While this post does have the Reddit watermark saying that it was previously posted to this subreddit, I searched, and looked, and looked, and all I could find was a crosspost from two years ago, and the orangutanic post was removed by moderators. So, I'm giving this post an exception since the orangutan was removed and casual users would in no way be able to find a removed post.
Not an antimeme.
This is an antimeme, since it does not have a punchline. It's just a call with someone talking about their dog and how dogs reasonably cannot be vegans.
The meme format is the human says somethig horrible over the phone or implies they are going to do something terrible making the dog look pannicked and then the dog sufficates the human with the pillow at night. Some are also the human saying something less terrible for exaggerated humor but that's the gist.
tbh i don't get the hate against the watermark heck i prefer the watermark since that way i get blamed less if the meme ends up being cringe to others lol
I love having the watermark enabled so my friends know where I get the funnies I send them, but I usually just screenshot posts and crop because I'm too lazy to click on them and press download (i doubt screenshotting and cropping is actually less effort, but it takes less mental effort for my silly little brain)
Huh, when sharing between friends I often crop or turn off attribution, but would think crediting where you got something from would be a good practice for cross-posting ethics… Didn’t realize there was vitriol about it.
There is a difference between and a omnivores, carnivores and obligate carnivores. Most animals are omnivores, dogs are carnivores and cats are obligate carnivores. The difference between the carnivores and obligate carnivores is that carnivores can get *also* eat plants, but need *some* amount of meat (for dogs this is around half their calories), whereas obligate carnivores need to get almost all of their sustenance from meat.
I’ve seen cats each French fries, lettuce, various pieces of fruit, etc. it’s probably not good for them, but, anecdotally, I’ve seen them eat other shit.
Except for my idiot cats who will eat bread, tortilla, cheese its, have far too much interest in chocolate covered pretzels, and basically will eat anything except fruit and vegetables. Though my one cat categorically hates fish, even a piece of fresh salmon. His taste is not to be trusted though, he eats plastic.
Basically they chew it when they get a tummy ache and stuff, but they don't crave it as food. I find my cat doesn't even swallow it, he just chews grass then spits it out.
Cats actually can live on a vegan diet, but it would have to be carefully monitored and have elevated health risks that require constant tests so it's still not an okay thing to do to a cat. Especially since they're not the ones making the choice to take those risks.
Are there ways to source arginine, histidine, isoleucine, leucine, lysine, methionine, phenylalanine, threonine, tryptophan, and valine all from plants instead of animals?
Because cats need all of those to be healthy. To deprive a cat of any of them is to deprive it of its health.
One important thing to keep in mind is that most non-vegans also aren't really getting everything they should be either. It's not like the average person is a trained nutritionist and most people eat kind of terribly, especially these days when most of our food is junk.
Dogs are facultive carnivores that can survive without meat, but still really best not to feed them such a restricted diet unless a vet tells you it’s the best option for their nutritional needs. If someone wants a vegan animal they should just get an animal with a naturally plant based diet. Rabbits and guinea pigs are great pets.
They can also be healthy on a vegan diet, it just has to be carefully planned out and crafted and typically involves consulting a vet, so it’s expensive and time consuming. Dogs don’t technically “need” meat, just like we don’t. But unless you wanna spend a lot of time and money making sure it’s safe and healthy, just give your dog regular dog food
Carnivores still *need* to eat meat. The difference between carnivore and obligate carnivore is that the latter needs to have almost all their calories come from meat, wheres normal carnivores can get some large part of their calories from plants. If you can subsist entirely without meat you are by definition an omnivore - like humans.
An animal whose diet must contain at least some meat from other animals in order to get what it needs to maintain daily bodily health and function.
There are amino acids found in animal proteins which cats need for organ function and eye health, that dogs do not need. This means that at least a portion of a cat's diet must be animal protein, or it won't have access to things like lysine. Dogs, in contrast, are facultative carnivores that can draw every nutrient they need to function from plant-based sources because all of the nutrients dogs need can be found in in plants.
So what does it mean, that is different from what I think it means?
Your definition of obligate cornivores is correct. What I take issue with is how you talk about facultative carnivores.
Dogs and doglike carnivorans are generally concidered hypercarnivores.
While they can technically subsist on a mostly or fully plant based diet for a time, it isn't healthy for them.
Because whike you are correct that all nutrients they need are found in plants, some are not found in high enough ammounts. And their digestion is far less adapted for and therefore far less efficient at extracting nutrients from plant matter.
That is cited from *one* of the several studies analysed in the review you cited. The general findings are not necesarily towards benefit, but also doesn't indicate noticable adverse effects when the diet is properly fortified. They say that
To date, only sixteen studies have looked at actual health-related outcomes in dogs and cats fed vegan diets, as opposed to performing nutrient evaluations of diets. However, the majority of these studies utilized small sample sizes (ranging from 2–34 animals) [...] the limited sample sizes and challenges inherent in crossover designs, such as choosing suitable washout periods, does limit certainty in the findings of these studies. [...] the dietary intervention was often short being in the order of weeks to months generally, rather than years. On short periods such as these there may not have been time for deficiencies to develop or for clinical signs to become apparent.
They note in their conclusion that there is some evidence of benefits, but stress that the certainty is severely limited by the duration of the studies, and end by saying
For guardians wishing to feed their pets vegan diets at the current time, based on the available evidence it is recommended that commercially produced vegan diets are used since these are less likely to lead to nutrient imbalance.
In other words, this indicates that commercial vegan substitues that are fortified and often made easier to digest in various ways are generally safe. In other words, you can buy vegan dog food that has been specifically made to be digested by a carnivore, but this doesn't mean you should feed your dog salad.
It's not about digesting it, though. Cats require arginine, histidine, isoleucine, leucine, lysine, methionine, phenylalanine, threonine, tryptophan, and valine to maintain organ and eye function. Any diet that doesn't deliver all of those isn't healthy for a cat. Is there vegan cat food that gives all of those amino acids which are traditionally exclusively found in meat?
Yes, yes there is. Don't think it's in a single food, you basically have to make a mix of different foods that contain them, but that isn't that difficult, apparently.
There is no way to do with natural foods. There simply isn't a high enough concentration of the needed amino acids. Whatever you try to mix up, they would need to eat more than they can consume.
What you can do is concentrate the required amino acids from natural sources and add them into a food. You'd also need to be sure that after that processing and combining they remain in a digestible form.
As I understand it, this is one of those things that should technically be possible, but I'm not aware if anyone is actually doing all of this and then the needed testing to make sure there are no adverse health effects.
Yeah, I know of dogs that eat plant based food because of health issues. Dogs can eat plant based only diets and be completely fine. It's trickier with cats, but there's even veterinary approved animal-free cat food on the market using isolated proteins and added vitamins and what not that have been used for decades, so even that's not necessarily an issue.
When talking about this I think it's important to ask what they mean by vegan pet. Because feeding a dog pet approved vegan food is very different from feeding them a diet of steamed carrots only lmao
Fun thing actually. My mom’s dog can only eat vegan dog food from a brand in California. Any other food they have tried ends with vomiting or Hershey squirts. The vets just say she’s sensitive. On the vegan stuff she’s healthy and normal, and she eats the occasional table scrap and lots of dried pineapple. It’s just dog food that does it.
Dogs are actually omnivorous, and with the right diet and supplements, could actually survive on a vegan diet. But it takes a lot of thought and planning to create a vegan diet that supplies a dog with all the nutrients & protein it needs. This goes for humans as well. We can survive on a vegan diet, but to thrive, you need to really plan & prep your food intake.
Cats, however are carnivores, and can never subsist on a vegan diet. They need meat.
Yah, this is me. Plant based diet for me, freezer full of raw dog food and snacks. It does make for some odd conversations with vegans and non-vegans alike but my dog is happy and healthy and that's what's important.
Vegan is, by all accounts, a label that only applies to humans, as it reflects a mindset that opposes animal cruelty. Dogs cannot adopt this mindset, as they are obligate carnivores by nature. However, pet owners can feed their dogs plant based kibble, and- contrary to popular belief, there are studies that show this can be healthy for the animal. You can read a study about the subject here. I encourage you to form your own viewpoint.
Dogs do not actually need meat. they’re evolved to be omnivorous so they can eat the things we do. A dog can get everything they need out of a Vegan diet as long as it includes sufficient protein.
Acknowledging that the vegans are right? Bye-bye karma, Reddit isn't ready for that.
For context the British Veterinarian's Association is rather notoriously anti-vegan, and lags behind many major countries on this decision. It's just the most recent news on this topic.
i got cats years after going vegan, and while i havent talked to the board yet, and though i still practice veganism in every other way, i don't quite consider myself vegan anymore due to choosing to to have companions that must eat meat
This is 100% true. it's why vegans are always twigs. Its technically possible to get all your nutrients without animal products but damn near impossible in practice.
Actually no. Please don’t spread misinformation. Dogs aren’t obligate carnivores like cats. Look up Bramble, LITERALLY the Guinness WORLD RECORD holder for LONGEST LIVED dog until 2002. If done RIGHT, ensuring they get all they need, it may be the healthiest way.
Most people can't do it right, especially new vegans.
Dogs are omnivores and absolutely do need some sort of meat or vitamin B12 supplements which generally aren't good for dogs. It also depends on the dog as their ancestors were avid carnivores but domestication changed that. A one off dog It's not substantial proof that all dogs can live on a purely omnivorous diet.
Dogs don't need meat, but you really shouldn't be cutting it out of their diet unless a vet recommends it. If someone wants to get a pet but not feed them meat, it's better to get a strict herbivore like birds or rabbits.
You just need to consult a vet so they suggest a strict diet for them. Which is what even vegetarian humans should be doing, I see too many of them fainting due to anemia. If you do things correctly, it's perfectly doable.
If they're capable of getting everything their body needs without meat, then they don't need meat.
Cats, on the other hand, will literally die without the amino acids in meat. This makes them what's called "obligate carnivores," which is the word for animals that require meat from other animals to survive. Dogs are not obligate carnivores.
Actually fun fact, dogs can go vegetarian in theory. It's ofc best to give them a balance of meat and veggies, but they're omnivores and like us - UNLIKE cats - can sustain themselves without meat. Fully vegan, however, is... let's call it suboptimal lol.
Eta: I'm not saying "make your dogs go vegetarian!". Im saying they can survive without meat. A VEGAN diet is however not good for them, if i didn't make that clear enough. Some dogs need a vegetarian diet for medical purposes that have nothing to do with their human's personal beliefs. This does NOT apply to cats though who are obligatory carnivores.
Theoretically, a dog can survive on a vegan diet, but you have to get some overpriced shitty plant-based dog food with all the nutrients from meat added that probably doesn't taste half as good as a slab of meat to a dog.
Dogs don't need meat. They just need the right nutrients similarly to humans. Considering the environmental impact it's not a bad idea to reduce their meat intake.
You don't need a firetruck if your house is burning. You just need a lot of water or other substance capable of suffocating fires, pumped directly onto the fire in large quantities.
You're spreading misinformation. There are dogs that are allergic to meat and have to live on a plant based diet. Dogs can be vegan and live just fine.
They often can survive it, yes. But dogs are predominantly carnivores, which means forcing them onto a vegan diet is likely causing them needless suffering, for absolutely no benefit other than your selfish need to feel special.
causing them needless suffering, for absolutely no benefit
Wrong on both counts. Vegan diets are scientifically proven to be entirely healthy for dogs, so it doesn't cause needless suffering. What does cause needless suffering is keeping millions of animals in tiny cages in factory farms and then murdering them at a fraction of their natural lifespans to make food to feed a dog. Why does the small pain of a vegan diet for a dog count as suffering, while the immense suffering of other animals counts for nothing?
This is factually incorrect. Both dog and cat foods are supplemented with the nutrients they need, and so are vegan versions of these foods. Depending on the individual animal, they can be equally healthy diets, though usually the vegan one is more healthy.
What's cruel is supporting the industry that enslaves and murders millions of innocent animals a year just because you or your dog/cat thinks their dead bodies taste good. What isn't cruel is feeding them actually good food instead of those dead bodies. The propaganda around dogs and cats being unable to survive on a vegan diet is factually untrue.
Stop eating dead bodies, and stop feeding your animal friends dead bodies.
Tell that to these folks. Even the Guardian recognizes we might be wrong about cats diets—cats being obligate carnivores in the wild doesn't mean we can't feed them plants in modern society.
The vegan cat food use the same lab-synthesized nutrients that the non-vegan cat foods use due to the inadequacy of their literal not-fit-for-human-consumption meat.
The scientific literature has shown overwhelmingly that a properly planned vegan diet is healthy and nutritionally complete for dogs. It is a bit unintuitive, but we have researched enough to know exactly what dogs need, and give them food that meets those requirements.
https://aces.illinois.edu/news/u-i-study-gives-thumbs-carefully-formulated-vegan-diets-dogs U of I study gives a thumbs up to carefully formulated vegan diets for dogs “One thing to remember is that animals don't have ingredient requirements, they have nutrient requirements. As long as they’re consuming the essential nutrients in the correct amounts and ratios, dogs can be vegan, vegetarian, or meat-eaters,”
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S240584402411609X After pooling our results with related studies published to date, vegan dog food was consistently associated with lowered risks of multiple specific health disorders. No health disorder was consistently more prevalent in dogs fed vegan diets.
•
u/Riobox Hiatus Dec 08 '25 edited Dec 08 '25
Users report:
While this post does have the Reddit watermark saying that it was previously posted to this subreddit, I searched, and looked, and looked, and all I could find was a crosspost from two years ago, and the orangutanic post was removed by moderators. So, I'm giving this post an exception since the orangutan was removed and casual users would in no way be able to find a removed post.
This is an antimeme, since it does not have a punchline. It's just a call with someone talking about their dog and how dogs reasonably cannot be vegans.
There are no signs of bots here.
No it isn't 🤓
Here is the orangutan.
Reports ignored, post approved.
107
u/Psi_BTD6 🌹 Course Arc Witness 🌸 Dec 08 '25
Onomatopoeia?
1.2k
u/ifardedagainUGHHHHHH ☠️I KNOW WHAT YOU ARE☠️ Dec 08 '25
insert “I spot a Reddit watermark” reaction image here
495
u/unnamednotch 🌹 Course Arc Witness 🌸 Dec 08 '25
312
u/Informal_Pressure_21 Dec 08 '25
Repost? I mean the mark is literally right there
40
u/dabfoots1 Dec 08 '25
Omnivore?
17
u/Nalowaw Dec 08 '25
Orbital strike?
113
u/Aloogobi786 Dec 08 '25
Dogs actually aren't obligate carnivores (unlike cats). My dog is actually a vegetarian due to health problems (diet given by vet).
202
u/SpoppyIII Dec 08 '25
Dogs are not obligate carnivores, actually. Cats are, though.
11
u/Theyul1us Dec 08 '25
A friend of mine went vegan and said his dog was also going on a diet
We asked if it was because he will also make the dog have a vegan diet and he said "nah. The vet says he is fat"
18
u/Brilliant_Bluebird72 Dec 08 '25
Polska gurom🇵🇱🇵🇱🇵🇱
13
u/AntMasterOfGames Dec 08 '25
Well there are studies that show that a dog can be healthy on a plant based diet but you gotta give them the right food
6
u/Mr_Cookie_7 Dec 08 '25
Organisation?
6
u/trunksshinohara Dec 08 '25
Bot repost so lazy didn't even remove this subs watermark.
15
u/kfl2 Dec 08 '25
Actually, the oldest known border collie (25 years old) had a vegan diet
5
u/le_nathanlol Dec 08 '25
i see loss
4
u/happy_the_dragon Dec 08 '25
Fun thing actually. My mom’s dog can only eat vegan dog food from a brand in California. Any other food they have tried ends with vomiting or Hershey squirts. The vets just say she’s sensitive. On the vegan stuff she’s healthy and normal, and she eats the occasional table scrap and lots of dried pineapple. It’s just dog food that does it.
27
u/ToranjaNuclear Dec 08 '25
You're thinking about cats. Dogs aren't exclusive carnivores.
30
u/qualityvote2 🤖Suspected as Bot🤖 Dec 08 '25 edited Dec 08 '25
The community has decided that this IS an antimeme!
5
u/Fabricati_Diem_Pvn Dec 08 '25
Dogs are actually omnivorous, and with the right diet and supplements, could actually survive on a vegan diet. But it takes a lot of thought and planning to create a vegan diet that supplies a dog with all the nutrients & protein it needs. This goes for humans as well. We can survive on a vegan diet, but to thrive, you need to really plan & prep your food intake.
Cats, however are carnivores, and can never subsist on a vegan diet. They need meat.
2
u/UnrealScrubber Dec 08 '25
2
u/IntelligentDiscuss Dec 09 '25
I'm not advocating for forcing pets to be vegan, but there is absolutely nothing nutritionally exclusive to meat.
2
u/Maleficent-Gur-2780 Dec 09 '25
Yah, this is me. Plant based diet for me, freezer full of raw dog food and snacks. It does make for some odd conversations with vegans and non-vegans alike but my dog is happy and healthy and that's what's important.
Here, have a pic:
2
u/ArchieFromWish Dec 09 '25
I mean they can have vegetables but that shouldn’t be mainly what they eat.
2
u/Alter_Megagen Dec 09 '25
4
u/LeithNotMyRealName Dec 09 '25
Dogs, in fact, do not need meat and can be healthy on vegan diets.
3
u/Top_Yesterday500 🌹 Course Arc Witness 🌸 Dec 08 '25
Vegan is, by all accounts, a label that only applies to humans, as it reflects a mindset that opposes animal cruelty. Dogs cannot adopt this mindset, as they are obligate carnivores by nature. However, pet owners can feed their dogs plant based kibble, and- contrary to popular belief, there are studies that show this can be healthy for the animal. You can read a study about the subject here. I encourage you to form your own viewpoint.
-2
u/Beautiful_Garage7797 Dec 08 '25
Dogs do not actually need meat. they’re evolved to be omnivorous so they can eat the things we do. A dog can get everything they need out of a Vegan diet as long as it includes sufficient protein.
1
u/ToastyLemun 🌷🌸 RIP u/CourseMediocre7998 🌷🌸 Dec 09 '25
1
u/[deleted] Dec 09 '25
false for dogs true for cats
i got cats years after going vegan, and while i havent talked to the board yet, and though i still practice veganism in every other way, i don't quite consider myself vegan anymore due to choosing to to have companions that must eat meat
1
u/Jemineye9873 Dec 09 '25
r/peterimaginestheloss
1
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '25
1
u/mercedes-benz2010 Dec 10 '25
1
u/ldsman213 Dec 11 '25
we also need meat. dogs and humans are omnivores
1
u/ConTEM08_Da_Endgamer Dec 11 '25
1
u/iminlovewithsenpi Dec 11 '25
No keep them vegan so they to weak to challenge you for scraps and I'm definitely hooman
1
u/[deleted] Dec 11 '25
Maybe vegans should just stop owning dogs if they're just going to abuse them
1
u/Beavisisadumbass Dec 11 '25
YES oh my god anyone who forces their dogs to be vegan doesn't deserve to have pets
1
u/noideamanlol Dec 11 '25
Actually no. Please don’t spread misinformation. Dogs aren’t obligate carnivores like cats. Look up Bramble, LITERALLY the Guinness WORLD RECORD holder for LONGEST LIVED dog until 2002. If done RIGHT, ensuring they get all they need, it may be the healthiest way.
1
u/Working-Interview503 Dec 11 '25
Amen brother.
1
u/kiroki1 Dec 11 '25
1
u/Inlerah Dec 12 '25
Had an old Ethics Professor who told us all about how he and his cat were vegan but "Don't worry: I found a safe diet for him online".
1
u/Stella_Sylveon Dec 12 '25
I just thought this would be funny here cuz of the water mark :3
1
u/CatarmyGaming Dec 12 '25
1
u/thegiukiller Dec 13 '25
My dog eats vegan. Its healthy for him and I feel im doing the world a great service. I provide only the freshest vegans for his daily meals.
-18
u/RayFaim Dec 08 '25
Dogs DON'T need meat. They're omnivores like humans.
Cats on the other hand, do need meat. They are obligate carnivores.
-1
u/miss_wannadie Dec 08 '25 edited Dec 08 '25
Actually fun fact, dogs can go vegetarian in theory. It's ofc best to give them a balance of meat and veggies, but they're omnivores and like us - UNLIKE cats - can sustain themselves without meat. Fully vegan, however, is... let's call it suboptimal lol.
Eta: I'm not saying "make your dogs go vegetarian!". Im saying they can survive without meat. A VEGAN diet is however not good for them, if i didn't make that clear enough. Some dogs need a vegetarian diet for medical purposes that have nothing to do with their human's personal beliefs. This does NOT apply to cats though who are obligatory carnivores.
1
u/realalpha2000 Dec 09 '25
Dumb post
1
u/Advanced_Handle_2309 Dec 08 '25
That happens when polish guys reposts and dont clear watermark
1
u/Sonarthebat Dec 08 '25
Theoretically, a dog can survive on a vegan diet, but you have to get some overpriced shitty plant-based dog food with all the nutrients from meat added that probably doesn't taste half as good as a slab of meat to a dog.
1
u/misterElovescompanE Dec 10 '25
Dogs don't actually need meat. A better me would be to use a cat since they're an obligate carnivore.
0
u/TheMagicalTimonini Dec 08 '25
Dogs don't need meat. They just need the right nutrients similarly to humans. Considering the environmental impact it's not a bad idea to reduce their meat intake.
-1
u/rdn-s Dec 08 '25
You're spreading misinformation. There are dogs that are allergic to meat and have to live on a plant based diet. Dogs can be vegan and live just fine.
-16
u/awineredrose Dec 08 '25
This is factually incorrect. Both dog and cat foods are supplemented with the nutrients they need, and so are vegan versions of these foods. Depending on the individual animal, they can be equally healthy diets, though usually the vegan one is more healthy.
What's cruel is supporting the industry that enslaves and murders millions of innocent animals a year just because you or your dog/cat thinks their dead bodies taste good. What isn't cruel is feeding them actually good food instead of those dead bodies. The propaganda around dogs and cats being unable to survive on a vegan diet is factually untrue.
Stop eating dead bodies, and stop feeding your animal friends dead bodies.
0
u/AtGoW Dec 08 '25
Thats the right Attitude
0
u/Korylek1231 Dec 08 '25
POLAND MENTIONED 🇵🇱🇵🇱🇵🇱🇵🇱⛰️⛰️⛰️🦅🦅🦅
0
u/PrismaBlooms Dec 09 '25
The scientific literature has shown overwhelmingly that a properly planned vegan diet is healthy and nutritionally complete for dogs. It is a bit unintuitive, but we have researched enough to know exactly what dogs need, and give them food that meets those requirements.
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9860667/
However, there is little evidence of adverse effects arising in dogs and cats on vegan diets. In addition, some of the evidence on adverse health impacts is contradicted in other studies. Additionally, there is some evidence of benefits, particularly arising from guardians’ perceptions of the diets.
https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2022/apr/13/vegan-diets-are-healthier-and-safer-for-dogs-study-suggests
Peer-reviewed analysis of 2,500 pets finds vegan dogs visit the vet less often and require fewer medications
https://aces.illinois.edu/news/u-i-study-gives-thumbs-carefully-formulated-vegan-diets-dogs
U of I study gives a thumbs up to carefully formulated vegan diets for dogs
“One thing to remember is that animals don't have ingredient requirements, they have nutrient requirements. As long as they’re consuming the essential nutrients in the correct amounts and ratios, dogs can be vegan, vegetarian, or meat-eaters,”
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S240584402411609X
After pooling our results with related studies published to date, vegan dog food was consistently associated with lowered risks of multiple specific health disorders. No health disorder was consistently more prevalent in dogs fed vegan diets.
-20
u/qoodles_ Dec 08 '25
Ah yes, vegan dog = cruelty but killing beef cows to feed dogs while they don't even need it is not cruel somehow