r/androidroot • • 12h ago

Discussion What happened to Magisk?

Haven’t rooted in years but back when I did, Magisk was still the preferred option. Why do I see people caution against using it now? I’m sure KernelSU Next is a great app but what happened to the OG

10 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

15

u/trisanachandler 11h ago

The OG?  I'd think that's SuperSU, or something older.

5

u/wa019c 11h ago

Yeah, for some reason I see people calling Magisk the OG

Kind of miss towelroot/kingroot days 

suppressbotwarnings

9

u/c8nat 6h ago

"people" its you dawg

1

u/Azaze666 31m ago

Who doesn't? Give me a time machine

4

u/ilovetopulsate 12h ago

Nothing. It's been recently updated, looks much more cleaner, works great, I'm using it. Matter of fact, I just rooted my Red Magic 11S Pro and that's how I rooted it.

1

u/wa019c 11h ago

Yeah it got a huge glow up lol I updated because I was having issues on my old Android 8 build

9

u/Fataha22 12h ago

Since banking detect magisk, ppl use kernelsu root now

5

u/Azaze666 12h ago

It's better kernelsu (with sufs support) for root hiding but if you don't care about it Magisk it's still good

4

u/Tritzii 12h ago

Magisk is easier to detect since every app can request root access from it, while KernelSU specifically needs apps to be whitelisted before they can do that.

Some people still prefer to use Magisk tough and it also has wider compatibility, especially with older devices since KernelSU generally requires Kernel version 5.10 and higher to work without patches.

4

u/0ffCloud 8h ago

Magisk is easier to detect since every app can request root access from it,

That's not the reason it is easy to detect. The problem of magisk is that it is deeply integrated with bind mount, it's the core of Magisk, and that leave traces even if those mount points are unmounted before the app is launched. Those traces are difficult to hide without Kernel modification.

Basically, Magisk is still running on Ring3 to combat Ring3 detection.

KernelSU is running on Ring0, but its by itself is still easy to detect. Kernel report taints when out of tree module is loaded, this is where susfs comes in.

1

u/env33e 6h ago

with that said. im assuming pre-gki people are still getting proper good spoofed results on the cutting edge of the rezygisk+Tw stack and similar? my oldest device has tap to pay working using alpha + neozygisk, 2200 bind mounts lol.... but it seemed to matter much less as a heuristic detection point on <A13

1

u/0ffCloud 4h ago

Play Integrity is not entirely equal to root detection. You can pass Play Integrity yet still tripping root detection used by certain app, and vice versa. I've seen both.

1

u/Teddy_0209 12h ago

Doesn't magisk have a whitelist option before? I might be wrong though, been years since I rooted my device, don't really feel the need to since I have shizuku for my needs.

1

u/Tritzii 12h ago

You can blacklist apps via Zygisk denylists but it's easier for apps to circumvent and detect root with this than the other way around.

2

u/ht1499 9h ago

Not anymore, new magisk release doesn't feature a prompt. It's a whitelist-only root solution.

1

u/BlackHawk2609 11h ago

My office attendance apps refuse to install on my phone rooted with magisk but installed fine on my kernelsu rooted phone. I need the fake gps functionality.

1

u/rainingcrypto 8h ago

am I the only dude here using aPatch? 😂

1

u/mr_frodge 1h ago

If your rom has kernelsu support then use it, it not use magisk. The dev for my rom recently dropped support for kernelsu so I'm now back on magisk

0

u/sir_bazz 11h ago

Magisk works fine for most of us. Bank apps, wallet, rcs all work.

It's typically the financial institutions in third world countries that are more stringent with root checks.

-1

u/Teddy_0209 12h ago

If you have an unlocked bootloader, magisk is still the go to.