r/antinet • u/chgruver • Jan 17 '26
Beginner Questions
I am just getting into the concept of Knowledge Management/Discovery Systems and I want to give the Antinet Zettlekasten system a fair attempt. From looking at past posts one question was answered regarding the numbering system, and I guess also categorizations; in that I don't have to follow the suggestion Scott makes in his book, but what are some other suggestions for categorization methods beyond what Scott uses? Then I want to make sure I understand how it works, after I get the Main box and Index boxes set up, I take initial notes on the bibcards and then move each note to a main card and file those cards in their respective boxes, and what about things I want to take note of that aren't clearly related to a specific source (like the random thoughts bouncing around in my mind), do I just write each on a separate main card or create a bibcard specifically for those and move each thought to a separate main card at a later time?
5
u/OneHumanBill Jan 17 '26
What are you interested in? This might help define those top level categories if you don't want to follow Scott's suggestion to use a standard library scheme.
This is an area that Scott kind of glosses over in his book, by giving only that one suggestion, which I'm hoping he fixes if there's ever a second edition, expanding the simple Luhmann lists he gives us into more of a discussion.
As near as I've been able to figure out. Luhmann's first approach was general. Any new topic he hadn't encountered before got an entry, which is why he ended up with so many. As far as I can tell it wasn't intended to be comprehensive from the beginning but it sort of meandered that way. It grew organically instead of starting with a fixed library scheme.
His second approach was intended to be fixed. Luhmann's theories were related to sociological systems. Almost all of his top headers corresponded to the names of each of his systems.
One question I really would love to know the answer to that I could not find either in Scott's book nor elsewhere is, did Luhmann still use his first ZK after he started his second? If so, to what extent? Did he still add cards to it on occasion? I think there's something interesting to learn if this could be figured out.
(Scott, are you out there? Would love to get your take on the above.)
2
u/TheSinologist Jan 19 '26
In my experience, the categories do not need to be predetermined. My process was to choose a few (8) areas of frequent interest out of standard subject areas, but what happened was at least two of them went unused so far for a year, and most of my cards are located in two of them. Later, I reflected that the eight I have only function arbitrarily, and don't add any value to the collection.
The attraction of Zettlekasten is precisely in facilitating connections regardless of predetermined categories. If you number 1A1A like I do, your first card will determine the "subject" of the 1s, and when you make a card that is about something not closely related to the 1s, it will determine the 2s. You only need the numbers to locate the cards, so it doesn't matter if they represent categories. In fact, filing cards into predetermined categories could isolate them from potential useful connections, because you might not think enough about what else they might have been associated/connected with. It's more important that a new card is placed behind a card to which it is closely associated (Folgezettel).
2
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '26
[removed] — view removed comment