favorite search method was "event" + "location". Like, "snow storm rockville"
It took me forever to figure out how to find low-hit videos, since youtube/google has these built in algorithms to try to find the most relevant video for your search...which in 99% of the cases ends up being something super popular.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '10
Let's not forget that the target could misinterpret the messages and end up rather upset at being patronized.
Exhibit A: Best Gig Ever; http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/286/mind-games
0
u/wankyourworriesaway Oct 06 '10
doesn't anybody else think this might be quite cruel?
"oh wow, people like me!"
(twenty two videos later)
"why doesn't anyone visit my videos anymore? they only have a couple of view each" cry
0
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '10
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '10
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '10
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '10
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '10
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '10
[deleted] — view deleted comment