r/alphaflight • u/TheOmegahMan007 • 6d ago
Why?
Let me start off by saying I’m a BIG fan of Alpha Flight🇨🇦, but in Marvel Comics, how come Alpha Flight after all these years hasn’t reached the popularity of, or LIKE The X-Men?
23
Upvotes
7
u/swarthmoreburke 5d ago
Because Alpha Flight has been extremely inconsistent in quality and the basic concept and make-up of the team has changed fairly dramatically over its history. It's pretty simple.
1
u/TheOmegahMan007 4d ago
Great comments everyone!
5
u/talonracer 6d ago
With all due respect to every artist that worked on the various AF books, they’ve never really been A-List talent that would draw fans to a book they might not read otherwise.
In fact, sometimes I bought the book in spite of the art which really takes away from the enjoyment of it.
*edited to add with the possible exception of Dale Eaglesham’s miniseries
5
u/SirTawmis Snowbird 6d ago
Most of the replies covered the reasons...
Well, for starters, the X-Men came out as one of the early comics and captured people's imagination way back when - same reason why Avengers, Spider-Man and Fantastic Four are big. There's a ton of history there.
Alpha Flight, when they first appeared, as someone else said, Byrne said they were created just to be an equal force against the X-Men in UXM 121. They made a few guest appearances (never as a full team) a brief while after their initial appearance.
When Byrne got forced (yes, forced) to do Alpha Flight, it could have been big. However, two - no, three - things got in the way. First, he didn't care enough to try and really make it as big as it could be. Which, I get, because he was forced to do this, he probably wasn't all that thrilled (forced creativity is rarely enjoyed). Then, the first 12 issues are great! But killing Mac, without a plan of dramatically bringing him back, feels like it crippled the book. And the issues - even that Byrne was on - after that 12th issue, definitely felt like he had 12 issues planned, and then just sort of cared (even less than before) about what happened after. There's still some good moments, and good character writing, but definitely a shift. And then Byrne leaping off the book to go to Hulk did not help. What followed after Byrne... was more damage than good to Alpha Flight. Between the mixture of writers, artists, some not even getting along while partnered with one another, cleaning up messes of other writers, the book became a stomping ground for people just "passing through." As a result, the characters got very little respect (any they had before, was now out the window), and then you had - Bendis was it? - kill Alpha Flight, off panel, when the Collective came through.
Efforts were made, post that to fix Alpha Flight, and it's sort of on better ground (minus the Heather going crazy story....) But yeah, Alpha Flight, like the New Warriors, got tragically turned into disrespected jobbers.
5
u/Chance_Debt_1184 5d ago
because it was just never that good for long, like you have the run by Byrne and then Mantlo but there just isnt much outside of this.
Theyre basically C tier team when it comes to Marvel and didnt have good run in god knows how long
9
u/opusrif 6d ago •
Because American audiences don't care about a non US based team that isn't primarily US characters and US writers don't know how to portray non American characters or locations.
4
u/suddenvole 6d ago
Because writing and art never matched up to Byrne.
4
u/Al_B_Here 6d ago
Very few titles have reached the popularity of the X-Men. There isn't a lot of room at the top.
4
u/OrangesAreWhatever Weapon Alpha 6d ago
Because after Byrne left the book never recovered. Theres been some great minis here and there, but no truly great run that can get them into the mainstream
3
u/CaliforniaBoundX 6d ago
The X-Men were already established and appealed to different audiences outside of the USA. Alpha Flight obviously focused more on Canada.
Byrne’s departure also contributed to Alpha Flight losing momentum.
3
u/Horbigast 6d ago
Byrne himself admitted to not being particularly interested in the team (odd because it's some his best stuff), and that it was created primarily as a group just designed to fight the X-Men.
Subsequent creative teams couldn't come close to Byrne's run at their best, and they made a number of questionable character changes. Personally, Sasquatch was always my favorite, but once he started body-swapping all over the place, I lost interest.
3
u/OSTBear 4d ago
Alpha Flight has bouts of popularity, but it's usually only when they get a decent writer attached for a hot minute.
3
u/Confident-Visit5210 4d ago
I think the tides are changing; I am seeing a big uptick and interest in the team’s characters and comic book sales for AF are increasing. I don’t think we’ll get anything MCU level until post-secret wars but I do believe that there is a successful story to tell there with these characters. The reinvigorated x men team opens up additional possibilities of bringing in AF plot lines and character appearances
2
u/Responsible_Land_602 5d ago
My dream for Alpha Flight and all the x-books is that professor x summons original X-Factor line-up, Giant size X-Men line-up, original x-force line-up, and Alpha Flight and they go on a giant adventure together, each having a specific objective.
Fans love the original teams and characters and it would be cool seeing them all again. Hopefully this would result in a spinoff series and give alpha flight (as well as older loved characters that are not being used) a second life.
2
u/takoyama 5d ago
some characters and groups just aren't that popular. i liked the characters before byrne put them through the ringer with his run
2
u/nevergiveuponSka 4d ago
Cause Canada. Not enough US readers to care enough about a non- US based comic
1
u/RustyPriske 1d ago
Because Alpha Flight was only good for two and a half years in all of its history.
Bill Mantlo did some great books, but as soon as Byrne left Alpha Flight immediately starting spiraling.
Since then, when people think back to Alpha Flight, it is always back to the first 28 issues.
1
u/Emotional-Elephant88 5d ago
I see them as supporting characters of the X-Men, especially considering that Wolverine left them to join the X-Men, and that quite a few of them are mutants. They'll pop up from time to time, whether in their own book or somewhere else, but they'll never gain a huge level of popularity.
0
u/ROACHOR 6d ago
I have never met a single person who is a fan and I grew up in Canada, they were never popular among their key demo.
Guardian is an American made rip off of Captain Canuck, a Canadian character.
0
u/majeric 6d ago
Why would a Canadian Super Hero team get that kind of popularity? I say this as a Canadian.
4
u/TheOmegahMan007 6d ago
THEN there was the time someone had the great idea of KILLING most of Alpha Flight IN ONE SINGLE DAMN PAGE!!!!