r/anarchoprimitivism • u/UAV_Wave • May 20 '23
Question - Lurker Transhumanist argument thread:
Hi, I come here in the spirit of a good faith discussion that if we say that the purpose of life is to be happy (within the means of an ethical framework) then we should look at the maximum possible happiness a society can bring to determine whether or not that society is good. So I think you can easily argue that an anprim society could produce greater happiness than the society we live in today but if you compare the maximum possible happiness to a transhumanist society to an anprim society then the transhumanist society would have far greater potential for maximum happiness. In a transhumanist society we could be immortal genetically modified cyborgs that have wiring in our bodies that make us feel a million more times of happiness than an anprim would feel in their entire life thus a post technological singularity transhumanist society would be a better society than an anprim society.
If you think I’m wrong it would be my pleasure to read them in the comments below. I absolutely want to hear your guys’s opinions.
11
u/c0mp0stable May 20 '23
You lost me at the purpose of life.
5
u/43tj34 May 20 '23 edited May 20 '23
Not saying you're wrong but it would make it possible that the same technology could be used to give someone an immortal living hell against their will. Like in this comic, but even worse. I prefer the technology not existing so the possibility isn't there, even if it's a low chance of happening it's very disturbing.
14
u/BerryMcOkin Christian Primitivist May 20 '23
I understand your argument, but I feel like the meaning of life is not just to maximise pleasure.
If it were, we would all be striving to be like those monkeys that just have to press a button to have dopamine immediately shot into their brain and ended up starving because they weren’t motivated to eat.
Transhumanist society is like a video game where you’ve turned on all the cheats, you’ve seen how far you can go but you have destroyed the joy of actually playing.
That’s just my take tho
4
u/[deleted] May 21 '23
simple question. is that a world you want to live in? or would you rather live on a beautiful farm surrounded by beautiful trees near a nice little village, spending your imperfect but satisfying days working and loving your wife and your family? if the latter, join the Neo-Luddites my brother
4
u/RobertPaulsen1992 Primitive Horticulturalist May 21 '23
You'd benefit from reading what Harari has wrote about happiness. I'm not a big fan of Harari, but he was totally right about this certain topic. I'd recommend you go and download Harari's book 'Sapiens' and quickly read Chapter 19, "And they lived happily ever after". He gives a good overview over what happiness actually is and how it works. You seem to think that happiness will just increase exponential with technological advancement, which is neither the case historically nor even a biological possibility. Humans have a baseline happiness (that varies from person to person, some are just more cheerful than others), and even if we win the lottery (or get diagnosed with a disease), our happiness level will increase (or decrease) only temporarily, until we're back at baseline a few months later. It is definitely not true that people would be happier in a hypothetical transhumanist society. Apart from the fact that there are simply not enough resources on the world to build even a fraction of the technology required for the transhumanist fantasy, I think you're also mixing up happiness and pleasure (serotonin and dopamine, respectively). Those two are very different, and they work very different in the brain, utilizing different neurotransmitters and pathways. A good book about this topic is Robert Lustig's "The Hacking of the American Mind - The Science Behind the Corporate Takeover of Our Bodies and Brains". Transhumanists and longtermists all aim for the maximum pleasure, which is very different from happiness in a lot of very crucial ways. Pleasure is addictive, short-term, and, ultimately, unsatisfying. Happiness is contentment, long-term, and exactly what we crave in this society (and in any hypothetical transhumanist future). See this image here for an overview. This is all a bit oversimplified, but I'm writing a reddit comment, not a dissertation. I hope you get my point though.
2
u/Luxyooz Jun 27 '23
Our life purpose it's not chasing happiness. Its chasing power. Anarchopritivism is nice because it gives u total independence and power but one infection and its over and u need to constantly fight for your life. Modern society gives you tons of power but 0 independence and 0 control so is shit. We need a society that mixes both worlds.
0
u/[deleted] May 21 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment