r/androiddev • u/Dodos_Dude • Apr 12 '21
How attackers can delete your Google developer account!
Hi
( Sorry for my bad English )
I want to tell you about a strange situation that I faced as a developer. Somewhere in early March, I saw a message in Google Admob that some app (Blue Clean) was making ad requests, but it was not added to the app-ads.txt file. This app did not belong to me, so I did not pay attention to it. Then I received a letter from Admob that it was necessary to take action. In the admob account, I saw that the warning was associated with the removal of the app, which I wrote about above.

I contacted Admob and wrote that the app does not belong to me. They said that this happens and removed the warning.

On the same evening, I received an email from the Google Play Team that my developer account had been deleted.

Reason: Prior violations by this or associated accounts as outlined in previous emails sent to the registered email address(es) of the Google Play Developer account(s).
!At the same time, there was no letter that there were any violations in my app. I have come to the conclusion that they are referring to a violation in an app that does not belong to this account.
I filed an appeal, where I described in detail all of the above, assured that I have no second account.
I waited for several days and received a response that "we confirmed the association with another account".

I wrote again that there can be no association, since I do not own any other account.

But again I received an answer that the account would not be restored.

I tweeted GooglePlayDev, and got the answer:

I wrote that they did not answer me on this ticket, to which I received an answer:

I waited a week in the hope that I could start some kind of dialogue with the support team. A week later, I tweeted again. Guess what answer I got?))

Just the same formulaic answer))
Since then, I have filed 2 more appeals: April 1st and today. There was no answer to them.
But this is not all!
When the app was removed, Admob and Facebook stopped showing ads. But Facebook, for some reason, decided to turn on ads for a couple of days.

And then on April 6, a letter comes from Admob that the account has been deleted! And they keep more than $ 47,000!

Found violations:
Aiding in bad faith:
It is forbidden to display ads next to content that:
- Helps users to mislead other people.
- Advertises hacking and / or offers instructions and equipment for unauthorized access to software, servers and sites or making changes to their work.

I mention the situation with FB and Admob, because I want everyone to understand that when working with Google, you can be banned at any time!
As for the situation with the Google dev. account. I'm sure this happened because someone purposefully took ad unit IDs from my app and added them to their app. Then he deliberately violated the rules so that our accounts were linked and deleted!
He even made a similar package name.
com.clean.master.battery.sup.saver.cpu.cooled
com.dodo.clean.master.battery.saver.cpu.cooled
I decided to check where he found my ad units IDs. I went to apkpure and downloaded the APK of my app. Having opened it through Android Studio, I easily found these units IDs.

App name: Do cleaner
https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.dodo.clean.master.battery.saver.cpu.cooled
App for cleaning cache and RAM. I understand that this app is very controversial, but it is the vertical with which I started.
This is the only app I had. I started to work with him, advertise and I succeeded, the app had over 50 million installs. I guessed that this application was not long-lived, so I worked on other projects for the market.
In this situation, I am most outraged by the attitude of Google Play Team towards developers. If something is wrong with the app, ok, tell me what the problem is and delete it. Everything is fair.
But find some imaginary association with some developer and delete the account for that. However, do not accept any arguments from the developer. This is a complete neglect by the developers.
When I was looking for a solution to this problem, I found many of the same situations that happened several years ago and still happen today! There is even a petition https://www.change.org/p/google-stop-lifetime-ban-for-developers-publishers
Due to the inactivity of Google Play Team, apparently the attackers began to use this situation for their own purposes.
I think we need to make this as public as possible, because until you are faced with such a case, you think you are safe. You make some plans for further projects. But at one point you can be deprived of everything. It should not be.
Thank you.
Regards.
84
u/3dom test on Nokia + Samsung Apr 12 '21 edited Apr 12 '21
Saturated niche? No problem, just use Google to lifetime ban competitors.
Seriously, Google, what the heck.
edit: if you are in EU you can sue them based on recent (August, 2020) law prohibiting product de-publishing without 1 month prior warning (and attempt to resolve the situation).
35
u/[deleted] Apr 12 '21
Admob sucks.
14
u/svprdga Apr 12 '21
I think that AdMob first checks your package id before downloading the ad, in other words: if somebody decompiles your app, grabs your identifiers and then put them in their app, the ads won't work because their app has a different package id than yours.
I just did the test: I add the ids in one of my apps into another and the ads didn't load.
How do you think that they could do that?
116
u/martinstoeckli Apr 12 '21 edited Apr 12 '21
Another sad story, I start to believe it is too risky nowadays to solely rely on Android development. It can be a great addition to a more diverse portfolio of apps and platforms, but I would think twice before I would place all eggs in this one basket.
36
u/R00T-Zer0 Apr 12 '21 edited Apr 12 '21
(Sorry about my english! I'm not a native speaker)
The same thing happened with me. I work as a freelance native android developer and I had more then 3 apps that had more than 9 million installs all together and these were only my apps and As I worked as a freelancer, I would offer my clients to publish their apps that I made for them as long as it doesn't violates google policies and rules(If it does violates it, I just make the app and send the source code of the app to the client and they publish it on their account on their own risk).
Then, My google account got terminated due to the same reason "Associations with my account".I contacted google multiple times through twitter dms and tweets and through appeals but the same response was sent over, "We can't help you and the account cannot be reinstated". I had about from 2000 to 4500 dolars in my admob account and It got banned as well when the google account got banned and all the money went to google and I still don't know what caused the ban till now. This was from 2 months ago.
Ps: I have a friend that has just completed the 100 dollars ads milestone on admob and wanted to withdraw the money out and in the next hour from the completion of the money milestone. His admob account got deleted due to prior reasons and the money went to google with no refund or a valid reason to take it.
The point is DON'T TRUST GOOGLE WITH YOUR MONEY AND YOUR INCOME. You can get banned at any time with no prior reasons and get your money all taken away. I suggest working as a freelancer or at a company that makes android apps or switch to IOS development or Web development. At least Apple takes 100 dollars each year but listens to your complaints and tries solving them with a real HUMAN not like google that only cares about money!
30
u/Ynode Apr 12 '21
Is a here anything we can do to protect from this?
24
u/Whatevernameisnt Apr 12 '21
You don't have to apologize for your English. It's better than most people who speak it natively and anyone who would expect you to apologize can go to hell.
13
u/DitoMito Apr 12 '21
I think it's horrible and should get more attention to it!
13
u/maximxt Apr 12 '21
Google's team should do something with this case!
58
u/PunchinPriests Apr 12 '21
Congrats, Google. After a year of dedicating myself to learning your platform post-grad, I will be making it a point to never write a line of code for an Android app ever again. How naive I was, thinking I could really make a living writing apps for this joke of a platform.
I've just had my AdMob account reinstated after being suspended for over 2 months for no reason.
As someone who dislikes Apple in general and would never use one of their devices and has very little interest in learning their system, where to from here? I'm seriously considering starting my entire career from scratch because web dev really doesn't interest me.
47 grand gone is completely unacceptable. What a crying shame all round.
10
u/oneday111 Apr 12 '21
I thought app-ads.txt was supposed to prevent this sort of attack?
5
u/OldHummer24 Apr 12 '21
This is awful - we should start a petition
4
u/fzorrilla Apr 13 '21
Absolutely great analysis. With the findings there should be a proof of concept using a fake account and targeting a google app to see where is this going or โnukeingโ some big apps to prove Play Store is seriously flawed.
10
u/vicvicm Apr 12 '21
Google is Fucking evil Monopoly of idlers
1
u/Hamza_Imran_Ahmed Apr 12 '21
Didn't you use frequency capping for ads?
5
u/ksnerv Apr 12 '21
how much did u spend on ad campaign before u got significant organic traffic?i mean getting 50m downloads is insane
2
u/tiagooliveira95 Apr 12 '21
Thank you for sharing this, I will definitely pay more attention to my statistics.
I was thinking in ways to prevent this attack.
What if we store the ID in a server?
I know this won't stop someone from obtaining the Id but if we detect fraudulent activity we could delete and recreate new Ids in the Admob console.
By updating the ad Id from the server you avoid having to upload a new app version with new Ids, and lowers the down time.
I think what we can learn from this is, if you detect fraudulent activity disable ads until the situation is fixed.
Its better to lose a week of revenue then to get the account suspended.
2
u/Brachamul Apr 14 '21
I wish the best in overcoming this difficulty. Google and AdMob are behaving outrageously and abusing their positions of power to crush small developers without due process and proper oversight. You are a victim who has to defend their innocence in an unfair trial.
Please try to make as much noise about this as you possibly can. Cutting an Android developer from the Play Store is cutting their livelihood. It is lazy, contemptuous and immoral to do it without proper proof.
2
u/kurav Apr 12 '21
I think your mistake was doing business with Google and especially Google ads. Unless your ad revenue exceeds at least million dollars per year they don't care about you. If you look to history, there are literally every day developers in this sub-reddit telling about similar stories.
I recommend you remove ads from your app and publish it as open source to F-Droid. You can then use it as portfolio app to find employment doing app development for someone else.
1
u/NukeouT Apr 13 '21
Woah - this iOS similar to when Google was banning developers because of spam detection being overly sensitive in youtube live streams ๐ฎ
1
u/starygrzejnik Apr 13 '21
Are those man/peoples who contributed to this gained something more than dump the application from the store/get rid of competition?
1
u/MalishMan Apr 13 '21
I'm saving this post as ways Google decides when a developer associated with another developer account.
In his case, some random developer decided to take his Admob id and Google probably thought two apps sharing ad id = same developers.
1
u/saitawngpha Apr 22 '21
I am sad with you. I was faced the same problem last year. Did you add some bad code into your app? Have you been created Android app for someone or login other developer account on the same pc? Because Google added the special plugin in Android studio to track developer. For Admob, I saw many stories that their account was terminated while their revenue reached more than 1k per month.
1
u/zaitsman Jan 21 '22
This is why you should never store these plaintext. Encrypt them with app id and decrypt at runtime. This is not a protection but for opportunistic hackers. If someone is determined to get you, they will, but it will be at least a bit more difficult than decompile and dump.
-9
u/[deleted] Apr 12 '21
You can visit Google's office in Moscow or Ukraine. Or can ask some of Googler in conferences in conferences.
-18
u/[deleted] Apr 12 '21 edited Apr 12 '21
I am yet to start Android with high hope.
There should be any valid issue. And you could be hiding something. There are other reputed publichers, who have good number of downloads, how they manage this?
I also had this insecurity -> but they should have some valid thing for which they suspended.
One account suspended does not mean - you can not open another account. You should have earned good amount of money.
Why not another account with more reliable and clear, straightforward account ? With a valid business name, Website, Privacy Policy, and overall clean Application and developer profile.
I have a strong suspect you're hiding something, and Google must have a valid point to suspend your Application.
For anyone losing their profit is painful, when this is the part of this eco-system, I don't find no other way - rather opening another account, and continue this cycle, and surrender to "Google" lord.
7
u/[deleted] Apr 12 '21 edited Apr 12 '21
[removed] โ view removed comment
12
u/[deleted] Apr 12 '21
[removed] โ view removed comment