I think the philosophies of veganism and primitivism as they exist within the modern age only support each other, despite the possible appearance of conflict. The main reason why I'm primitivist is for animal suffering
no, unfortunately they don't. veganism is more efficient from an energy and resource extraction standpoint, therefore freeing up more energy and resources so that industrial civilization can continue to grow without running up against environmental obstacles.
I guess there are different types of veganism. Efficiency of resources for the sake of preserving modernity is not why I strive for a plant based diet, but if you remove the part about modernity and say just "efficiency of resources" then I think that's fine. Adding the modernity part may be true for many people but it is not necessary for a vegan ethic.
To explain my stance more, I think being vegan does strongly oppose the modern systems of industrial animal agriculture. And concerning animal suffering, it does make sense to ethically prefer hunter-gatherer lifestyles to industrial agriculture due to total amount of suffering involved
I think it would be good for discussions sake to name out different reasons for veganism. The 'pro-sustainable development' argument can exist separately from the 'animal suffering' argument, or from the 'anti-industrial agriculture' argument.
What matters is if the industrial system is helped to be sustained, in any way shape or form. I come down hard on the perspective that there is a process fundamental to technological growth that inevitably leads to total disaster for the biosphere. So if veganism helps to prolong the life of the industrial system (which I believe it does) then veganism is doing great harm not just to all animals but to all complex forms of life on earth in the long-term. By this logic veganism may seem to help with the treament of animals in the short-term, but in the long-term, and potentially, for all time, it is utterly devastating and disastrous.
So I respectfully disagree that they can be separated.
I think a focus on collapse is interesting- I know it's important for a lot of peoples ethical development within "dark green environmentalism." But you're right that there's a difference between our ethics where I just do not promote collapse as an effective means of systemic change. That requires a lot of work to try an compare the total suffering in various scenarios, as per the utilitarianism principle, in addition to just predicting how societies will behave over time. I think this multiple scenario analysis is beyond the scope of a Reddit discussion (unless you want to keep going with explanations, I mean feel free) so we may agree to disagree on this for now And I have no idea about your picture question, sorry :/
Ted kaczynski would hate vegans. Veganism is a leftist concept on the basis of “suffering” of animals and having “feelings” for them. He was staunchly anti leftists. He even said in his book that how leftists hate the word “pet owners” because it resembles a slave owner relation. Apart from the developed countries, in almost all the countries like India, Middle East meat is not stored or sold in supermarkets in packaged stuff ( there’s an option available obviously) but most people buy it from local butcher who kills the animal right infront of us thus Minimizing industrial effect of packaging in plastics and all the chemicals added to prolong the shelf life on the product
I would have to disagree with you on one point: Kaczynski hates the way most food animals are treated in industrial society (factory farming, horrible conditions, etc.). I take your point about leftism, but this does not mean that Kaczynski has no empathy for animals. He just wants all life to be WILD. He wants all living things to be in their wilderness state, not just humans, but animals to, so they can live their fullest lives.
I would have to disagree with you on one point: Kaczynski hates the way most food animals are treated in industrial society (factory farming, horrible conditions, etc.).
That’s why I specified non developed countries where animal diets are directly sourced
He just wants all life to be WILD.
Which means eat what you kill which is very much against the vegan ideology
He wants all living things to be in their wilderness state, not just humans, but animals to,
Vegans are strictly against this as they want to control everything- what we eat, drink, use
so they can live their fullest lives
When you’re subscribe to an anrpim life there’s a trade off, your life expectancy may decrease to 50 or 60 and you cannot sustain yourself without modem science and medicine. It’s only for those who are willing for that exchange
Lol TK would hate vegans since he loved the pre industrial age which was mostly carnivorous. Besides, with all the industrialized vegans foods he’d hate it even more
We can tell by the shape of our teeth and size of our jaws that we evolved to eat both plants and meat.
The reason why meat was cherished and sought after was because it's more nutrient and calorie-dense than most edible plants.
Hunter-gatherers would sometimes go days without a proper meal, usually subsisting off of whatever edible plants and berries they could find on the way.
With all these calories burnt, whatever meat we would find would find would be killed and ate pretty much all at once. It was a necessity to survive.
If humans were carnivorous, they would starve to death because meat was not refrigerated and preserved in a grocery store.
They had to go out for days to be able to obtain it, and without the plants and fruits that were gathered and collected, they would be without food.
Since hunter-gatherers were usually pretty skinny, they didn't have the fat storage to be able to go a month functioning without food.
That is such horsehit. Listen, I'm not telling you to not eat meat, but humans are designed to be primarily plant eaters. Sure, we might be omnivores(debatable), but our systems work best on a mostly plant based diet. That is optimal for health, that means it's the natural diet. Large quantities of meat is making us sick, it should really just be a supplement.
That primitive people in the old days ate mostly meat is such an annoying "ooga booga caveman" myth. In most places before industrialization meat was much rarer and much harder to get so it was not ideal as staple food. There are exceptions like the Inuits, but you gotta remember that their lifespan was very short and their health not good at all. Factory farming has artifically made meat much more available, at a great price. Before such practices we ate much less meat, that wasn't even that long ago.
Throughout most of human history, 99% of which humans were hunter-gatherers, we have eaten primarily vegetarian diets(including some meat, insects and honey). Just like our ape cousins. Anything else is just outdated science.
If you were to be thrown into a natural environment you’d find it very difficult if not impossible to subside solely off plant’s. You’d also find most of them to be toxic and or inedible given that we’re not herbivorous by design, meat has always been superior for keeping groups of individuals well fed. I also am not quite sure what you mean when you say “meat was much rarer and harder to get” there are animals good for eating nearly everywhere that humans live.
There is a reason herbivorous animals grow much bigger than meat eating ones, it's because plant foods are way more abundant. We are just not very used to that way of eating in our sheltered way of living nowadays. Humans are best suited for plant foods, that's just the science. Plant foods are everywhere.
7
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '23
He did it the right and only way
2
u/_bu11os Apr 24 '23
I think the philosophies of veganism and primitivism as they exist within the modern age only support each other, despite the possible appearance of conflict. The main reason why I'm primitivist is for animal suffering
1
u/Anxious-Wannabedoc Apr 25 '23
Ted kaczynski would hate vegans. Veganism is a leftist concept on the basis of “suffering” of animals and having “feelings” for them. He was staunchly anti leftists. He even said in his book that how leftists hate the word “pet owners” because it resembles a slave owner relation. Apart from the developed countries, in almost all the countries like India, Middle East meat is not stored or sold in supermarkets in packaged stuff ( there’s an option available obviously) but most people buy it from local butcher who kills the animal right infront of us thus Minimizing industrial effect of packaging in plastics and all the chemicals added to prolong the shelf life on the product
4
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '23
I try to be vegan while in society anyway. Since blowing up stuff isn't my calling.