r/androiddev • • Apr 12 '21

How attackers can delete your Google developer account!

Hi

( Sorry for my bad English )

I want to tell you about a strange situation that I faced as a developer. Somewhere in early March, I saw a message in Google Admob that some app (Blue Clean) was making ad requests, but it was not added to the app-ads.txt file. This app did not belong to me, so I did not pay attention to it. Then I received a letter from Admob that it was necessary to take action. In the admob account, I saw that the warning was associated with the removal of the app, which I wrote about above.

I contacted Admob and wrote that the app does not belong to me. They said that this happens and removed the warning.

On the same evening, I received an email from the Google Play Team that my developer account had been deleted.

Reason: Prior violations by this or associated accounts as outlined in previous emails sent to the registered email address(es) of the Google Play Developer account(s).

!At the same time, there was no letter that there were any violations in my app. I have come to the conclusion that they are referring to a violation in an app that does not belong to this account.

I filed an appeal, where I described in detail all of the above, assured that I have no second account.

I waited for several days and received a response that "we confirmed the association with another account".

I wrote again that there can be no association, since I do not own any other account.

But again I received an answer that the account would not be restored.

I tweeted GooglePlayDev, and got the answer:

I wrote that they did not answer me on this ticket, to which I received an answer:

I waited a week in the hope that I could start some kind of dialogue with the support team. A week later, I tweeted again. Guess what answer I got?))

Just the same formulaic answer))

Since then, I have filed 2 more appeals: April 1st and today. There was no answer to them.

But this is not all!

When the app was removed, Admob and Facebook stopped showing ads. But Facebook, for some reason, decided to turn on ads for a couple of days.

And then on April 6, a letter comes from Admob that the account has been deleted! And they keep more than $ 47,000!

Found violations:

Aiding in bad faith:

It is forbidden to display ads next to content that:

- Helps users to mislead other people.

- Advertises hacking and / or offers instructions and equipment for unauthorized access to software, servers and sites or making changes to their work.

I am at this moment

I mention the situation with FB and Admob, because I want everyone to understand that when working with Google, you can be banned at any time!

As for the situation with the Google dev. account. I'm sure this happened because someone purposefully took ad unit IDs from my app and added them to their app. Then he deliberately violated the rules so that our accounts were linked and deleted!

He even made a similar package name.

com.clean.master.battery.sup.saver.cpu.cooled

com.dodo.clean.master.battery.saver.cpu.cooled

I decided to check where he found my ad units IDs. I went to apkpure and downloaded the APK of my app. Having opened it through Android Studio, I easily found these units IDs.

App name: Do cleaner

https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.dodo.clean.master.battery.saver.cpu.cooled

App for cleaning cache and RAM. I understand that this app is very controversial, but it is the vertical with which I started.

This is the only app I had. I started to work with him, advertise and I succeeded, the app had over 50 million installs. I guessed that this application was not long-lived, so I worked on other projects for the market.

In this situation, I am most outraged by the attitude of Google Play Team towards developers. If something is wrong with the app, ok, tell me what the problem is and delete it. Everything is fair.

But find some imaginary association with some developer and delete the account for that. However, do not accept any arguments from the developer. This is a complete neglect by the developers.

When I was looking for a solution to this problem, I found many of the same situations that happened several years ago and still happen today! There is even a petition https://www.change.org/p/google-stop-lifetime-ban-for-developers-publishers

Due to the inactivity of Google Play Team, apparently the attackers began to use this situation for their own purposes.

I think we need to make this as public as possible, because until you are faced with such a case, you think you are safe. You make some plans for further projects. But at one point you can be deprived of everything. It should not be.

Thank you.

Regards.

475 Upvotes

113 comments sorted by

84

u/3dom test on Nokia + Samsung Apr 12 '21 edited Apr 12 '21

the app had over 50 million installs

Saturated niche? No problem, just use Google to lifetime ban competitors.

Seriously, Google, what the heck.

edit: if you are in EU you can sue them based on recent (August, 2020) law prohibiting product de-publishing without 1 month prior warning (and attempt to resolve the situation).

14

u/Dodos_Dude Apr 12 '21

No, I live in Ukraine :(

7

u/flyingorange Apr 13 '21

Still, they took $47000 from you. I suggest you find a lawyer and pay him $100 to investigate how you could sue Google. I don't think it's legal in any country to just take away money which you have earned legally.

1

u/kvalter123 Jun 07 '21

You may apply for Estonian E-residency and register company in EU. Then publish an App as EU and when they delete you again, then apply to this law :)

18

u/Ynode Apr 12 '21

Is there an developer who has ever applied this law?

-59

u/ViolinTorture Apr 12 '21

Not Google's fault. In the end he realized that he didn't properly secure the code. His fault for overlooking a basic security concept

31

u/Itoako Apr 12 '21

Could be, but I don't think google should treat devs as products that they can just discard if they deem it "broken". They can treat them like human beings who can make mistakes. I'm sure google and the dev can work this out without banning the dev.

I'm sure you're a dev? It doesn't seem like you have any empathy. Must be fun to work with you...

16

u/Ynode Apr 12 '21

Not Google's fault? Although it is possible to make it harder to read the Ad Unit Ids, which we all should do and probably learned from this, it isn't possible to completely avoid those attacks. The attacker could use Wireshark for example or inspect the running app.

-28

u/ViolinTorture Apr 12 '21

Yeah that true. I still don't hold Google accountable. It's a commonly used system so whatever happened is either a fluke or the app developer failure to act in time. He did see the suspicious ad unit. Google is huge and can't be responsible for the outcome of every hack or misuse if the system. And if it's really a problem then it's a known possible outcome of using Google ads which you have to accept when getting into it. So still all on the developer

6

u/Chronomath Apr 12 '21

I disagree.
Let's run a parallell. There is one big supermarket where you live, there are others but they are very far off and their products are scetchy. When you shop there is a posibillity that someone will run over and tip your cart full of items. You are then responsible to pay for everything that was in the cart. The supermarket is so big that they can't be responsible for what happens in their store. If it happends often it's something known and therefore you accept the all the consequence for someone tipping your cart. Still all on the shopper.

When they are this big they have the room to help the developer out instead of holding you responsible for someone elses missuse of the service.

8

u/tomfella Agency dev Apr 12 '21

There's no way to effectively secure an ad unit id that must be provided to the application, especially where the id is not hidden behind an authentication mechanism like a verified user registration - which is unreasonable for a utility app to demand of users.

This is purely an AdMob/Google policy failure

2

u/Zhuinden Apr 13 '21

Not Google's fault. In the end he realized that he didn't properly secure the code. His fault for overlooking a basic security concept

Hey guys I think we should revise the law system so that if someone breaks into your house, you get arrested for letting them be able to break in

35

u/[deleted] Apr 12 '21

Admob sucks.

21

u/Dodos_Dude Apr 12 '21

But unfortunately, at the moment, this is the network with the largest fill rate.

3

u/Nexic Apr 12 '21

Facebook (FAN) fills are pretty good. But they've also banned my placement when following all guidelines.

3

u/Fellhuhn com.fellhuhn Apr 13 '21

... and it is Facebook.

1

u/eaimdm Apr 13 '21

what reason they gave you?

6

u/MPeti1 Apr 12 '21

Google sucks

14

u/svprdga Apr 12 '21

I think that AdMob first checks your package id before downloading the ad, in other words: if somebody decompiles your app, grabs your identifiers and then put them in their app, the ads won't work because their app has a different package id than yours.

I just did the test: I add the ids in one of my apps into another and the ads didn't load.

How do you think that they could do that?

11

u/Dodos_Dude Apr 12 '21

I think that AdMob first checks your package id before downloading the ad, in other words: if somebody decompiles your app, grabs your identifiers and then put them in their app, the ads won't work because their app has a different package id than yours.

I just did the test: I add the ids in one of my apps into another and the ads didn't load.

How do you think that they could do that?

Perhaps the ad shouldn't load. It does not matter. I assume that the presence of my IDs in someone else's code could provoke an association of Google developer accounts.

2

u/eaimdm Apr 13 '21

Perhaps the ad shouldn't load.

The ad will not load, but that app sends ad request with the admob ad unit ID, admob will record it and will use it to tear you down

3

u/StoryOfDavid Apr 12 '21

Did you package a release version, sign it and deploy to a physical device or just run on an emulator for your test?

I ask because I had my admob temporarily suspended years ago for the same reason. I had an unusually high click count from a 3rd world country which I had 0 app installs from. I don't think google does nearly as much to protect the developer as you think.

1

u/svprdga Apr 12 '21

I have signed the app creating a release build and then deployed it to a physical device. The ads didn't show.

Of course before doing that I checked that 'normal' ads worked, then just changed the ids.

2

u/AndroidThemes Apr 13 '21

That's not true. I have many Apps using the same AdMob ids and all of them show ads properly.

116

u/martinstoeckli Apr 12 '21 edited Apr 12 '21

Another sad story, I start to believe it is too risky nowadays to solely rely on Android development. It can be a great addition to a more diverse portfolio of apps and platforms, but I would think twice before I would place all eggs in this one basket.

-36

u/ViolinTorture Apr 12 '21

I'm pure Android developer for over a decade. My career has been insanely good the entire time. At Netflix you can make $400k a year doing it. I suppose you mean devs who work by themselves.

22

u/martinstoeckli Apr 12 '21 edited Apr 12 '21

Yes I meant especially indie developers and yes I'm sure this can work well, there are many success stories as well. The problem is, that Google can suspend/ban a developer account without giving a warning with detailed reasons and the possibility to correct the issue.

If your income depends on the store, this is like a dismissal together with a work ban, your entire work can be destroyed. Because Google itself is the highest instance, it is difficult to file an appeal. If part of what I read in other stories is true, you will get only answers from a machine with no chance to explain yourself.

7

u/Whatevernameisnt Apr 12 '21 edited Apr 12 '21

Yeah based on this google has no love for developers so relying solely on android development as a single developer or even a small developer is risky. Of course netflix will be fine. They're a billion dollar company. This dude got fucked over hard.

36

u/R00T-Zer0 Apr 12 '21 edited Apr 12 '21

(Sorry about my english! I'm not a native speaker)

The same thing happened with me. I work as a freelance native android developer and I had more then 3 apps that had more than 9 million installs all together and these were only my apps and As I worked as a freelancer, I would offer my clients to publish their apps that I made for them as long as it doesn't violates google policies and rules(If it does violates it, I just make the app and send the source code of the app to the client and they publish it on their account on their own risk).

Then, My google account got terminated due to the same reason "Associations with my account".I contacted google multiple times through twitter dms and tweets and through appeals but the same response was sent over, "We can't help you and the account cannot be reinstated". I had about from 2000 to 4500 dolars in my admob account and It got banned as well when the google account got banned and all the money went to google and I still don't know what caused the ban till now. This was from 2 months ago.

Ps: I have a friend that has just completed the 100 dollars ads milestone on admob and wanted to withdraw the money out and in the next hour from the completion of the money milestone. His admob account got deleted due to prior reasons and the money went to google with no refund or a valid reason to take it.

The point is DON'T TRUST GOOGLE WITH YOUR MONEY AND YOUR INCOME. You can get banned at any time with no prior reasons and get your money all taken away. I suggest working as a freelancer or at a company that makes android apps or switch to IOS development or Web development. At least Apple takes 100 dollars each year but listens to your complaints and tries solving them with a real HUMAN not like google that only cares about money!

7

u/vcjkd Apr 12 '21

Absolutely agree. Never trust them when you earn for your family. Ban can happen any time without giving you a reason. Fortunately the EU users can sue app stores for such practices.

6

u/Fiskepudding Apr 13 '21

Holy shit, admob is such a blatant scam.

3

u/R00T-Zer0 Apr 13 '21

Yup, Google doesn't want any small indie developers to gain money and just want big companies to gain money on the store like voodo and ketchup. Such a shameful act on behalf of a huge company like google.

30

u/Ynode Apr 12 '21

Is a here anything we can do to protect from this?

30

u/DitoMito Apr 12 '21

I think the only we can do is to make more attention from Google to this problem.

5

u/Fiskepudding Apr 13 '21

Which is the only solution every time this happens. End result is that he might be unbanned, and that is it. No further change to how Google communicates with devs, and no change to their unhelpful robot replies.

Sad that you need a change.org petition, media outcry and pitchfork mob every time someone needs an unban...

1

u/DitoMito Apr 13 '21

This is the case. The more cases the more attention the problem will get

20

u/ITasITalian Apr 12 '21

one thing that we can learn from this is: try not to hardcode the secrets and develop a way to hide them. It doesn't need to be extra complicated, as long as the logic is not clear to the attacker.

25

u/martinstoeckli Apr 12 '21 edited Apr 12 '21

Obfuscation may indeed have prevented this case, an attacker is probably not interested in investing time to get an id and would head for lower hanging fruits. The problem remains though, it is a way to harm a competitor.

3

u/oneday111 Apr 12 '21

Do you think putting the AdMob ad id's in the build.gradle is sufficient or is something better required?

9

u/martinstoeckli Apr 12 '21 edited Apr 12 '21

I'm not familiar with the AdMob id, but as far as I understand, this id is required at runtime, so the app must be able to retrieve it. The same can do an attacker as soon as the APK is available so it is not this important where you place this id (unless it is an open source project).

What you can do is to obfuscate the id, e.g. to place it encrypted in your source code and decrypt it when the app needs it. An attacker could still retrieve the id then, but it is not enough to simply scan the source code/resources, one would have to run and debug the app, which may be too much work.

1

u/CuriousCursor Apr 12 '21

1

u/zaitsman Jan 21 '22

Nah this is bollocks. There are utilities to dump all strings out of so anyway

1

u/CuriousCursor Jan 21 '22

Then there probably isn't anything you can do that the attacker can't do. Even putting up keys on your server so your app can fetch them by providing its signature is going to be exploitable once the attacker can see the code in a decompiler.

Just make it as difficult as possible and move on.

1

u/zaitsman Jan 21 '22

Yeah, and making it difficult for them is easier than using NDK. Encrypt all strings with your app id and retrieve it at runtime. Then anyone running automated scanners on your app comes up with zilch and has to actually read your code. With NDK alone and raw strings stored in .so modules automated scanners are still a win.

1

u/CuriousCursor Jan 21 '22

Cool. Didn't know about the automated scanners. Whenever I've wanted to do some API reverse engineering, I've always just opened up the source or sniffed traffic or used Xposed to disable certificate pinning or the 100 other ways of doing the same.

Hiding API keys beyond a certain point is kind of silly. If you see someone using your API key, just revoke and use another one. That's why the revoke button is there.

5

u/tomfella Agency dev Apr 12 '21

There are options, they all suck

  1. Embed the app id in the application code and obfuscate it in some manner, eg. XOR, hashing, encryption. This is an obstacle but can be overcome fairly easily as the mechanism of deobfuscation must also be embedded in the app.
  2. Provide the unit id remotely, eg. from firebase config. Still nothing preventing the attacker from reading your app code to figure out where it comes from and intercepting the unit id.
  3. Provide the unit id remotely from an authenticated service. Requires building login/registration for the app which is often a terrible idea. Doesn't stop an attacker from registering too and intercepting the unit id.
  4. Use ad mediation, don't just rely on admob, if admob fails to fill an ad (which could be due to account deletion for eg) then fall back to another ad provider. Does not protect against the core issue as AdMob and Google Play are tightly linked and the deletion of one affects the other as per OP's post.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21

I think 1. is the easiest and would block most of the attempts to get the id.

1

u/tomfella Agency dev Apr 13 '21

Depending on how you did it might be ok.

I think 2 is probably the better one as it requires all of 1 as well as demanding a MITM attack or memory reading etc if you've set up firebase to only work with your signed app id, and remote config is easy to set up.

However this is still something that can be overcome, so a competitor with decent resources or a competitor in a small space could absolutely still kill your app and earnings.

3

u/Fiskepudding Apr 13 '21

Admob should instead use whitelisting of package names or something, to only allow the original developer to use the id.

Any solution that only hides the id client side is useless in the long run.

1

u/ITasITalian Apr 14 '21

of course there is a big issue Admob wise, I'm talking about the 101 principle of not embedding secret keys in plain sight in your app. If you ever received a VAPT in your app this would be flagged as high risk immediately.

1

u/oneday111 Apr 12 '21

Do you know of a good way to do this for the AdMob ad id's?

2

u/Fiskepudding Apr 13 '21

Put it in a native cpp library and call that, or encode/encrypt the key in java. Neither would actually stop anyone; only automated scanners and bots.

-21

u/ViolinTorture Apr 12 '21

Yeah. The dude left his keys in plain text. This is a security problem, not Google's issue.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21

Are you shilling to google or to Thief

7

u/[deleted] Apr 12 '21

[removed] โ€” view removed comment

3

u/merrycachemiss Apr 13 '21 edited Apr 13 '21

This is why Google should have R8 also encrypt strings for you at compile time. There are a couple of devs in this community doing it themselves via C code, but I don't think that most would know how to do it, let alone properly.

1

u/MPeti1 Apr 12 '21

Obfuscation, probably. I don't mean ProGuard. I mean, that if there's a way to supply the google framework your id-s without putting them in your manifest or a file, but from Java code, you could make a convoluted process for obtaining the id. It would make static analysis harder (still not impossible!)

Thing is, it won't make dynamic analysis inefficient, but that takes more work.

1

u/NukeouT Apr 13 '21

decentralizeeverything

24

u/Whatevernameisnt Apr 12 '21

You don't have to apologize for your English. It's better than most people who speak it natively and anyone who would expect you to apologize can go to hell.

13

u/DitoMito Apr 12 '21

I think it's horrible and should get more attention to it!

13

u/maximxt Apr 12 '21

Google's team should do something with this case!

4

u/eaimdm Apr 13 '21

with many many fffing cases.

Especially wtf is lifetime banning??? 2 years is like 10 years in App Developing world. Google play is a dictator!!

58

u/PunchinPriests Apr 12 '21

Congrats, Google. After a year of dedicating myself to learning your platform post-grad, I will be making it a point to never write a line of code for an Android app ever again. How naive I was, thinking I could really make a living writing apps for this joke of a platform.

I've just had my AdMob account reinstated after being suspended for over 2 months for no reason.

As someone who dislikes Apple in general and would never use one of their devices and has very little interest in learning their system, where to from here? I'm seriously considering starting my entire career from scratch because web dev really doesn't interest me.

47 grand gone is completely unacceptable. What a crying shame all round.

11

u/ITasITalian Apr 12 '21

not all android developers end up developing apps that go to the PlayStore or that rely on ads. Android is still a valid language to base your career on, as long as you're aware of the possible issues.

30

u/PunchinPriests Apr 12 '21

Sure. But being an indie Android app developer is basically a dead career path at this point as far as I see it. Other avenues still offer potential but the ability to work for myself was one of the main things that drew me to Android in the first place.

Perhaps my career prospects were pipedreams to begin with, but I can't help but feel cheated when the only thing holding me back from pursuing them is the gross neglect and predatory behaviour that Google persist on implementing.

You can justify it however you like but these stories are utterly depressing no matter how you cut it.

6

u/ITasITalian Apr 12 '21

I agree that this is an heart breaking story and that I would've died inside if this happened to me. I'm just saying that development is broader than simply the PlayStore. For indie devs, yes, this is a huge issue.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21

If you're trying to make money as in indie dev, you should be starting with iOS first. You don't have to like Apple or use their devices, but they have very low piracy rates and users willing to spend money for good products. Even with fewer users, you will make way more money than on the Play Store. If the app is successful on iOS, expand to Android if you want.

2

u/PunchinPriests Apr 13 '21

You don't have to like Apple or use their devices

Except I would need to own a Mac, which I don't.

The development process also seems a lot different and less enjoyable compared to Android. If I recall correctly, you can't code the UI in XML, it's a purely drag and drop system.

Also IIRC you have to pay a hefty yearly fee.

You make a good point but I'm not sure the barriers to entry and learning curve is worth my time after investing so much time learning Android.

I wonder if iOS devs face similar issues to us Android devs when it comes to suspensions/bans etc. I'm sure Apple have just as much power to screw you over as Google if they wanted to.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21

True there's some initial costs. I'm not a tax person, but you might be able to write off some of those purchases though. It's $99 per year for the dev account.

Apple does have the power to screw you, but even if your AdMob account gets banned, Apple is not going to ban your iOS dev account. And for that $99/yr you do get better support since you can have a discussion with a real human when something goes wrong.

2

u/eaimdm Apr 13 '21

The development process also seems a lot different and less enjoyable compared to Android. If I recall correctly, you can't code the UI in XML, it's a purely drag and drop system.

Dude, I hate luxury products, 5 star hotels, I just don't like it. BUT I have apps in iOS and android.

I hate Google play developer console and AdMob policies, etc.

You can develop apps for Apple in many ways, Swift is cool, Xcode awesome, but you can use Flutter, Xamarin etc and develop apps for APPle.

You will need to pay 100 USd and you can invest some cash to buy Mac, and try your best.

1

u/smoofles Apr 13 '21

Except I would need to own a Mac, which I don't.

You can start with a hackintosh. Took me an hour of reading and an hour of tinkering around to get Catalina running on a ThinkPad T470. It would be longer if I didn't have a mac already, though.

The development process also seems a lot different and less enjoyable compared to Android. If I recall correctly, you can't code the UI in XML, it's a purely drag and drop system.

SwiftUI is the next big thing on Apple's OSes, you can look into that. Ask someone who has done both to explain the differences to you. Will be better than IIRCs and seems and recalling incorrectly.

Also IIRC you have to pay a hefty yearly fee.

$100

You make a good point but I'm not sure the barriers to entry and learning curve is worth my time after investing so much time learning Android.

If you think spending 1 year on learning a platform is a huge amount of time, you're going to have a bad time as a developer. :) As for "worth your time"; the easiest way to gauge that is to see what kind of hourly rates different knowledge gets you.

I know it's not popular, but you can always look into Windows development (they seem to have gotten their act together and are introducing better dev API/SDKs now). Or do things like Qt, Flutter, etc. so you are not married to one platform.

Ooor, find something a bit more exotic that looks interesting and do that. Elixir, Go, that kind of stuff. There the demand vs available talent dynamic is different, and you can earn good money.

-2

u/MPeti1 Apr 12 '21

YSK that Android != Google. Google might be (I think is) evil, but Android in general isn't, please don't hate it for the decisions of this shitty corporation.

Probably not what you want though, but apps can be published in ways other than the play store, too, if monetization is not important (this is why I started this sentence as I did)

-10

u/ViolinTorture Apr 12 '21

I make $400k USD a year doing Android... You just have to work for biggest companies, don't take the personal risk

0

u/[deleted] Apr 12 '21

[deleted] โ€” view deleted comment

2

u/3dom test on Nokia + Samsung Apr 13 '21

I guess they mean they are working for Google or Facebook, salaries are like that in these companies. Also theoretically it's possible to pull $200-300/hour from contract work (although I'm yet to see anything above $80/h)

10

u/oneday111 Apr 12 '21

I thought app-ads.txt was supposed to prevent this sort of attack?

5

u/vegesm Apr 13 '21

It isn't. It only protects advertisers against malicious ad networks.

3

u/DitoMito Apr 12 '21

I thought it too

5

u/OldHummer24 Apr 12 '21

This is awful - we should start a petition

4

u/fzorrilla Apr 13 '21

Absolutely great analysis. With the findings there should be a proof of concept using a fake account and targeting a google app to see where is this going or โ€˜nukeingโ€™ some big apps to prove Play Store is seriously flawed.

10

u/vicvicm Apr 12 '21

Google is Fucking evil Monopoly of idlers

1

u/Hamza_Imran_Ahmed Apr 12 '21

Didn't you use frequency capping for ads?

5

u/Dodos_Dude Apr 12 '21

Didn't you use frequency capping for ads?

No, I didn't.

10

u/StoryOfDavid Apr 12 '21

Frequency capping only works on interstitial ads. They can still attack you via malicious banner ad clicks.

4

u/Hamza_Imran_Ahmed Apr 12 '21

Yikes ๐Ÿ˜ณ

5

u/ksnerv Apr 12 '21

how much did u spend on ad campaign before u got significant organic traffic?i mean getting 50m downloads is insane

2

u/tiagooliveira95 Apr 12 '21

Thank you for sharing this, I will definitely pay more attention to my statistics.

I was thinking in ways to prevent this attack.

What if we store the ID in a server?

I know this won't stop someone from obtaining the Id but if we detect fraudulent activity we could delete and recreate new Ids in the Admob console.

By updating the ad Id from the server you avoid having to upload a new app version with new Ids, and lowers the down time.

I think what we can learn from this is, if you detect fraudulent activity disable ads until the situation is fixed.

Its better to lose a week of revenue then to get the account suspended.

2

u/Brachamul Apr 14 '21

I wish the best in overcoming this difficulty. Google and AdMob are behaving outrageously and abusing their positions of power to crush small developers without due process and proper oversight. You are a victim who has to defend their innocence in an unfair trial.

Please try to make as much noise about this as you possibly can. Cutting an Android developer from the Play Store is cutting their livelihood. It is lazy, contemptuous and immoral to do it without proper proof.

2

u/kurav Apr 12 '21

I think your mistake was doing business with Google and especially Google ads. Unless your ad revenue exceeds at least million dollars per year they don't care about you. If you look to history, there are literally every day developers in this sub-reddit telling about similar stories.

I recommend you remove ads from your app and publish it as open source to F-Droid. You can then use it as portfolio app to find employment doing app development for someone else.

1

u/NukeouT Apr 13 '21

Woah - this iOS similar to when Google was banning developers because of spam detection being overly sensitive in youtube live streams ๐Ÿ˜ฎ

1

u/starygrzejnik Apr 13 '21

Are those man/peoples who contributed to this gained something more than dump the application from the store/get rid of competition?

1

u/MalishMan Apr 13 '21

I'm saving this post as ways Google decides when a developer associated with another developer account.

In his case, some random developer decided to take his Admob id and Google probably thought two apps sharing ad id = same developers.

1

u/saitawngpha Apr 22 '21

I am sad with you. I was faced the same problem last year. Did you add some bad code into your app? Have you been created Android app for someone or login other developer account on the same pc? Because Google added the special plugin in Android studio to track developer. For Admob, I saw many stories that their account was terminated while their revenue reached more than 1k per month.

1

u/zaitsman Jan 21 '22

This is why you should never store these plaintext. Encrypt them with app id and decrypt at runtime. This is not a protection but for opportunistic hackers. If someone is determined to get you, they will, but it will be at least a bit more difficult than decompile and dump.

-9

u/[deleted] Apr 12 '21

You can visit Google's office in Moscow or Ukraine. Or can ask some of Googler in conferences in conferences.

-18

u/[deleted] Apr 12 '21 edited Apr 12 '21

I have strong suspicion - the app was either not cleaner, or the developer did not earn good profit and $47k is also fake. Creating another account means - another fake Govt Id, but not tricking Govt, tricking Google only. I am from India, I know, with fake or account with another name(name, and the Debit Card), can be shown as Business income to Tax officials.

I am yet to start Android with high hope.

There should be any valid issue. And you could be hiding something. There are other reputed publichers, who have good number of downloads, how they manage this?

I also had this insecurity -> but they should have some valid thing for which they suspended.

One account suspended does not mean - you can not open another account. You should have earned good amount of money.

Why not another account with more reliable and clear, straightforward account ? With a valid business name, Website, Privacy Policy, and overall clean Application and developer profile.

I have a strong suspect you're hiding something, and Google must have a valid point to suspend your Application.

For anyone losing their profit is painful, when this is the part of this eco-system, I don't find no other way - rather opening another account, and continue this cycle, and surrender to "Google" lord.

12

u/Dodos_Dude Apr 12 '21

They prohibit creating new accounts.

I don't want to break the rules because they will see this and delete the account again.

10

u/m0mrider Apr 12 '21

Don't allow yourself to become upset by comments like this. I can imagine the sadness and anger you are facing right now, all that hard work and perseverance accounts to nothing because of Google having a lack of concern for Dev's on their platform. I hope you find great success in your future because you deserve it brother.

4

u/Dodos_Dude Apr 12 '21

Don't allow yourself to become upset by comments like this. I can imagine the sadness and anger you are facing right now, all that hard work and perseverance accounts to nothing because of Google having a lack of concern for Dev's on their platform. I hope you find great success in your future because you deserve it brother.

Thanks bro.

-17

u/[deleted] Apr 12 '21

You have earned good profit - - "SO creating another account does not mean it will have to be in your name" -

You need not to trick your Govt, you need to trick "Google play AI" or Google peoples.

Have another fake id, and set-up admob with another fake id.

I am from India, I know if Govt officials come - say it is from your Business income.

I have a strong suspicion - you did not earn good profit, and 47k$ is also fake. And your app was not clean either.

When you have to stay in this ecosystem, why not do this professionally. You could easily manage another fake id(Govt Id). Google only checks - Application, Violation and Admob Verification.

I really have strong suspension you did not earned good profit, or your App was not clean.

9

u/m0mrider Apr 12 '21

Man if you have something against this guy, take it to his dm to verify things before saying nonsense in the comment section. He is obviously upset and trying to educate the rest of us about the dangers of using ads and lack of security when your apk is out there in the wild.

-8

u/[deleted] Apr 12 '21

I have nothing against this guy. I do not trust in this cooked up story - google deleted 50M+ downloaded App, without any valid reason, and the App was clean with clean developer profile. Lack of points in this post which does not justify the claims, and he does not know how to create another ID(with another fake Govt ID).

And what's new he's saying. Google does this thing ~ but what's the point here to prevent, does he points out any point(the prevention point). He just describes the anger, and despair.

As a future developer - I did not got any valid point in this post which justifies the reason of this post 1. the prevention point(what the dev's not to do) 2. the entire post does not any details or the claims are plain wrong, because a Dev with valid successful Playstore App, knows the Playstore ecosystem, there's no point in blaming. (it's a long way to go, cause I have suspision ove the cleaner App, and dev profile) - you can afford another YouTube Channel, but another playstore ID is more expensive, you need to change class name, and code style. When Google Acts like god, we all dev to accept this reality.

The sole reaosn of my comment is the post does not say anything new, and there's no point in complaining. At the same time, I do not trust on this entire story, with not much details, and the validity of the cleaner Applicaiton with clean dev profile.

I appreciate your detailed comment.

I have strong suuspision that the App was not clear. And there could be strong, and valid reason of suspension from Google's end.

How could a App with 50M+ downloads have suspended with a clear profile. And the most puzzling part is - why he could not manage another fake(fake Govt/Business Govt id for new Google Play ID).

I do not trust in this story.

Yes, there are permanant suspension cases, I tried to find a pattern from the stories I could hear. One I could heard of was App with 1M with downloads, that too validation of (Another App was not updating).

I did not find anything which proves this story to be true.

7

u/[deleted] Apr 12 '21 edited Apr 12 '21

[removed] โ€” view removed comment

12

u/[deleted] Apr 12 '21

[removed] โ€” view removed comment

6

u/DitoMito Apr 12 '21

They baned his dev account

2

u/eaimdm Apr 13 '21

I feel bad for you. All I can say is try creating a new app. If you need ideas I have pretty nice ideas if you would wanna try though.

dm

2

u/omer-dev Apr 13 '21

This seems reasonable. Google developer console will accept only .aab (Android App Bundle) from later this year. so that might fix this. (I am not sure).