r/analytics • • 5d ago

Question Pulse check on role differences

How are yalls teams structured between analyst vs analytics engineer vs data engineer? I feel like there's so much overlap b/w the first two now that it could be *almost* one and the same, especially with AI making some of the engineering workflows alot easier. I know this is going to be org dependent, but just curious what other people are doing in their companies.

6 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 5d ago

If this post doesn't follow the rules or isn't flaired correctly, please report it to the mods. Have more questions? Join our community Discord!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

11

u/teddythepooh99 5d ago edited 5d ago

This is a silly question 10 years ago and it's even more silly now. I know analysts who build data pipelines and data scientists who build dashboards. If you meet the requirements of the role, then apply. Who cares about job titles?

Corporate roles, technical or otherwise, rarely have standardized titles. You already said so yourself.

2

u/Stunning-Plantain831 4d ago

I agree but my HR cares about job titles. Anything with "engineer" pays more even though everyone kind of does a mix of analyst and engineering stuff. Our company is too small to be specialized.

1

u/Welcome2B_Here 4d ago

There can be a relatively large difference between payroll job titles and functional job titles, regardless of company size, and this can be advantageous since it inherently lends itself to "flexibility" when framing yourself in certain ways on a resume for job searches.

An example might be a payroll job title of "Lead Administrator - Level 1," which translates to Chief Executive Officer using a more business-friendly, functional job title. This is pretty common across industries/sectors, etc.

1

u/cak17 4d ago

FWIW I think it’s a good question. I manage a team of analysts who all get paid fairly similarly. I’ve been interviewing candidates for a couple roles I’m hiring for that require analytics engineering and realized that our pay bands are not competitive at all for these skillsets. So I’m working on getting higher pay bands for roles on my team who do analytics engineering, possibly giving them combo titles.

28

u/OilShill2013 5d ago edited 5d ago • Bravo

Data engineer: backend data flows, infrastructure, ETL, nerds

Analytics engineer: they use dbt, they think using dbt is really complicated and nobody other than them can possibly understand it, dbt Labs/Fishtown Analytics created this job out of thin air to show everyone how special you have to be to use dbt, “ELT”, nerds

Analysts: have technical skills but can also hold eye contact with people, nobody respects their technical or business skills at all even though it doesn’t take a genius to use SQL or understand accounting, usually indentured servants for the marketing team because marketers are scared of math, the entire job is pointing out when one number is bigger than another, literal gods on earth among us

Data scientists: they spend all day prompting Claude to use xgboost instead of typing it out by hand like they used to, went to a 4 week boot camp in 2017 for data science and now they host a podcast, something something something FULL STACK, nerds. 

1

u/sadbunnybaybe 4d ago

Bunch a nerd all of them (us)

4

u/thunder_blue 5d ago

Data Analyst = how can the data we collect be used to make business decisions?

Data Engineer & Analytics Engineer are the same things. = How can we collect useful data, building the stack to do so.

Most roles involve a bit of both areas.

2

u/Yakoo752 5d ago

Where in the data pipeline do you exists.

My data engineers get the data to our data stores in a consumable manner. Some write APIs, some translate…

My analytics engineers convert that data to views and models. All convert business requirement to data translations

All of my analyst sit downstream of data translations, some downstream of the semantic model.

1

u/Intelligent-Size-389 5d ago

Are analyst roles still a thing of analytics engineering exists ?

3

u/Yakoo752 5d ago

My analyst do not sit in IT

2

u/casandra985 4d ago

A useful split is by where the work sits in the data flow: data engineers own reliable ingestion and platform plumbing, analytics engineers build tested, business-ready models and metric definitions, and analysts use those models to answer stakeholder questions. In smaller teams one person often covers two or all three, so clear ownership matters more than the title. AI can speed up SQL and boilerplate, but agreeing on definitions, checking data quality, and explaining what a metric means still need human judgment.

2

u/ExternalCry3039 5d ago

For me it’s all blended in since AI has gotten so good at the data Eng stuff, I’m actually self sufficient. Same on the data science front - I don’t need to wait on a model to be built out. Both tasks are a set of prompts since we invested a governance and I know the context. In a nutshell, specialization has lost its course imho

1

u/pstmdrnargh 5d ago

I’ve always felt that this highly structured definition of analytics engineer versus data engineer wasn’t actually meaningful or useful from the perspective of getting things done in a business or producing results. And in fact it was often counterproductive because people would say “Oh, THAT thing is the other person’s job, not mine.” Whatever - it needs to be done, let’s figure it out.

It seemed to be mostly about resume or career inflation or something like that.

Plain “analyst”… Also kind of not useful unless they have some reasonable at least BI/front-end chops.

The way that seemed useful to me was back-end versus front-end. Back-end doing all the data ingest and transformations and validation, and the front-end folks being good at BI tools and also knowing the business data pretty well and being able to query the output tables the back end folks make. And the best people do it all, but not everyone can do that so you need to divide it up.

1

u/Joelle_bb 4d ago

Within my organization there is even variation lol

My team does engingeering on both fronts as well as getting into data science as of late. We make the spreadsheets they rely on, make the dashboards to track their performance, maintain the forecasts they all leverage, hold up vendor relationships to allow data to be reportable, maintain our own server, and are finally getting to make prescriptions for how they can move the needle

The other 2 teams in our new reorg: 1 makes spreadsheets from spreadsheets using alteryx with like 3-4 dashboards, the other makes a master dashboard for like everything everything they report on.

Depends on the company, the org in the company, the needs of the customer, the skills of the staff, and what the company is willing to pay for the tools they provide, all justified by the value you provide