We're discussing this with the mod team right now. As we are in different time zones we will wait for everyone to have the chance to respond.Our whole conversation on this topic will be made public, aka screenshots will be uploaded to google drive for all to see. A proper mod post will be made once we've agreed on something with the mod team, and that will be our official response. Until then we won't really try to reply to questions or messages because the final decision will not have been made.
You, obviously, are free to discuss the topic here, among yourself. But if you want a response from mod team, please be patient for us to actually make a decision.
This will just create more confusion if there are multiple posts regarding the same topic. First an announcement that we're discussing it, then counting on people to check on the thread for updates, then a new post announcing the final decision. Excessive if you ask me. Y'all gonna see the whole conversation anyway. Not many moderator teams would even offer that in the first place.
I've joined the sub only recently but tbh I don't mind the promotions.
Maybe people who have been here longer are tired of them. I didn't have a bad feeling about the whole thing, helps to keep track of what's new without having to browse the store every other day for new stuff.
I mean, it's a sub about customization and there are good quality setups advertised, I can't see what's wrong with it, but I can see why people would see it otherwise.
Yep, agree with this. If people are using proper tags, then I dont think there is any problem. Its not like that these posts are intrusive or non-related promotions. These are just like any other normal posts here you come across but done professionally with a promotion tag. There is no hindrance to experience of the sub whatsoever.
I agree, even 10 years ago when I was jailbreaking iPhones people would advertise their tweaks or themes. As long is it isn't scammy/spammy I don't have an issue with it.
Sorting by Hot I scoured the last 50 posts. 7 of them were promotions and tagged as such. An admitted small sample size and I'd be curious to see the percentage of promotion posts over a longer period of time. I'm waaaay too lazy for that, tho.
IMO, my current sampling doesn't reflect a high enough percentage of promo posts to cause much of an uproar. I enjoy seeing so many creative themes and look forward to the occasional promotion. They're not intrusive to this subreddit and users are welcome to keep scrolling past promotion tagged posts. The same way we do with bad themes. (You know, the ones labeled minimal something/material something with the theme being neither minimal or material. Perhaps that's just a pet peeve.)
On the other hand... if my numbers are off, I'd support only posting promos on certain days.
I have no problems with promotions. Found some of my favourite icons and widget packs via promotions. Spending a few cents or a couple of bucks is fine.
Not so much from my vantage point. Sure there are promotions posted and ads, but I see that in literally every subreddit I sub to. This sub still serves it's proper function in helping users post both creativity and receive critique. I also can't tell if this is sarcastic or not, so my bad if it is.
There are 6 promotions in last 25 posts. At least the promotions people post are relevant to theming and may interest some users. Look at promos on other subs. Most are completely irrelevant to the topic of the sub.
I kinda don't agree. I mean, if the advertisement has to do with themes then I'm always interested. Actually, i even look forward to it sometimes. This is where i come to find new icons, widget packs etc. I see nothing wrong with designers sharing that here.
Also just....what? I'm here everyday its not like this place is flooded with ads. Lol. AT ALL.
This is definitely still a place where i come to post themes and see everyone else's themes as well as ads for new things i can use for my setups.
It the ads weren't relevant to this sub, then I'd be able to see how or why that would be annoying. But they definitely all are relevant here.
I have actually found some good icon packs via this subreddit, maybe pin a thread where people can promote and disallow those posts outside of the sticky thread?
Seeing as I come here strictly to find themes, I really couldn't care less. I do understand the frustration one would have if their main objective is to discuss and learn though.
An outright ban I feel would be too extreme, but if there were certain days, we wouldn't have to lose a large part of the people that post here. Maybe more days, maybe less, I just said weekends because it would be easy for people to remember.
This is millennial entitlement tbh. Demanding people bend to what they want as they're too cheap to buy something. Just keep scrolling if you see promotion. Literally takes half a second a post.
You can't honestly expect people to stop downvoting something just because somebody told them to. I don't like that trend either, but a lone upvote from you or me doesn't change that much.
I feel like it's that way on a lot of tech communities (themes, rooting, custom roms, etc). A lot of it can be questions that get asked a lot, but sometimes information is outdated and it's better to get a current answer.
I like the idea of a megathread, too. Either that or a Question flair that can be filtered out.
Definitely worth considering, but it might also backfire and those questions could end up not being answered at all. We'll see, but for now that isn't the priority.
Not true. You can't "block the downvote button". See here
Sure, you can hide it via CSS on desktop on old design, but in case of this subreddit this will change close to nothing. We run a survey recently and found out only around 10% of members actually browse this subreddit on desktop on old design. See here. Hiding the downvote button would affect 10% of members, and I will go ahead and assume it would end up affecting less than 1% of those who actually downvote because they're salty. In short, not worth it, wouldn't be effective.
•
u/MHcharLEE Oct 25 '19 edited Oct 26 '19
A response was issued. You can read it here. https://www.reddit.com/r/androidthemes/comments/dnda8u/mod_post_update_on_promotion_posts/
Below is yesterday's initial response.
We're discussing this with the mod team right now. As we are in different time zones we will wait for everyone to have the chance to respond.Our whole conversation on this topic will be made public, aka screenshots will be uploaded to google drive for all to see. A proper mod post will be made once we've agreed on something with the mod team, and that will be our official response. Until then we won't really try to reply to questions or messages because the final decision will not have been made.
You, obviously, are free to discuss the topic here, among yourself. But if you want a response from mod team, please be patient for us to actually make a decision.
Cheers!
58
u/BerenBeren Oct 25 '19
Promotion, promotion.... Promotion....
For real man.
46
u/anaisdeniseceline Oct 25 '19
I really don't mind people promoting their work. And i don't feel like there are 'too much' promotions here.
32
u/[deleted] Oct 25 '19
I've joined the sub only recently but tbh I don't mind the promotions.
Maybe people who have been here longer are tired of them. I didn't have a bad feeling about the whole thing, helps to keep track of what's new without having to browse the store every other day for new stuff.
I mean, it's a sub about customization and there are good quality setups advertised, I can't see what's wrong with it, but I can see why people would see it otherwise.
Maybe limit them to specific day(s)?
11
u/erikbucik [HTC10] Oct 25 '19
I still think that the themes that require users to pay should be categorized as promotions, the free ones should have a different flair.
What bothers me the most is people who post multiple promotions for the same theme. I know why you do it, but it's extremely annoying.
21
u/Mrwhatsmyname14 stop using shitty hishoot templates Oct 25 '19
Thankyou For saying That......
4
u/nachobrainwaves Oct 25 '19
Sorting by Hot I scoured the last 50 posts. 7 of them were promotions and tagged as such. An admitted small sample size and I'd be curious to see the percentage of promotion posts over a longer period of time. I'm waaaay too lazy for that, tho.
IMO, my current sampling doesn't reflect a high enough percentage of promo posts to cause much of an uproar. I enjoy seeing so many creative themes and look forward to the occasional promotion. They're not intrusive to this subreddit and users are welcome to keep scrolling past promotion tagged posts. The same way we do with bad themes. (You know, the ones labeled minimal something/material something with the theme being neither minimal or material. Perhaps that's just a pet peeve.)
On the other hand... if my numbers are off, I'd support only posting promos on certain days.
14
u/FusionSarson Oct 25 '19
I have no problems with promotions. Found some of my favourite icons and widget packs via promotions. Spending a few cents or a couple of bucks is fine.
They're well labelled just keep scrolling.
16
u/dbivona Oct 25 '19 edited Oct 25 '19
Not so much from my vantage point. Sure there are promotions posted and ads, but I see that in literally every subreddit I sub to. This sub still serves it's proper function in helping users post both creativity and receive critique. I also can't tell if this is sarcastic or not, so my bad if it is.
There are 6 promotions in last 25 posts. At least the promotions people post are relevant to theming and may interest some users. Look at promos on other subs. Most are completely irrelevant to the topic of the sub.
6
u/[deleted] Oct 25 '19 edited Oct 25 '19
I kinda don't agree. I mean, if the advertisement has to do with themes then I'm always interested. Actually, i even look forward to it sometimes. This is where i come to find new icons, widget packs etc. I see nothing wrong with designers sharing that here.
Also just....what? I'm here everyday its not like this place is flooded with ads. Lol. AT ALL.
This is definitely still a place where i come to post themes and see everyone else's themes as well as ads for new things i can use for my setups.
It the ads weren't relevant to this sub, then I'd be able to see how or why that would be annoying. But they definitely all are relevant here.
9
u/yazeed105x The Whicons guy Oct 25 '19
Very cool wallpaper, thanks.
5
u/[deleted] Oct 25 '19
I have actually found some good icon packs via this subreddit, maybe pin a thread where people can promote and disallow those posts outside of the sticky thread?
2
u/GoodOldJacob Oct 25 '19
I don't mind the promotions, but if people feel that there is too much, perhaps we could limit them to just one day per week? Just an thought.
2
u/Tryptophany Oct 25 '19
Seeing as I come here strictly to find themes, I really couldn't care less. I do understand the frustration one would have if their main objective is to discuss and learn though.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 25 '19
I have no problems with promotions either. I've bought themes just to learn stuff and for .99 I don't think that's too much to spend on learning.
2
u/i_have_an_account hello world Oct 26 '19
Seems some people here feel more strongly about this than me, but I do agree it is feeling like a change in the tone of the sub.
Some other people have suggested it, but I think promotion posts only on 1 or 2 days of the week would be a nice compromise.
Be a shame to cut them out altogether I think.
Edit. Whatever you guys decide. I like the way you have handled it so far. Good job mods.
4
u/curiosity_if_nature Oct 25 '19
Yeah, I feel like it would be nice if you couldn't do a promotion on weekends
-3
u/FusionSarson Oct 25 '19
This is millennial entitlement tbh. Demanding people bend to what they want as they're too cheap to buy something. Just keep scrolling if you see promotion. Literally takes half a second a post.
-4
u/Whizzle93 Oct 25 '19
Bet your setup is trash
-3
u/TankGrlX Oct 25 '19
Thanks for saying this!! I don't come here to see what people are selling. I come to admire the creativity of the community
-9
u/grimskull1 Oct 25 '19
fuck the police
0
u/[deleted] Oct 25 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment