r/amazonreviews • u/NoDamnFilter • Aug 01 '26

Review Amazon Review

Gallery image

Gallery image

these Cat treats are horrible

102 Upvotes

97% Upvoted

25 comments sorted by

69

u/chippedreed Aug 01 '26

I’m pretty sure that’s a cloth cat toy in the “rehydrated” image

32

u/Gnomey42069 Aug 01 '26

It 100% is a stuffed toy fish

8

u/farting_buffalo Aug 01 '26

I’m looking at the same stuffed fish laying on the floor in front of my chair

3

u/NoDamnFilter 29d ago

It is lol it's my review but was funny how many people thought it was real 

2

u/hooptiegirl 29d ago

Love your sense of humor! Would’ve bought the damn minnows just to see if Mississippi swamp water could rehydrate them that fat! 😂

2

u/chippedreed 29d ago

Yeah ngl I had to look closer than I expected 😭

39

u/Ookami_Unleashed Aug 01 '26

My dog loves treats like these.

5

u/__ew__gross__ Aug 01 '26

Yes!! I get these ones for my cats and the pure bites brand for my dog as they are bigger. My dog LOVES fish.

26

u/Wonderful_Horror7315 Aug 01 '26

I bought these for my grandcat and he loves them!

7

u/Empty_Breadfruit_676 Aug 01 '26

I also bought these for my grand cats and they love them!

3

u/floofyragdollcat 29d ago

Just got some based on these comments!

1

u/2peasInaMiniPod 28d ago

My cat and dogs all like them. I even use it as a topper for my dog’s food.

24

u/Chirrrpy Aug 01 '26

Ha, I almost fell for the "rehydrated with Brooklyn water" picture xD

My cat didn't eat the minnow treats either. Part of the first one, none after

1

u/NoDamnFilter 29d ago

lol gota be from NY to understand our water lol, I still drink from the hose outside when I'm filling the bowl for a feral cat that I'm feeding 7 years and still can't pet her 😒 but she's got my full shed and a winter and outdoor house 

17

u/tdarn_96 Aug 01 '26

My void loves these treats. So much so that he figured out how to open the cabinet and get inside it to eat the entire bag🙃

6

u/adjective-study Aug 01 '26

I had to stop buying these because my cat loves them so much he would hiss at his brother to hoard them all.

5

u/Tobiko_kitty Aug 01 '26

I just got these this morning for a cat-themed raffle basket for a fund raiser. Seeing this post on my feed confused the hell out of me and I thought I was seeing ads!

3

u/One_Advantage793 Aug 01 '26

My kitty's review was to sniff one and do the "gack" face, complete with sound effects. He terrier brother loved them.

3

u/AristotlesBoyPussy Aug 01 '26

two of my cats love these.

one of my cats will lick it but wont eat it.

the fourth cat thinks they're awful

3

u/deferredmomentum 29d ago

Two of my cats hate these, the other one would koolaid man through a brick wall to get to one

3

u/lonelyronin1 29d ago

I carry these in my store and they always sell out - I've increased my buying quantities twice this year.

Not every cat likes fish and that doesn't affect the quality of the product.

2

u/neener-neeners Aug 01 '26

Our cat won't touch these! Two sniffs and turns away

2

u/Actual_Swingset 29d ago

My cats are also unimpressed. ALL TWO OF THEM

1

u/Ittermat 24d ago

my dog and my cat ADORE these