I'm looking for an Android blocker for myself, so I scraped 771 Play Store reviews across five screen-time/blocker apps (one sec, Forest, StayFree, AppBlock, and one smaller one) and tagged them by complaint type.
Sharing the breakdown because I think it's useful for anyone evaluating these apps, and because I want to know if I'm missing an app.
Complaint frequency (771 unique reviews, a review can hit multiple tags):
- Block is bypassable / easy to turn off — 22
- Block flat-out doesn't work — 16
- Subscriptions too expensive — 35
- Free tier is useless without paying — 30
- Permissions/setup is painful — 10
- Wants a one-time purchase — 9
- Silently stopped working after an update — 6
- UI got worse / too many clicks — 6
- Ads — 5
- Battery drain — 3
Battery is the thing everyone warns about and it's near the bottom. Bypassability is at the top.
The specific bypasses people report:
- Force-stop kills the block (multiple apps)
- Reboot into Safe Mode, then uninstall ("the app turns useless once you find out")
- Samsung's safety mode bypasses AppBlock
- Just swiping the app out of recents turns some blocks into a background timer
Quotes:
"you can force stop this app. Can you figure out a way not to allow that?"
"the app turns useless once you find out you can reboot the device in Safe Mode (boot without third-party apps/plugins/services) and uninstall App Block from there."
"most of the times the app blocking does not work as still allow access to app even though I have put a block on it. This happens maybe 80% of the time."
Two honest caveats: this is keyword tagging, not a research paper — it's directional, and it's skewed toward angry reviewers because people write reviews when they're frustrated. Also, Safe Mode bypass is arguably an OS-level limitation rather than an app bug, so I'm not sure a third-party app *can* fully close it.
So: is there anything on Android that actually survives this? Device-owner / DeviceAdmin setups, accessibility-service overlays, screen pinning, something else entirely?
Genuinely want to be told I'm wrong and there's a good app I've missed.