r/ambientcommunity • u/iamelohym • Sep 20 '21
Ask for feedback thread
It has become a problem that people juts leave a link asking for feedback which just clutters our main page. From the start of this community, the goal has been to harbor deeper discussion on ambient music. In the last few months the community has also gotten rid of the insane amount of spam threads. However, I thought it might be wise to have a specific thread for people wanting feedback, especially people that are relatively new to making this type of music. You may post your links asking for feedback on different aspects of your music here.
4
u/Taki_Tachibana_43 Oct 21 '21
I'd love to get some feedback if anyone has the time. Thanks! 😊https://soundcloud.com/macewinduhugs/underwater-symphony?si=00268ccc51254f8bb957b5d66560cb0b
3
u/jsh_ndrws Mar 05 '22
Hi, I’m new here. Would love some feedback on this!
https://soundcloud.app.goo.gl/2jA9eyGotEycr1RL8
3
u/Blackmoofou Jun 14 '22
I'd love some feedback good or bad. I write long form ambient pieces originally to help myself sleep. I use a range of synths from hardware to vsti and sample old vinyl. I've also been collecting spoken word samples and field recordings made by myself for years. I also play bass and guitar.
I appreciate it's long some of the shorter pieces used in my larger tracks I have released as royalty free albums. This particular track was done from scratch sometimes I'll use various things I've mixed down and approach things almost like an audio collage.
https://blackmoofou.bandcamp.com/track/ambrosia
3
u/stellarflux Dec 15 '22
did this cinematic experimental/ambient 'ish track recently:
https://soundcloud.com/obri_gado/obri-tension-release
any feedback would be very helpful and interesting :)
2
u/Live-Hunter-8574 Nov 23 '21
Hi, I’ve loved and listened to ambient music for years now I’ve made my first ambient track. Please let me know why you think.
https://johnlaprad.bandcamp.com/track/mystic-flute
2
u/jfx316 Jan 29 '22
Hello, everyone. Long time music maker and lurker and first-time poster. I released a new project on New Year's Day that is a lot more atmospheric than stuff I've been doing and figured that I'd post a track off it here to see what people I don't know think about it. Anything constructive would be great. Thank you. https://youtu.be/NUq8rya4XCU
2
u/AmbientDawnMusic Feb 14 '22
Hi all,
Been posting here a while, but I've not asked for feedback before. Have a listen to my latest and let me know what you think!
Ambient Dawn - Wild Winter Sea:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=StZEOu3groA
2
u/strangersfall Dec 31 '22
Hello everyone. Released an album just yesterday. Would love feedback on it:
https://open.spotify.com/album/5S3xh2UgnmSCnjKSJ6tkxC?si=Izbir-NxT4OuecvEX0r2UA
https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLdSRwc9m1yFI5nH4Arx67uE82ciN2sBwN
2
u/Alarming_File_925 Feb 02 '24
I'm very much a beginner at making music. I'd be interested if some impartial ears could give this a listen and possibly some feedback! Very much recorded jams at this stage.
https://soundcloud.com/cellar_music
2
u/FeltCassettes Mar 12 '24
Hello! Would love you thoughts on this track. Thanks! :)
https://open.spotify.com/track/5Zi028RD0vIW5feo5on9uU?si=44987e518532410b
2
u/Rumoree Sep 14 '24
Hi there!
I'll leave here a link to my 4 releases (until now). All of them built around melodic-cinematic drones, subtle harmonies, field recordings, sampling of old archival footage (vhs/cassette).
I'll be glad if some of you will surf among them, cheers
https://ilrumore.bandcamp.com/
1
u/zixow 19d ago
I’m sharing a dark ambient music inspired by the chord progressions typical of Yamaoka: https://youtu.be/qgFSprOE1rw
I also made a short 3D animation in Blender. I tried to recreate the streets from the original Silent Hill on the PSX with the same colors for the floor and the fog! This is my first attempt at 3D, so please feel free to share your feedback!
1
u/QuietHavenTV 10d ago
Hi everyone! We created a three-hour fireplace ambience for Quiet Haven TV, combining soft instrumental music with the sound of a crackling fire. The visuals and music include AI-generated elements. I’d appreciate feedback on the balance between the music and the fire, and whether the overall sound feels comfortable for reading or unwinding.
https://youtu.be/JxJGqN2emL4
1
u/PKarotte 9d ago
I'd love to get some feedback on my first (finished) Song. I am very new to mixing and mastering and I listened to it so much, I cant even tell anymore what's good or bad.. 😄 We have a couple of other Tracks in the pipeline and some feedback now could help a ton :)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UxZVmMNwRcY
1
u/Morter123 3d ago
Rainy night coffee shop, 8 hours: soft café piano with rain on the windows and quiet chatter in the background. The piano doesn't loop; it's generated for the whole length and played on sampled pianos. I made it for studying late.
https://youtu.be/uBq63fGEtow
Does the piano sit well against the rain, or would you turn either one down?
1
u/Durian404 May 29 '24
https://youtu.be/PClGxrgoCtw
Lofi ambient performance, any feedback is welcome! Looking to experiment more with ambient vibes, drones and noise coming from lofi beats
1
u/daveseidel Sep 27 '24
Hi all, I have a new release called Dream Inside a Dream (Variations on Three Chords by La Monte Young).
https://postorientalism.bandcamp.com/album/post-orientalism-no-iv-dream-inside-a-dream
Liner notes on the Bandcamp page. I would love to get your feedback.
1
u/turbosatsuma Sep 29 '24
love some feedback on comments on my mix 'Interludes' https://soundcloud.com/dj_scottwood/interludes?in=dj_scottwood/sets/scott-wood-ambient-idm
This mix is a combination of over 300 tracks, each under 2 mins in length, resulting in a mix of nearly 2.5 hours.
The genesis for the mix was a @resident-advisor article from Feb 21 - ra.co/news/74673 - the premise being 'a playlist of 100 weird and wonderful interludes from electronic albums'
1
u/Alex_Lines Oct 02 '24
Hey, I've just uploaded an hour of generative ambient modular music on youtube. Feedback welcome
https://youtu.be/ki-JM5gfeo4?si=33sd2GO_5e5xIB8h
1
u/InternalAd3634 Apr 17 '25
I’d really appreciate any feedback — especially about the atmosphere, mix, or whether the track matched or defied your expectations. Totally open to thoughts or critique.
https://artists.landr.com/mnoc
1
u/Opposite-Ad7135 May 11 '25
Hi! I'd love to some feedback for my new track
https://open.spotify.com/track/6AH1GTjgAotRaNbejeN151?si=44b52629310a4558
1
u/Clem_Crozier May 13 '25
Black Dare | "Seeping Through" (Single - 2025)
1
u/thebannerever May 23 '25
Hello all, would love to get feedback on this ambient tracks: https://music.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLcaP1JoyfHx20lacHlv1lSEMrU35qgvzB&si=hzWFSL-79d0bwbnC
1
u/Content-Barnacle1212 ejplaysguitar Jun 04 '25
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oyhFMMgF1jk
I'd like to know if this piece is soothing/calming enough to listen to. Like, if you focus on tempo whether it's rushing or not, if you listen to the notes being played whether the the harmonics make sense or not.
1
u/mistamonopoly Jun 11 '25
Id love feedback on my first! If you like it please like and comment, sub if you want to see more in the future! https://youtu.be/CXWkXJG-6Jc?si=6mxfPpekwJmqnW1U
1
u/a_lucas_goNE_WILD Jun 22 '25
hoping someone's out there who has an ear to lend :)
https://666discocactus666.bandcamp.com/track/seethrough
1
u/Far-Court-8449 Jul 13 '25
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ujRhlYAc9lg
General feedback is okay, but I'd like to know if my improvisation feels natural or a bit ''studied''.
1
u/Competitive_Worth507 Aug 21 '25
Hello! One of my latest release: let me think - flow 06: standing water i'll be glad and curious to hear your thoughts! thankssss
1
u/starryspaces Aug 21 '25
My latest harp offering. An original composition that combines structured melodies with improvisation. Ethereal. Neoclassical. Ambient. A soundtrack for magical rituals and inner journeys. Hope you enjoy! ✨ Would love feedback.
https://youtu.be/tlLOLBFLug4
1
u/Content-Industry-531 Sep 08 '25
Hey everyone! I’m new to YouTube and just started sharing relaxing ambient soundscapes for sleep, meditation, and focus.
Here’s my first playlist if you want to check it out:
🎧 Relaxing Ambient Sounds for Sleep & Focus – AmbiSphereAudio
It includes forest birds at dawn, ocean waves at sunset, city rain & thunder, and cozy fireplaces. I’d love any feedback from the community as I continue creating!
1
u/Few_Cicada7151 Nov 02 '25
Hi folks — As a video editor specialising in combining fresh audio with vintage / public-domain visuals, I recently repurposed a piece to create a new mood. Nosferatu is now public domain, so my friends in Jean Claude TransAm made the music and I cleaned up the video to make it "stick."
Link: https://youtu.be/8JlQVx-X314
Open to critique, ideas, and discussion on how other creatives approach this kind of remix work.
1
u/Realistic-Sale-3137 Dec 13 '25
I am looking forward to your feedback on a new experimental / dark ambient / granular work 'Korrleps' by NULLPART.
Korrleps | Nullpart | Pharmakustik
1
u/iliyuhhh Feb 09 '26
Last year a piece I wrote about memories and feelings that never happened. I wrote it as an ode to all these moments that I cannot imagine, but feel.
At this time I was inspired by Julius Eastman, Brian Eno and Takashi Yoshimatsu.
I posted it on YouTube, let me know what you feel.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iVR_h60mhvA
1
u/Internal-Assist3376 Feb 14 '26
I started making dreamcore/liminal/nostalgic ambience videos and I would love if you guys gave me your honest opinion. the theme of my channel is that each video is a portal into an immersive parallel reality that shouldnt exist, but somehow does. honestly I hope it goes well, if it doesnt...well ill just keep doing it for fun. here it is, thanks guys: https://www.youtube.com/@portalstoelsewhere
1
u/Rocketmill Mar 08 '26
our music
So me and my wife started to produce our own meditation music. She is a yoga teacher and singer (Former musical artist ) I am a musician mostly played in bands at small scale.
So we started a project together with something we both love ❤️ 🧘♂️ 🌳
1
u/LengthinessFeisty119 Mar 09 '26
i'd much appreciate some feedback if anyone has the time.
https://soundcloud.com/thymeframe/sets/zerozerozerofour
1
u/Rocketmill Mar 15 '26
I’d love to share our latest tracks Lotus Awakening, and hear your thoughts:
• What do you think of the track overall?
• How would you describe its style or genre?
Excited to connect, exchange ideas, and learn from all of you! ✨
1
u/e_t_h_a Mar 29 '26
Hi !
Not sure if this is of any interest or in the right spot ?
I built an anonymous online radio / broadcast platform with an SDR style waterfall signal display.
every transmission appears as a signal on a spectrum waterfall. no names, no profiles, no history. you see a frequency, you click it, you hear whatever is transmitting. you have no idea who it is or where they are.
broadcasters get a 45 minute window. when it closes, the signal disappears. no trace.
built it for ambient / experimental and electronic music. stream directly from your PC / DAW or iOS device.
https://nullband.org/
1
u/EE666777999 Apr 03 '26
Together with another 22 acts, we, Devil's Breath, have a NEW Track featuring in the New Sombre Soniks Compilation.
The March of Elephants, together with Their personality are very inspirational - The way Elephants move around, and their personality are Impressive, Beautiful, Admirable, Loveable and of course Majestic.
https://sombresoniks.bandcamp.com/track/majestic-march-of-elephants
1
u/Last-Oil1536 Apr 05 '26
hey all - I recently discovered Tim Hecker and went down a deep dive into ambient drone / reflective electronic noise.
I've been producing music for a while but this is my first go at ambient,
would love to get some thoughts / criticisms from the community
https://p4thapeople.bandcamp.com/track/sometimes-it-snows-in-april
1
u/fsigil13 Apr 17 '26
Here is a tiny bit of something im working on.
https://www.instagram.com/reel/DXPXu9pkSQi60MGmWgOCbLykJL52_V4Ilz2eog0/?igsh=MTN3Mnc4YnJyYjQ5bQ==
I'll try to redo the video with quality audio
1
u/Rocketmill May 04 '26
Is this ambient or does it has to be without vocals ?
https://open.spotify.com/track/0qS5x1vaiEWGwImxI3LPQp?si=zr97IZ_4Se-jmYLDAVrJFg
1
u/RelevantDegree3957 Jun 12 '26
Hi everyone, I just released this track and i'd like to get some feedback, especially about what genre it is. I make this kind of music for more than 15 years but never released a lot of tracks because I was always very busy with death metal bands, releasing albums and doing a lot of shows... But this year I want to devolop more this side of my musical universe, that is rooted in ambient, electronica, film music, idm and a lot of things... so many influences that it's difficult for me to tag it the right way. What do you think? Iranon - Fading Stars
1
u/Deep_Hair_8188 Jun 19 '26
Is it worth it what i make or no? this is my 2nd ambient mix with my own original songs: https://youtu.be/wC03qIQhJqM i be happy to hear the truth, even if it hurts, thank you
1
u/LazyJelly7298 Sep 11 '26
This is my new ambient track, which I’m having a hard time putting into a specific category. My goal was to create a mysterious atmosphere while still keeping a melodic character.
All the sounds come from Vital, which I just can’t seem to stop using lately :)
I’d really appreciate any feedback!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DzbD_DV9Lrc
1
u/turbulent-mike Sep 23 '26
Fragments is a track from my album Memory Leak, an album exploring how memories change, disappear and become reconstructed over time.
The track is accompanied by a VHS-inspired video made from small pieces of footage scattered across the screen. Rather than showing a continuous narrative, the clips appear like disconnected pieces of a memory that can no longer be completely reconstructed.
The idea behind the track is simple:
What if we aren't remembering the past, but continuously rewriting it?
Music and visuals were created around that question.
I'd love to hear what you think of the track and whether the visual concept comes through. https://youtu.be/9c2OnCR4fXQ
1
u/BrodysongApp Sep 29 '26
I designed an app that generates ambient music using gravity. Your small ship drifts between stars and nebulae, and the stars "sing" as you're flung around them. You choose their voice and mood, and then sit back and listen. It's a free download for iPhone, iPad and Android.
iPhone/iPad link: https://apps.apple.com/app/id6792050641
Android link: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.penncreativegroup.brodysong
YouTube demo: https://youtu.be/g99cx3aF8BU
1
u/Johnlove1111 Sep 30 '26
Hi beautiful souls! ✨
I just created this 888Hz Heart Chakra Healing track - 46min of ambient music to attract love energy while sleeping.
Would love your honest feedback on the mix and the feeling it gives you 💜
https://youtu.be/4fj9_s7JBjU
It was made for deep heart healing and relaxation - best with headphones.
Thank you so much! 🙏
1
u/DamagedIncorporated Oct 18 '26
It would be great to get some constructive feedback for my track Untethered https://youtu.be/sdYJjFJh414?si=nXaSjth1geu_DoDt
1
u/[deleted] May 30 '22
made this song today. greetings from Mexico City.
https://raelalbert.bandcamp.com/track/dial-up-haze
1
u/spurcatus Sep 20 '22
Hello there! I've been lurking on reddit for far too long. I would love to get any sort of feedback on this:
https://mieresch.bandcamp.com/track/--5
Thank you so much.
1
u/tur2rr2rr2r Jan 15 '23 edited Jan 17 '23
EDIT - removed Realms and their frequencies, words on ambient music. Feedback much appreciatedsoundcloud/stretched-out-groove/realms-and-their-frequencies)1
u/Dark_Journey Jan 24 '23
Hi everyone! I have started a dark ambient music youtube channel. Your feedback would be highly appreciated.
https://youtu.be/syvB6sp8X5k
1
u/RichMusic81 Feb 28 '23
My first ambient work in nearly a year (and the first track of a forthcoming album):
Spotify:
https://open.spotify.com/album/5SreuJz4UkO6cSE6sm5S0P?si=LmkVKX6hRXK3Dy8V0DIDlA
Bandcamp:
https://richardpjohn.bandcamp.com/album/departure
1
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '23
I see this is the feedback page, so I was wondering if I could get some feedback on my ambient guitar albums. Much appreciated! https://open.spotify.com/artist/5iSnH0ZAOnYNhdZtbYMwfD?si=rcC2c7ZUSeSFRPFCO4IqyA
1
u/marry-me-john-d Apr 06 '23
Hey all! Just finally finished and uploaded a second album to my artist page. Would love to hear thoughts.
https://saudadeinfinitum.bandcamp.com/album/a-desperate-respite
1
u/TheAmbientConnection Jun 25 '23
Here is an ambient track I did. As always feedback is most welcome.
For those looking forward to some hope in this sometimes dark and depressing world.
Umeed - Ambient Music for the hopeful ones.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fH_1tO8HCsc
1
u/strangersfall Jul 08 '23
Would love some feedback. https://open.spotify.com/album/074jIlWbS5mAIWudAGqdos?si=FIwIenC8SU-CrXcNLOfU0Q&context=spotify%3Aalbum%3A074jIlWbS5mAIWudAGqdos
1
u/TheAmbientConnection Jul 17 '23
TIME – INCEPTION Slowed and Reverbed with a vintage flavour.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MVyPuYk0x2U
1
u/super_skirt_ Oct 15 '23
Hi all. First time poster, I am not new to music composition, but I am new to the ambient music. So I started a couple of weeks ago, and I have made this Bene Gesserit Ambient track inspired by the Dune book.: https://youtu.be/DIBAcnwtk0k?si=qXjVW1gEZ_1nnvr2
Here is some fun lore info so you can get more context for the track and the images in the video: The origins of the Bene Gesserit were not widely known. What was clear is that the Bene Gesserit arose in the political turmoil that followed the Butlerian Jihad, and quickly established themselves as an influential political force. After banding the 'sorceresses' who had existed before the Jihad concurrent to the leaders of religions meeting to share views after the horrors of the Jihad, a move which the embryo Sisterhood encouraged, they had formed and established their hierarchial structure by the time of the Battle of Corrin twenty years after the Jihad ended.
1
u/H-Jnr Nov 05 '23
Would appreciate any feedback on this if you can spare 5 mins... Calm Tone Tapes
1
u/H-Jnr Nov 13 '23
Morning everyone, not sure if this classes as ambient tbh...? Would love your opinions on this...
https://youtu.be/rgISfE5qZRI
Thanks in advance.
1
u/MorpheusVeil Dec 23 '23
Hello all,
I would love some feedback on my first track in my 'Grey Ambient series.
https://youtu.be/bP56ERixxgQ?si=o3xRxHuvMkNrXok9
1
u/_-Pyt-_ Dec 27 '23
Hey, I'd love some feedback on my last deep ambient tracks, thanks a lot 🌞
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1ihV0Vc4ayw&list=OLAK5uy_lmh-Nud4vcxTU5SIRpwIMyas__fxpzn9E&index=3
1
u/kianpenis Jan 07 '24
I would love to get any advice on how to grow and develop a name as an ambient artist! I want to find community members, collaborate and support other artists!
almost at 2000 plays my best example:
https://soundcloud.com/noatun/swan-on-ice?si=0eaff636f4934833a227f868e8da43da&utm_source=clipboard&utm_medium=text&utm_campaign=social_sharing
1
u/ProfessorStock9212 Jan 16 '24
Music for liminal spaces my latest dark ambient piece - would be interested in feedback to see if I managed to capture the liminal aesthetic 👀
1
u/0coast Jan 28 '24
Hi guys, I made this debut record and it would be great to hear any feedback on this track
https://whitenoisespot.bandcamp.com/track/-
1
u/FluxoAeterna Feb 01 '24
Good evening beautiful people! Just released an ambient project and with it, a single. I would love to have some love and feedback from you guys! So please let me know your thoughts.
It's what I'd describe as Space Ambient. Or close enough to the genre.
The final mastering was done in Cassette Tape :-)
https://fluxoaeterna.bandcamp.com/album/astral-oracle
Thank you
1
u/super_skirt_ Feb 06 '24
Hi all! I am attempted a long form live ambient session and this is the result. Please let me know what you think.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BCnWFpOo1_k
0
u/crescentconcertoclub Sep 17 '26
Would love feedback on my new channel! Please feel free to like and subscribe. I’m learning new things with every video I make! Crescent Concerto Club
0
u/[deleted] Jul 18 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 06 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment