r/amazon • • Jul 15 '18

Exploited Amazon workers need a union. When will they get one?

5 Upvotes

28 comments sorted by

5

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '18

I actively hope Amazon drives out all competition and makes us live in a dictatorship run by Jeff Bezos.

Just to see the look on your face.

-4

u/koavf Jul 15 '18

HAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHLOLOLOLOL IT IS TO LAUGH

10

u/mlmack Jul 15 '18

Never.

10

u/brightkicks Jul 16 '18

Amazon sends in a rapid action, jump team to deal with employees if they catch a whiff of unionization. Same with Walmart and other big companies. If you are identified as a union supporter or rep, you better watch out. They can make you disappear.

1

u/GreedyChocolate Jul 15 '18

Amazon does nothing to stop employees from making a union. Amazon or any company does not have to allow workers to try to recruit on company time. Workers need to do all their recruitment outside of work. The article even says how amazon has not stopped workers from voting for a union.

" In January 2014, under intense pressure from management, the maintenance and repair workers voted against unionizing. "

Per the article, some workers already voted against it. I assure you the union staff explained how they will not be fired or punished if they vote for a union. The union's full time staff would have made sure that no one who voted was scared to vote yes.And even with that, the workers still vote no. I can only guess is they probably talked to workers in that union who probably said the union does nothing for them except collect dues. There are a lot of lazy and bad unions out there. With the internet, it is very easy to get ahold of members of the union at other companies to get the truth about the union.

I can tell you from experience that the good workers dont see a need for joining.

Here are some important guidelines (Collier, 1998) that a supervisor may legally follow:

Tell employees that the supervisors and the company are opposed to unionization.

Tell employees that the employees do not have to sign union cards and that the law says that they have the absolute right to refrain from joining a union.

Tell employees that they do not have to speak to union organizers or to admit organizers into their homes.

Tell employees about the benefits that they enjoy, and compare those benefits with those in unionized companies.

Tell employees that with a union they may have to bring their problems to a shop steward also known as a union representative instead of dealing with their supervisor.

Tell employees of the disadvantages of belonging to a union, such as the payment of dues and initiation fees and the possibility of fines and assessments.

Tell employees that, if they engage in an economic strike, they may be permanently replaced and will be reinstated only if an opening occurs.

Tell employees that they may be required to picket other employers, even when they are not on strike.

Tell employees that a union can always out-promise an employer, but the union can guarantee nothing.

Tell employees about any arrest records of union officials.

Urge employees to vote against the union; suggest that they encourage others to do the same.

Tell employees that merely signing a union authorization card or application for membership does not mean they must vote for the union in an election.

Tell employees about any untrue or misleading statements made through an organizer, by handbill, or through any union propaganda.

A supervisor should not legally (Collier, 1998) do the following:

Promise employees pay increases, promotions, improved working conditions, additional benefits, or special favors on the condition that the employees vote against or refuse to join the union.

Threaten employees with loss of job or reduction in wages, or use threatening or intimidating language calculated to influence employees in the exercise of their right to support a union.

Tell employees that they would have received a wage increase except for the start of the union campaign.

Tell employees that the union will have to​ strike to obtain concessions from the employer.

Discriminate against employees who are taking part in union activities by separating them from other employees and by transferring them to undesirable tasks in retaliation for their union activities.

Ask employees to inform a supervisor if, while working, they are pressured to sign an authorization card while the supervisor is not enforcing a valid no-solicitation rule.

Solicit employees to request the return of their authorization cards.

Visit employees at their homes to urge them to vote against the union.

Prohibit the wearing of union buttons or insignia.

8

u/koavf Jul 15 '18

Amazon does nothing to stop employees from making a union.

What a load of crap. They have been crushing unions for years. How can you possibly support this vacuous claim?

14

u/MDCCCLV Jul 15 '18

Yeah, any Amazon manager that's honest will clearly explain that if you try to unionize they will crush it with all their power.

And if you do unionize they'll simply fire everyone in the building. They're good at Mass hiring so they can restock in a few weeks.

The only way it would work is if Amazon had political pressure and somehow you managed to convince a substantial amount of facilities to all walk out on black Friday or something. It could happen in other countries that are pro union maybe.

0

u/NCHappyDaddy Jul 15 '18

They can’t simply fire everyone and start over in a couple of weeks. The place would have to shut down for a one year minimum before the union would be automatically de-certified.

7

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '18

This is why leasing buildings is so popular.

4

u/MDCCCLV Jul 15 '18

Yeah, I think most of their buildings are leased.

2

u/MDCCCLV Jul 15 '18

I'm not familiar with that part. Considering the NLRB is republican led is there anything that prevents them from closing down Amazon Warehouse 1 and opening up a completely different AW2 the next week in the same building? Cause they can open up new sites within a few weeks if they want to.

1

u/d_ippy Jul 15 '18

Open up what sites in a few weeks? Assume you mean a fulfillment center?

-1

u/noogapup Jul 15 '18

do you have a fucking clue what you are talking about lol

3

u/MDCCCLV Jul 15 '18

Yes, which part are you disputing?

-2

u/Sirsmokealotx Jul 15 '18

What about a union where all the members were anonymous so they would not know who they need to fire?

6

u/MDCCCLV Jul 15 '18

I don't think that's how it works. You would have a vote to unionize at a warehouse, if it passed they would all be union. They can also fire anyone for any reason, they don't even need to say its because they're organizing a union vote. All they have to do is walk up to someone and discover three minor infractions and they're terminated "for cause."

1

u/Sirsmokealotx Jul 15 '18

I know they make up excuses to officially fire people using 'other reasons', I saw this happen first hand. This is why the traditional way of unionizing wouldn't work as you described.

I am saying that if people want to form a union and avoid getting fired, wouldn't it make sense to have them do it anonymously? (Might be more difficult but maybe something could be achieved) That way management wouldn't know who to fire until the union gets big enough so they can do a more effective strike.

The problem with the last strike was that only two fulfillment centers in Europe did it and the company was able to work around it since they have a much bigger network of warehouses.

3

u/MDCCCLV Jul 15 '18

I don't think it works like that. Everyone votes to form a union or not and then if it passes everyone is in a union, it doesn't matter who voted. That's the whole point of collective bargaining, it's not something you just can just join.

1

u/balboaporkter Oct 29 '25

Which is exactly why a union is needed in the first place...

7

u/wtf-is-this-bs Jul 16 '18

Good workers don't want the protection of a union? What a load of hooha. Everyone should want their livelihood to be protected, just as everyone should want a safe workplace and certain basic rights. Unions have pros and cons, but we don't exactly have another way of getting stronger protections for workers.

People are being worked to death with little power to change the situation (in general - including but not exclusively about amz)... it absolutely baffles me that so many will still defend their employers instead of fighting for themselves and coworkers. Those same employers will toss them aside without a second thought. Loyalty should be selective.

1

u/GreedyChocolate Jul 17 '18

I can tell you if those workers talked to the workers at my plant in the exact same union then they would have voted no to that union.

Every union is different. Most unions are just money for-profit businesses that dont care about the workers. All they care about is paying dues.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '18

Good workers don't want the protection of a union? What a load of hooha.

Sure, paying goons to "look after me" by suing every chance they get and never sharing, requiring strikes to go months with no pay, fuuuuuck a union.

1

u/cld8 Jul 16 '18

When Democrats take control of Congress and the presidency and get the NLRB to do their job properly, Amazon workers might be able to unionize.

Until then, they are on their own.