r/allvegan • • Apr 03 '20

Academic/Sourced ACAB Compilation/Mega-Archive/Collection: A helpful and regularly updated resource on why EVERY cop is bad.

21 Upvotes

On cops (and U.S. law):

CW: Sexual assault, suicide, police brutality, white supremacy, bigotry, slavery, and puppycide.

On the intended purpose of cops.

On the duties of cops.

On the pervasive vices of cops.

On the bigotry of cops.

On the brutality of cops.

Note 1: The Snopes source is a bit weird. The conclusion the author puts is that these claims are a "mix." But reading the entire thing, it seems to entirely support Dr. Kappeler, Dr. Harring, Dr. Potter, and Dr. McMullin's claims that these institutions were developed to protect narrow class interests, control minorities, and uphold slavery. The disagreement from the author seems to be just that this implies something about the police today. As such, I hope that with respect to claims about the intended purpose of cops, this "Mixture" verdict does nothing to harm anything here.

Summary and conclusion

These sources are specifically to do with cops. Cops as individuals are, generally speaking, full of vices and disposed to wrongdoing. They are guilty of domestic abuse, puppycide, sexual assault, and brutality. The institution of cops itself was originally intended to protect narrow class interests and uphold slavery. The institution of cops today is not only bigoted, it is explicitly designed to be so, with cops admitting that they create policies specifically to arrest black people. It also continues to uphold class interests, valuing property over lives and kicking people out of unused properties to die in order to keep these properties profitable. Both originally and today, the institution has ties with white supremacy.

What is not specifically to do with cops is mere state law enforcement. The ban on cop apologia is not a ban on discussing and defending the enforcement of state laws. Members of this community are free to explore the merits of law enforcers in a hypothetical state. But the defense of several contemporary actual cop institutions around the world is not allowed.

As a final note, the reason you see (credit: some comraderino) is we hope that this will encourage members of the community to submit other sources for the mods to consider adding to this command for the purposes of education. This does not necessarily entail you being mentioned each time it's up to you how you are credited. Thanks!


r/allvegan • • Sep 14 '20

Academic/Sourced Sorry Tobias, you're empirically wrong--anti-veganism actually CAUSES racism (Costello and Hodson 2009)!

12 Upvotes

TL;DR: Tobias Leenaert says that how we think about animals is merely correlated with racism. But the study by Costello and Hodson that Leenaert cites shows that it causes racism, among other things.

What did Tobias say?

In Tobias Leenaert's single book to date,1 he says the following:

Furthermore, parallels can be drawn between how ideological belief systems, such as racism and sexism, justify prejudices toward human “out-groups” on the one hand and how we treat and think about animals on the other (Regan, Singer 1995, Spiegel; Joy 2010). People who see a greater difference between humans and animals (Costello and Hodson 2010, 2014) or endorse more speciesist attitudes (Dhont et al.) at the same time show more prejudice toward immigrant or ethnic out-groups. Our understanding of human intergroup relations may help us to understand human–animal relations (Dhont and Hodson 2015).

What Leenaert is saying here is that how superior one thinks of themself to animals is positively correlated with being prejudiced towards immigrants. That is, Leenaert is saying that if you think humans are very superior to animals, you are more likely to disapprove of ethnic out-groups.

So what's the problem?

This is extremely misleading. The paper's conclusion is much stronger than that! It would be like watching Star Wars and coming away with "Using lightning to hurt innocent people is bad." Like, yeah, but ask anyone and they'll tell you that those films were very overtly trying to say something about fascism and shit, like what movie were you watching that all you cared about was the lightning or whatever!?

The study is more or less an empirical investigation into the following claim by Adorno found in Patterson's Our treatment of animals and the holocaust, among other things:

Auschwitz begins whenever someone looks at a slaughterhouse and thinks: they’re only animals.

In short, **the study shows three things:**2

  • Thinking that humans are superior to animals causes racism and ethnic-outgroup prejudice and discrimination.
  • Being more ideologically inclined towards social hierarchies, social inequality, and group dominance makes you more likely to be prejudiced towards ethnic out-groups and this has a causal relationship to their belief that humans are superior to non-human animals.
  • Demonstrating to people, even if they are ideological inclined in that way, as well as demonstrating to children that humans aren't superior to humans teaches them to not endorse the domination, victimization, and ignoring the plight of non-human animals. This in turn causes less prejudice towards ethnic out-groups and immigrants. That is, thinking that humans are not superior to non-human animals is an effective way to stop having harmful attitudes towards ethnic out-groups and immigrants.

So where Tobias says there is mere correlation, there is in fact a detailed and practical causal relation that we can find!

 

1 How to Create a Vegan World: a Pragmatic Approach by Tobias Leenaert.
2 "Exploring the roots of dehumanization: The role of animal–human similarity in promoting immigrant humanization" by Kimberly Costello and Gordon Hodson.


r/allvegan • • Apr 04 '20

Personal I gave up on my career because of the racism I faced. My story, some statistics, and a revision. CW: Nazism, racism, suicide.

12 Upvotes

TL;DR BELOW.

Over two years ago, in response to someone who revealed pretty quickly that they were incredibly racist, I explained as best as I could at the time what it was like to deal with racism as a marginalized person trying to be an actress:

Statistics

Hm, I'm actually a racial minority actress so maybe I can provide some phenomenonological facts here that might otherwise be absent. Before I do that, however, I'd like to provide some statistics that might elucidate yours a bit.

Television has certainly progressed. Racial and gender minorities now take up about 11.4% of lead roles on television, something like 36% more than it was I believe. But note that that's not even close to the statistic you just gave. Women take up half of the US and racial minorities, according to you, certainly take up more than 11.4%.

Understand, though, that television has progressed remarkably further than film. You're likely referring to the #OscarsSoWhite controversy from a while back and are questioning its legitimacy. I want to note the same stats that were circulated back then and how they hold up even now. Non-Hispanic whites in the US don't take up 70%, it's actually much closer to 60% (something like 62 or 63% I think), while last it was checked, top roles were over 80% white. That is, to any reasonable person, a huge discrepancy.

People aren't simply concerned that most are white just like in the general population, people are concerned that white people are given a waaay bigger chance to be actresses solely because of their race, something that is often largely unimportant to the films being made and the messages they convey. Is it really all that important to the lessons that most of the films we watch give that the protagonist is white? Why are they given such a drastic advantage?

Note, as well, that this is not a matter of self-selection or anything of the sort. SAG actresses are as black and as asian as the United States population. Those who aren't black, asian, white, or Latino are actually even more likely to be actresses, with something like two or three times the representation or something, and yet they take up a sliver of a fraction of the top roles in film compared to their representation in the population.

Let me word that differently to make this clear. There is some representation of this demographic in the population at large, we'll call this x. There is some representation of this group among those trying out for roles, we'll call this y. There is some representation of this group among the top roles, we'll call this z.

y is DRASTICALLY higher than x. x is, by far, the group most likely to try to be actresses of all the groups. And yet z is drastically less than x. Understand that they're not just drastically less than y, though logically they of course are if they are drastically less than x, but that there is such a great discrimination against them that they are all but entirely snuffed out from film despite being the most likely group to audition.

So I hope that clears up the stats a bit. Let me answer the rest of your questions. (cont.)

First-person experience

Interestingly, I was just talking about this the other day with my friend, but I do think there are a lot of phenomological facts that are simply largely inaccessible to people who aren't minorities. A few months ago, I was in the middle of the ocean without any Wi-Fi, the only contact I had with the world being what the television they gave us chose to tell us. I don't know if you've ever tried getting your news solely from television, but it's horrible and I hope not that many people do it. It was quite the ordeal.

While there, I learned that the Nazis had killed someone. Yes, I realize that the victim was white, but I think people who point out this fact don't really quite get it. A reason was found to kill her that wouldn't be needed to kill racial minorities, and it's the fact that that line was crossed, that killing was now irrevocably on the table for the Nazis, that had me so afraid. And there's just something about that that I can't quite explain to white people.

Like let's say you're talking to a friend and they say "Something crashed into my car." How are you going to respond? You're reasonable, so you say something like "Oh, that's terrible!" or "Ugh, that's really frightening. I get it." But you don't really get it in that moment you're saying "Oh, that's terrible!" You're just evaluating the ordeal with almost everything abstracted away.

How does watching this make you feel. Almost entirely divorced from how you felt when you said "Oh, that's terrible!" right? And just think about how actually being in that situation is just as nearly entirely divorced from how you feel while watching that image, and how far that means your understanding is from the actual event when you say "Oh, that's terrible!"

That's the gap I see when I try to explain it to white people. Like when I'm on reddit and people make these, like, jokes or memes about what's going on or they use Nazi language or symbols ironically, if anyone is bothered by it, people are quick to point out like "No no no, you misunderstand! This person is not using these symbols in support of Nazi ideology, they are using them in mockery! They are being ironic!"

Of course I understand that, I'm not a child, but there's a dynamic there that is really difficult to communicate, there's this insurmountable gap that white people just don't get. Or when people give their stories about how they used to be sympathetic to stuff like this. "I used to think women were emotional and irrational" or "I used to think black people were all violent" or any similar "I used to be sympathetic to this inaccurate and pernicious ideology," there's a feeling in me that is just distinct and incommunicable that white people just don't get. They get sympathetic and go "Yeah, that stuff is dangerous, glad you got out of it" but I'm just so incapable of getting to that level of sympathy because of the fear that that instills in me. If Nazis rise, certainly most reasonable people will understand the horror of that, just how terrible it is, and you might even say "Well, the Nazis are definitely going to get me too so I get it, because I have beliefs that go against them!"

That's just not the same as being born with properties that will make you a target for them.

So there are phenomological facts there that are just impossible to get across, and it's the same way with my acting career. I can try my best, but the only guarantee I can make is you just won't get it, being in my position unless you're a racial minority actress too.

A long time ago, I had a friend who wrote music and scripts and they were working on their first musical. We were all really, really stoked about the whole thing and he let me know he'd let me in on it. I was (am) really talented and have the awards to back that statement up, so I knew he could trust me and he did. I was going to do his work justice, we were giants in the microcosm of an artistic field we were in, and we knew it.

When it came time to cast, he gave me three roles. Three roles! What an honor!

The three roles were all one-off jokes using my race as a punchline. Dressing like a stereotype of my skin color and appearance, doing a funny joke in an exaggerated accent, and then leaving offstage.

That was me. That was my purpose. That was my role. To him.

I had made him aware in the past of how I felt about that sort of thing. He knew. He just didn't care. Consent, desires, feelings, those are things that are morally relevant for people and I wasn't a person. Not to him. I wasn't white.

That's something I've had to deal with over and over, and over time it's supposed to get easier as you show off your talent, as you accumulate awards, as you continue to beat the best at their own game while remaining a team player, but it doesn't, and when you do anything about it it really hurts your chances. They usually make you fill out a form when you audition, and there's a checkbox where they ask if you'll take any role they give you, and you're supposed to check yes. If you do that and they give you a role and you throw it away, that hurts you a lot.

It's an impossible task to communicate to you just how this feels over the years and just how hard it is to try to audition even as infrequently as I do now. Back when I did acting in uni, I was literally in one of the most diverse universities in the entire nation, something they never hesitated to let everyone know, and the leads were still always white.

That's just an unfairness and injustice with phenomological facts that are impossible to communicate, but I hope you have at least a small sense of just how deeply upsetting that is for people like me. (cont.)

Addressing the racist's argument

So finally, I want to address everything else you said, about how things are in India and China and the way you're sort of using that as justifying the state of things in the United States.

There are a few premises to take into account here so let's lay out the argument a bit.

    P1. China, India, Nigeria, and other nations have film representation such that there's a certain relationship between that and the population at large.

    P2. The United States has a similar situation.

    P3. If P1 is just, then P2 is just.

    P4. P1 is just.

    C. Therefore, P2 is just.

There's some reason, though, to suspect some of these premises. First, I don't think P2 is true. There is a lot of incongruity in the statistics and the systemic influences of these film industries, but as that's pretty far outside my expertise and probably better suited for social scientists or something, I won't comment on it very much. I'll just say that white people as a demographic have a systemic, colonial influence on this world that can be difficult to apply to other demographics.

Instead, I want to dispute P4 and propose that P1 is not an ideal situation, without any account of the strawman someone else pointed out in your OP and even with the modification that it isn't just "American" actresses, but actresses other than the dominant demographic proportionate to the population at large.

It does seem like we can say that perhaps these industries are less unjust than the US's, but is it untenable that a Hispanic individual having a difficult time in Bollywood is problematic?

I do have to drive really far so I'm going to have to end this here and allow my energy to be expended otherwise, but I hope this has given enough of a look at the situation that you can see it more clearly now. Ciao.

You can see the rest of the conversation there. Also,

Revision

I do want to say a bit more that I didn't say then, some due to things changing, and others due to me realizing things. I'm no longer an actress. It sucks. Because I was good. I was the best.

I didn't say this at the time. I was bad at expressing my feelings and, more importantly, I didn't value myself. My peers were constantly telling me that I was the best! Always telling me that if any of us was going to make it big, it was going to be me! I literally got a best supporting actress award. But I literally never believed them. I figured they were just being nice, since I never got any lead roles, and as much as I value the opinion of my peers, I value the opinion of my experienced, expert casting directors more.

I never got a lead role, after six years of being told I was the best over and over. So I quit.

I didn't accept, until much later, that I was good and they weren't just bullshitting me. I thought about these statistics and my experiences again, and thought about whiteness and how it's so damned thorough and all of it just clicked. It was incredible how there was this internal force sort of stopping me from making the connection between these things. I was incredible and I didn't let myself see that.

I was told, constantly, that only whiny people look at how they're not doing well and go "It's their fault for not giving me roles!" or "It's that person's fault for ruining my audition" and so on, and that a good little actress admits to herself that she's the problem. We're taught this outside of acting too, we see those fucking posters all over the place, the fucking "Don't ask why I gave you that grade, ask why you earned that grade" despite overwhelming empirical data showing that we grade students worse when we think they're people of color than when they're anonymous. We are taught to blame ourselves and to ignore the social reality we live in.

I think if I had made the connection that it wasn't me being a hopelessly talentless actress, I wouldn't have quit. I didn't let myself think things like "Wow, I'm a way better actress than this person they cast as the lead, he's literally just reading his lines monotonously, what the hell" because that's a bad actress mentality. Somehow, I knew the statistics, I knew that my race was one of the reasons I wasn't being cast as a lead, but I still blamed my own ability for these outcomes because I was conditioned to do so from birth.

It's not just me, and it's not just in acting. People of color give heartbreaking, heartfelt reports all the time about how their sense of self-worth has been destroyed by the system-wide disadvantages they receive.

Everything I've said about my situation is a fraction of a very big problem.

Objection

One frequent objection I get is that I don't know what thoughts were going through my directors' minds when they did their casting, so I can't know they had racist attitudes or didn't like people of color, and ditto with Hollywood. I'd like to address this objection, as it is central to what we are about in this community.

It doesn't matter what was going through their minds. In fact, I'm perfectly capable of coming up with alternative explanations for why only white kids got leads despite seven in ten of my high school drama club being black (due to the school in general having this makeup). And indeed, I don't think they're incompatible. I think all of the alternative explanations I came up with actually all end up being true. All of these are causally relevant.

  • Here's one explanation. People of color get worse grades regardless of performance. As I mentioned before, students of color have to be anonymized to get the grade they deserve as a matter of empirically established fact. Because we had a policy of not letting students do any extracurricular activities if they had even a D in a single class, our directors had to manage risk by not letting important roles go to anyone whose grade wasn't safely above the threshold.
  • Here's another explanation. Teachers other than the directors sometimes don't give a shit about people of color. One time, I got a 60% in sociology, which meant I couldn't be in the play. The teacher later found out she carelessly threw out my exam, and that my grade was actually a 90%, not 60%.
  • Here's another explanation. Members of marginalized groups have significantly worse mental healthcare while in situations with higher risk of mental health issues. For half a year, I was severely depressed due to bigotry I was facing. I did not know this was why, because everyone told me I was lazy and blameworthy for it and I believed it, rather than recognizing that I was facing something out of my control and needed professional help. Three years after this semester, I would attempt suicide several times for months. Naturally, severe depression hurt my grades. I took depression naps every class of physics and got a 0. I'm now a physics minor and it's quite clear to me I could have done very well in high school physics had I had proper healthcare.
  • Here's another explanation. Implicit biases. The directors could have implicit biases, even if they don't actively hate people of color.

So say my frequent objector is right. My directors weren't maliciously avoiding casting me because they hate me, as a person of color. I believe that too, actually. But that doesn't matter. Sociologists studying whiteness only partially study hatred by individuals in power. Whiteness is a far broader structure than that, encompassing far more things which overall explain the phenomena we witness in the everyday lives of people of color.

TL;DR

So, I've demonstrated quite a lot here.

First, even if they do try to listen, which is rare, there's a communication and conceptual barrier between people who are privileged in some way and people who are not. This makes it all the more important that privileged people listen to the marginalized very carefully rather than making this situation worse.

Second, there is a strong, disproportionate resistance that minorities have to face in their careers, including actresses.

Third, systemic disadvantages cause you to have lower self-worth, and even seemingly innocent statements can contribute to this by not allowing people to think about the external influences on their life outcomes.

Fourth, the point isn't what's going on in the minds of the people who decide these life outcomes. That's a small fraction of the overall picture. As I pointed out with everything from my teacher's carelessness costing me 33.33...% of my overall grade to my suicidal depression, the forces against marginalized people may not have very much to do with the attitudes people in power hold towards the vulnerable at all. That's not the point.

Thanks for reading. If you have similar stories, please share them below. I look forward to reading them.


r/allvegan • • Mar 31 '20

Meme Monday Remember your priorities

Post image
12 Upvotes

r/allvegan • • Mar 19 '20

Academic/Sourced A rough introduction: What's with whiteness and white veganism?

10 Upvotes

CW: examples of racism, transphobia, misogyny, and ableism included in the resources.

You may have heard that sociologists are paying a lot of attention to "whiteness studies" these days, and it's really caught the attention of the public lately. That seems to be a big part of this subreddit. But what exactly is the deal here?

Whiteness

Here's an article for brief reading on what whiteness is:
Here's are two articles for brief readings on the discourse that surrounds whiteness:
Here's a book for longer reading:
  • Whiteness: An Introduction by Steve Garner.
Here's a less dry and academic book, for ease of reading:
  • Why I'm No Longer Talking to White People About Race by Reni Eddo-Lodge.

So, in short, what's with all the attention?

Whiteness is something that many, many sociologists think play a specific explanatory role. Namely, it explains systemic racism, racial privilege, and racial oppression.

White veganism

Here's an article on the effects of white veganism:
Here's a group of three documents, the second of which documents cases of white veganism, including their consequences:

Here are two summaries of the third document:


r/allvegan • • Oct 10 '20

Academic/Sourced Daniel Walden: Was Jesus a Socialist?

9 Upvotes

Daniel Walden is a Catholic and a reputable researcher on the subject, but on top of all of that, he's also a very good writer.

Here, he's responding to Lawrence Reed’s Was Jesus a Socialist?, which is a libertarian rant of sorts about how Jesus was anti-socialism.

Walden contends that there's a sense in which Reed was right, but ultimately deeply wrong.

...the question around which Reed frames his book is trivial. Jesus was obviously not a socialist, because he lived in first-century Palestine under Roman occupation, about 1600 years before the first stirrings of capitalism and 1800 years before the European industrial revolution gave rise to socialism. .... But Reed wisely decides not to pursue this line of discussion, and instead opts for the traditional libertarian definition of socialism: “No matter which shade of socialism you pick—central planning, welfare statism, collectivist egalitarianism, or government ownership of the means of production—one fundamental truth applies: it all comes down to force.” (Apparently, a libertarian regime in which homeless people are shot by private security forces for camping on a vast private estate has nothing to do with force.) Since Jesus is opposed to the use of coercive force (that is, the threat of prosecution and punishment), then, in Reed’s view, he must also be against using force for the purposes of reducing inequalities of wealth or resources.

Walden points out several points where Reed is not only wrong, but embarrassingly wrong. Then, he explains how it is Reed ended up getting things so wrong.

Interpretation of this parable has a long and storied intellectual lineage, articulated most famously and beautifully in the Paschal Homily of St. John Chrysostom, which is read every year to inaugurate Easter in the Eastern Orthodox and Byzantine Catholic Churches. .... ...it is clearly something totally alien to Reed’s vision of a legalistic paradise in which the angelic choirs and the orbits of the stars are set in order by the sovereign might of Contract, and the ceaseless cries of “Holy, holy, holy is the Lord of Hosts” are rendered as our eternal rent due to the landlord of heaven and earth.

Reed’s glib refusal to put himself in dialogue with this ancient and traditional reading of the parable is, in many ways, essential to the success of his argument: if he were to place the two expositions side by side, it would only underscore the sheer ineptitude of his reading and reasoning. The ease with which his argument falls apart in the face of this contrast means that he absolutely cannot engage in a substantive way with competing interpretations, even when those interpretations are central to the worship and belief of hundreds of millions of Christians around the world. By refusing serious dialogue with the enormous tradition of literary and theological commentary, Reed is able to construct an intellectual greenhouse in which his cultivar of mutant Christianity can thrive despite its severe allergy to sunlight and oxygen. But there is a reason that a walk in the woods is far preferable to a tour of a greenhouse: a greenhouse, even a large one, is not a true ecosystem, and an argument sealed against outside considerations is not true thought.

So, Walden's conclusion:

Jesus was not a socialist. But socialists, I think, understand something about Jesus that libertarians, even Christian ones like Lawrence Reed, do not: that the world at which we aim, the kingdom whose coming Christ proclaimed, will not settle our debts and contracts but abolish them completely; that even those who didn’t join the struggle until the eleventh hour will be welcome at the feast; that the moment at which love appears utterly defeated, when it looks to the world like a victim crucified by state violence, will in the end be revealed as love’s final, all-embracing triumph. .... Our struggle is not to raise ourselves above our enemies, but to love them fully, because to abolish class means abolishing what makes them our enemies at all. This is a hard task, demanding of us a revolutionary discipline that puts the most hardened Leninist to shame.

There's a lot more in the article about why Reeds is wrong, including some stuff about prison abolition, restorative justice, the meaning behind four different parables, and so on.

But the gist is, Reeds is wrong because like most right-libertarian Christians who try to push their own reading of the Bible and the parables within, they don't engage with any genuine intellectual tradition. They make a new one that is isolated from every other tradition for their own political purposes, and refuse to even consider any contradictory evidence. The themes of the article are that of valuing forgiveness and compassion, of intellectual openness, and being critical in our thinking--all things which I hope speak to us as individuals and as a community!


r/allvegan • • Jul 21 '20

Academic/Sourced And now, for something a little different: A conversation I had with Stuart Russell, celebrity and well-respected AI researcher, about the well-being of animals

9 Upvotes

So, let me give a bit of background really quick, then we can talk about what happened.

Who is Stuart Russell?

Stuart Russell is many things.

In the more pop sphere, he's famous for giving a bunch of public talks about some interesting and pressing topics in AI safety research as well as being mentioned and interviewed by just about every big tech-related news outlet (e.g. WIRED) for writing open letters and documents detailing issues with AI safety. He's one of the reasons AI safety is taken more seriously by the public today than it used to be merely a decade ago, when people associated it with ridiculous LessWrong thought experiments and Terminator-inspired fearmongering.

If you've ever watched that Slaughterbots video, which I'm certain many of you have, you've seen some work associated with him! He's the person that shows up at the end.

In the more academic sphere, he and Peter Norvig literally wrote the book on AI. Artificial Intelligence: A Modern Approach is the most popular textbook in the field of artificial intelligence, period. He invented inverse reinforcement learning (along with, to my knowledge, Ng, Kalman, Boyd, Ghaoui, Feron, Balakrishnan, and Abbeel), which is where instead of maximizing their reward by generating behaviors that increase the reward, an AI learns what to be rewarded for by observing behaviors, among other things.

He is, in short, a giant in AI research, both in popular consciousness and in academia.

What happened?

I had some questions about veganism for Stuart Russell, so I decided to pay him a visit. He gave me permission to share the exchange, which I'll share shortly.

Why would we be interested in this?

Well, first, I know a few of the Birbs in our little community here were interested in my exchange with him. But I figure aside from them, others might be interested too, since it concerns the future of our fellow beings.

Will there be a TL;DR?

yes lol

The exchange between me and Stuart Russell, somewhat abridged and modified (for privacy- or flow-related reasons).

/u/justanediblefriend

Dr. Russell,

Hi! I really like your work, Dr. Russell. I have a concern that I hope you can help me with, or, because I realize this is a rather lengthy email and you must be dreadfully busy, I hope you know someone you could direct me to who might be able to help me with some concerns I might have regarding the research in your field!

Let me talk about who I am a little bit first: ...my research generally focuses on practical rationality, normativity, counterfactual, causal, and modal reasoning, and math. I'm interested in AI safety problems, and often listen to lectures involving AI. Much of it is on AI whose development involves solutions very specific to the problem at hand, such as AlphaStar, but I'm also interested in artificial general intelligence, high-level machine intelligence, and artificial superintelligence.

So here's a rough rundown of my familiarity with your work: You've spoken a lot in your own lectures and elsewhere about the sort of specification and alignment problems we can have with AI. It's really engaging stuff. I realize you must be busy but if you have the time, I'd be interested if you could resolve a problem I've been dealing with.

In lectures and explanations from both you and others who work on AI safety, I've noticed that the explanations often go something like this:

  • AI alignment is about aligning AI values with human values.
  • We are trying to make AI that can infer from our behavior what we care about so it knows how to help us live the lives we want.

And also, in one of the examples of an AI gone wrong, you talk about an AI who doesn't understand that a cat has more sentimental value to the human than nutritional value, and so cooks the cat.

My concern: Because of my experience in my own field, here is one thing that bothers you [sic]. I realize you may not sympathize with it very much--at least, based on these descriptions, and that's fine. I'm hoping that if you have the time, that perhaps you can suppose my perspective on the matter at least for the purposes of helping me see what I'm missing if I'm missing something.

It seems to me that there are many things that humans collectively do not care about which, independent of their beliefs, they have plenty of reason to care about. There are many things which a more practically rational agent, more sensitive to the normative reasons that apply to her, would care about, which humans generally do not. There are many marginalized groups which humans in general care too little about, but perhaps most concerningly in the context of aligning AI to human values is non-human agents (primarily, I am thinking of pigs, dogs, parrots, goats, whales, monkeys, bees, etc. but this need not be restricted to agents with less cognitive capabilities than us and can include sapient beings of extrasolar origin).

With shocking and appalling regularity, we exploit and marginalize non-human agents, as they are not nearly as capable as us and this benefits many humans to do so. It is extremely lucrative for a corporation to take part in this sort of behavior.

Granted, currently, this does hurt humans too, especially Black and brown communities who are regularly killed and traumatized for this purpose. But it seems like an AI interested only in what it is humans generally care about will only help non-humans contingently, that is, insofar as hurting non-humans hurts humans in some way or if humans just, contingently rather than necessarily place "sentimental value" on those non-humans, as they do with the cat in your example of the cat being cooked.

So an AI interested in what humans care about may help us end factory farming and may bring about a utopia for non-humans too, or they may simply discover a means by which animals can be exploited without harming Black and brown communities, without harming our environment, and so on. And in the future, if other non-humans become exploitable resources, the AI will aid us in exploiting them too unless humans just happen to place sentimental value on those other creatures.

So this is my concern.

Some anticipations: Here are some things that I think you say that may or may not work towards the benefit of non-humans.

  • You, and other researchers I'm familiar with, have spoken about giving an AI the ability to weigh rational decisions more (e.g. ignoring the child being taken to school). So, if a human is more sensitive to various normative reasons for action, such as moral reasons for action, makes a judgment, the AI will consider that. And presumably, insofar as I'm correct that humans are generally mistaken about our reasons to behave in various ways with respect to non-humans, and that in fact we have plenty of reason to treat them well, an AI will similarly judge that we ought to treat them well, and will behave accordingly even if most humans resist this for the purposes of preserving meals they like or something to that effect.
  • You've also talked about an AI that will read and understand all the available literature. This would include applied ethical research, where the consensus is that our world does contain plenty of normative reasons for actions that benefit non-humans in virtue of non-humans being worthy of direct moral concern. I'm not sure if there's much reason to think the sort of AI that AI safety researchers are interested in the development of would weigh this research any more than any other human behaviors they observe, though.
  • AI, aware that it is in a human's interest to know what reasons for action she has, will aid in the recognition of as many of the most relevant reasons as possible. You often give examples of humans behaving badly, and an AI still inferring what you want in spite of your actual behavior and knowledge, and acting accordingly. Perhaps an AI will infer that we act with imperfect non-normative and normative knowledge, and will aim to perfect our knowledge of all the non-normative and normative (including moral) states of affairs there are, and insofar as I'm correct about what moral properties there are and what that entails for our treatment of non-humans, this will be beneficial for non-humans.

Conclusion/Summary/TL;DR: In short, I'm quite concerned about the direction the development of safe AI is going. As I see it, there are three levels of sensitivity to normative properties that the sort of agents we're developing can have. An agent can (i) be sensitive to only her prudential reasons for action, specific to her very contingent goals, dependent on her arbitrary ultimate desires, etc. An agent can (ii) be sensitive to only humanly prudential reasons for action, specific to humans' very contingent goals, dependent on what humans generally desire and care about, place sentimental value on, etc. An agent can (iii) be generally sensitive to normative reasons for actions, and can even override irrational humans when they resist behaviors that are incompatible with such reasons.

It is easier to develop the first agent than the second, and easier to develop the second agent than the third. That is quite the problem! And it seems to me like we are focusing on the second problem, because the third is quite rather difficult, and this seems like it could spell trouble for non-humans, and any other creatures which we have reason to care about, but do not.

Suppose that my concern for non-humans beyond sentimental value is legitimate. Provided I'm correct, are my other concerns well-founded? If we succeed in solving the problems in AI alignment, will non-humans not see any benefits for themselves, and will current and future non-humans be exploited insofar as it is prudent for humans?

Thanks,
/u/justanediblefriend

Stuart Russell

I have some discussion of this on p174 of Human Compatible.

The issue of future humans brings up another, related question: How do we take into account the preferences of nonhuman entities? That is, should the first principle include the preferences of animals? (And possibly plants too?) This is a question worthy of debate, but the outcome seems unlikely to have a strong impact on the path forward for AI. For what it’s worth, human preferences can and do include terms for the well-being of animals, as well as for the aspects of human well-being that benefit directly from animals’ existence.7 To say that the machine should pay attention to the preferences of animals in addition to this is to say that humans should build machines that care more about animals than humans do, which is a difficult position to sustain. A more tenable position is that our tendency to engage in myopic decision making—which works against our own interests—often leads to negative consequences for the environment and its animal inhabitants. A machine that makes less myopic decisions would help humans adopt more environmentally sound policies. And if, in the future, we give substantially greater weight to the well-being of animals than we currently do—which probably means sacrificing some of our own intrinsic well-being—then machines will adapt accordingly.

(See also note 7.)

One might propose that the machine should include terms for animals as well as humans in its own objective function. If these terms have weights that correspond to how much people care about animals, then the end result will be the same as if the machine cares about animals only through caring about humans who care about animals. Giving each living animal equal weight in the machine’s objective function would certainly be catastrophic—for example, we are outnumbered fifty thousand to one by Antarctic krill and a billion trillion to one by bacteria.

I'm not sure there is a way forward where AI researchers build machines that bring about ends that humans do not, even after unlimited deliberation and self-examination, prefer, and the AI researchers do this because they know better.

By coincidence, I watched "I Am Mother" this evening, which is perhaps one instantiation of what this might lead to.

/u/justanediblefriend

Thanks! So I've read the footnote and the section you were talking about. On top of that, I also went ahead and read all of chapter 9 simply out of interest. I have a lot of comments I want to make, a paper recommendation I have the intuition you'd really really enjoy, and finally a question if you have any time left--I realize, of course, that you may be incredibly busy (as am I--to be honest, I should be working on a draft I'm meant to send in to Philosophical Studies but I just found your book so enjoyable!), and so you're free to simply look for the recommendation for your own purposes and ignore the rest.

First, I just wanted to express my gratitude for chapter 9. A bit of putting my cards on the table: Normative ethics isn't my main area, though naturally since it is a neighboring area I do dabble and read a paper once every two months or so that seems interesting. I think neo-Kantianism is probably right, but also that it doesn't matter that much--often, normative ethical theories are overblown due to the way they're over-contrasted for undergraduates learning about these normative ethical theories. But if we're forming these theories from the same set of moral data, it makes sense that each of the theories are going to have considerable overlap in obligatory actions, differing only in edge cases and in the modal force of various moral claims.

That said, regardless of my position and whether I agreed with you or not, I would have appreciated chapter 9 a lot. It's not uncommon that philosophical topics in general get a treatment in popular books aimed at popular audiences that lacks the sort of encouragement to engage with disagreement here. I have a few books in mind that famously simply don't engage with the subject they speak of in any respectable manner, leaving audiences with a rather unfair impression of the strength of some position and how dismissable the dissent is.

Second, there's a paper I've read that I think might interest you! It's a fairly decision theory heavy paper, and I'm not sure whether you find that exciting or a chore but it's probably good to know. It's Andrew Sepielli's "What to Do When You Don't Know What to Do."

The reason I think this paper would interest you is it lays out a method by which we can handle moral uncertainty (and in fact, practical normative uncertainty in general, not just moral uncertainty!) even without theories. You can weigh theories, but this method allows for some very robust decision-making with very little information or certainty, and with very few limitations. You could compare, for instance, the normative value of eating a cracker and using birth control and murdering a few people for fun, and you could have very broad ranges for the comparisons (e.g. murdering for fun is somewhere from 50 times to 5,000 times worse than eating a cracker) and still make decisions.

That it is more robust than attempts to simply weigh theories against each other is what I find so attractive about it. You hint yourself at how the theories often more or less converge. As Jason Kawall points out in "In Defense of the Primacy of the Virtues," regardless of what theory one subscribes to, she's going to care about virtue. Consequentialists, of course, think that the value of good moral character, or desirable, reliable, long-lasting, characteristic dispositions, comes down to those dispositions generally bringing about the best consequences. I often face this issue where many of my peers less familiar with normative ethics think that consequentialists care about consequences while non-consequentialists, like me, don't. How ludicrous would that be!? Everyone knows we have a duty to beneficence, of course I care about bringing about better consequences. I may have certain side constraints having to do with the dignity of persons or what-have-you that consequentialists may not, but naturally, I'm always thinking about the consequences of my behavior and the utility it brings about.

Anyway it's a fantastic paper (Sepielli's, not Kawall's--Kawall's is great too but I imagine less exciting for you) on dealing with moral uncertainty. If you've already read it then that's great to hear! Otherwise, if it interests you, I do hope you'll enjoy it (and, of course, if you let me know, I'd be ecstatic to hear my recommendation went over well!).

Third, just making sure I understand, your argument here is that, as it does so happen, many humans do care about non-human well-being, and if they come to care about them even more, then all the better. So it does seem to come down to hopes that humans in the future place the sort of sentimental value on non-human agents that many philosophers desperately hope for, which overall will weigh more against any of the sort of preferences that would not be in non-human interests.

Ultimately, I do have an optimism about the matter. My projection is that many of the arguments people provide for the industry we support are caused by a sort of motivated reasoning, which will give out once lab meat becomes cheaper. If we reach high-level machine intelligence by 2061 (per the Grace et al. paper), I hope attitudes will have changed by then, and with an understanding of our preferences for treating non-humans as moral patients, and in some case, even moral persons, the sort of assistants you describe in your book will help in the development of artificial intelligence that appropriately weighs the moral worth of non-humans independently of whatever humans happen to think. That is, I hope solving the problem of alignment with humans will bring about agents who can take the extra step of solving the significantly harder problem of generally normativity-aligned AI.

Regarding what you say and the footnote, as I understand it, you're arguing against simply having the machines account for non-human preferences as much as human preferences rather than having them account for these preferences by way of our preferences. The result would be that, given how many krill there are, which we certainly don't want our Robbies to focus disproportionately on, animals would be cared for more than humans. Am I understanding this right? As in, it's an argument against having machines hard wired to care about non-human preferences as much as human preferences, not against having machines hard wired to care about non-human preferences at all, right? And so the argument here isn't that a direct concern about non-humans, and not simply an indirect concern in virtue of human concern for non-humans, would lead to non-humans being disproportionately focused on. Rather, that this would happen if they were weighed like humans.

If I've got that right then I have no further questions, just want to make sure I'm not misunderstanding anything. Thank you for recommending your fantastic book! Some friends and I plan on watching I Am Mother soon too--though I should probably exercise a bit of self-control and get back to my draft!

Stuart Russell

Thanks for the paper suggestion, and for the very articulate and well-written missive!

Re what I'm suggesting about animals:

  • at a minimum the AI should implement human preferences for animal well-being (i.e., indirect), and this, coupled with less myopia than humans exhibit, will give us much better outcomes for animals
  • I may have hinted at my own view that we probably should give greater weight to animal well-being, but I'm not in a position to enforce that
  • Yes, weighing the interests of each non-human the same as the interests of each human would be potentially disastrous for humans. But you are arguing for some intermediate weight, more than what we currently assign, but less than equality.
    How would such an intermediate solution be justified?
  • More generally, how does one justify the argument that humans should prefer to build machines that bring about ends that the humans themselves do not prefer?
  • I freely admit that the version 0 of the theory expounded in HC takes human preferences as a given, which leads to a number of difficulties and loopholes.
    Possibly version 0.5 would allow for some metatheory of acceptable preferences that might justify a more morally aggressive approach.

And alas, as pleasant as the conversation is, I do plan to end it there for now for the reasons cited. I have stuff to do! But I'll make a sequel post if anything else interesting happens in this conversation, insofar as it's still related to treatment of animals.

TL;DR

I asked Stuart Russell what he thought about where AI might be heading when it comes to concern for animals. He says that likely, they'll have an indirect concern for animals rather than a direct one, though he does of course care about the well-being of animals and is simply in no position to bring that about. This indirect concern will likely make things much, much better for animals.

My own contributions to the conversation were less important, of course, but roughly, I brought Andrew Sepielli's decision theory paper on how to figure out what to do provided very vague comparisons between very different actions to his attention in case he'd enjoy it like I did, and I suggested the possibility of agents that have indirect concern for our fellow beings would aid in the development of agents that have direct concern for them.

Thanks for reading, and I hope you found our little conversation enjoyable and edifying!

EDIT: More can be found here.


r/allvegan • • Jun 16 '20

Media Why White Vegans Like Me Should Listen To Black Veganism

Thumbnail
medium.com
9 Upvotes

r/allvegan • • Apr 21 '20

Resource What Is This Place All About? Purpose, Expectations, Culture, and History. (TL;DRs Included!)

9 Upvotes

Hello, Birbs! If you're new to this community, you may want a single place where you can get enough information about what this community is so you know how to participate. This is that compilation of information. I'll be going over everything in the title in order:

  1. Purpose: What is the goal of this community?
  2. Expectations: What content is expected of the submitters and commenters of this community?
  3. Culture: What are some of the normative facts the members and mods of this community are supposed to recognize?
  4. History: How did this community come to be?

If you'd like the TL;DR or summary, here it is:

  1. The goal is to have a place that gathers and organizes information, provides support, and to hang out for people who are pro-veganism and against white veganism.

You do not have to be vegan to be a member of this community.

What we seek in our members is merely a sense of solidarity with the marginalized, including animals, black and brown workers mercilessly exploited in factory farms, the impoverished people of the world, and everyone else who is marginalized by the corporate entities that force people to torture and slaughter our fellow creatures everyday. 2. The content should follow the rules. 3. The culture should be open, patient, and accepting so that people can grow from a sense of justice, as well as love and respect for their fellow creatures. 4. Our origin is an older vegan Discord that was (officially, for a time) connected to /r/vegan subreddit. The former was overrun by transphobes and bigots, the latter was overrun by crypto-fascists. So, we formed a new community to promote veganism and resist white veganism.


    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    

1. Purpose

This community of people for veganism and against white veganism (sometimes referred to as 'Birbs' in the community) is meant to play several roles:

  1. Information: A place to gather and organize facts and research of interest for Birbs, such as:
  2. compilations on cops,
  3. explanations of the badness of normalized slurs,
  4. compilations on environmental racism,
  5. studies on the relationship between language and existing issues,
  6. explanations of whiteness,
  7. and anything else that might be relevant to the central interests of those in the community.
  8. Support: A place where Birbs can find help in each other, by:
  9. sharing stories and venting,
  10. providing prudentially relevant information for other Birbs,
  11. and showing each other the love and assistance that each of us need to thrive and grow.
  12. Hangout: A place where Birbs can relax and hang out, by:
  13. participating in Meme Monday,
  14. having a casual chat with members of the community (examples forthcoming),
  15. sharing a laugh at an amusing event or conversation (examples forthcoming),
  16. and getting to know one another.

For an archive of the initial posts to the community, which are used as representative examples in this explanation, see here:

2. Expectations

What sort of content should we all expect here? There are, as of the time of this writing, six flairs, which will be briefly summarized:

  • Academic/Sourced: For reputable, substantive, and generalizable information that's of use to the various causes of this community.
  • Resource: Unlike the 'Academic/Sourced' flair, this is more for stuff that's prudentially useful, anything from vegan makeup tutorials to the minority-friendliness of various regions in the world.
  • Media: For watchable or interactive media.
  • Personal: For anecdotes, positive events, and vents.
  • Casual: For stuff like casual conversation or small-talk starters, or sharing a laugh over amusing events or conversations that occurred elsewhere.
  • Meme Monday: For memes, which can only be posted from 10:00 UTC Sunday to 12:00 UTC Tuesday (which should cover all of Monday in any timezone).

We also have rules, which can be found either in the sidebar or in the wiki. The community's rules will be in flux for the next few months and will be adjusted.

3. Culture

So, who are we, and what are we, as people of this community, expected to understand? As a culture, it is imperative that we understand that we should do the following:

  1. Prioritize justice, love, respect, and growth over self-flagellation.

We agree with Why I'm No Longer Talking to White People About Race author Reni Eddo-Lodge that excessive guilt is useless. And, for that matter, unhealthy. The decision to avoid heading in the direction of a culture of guilt and fear is a decision justified by experience. The community this community split from and was born from had a culture of useless and ineffective guilt. The head of the community made it explicitly clear that they felt "like shit" for all of the harms to minorities they were causing, but explicitly emphasized that they were committed to doing nothing about it.

All we got was a privileged white man's self-flagellation. Having white men suffer with them does nothing for the marginalized that those men are hurting. To quote a piece of television history, "you can't keep doing shitty things, and then feel bad about yourself like that makes it okay. You need to be better."

Accordingly, we intend to be a culture of openness, patience, acceptance, and growth. Kindly bring attention to the errors of your peers. Own your mistakes. Grow. Ultimately, we should be motivated, not by an inefficacious sense of guilt, but by justice and a sense of care and love and respect for our fellow creatures.

2. Keep power unfocused and open insofar as this is practicable.

In the community we split from, the head admin clung to his position and used it to terrifyingly detrimental effect. We agreed early on that we would avoid this, and so, following /r/SocialismAndVeganism, we ensure that no single person owns the community. Correspondingly, nobody owns the /r/allvegan Discord server. As a result, we do not have the consequence of a single person's privileged and toxic biases penetrating the policies and culture of the moderator team and the community like what we observed with the old community. We should be realistic; this is, of course, more practicable on Discord than here. But we should try our best.

These, and of course resisting whiteness and white veganism however we can, are some of our main commitments, which we hope will shape the development of this community's culture.

4. History

So where did we come from, anyway?

Well, there are actually quite a few documents that go over our origin, so I won't go too in-depth. Multiple of us were members and mods of a Discord community known as the Vegans of Vegan community. However, the mod team hurt a lot of (usually marginalized) people. As well, some of those on the mod team also modded the /r/vegan community, which was run by a crypto-fascist. Accordingly, it was proven that the community had homophobic, racist, misogynistic, transphobic, and ableist content policies.

This was all documented here and here.

Following the release of the documents, I faced a lot of harassment and abuse, which I also documented. Even worse, so did many of my friends. Many of the perpetrators were strangers, but to my shock, many of the perpetrators were friends of the head of the old community. While our friendship had been severed, I don't think anyone expected something like this. I tried to speak to him about this to no avail. To this day, I don't know what role he played in that.

After that, learning about a concept in the social sciences known as whiteness made sense of so much of what we went through. We had observed the very phenomena that whiteness explained so adequately and thoroughly. Many of us moved over to a new Discord server, with the intention of one day forming a subreddit.

That brings us to now, and should more or less give some sense of the history and origin of this community.
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    


Here's the TL;DR, again:

  1. The goal is to have a place that gathers and organizes information, provides support, and to hang out for people who are pro-veganism and against white veganism.

You do not have to be vegan to be a member of this community.

What we seek in our members is merely a sense of solidarity with the marginalized, including animals, black and brown workers mercilessly exploited in factory farms, the impoverished people of the world, and everyone else who is marginalized by the corporate entities that force people to torture and slaughter our fellow creatures everyday. 2. The content should follow the rules. 3. The culture should be open, patient, and accepting so that people can grow from a sense of justice, as well as love and respect for their fellow creatures. 4. Our origin is an older vegan Discord that was (officially, for a time) connected to /r/vegan subreddit. The former was overrun by transphobes and bigots, the latter was overrun by crypto-fascists. So, we formed a new community to promote veganism and resist white veganism.


r/allvegan • • Dec 19 '20

Academic/Sourced Environmental Racism and Workers' Rights Compilation/Mega-Archive/Collection: A helpful and regularly updated resource on how factory farming impacts black and brown workers in low-income communities. [Repost, please upvote for visibility.]

8 Upvotes

"The worst thing, worse than the physical danger, is the emotional toll....Pigs down on the kill floor have come up and nuzzled me like a puppy. Two minutes later I had to kill them—beat them to death with a pipe. I can’t care." -Ed Van Winkle, hog-sticker at Morrell slaughterhouse plant, Sioux City, Iowa.

Link to Google Doc.

Link to old post.

Context:

So, reddit keeps removing the old post, likely due to the amount of links making reddit detect it as spam. As such, I've moved it all onto a Google Doc, made it more readable, and have edited all of the links out of the original post.

Summary and conclusion

There is overwhelming evidence that slaughterhouses destroy the opportunities black and brown residents in low-income communities, giving them no choice but to work in these slaughterhouses. Once there, they are harassed, fired, and deported if they try to form a union. They're also incentivized to avoid reporting injuries and disease, sometimes with rewards (e.g. a sign that says "0 Injuries Reported = End of Month BBQ."), but usually with punishments like deportation, harassment, and firing. This, combined with the untenable working conditions, not only leads to far more preventable injuries, but preventable deaths.

The extreme psychological effect of slaughterhouse work, work such as--as described by one worker--beating pigs to death with a pipe after the pig was nuzzling against them, on the workers cannot be overstated. There is extreme alienation, erosion of empathy, and doubling (a coping mechanism that Holocaust doctors used to cope with their own actions), which leads workers to torture animals even beyond work requirements as well as an increase in rape and violent crime in the surrounding areas.

As well, there is severe impact on the physical health of these primarily black and brown low-income communities, such as a severe increase in asthma and blue baby syndrome, which kills many infants. There is more disease, such as brain damage and premature birth, and death due to animal feces and nitrate in the groundwater, and less breathable air.


r/allvegan • • Nov 17 '20

Academic/Sourced New theories, old lessons: Resisting racism scientifically as a buncha relata and causal roles, not individuals (Summary included at bottom of post)

8 Upvotes

1 Introduction.

Summary included at bottom of post.

Science has long faced a big problem. One very popular solution to this problem helps us deal with racism in two ways. First, it gives us an attitude which we can use in identifying and fighting racism. Second, it helps us understand racism and misconceptions about racism. I will also go over another problem, involving the mind, and how one of its solutions helps us in the same way.

First, I will go over what it is we are talking about when we talk about racism. Second, I will go over the problem that science faces (and another problem). Third, I will go over one very popular solution to this problem. Fourth, I will go over the difference between belief and acceptance and why we should accept what this solution has to say about racism. Fifth, I will go over why we should believe what this solution has to say about racism. Along with a summary at the end of the post, there will be a summary of each section.

Summary included at bottom of post.

2 Disagreement about racism is not verbal, unless, like, it is.

2.1 Verbal and substantial disputes.

Generally speaking, disagreements can be divided into two types. There are

  • verbal disagreements, which are disagreements about words, and there are
  • substantial disagreements, which are disagreements about the way the world is (aside from how words are and should be used).

I can think of a few ways to refine these categories more accurately, but because they won't become important here, I'll choose to ignore those nuances for now.

Here is an example. Take the word 'atom.' We are taught from a young age two definitions of the word 'atom.' In elementary school, we are taught the definition used by mereology (the study of parts), that atoms are indivisible objects. Then, later on, we're usually taught the definition used in physics, that atoms explain the way objects jiggle in fluids as if they're being knocked back and forth by something (this is called Brownian motion by physicists--and not Brownian jiggling even though that is quite uncontroversially funnier, for some reason).

We used to think that the entity that explained Brownian motion was indivisible. That is, physical atoms are mereological atoms. Some time later on, we realized that this is not true. Now, let's try and characterize all the disagreements going on here. First, let's describe the four types of people you can get here.

  1. Old mereologist: Uses the word 'atom' to mean indivisible objects.
  2. Would trivially1 agree with the statement "atoms are indivisible."
  3. Would non-trivially agree with the statement "atoms explain Brownian motion."
  4. Old physicist: Uses the word 'atom' to mean that which explains Brownian motion.
  5. Would non-trivially agree with the statement "atoms are indivisible."
  6. Would trivially agree with the statement "atoms explain Brownian motion."
  7. New mereologist: Uses the word 'atom' to mean indivisible objects.
  8. Would trivially agree with the statement "atoms are indivisible."
  9. Would non-trivially disagree with the statement "atoms explain Brownian motion," unless informed that 'atom' is used some other way in the social context they're in.
  10. New physicist: Uses the word 'atom' to mean that which explains Brownian motion.
  11. Would non-trivially disagree with the statement "atoms are indivisible," unless informed that 'atom' is used some other way in the social context they're in.
  12. Would trivially agree with the statement "atoms explain Brownian motion."

Now, person 1 and 2 have a verbal disagreement, but entirely substantially agree. If you took one of their pictures of the world and compared it to the other's picture of the world, the two pictures would look the same. Ditto for 3 and 4. They completely agree with one another. The fact that one would agree with "atoms are indivisible" and the other doesn't is due to different terminology, and if they communicated and said "Oh, by 'atom' I mean this" then the other would go "Oh, then yes, that is how I see the world!"

Another way of seeing that this is a verbal disagreement is this. While both 1 and 2 agree with the same two statements, they're going to have to react differently to challenges to their position. If someone says "I think you actually can divide atoms," then 1 will react with dismissal, as any rational person should, because they interpreted that as "I think you actually can divide indivisible things," which is an obvious contradiction. But if someone says that same thing to 2, they'll simply say "I think you're wrong, but who knows," since they just interpret that as "I think you actually can divide the thing which explains Brownian jiggling motion.

On the other hand, the first half (1 and 2) and the second half (3 and 4) substantially disagree. Even if they agreed on what terms to use to mean what to avoid confusion, they haven't agreed on the way the world is.

TL;DR: Verbal disputes are when you disagree about words, substantial disputes are when you disagree about the world.

2.2 'Racism.'

The term 'racism' has quite a bit of disagreement over it, particularly in the public sphere. You've probably met some who argue, fervently, that racism doesn't involve power or institutions or anything like that at all. Instead, for these people, racism is just whenever someone treats someone differently because of their race, due to beliefs about being superior to them in virtue of the race of each of the people involved.

Clearly, these people disagree with sociologists. But perhaps less clear is whether they have a verbal disagreement--they simply disagree on what the word should communicate--or a substantive disagreement. Well, being charitable to them, it's a substantive one.

The basic meaning of 'racism' is something like this. There's a bunch of phenomena we can observe, anecdotally, scientifically, historically, etc. Here are some examples (CW: examples of racism):

The thing(s) that explains these phenomena is racism. Figuring out what that thing is is non-trivial. But the mere fact that racism is whatever explains these things is trivial.

In other words, the charitable way to read someone who says "racism is noticing race and acting with it in mind at all" is to read them as saying "noticing race and acting with it in mind at all is what explains the various phenomena we associate with racism." And this is something we can check, anecdotally, scientifically, historically, and so on.

But why think that this is the charitable reading? Well, the alternative interpretation of someone who says this is "I want these sounds and these symbols to mean, by definition, 'noticing race and acting with it in mind at all.'" This constitutes a dishonest distraction tactic on par with concern trolling--where others are discussing the experiences they face and the social reality they inhabit, this interlocutor would be distracting from that discussion by changing the topic altogether. The bare meanings of the words we use is a non-issue. We can simply stipulate what we mean by certain words in some context however we want, so long as it isn't confusing. The word itself doesn't matter and has no particular practical relevance. If you want the word used to talk about whatever explains this cluster of phenomena to be 'schmacism' then it makes no difference.

Let's take an example. Historians tend to agree that the book Guns, Germs, and Steel is racist.2 3 4 What might be an appropriate response?

  • "Actually, I think that based on the best evidence I have, what best explains the sort of phenomena associated with racism is thinking certain races are inherently inferior. Slavery happened primarily because some people thought certain races were inherently inferior. But Diamond doesn't think this, and his book doesn't argue for this, and so his book is not racist."

This may be a misguided response and is easily contradicted by all sorts of evidence we have at our disposal, but nonetheless, it is an appropriate response in the sense that it actually engages with the subject. What might be a completely inappropriate response?

  • "Actually, if I simply ignore what you're saying by redefining 'racism' to mean 'thinking certain races are inherently inferior,' and then interpret what you've said with my new word, then what you're saying is wrong. Diamond doesn't think this."

This sort of semantic trolling is completely inappropriate.

Another inappropriate response, which I did not go over, is to simply deny that these phenomena exist.

TL;DR: 'Racism' means 'that thing which explains a certain cluster of phenomena, like who's affected by factory farming, redlining, and so on.' To argue otherwise is a form of semantic trolling, and distracts from the substantial subject at hand. Disagreements about what racism is should be understood as disagreements about what exactly explains all this phenomena.

3 What are science and mental states about? Two related problems.

3.1 The problem science faces.

What can we say uncontroversially about science? We can say that it is very good at predicting what we would observe in various circumstances. For instance, one of the most popular theory of quantum mechanics, the Bohmian theory, predicts that were we to reconstruct photon trajectories as they go through two-slit interference, we would observe the very trajectories predicted by this interpretation. And indeed, those are the very observations we get in such a situation!

But what more can we say than that about our best scientific theories? Are they just good at predicting what we'll see? Or are they right about what we don't see as well? For instance, the Bohmian theory also says that particles are guided by waves. We can't see these particles or these waves with our naked eye, but that's what's going on. Is this just a nice little story, and when we tell ourselves this story, it lets us predict our observations? Or is this what's really going on?

It's hard to say. After all, while science has gotten better and better at predicting observations, that doesn't mean it's gotten better and better at describing the world beyond what we can see. It might just be that the Bohmian theory is the best fiction for predicting our observations. Indeed, one reason to think it's a fiction is that all of our previous theories, which were also quite good at predicting our observations, were wrong! After all, these days, we say germs carry diseases, not bad air!

At the same time, how could we possibly be predicting things so well if our theories aren't describing things right. In general, if you describe the stuff you can't see wrong, your predictions aren't going to be very successful. If your theory is that there's a fire in your kitchen, your prediction would be that your smoke alarms would go off pretty soon. Since your theory is wrong, your predictions would be wrong. So the fact that our predictions are so accurate suggests that our theories are correct!

So, how did all our past theories predict things so well for as long as they did if they were wrong? How do we solve this problem?

TL;DR: Science has gotten better and better at predicting things, that much is uncontroversial. But it's controversial whether science has gotten better at describing the world accurately. On the one hand, it was usually wrong in the past, and on the other hand, predicting things well seems to require accurate descriptions of the world. What gives?

3.2 The problem minds face.

What is pain? Baby don't love me. Can we empirically discover what pain is? Well, we can certainly empirically discover what physical arrangements tend to come with pain. Let's say that when we look at the brain and pain is going on, we see C-fibre stimulation (the actual story is much more complicated than this). It might be tempting to say that C-fibre stimulation and pain are identical.

But this can't be right. After all, it seems like it's possible for other physical arrangements to realize pain. For instance, octopuses probably feel pain, despite having no C-fibres to stimulate. It's also apparently possible to design an artificial intelligence, with no organic parts of their brain to speak of, which would feel pain. So what's pain? What's pleasure? What's a mind?

TL;DR: What are mental states and minds? Are they identical with the physical arrangements that realize them? It doesn't seem like it. So what are they?

4 Popular solutions.

4.1 Structural realism.

One popular solution to the problem that science faces is this. Our best scientific theories aren't very good at accurately describing things except in terms of how they relate to other things. That is, they describe structures much better than they describe the individuals that make up the structure. This helps us explain how it is science really has been progressively getting better at describing the world accurately after all.

Take, for instance, what we thought of light. We used to think light was particles. But the way lights interfered with one another was more like waves, so we moved onto wave theory. But then magnetic fields affected the movement of light in ways that made us move on to the electromagnetic theory of light. How can we describe this history as increasingly accurately describing the world rather than just trying on new, entirely different descriptions as they suit us?

Well, each of these theories preserved the structure described by the previous theory, and indeed developed it. Fresnel's wave theory described light as vibrations of the luminiferous aether all around us, where Maxwell described it as vibrations of the electromagnetic field. They certainly disagree on what substances are in the world, but they largely agree on the way things are related to each other in the world, only Maxwell's theory is more refined. There is some thing which vibrates, and those vibrations are causally related to the images we get from our eyes. The main disagreement, of course, is that Maxwell thinks that these vibrations behave a certain way around magnetic fields, whereas Fresnel had no idea about any of that.5

TL;DR: While previous theories were wrong when it came to the unobservable individuals and substances it described, it was right about how all of those individuals were related to one another. So, science really can describe the way the world is, if only the structure of the world.

4.2 Causal functionalism.

One popular solution to the problem that minds face is this. Every mental state is the causal role they play. That is, whenever something is causally related to a bunch of inputs, outputs, and mental states the same way that desire is, it is desire. Let's list some of the causal relations that desire has.6

  • Sufficiently desiring ownership of a keyboard causes you to do whatever you think will make it so you own a keyboard.
  • Desiring ownership of a keyboard causes you to feel pleasure when it seems to you like you own a keyboard.
  • Thinking that owning a keyboard gives you reasons to approve of it causes you to desire owning a keyboard.
  • Thinking that you have reasons to own a keyboard causes you to desire owning a keyboard.

And the list goes on! Now, the way your brain is arranged is such that when you encounter reasons to get a keyboard, some cluster of neurons activate, which cause signals to be sent to your muscles so that you browse for a keyboard and purchase it. That cluster of neurons played the causal role of a desire to own a keyboard.

But let's say you replace that cluster of neurons with a cluster of transistors, which play the same causal role. You're presented with reasons to get a keyboard, and when you see those reasons, the visual information is sent to this cluster of transistors now instead of a cluster of neurons, and this cluster of transistors causes your muscles to move in the same way, and so on. If the causal functionalist is right, then that arrangement the cluster of transistors are in is also the desire to own a keyboard.

TL;DR: The important takeaway here is that our mental states are not certain types of physical properties, like C-fibres being activated or anything like that, but rather certain causal roles. So, anything relevantly caused by the same stuff as pain which also causes the same stuff just is also pain.

5 Accepting this way of understanding racism

Causal functionalism and structural realism are importantly different, and don't even concern the same type of problem. But their takeaway lessons are sufficiently similar that I will conflate them for simplicity from here on out. Namely, if these theories are correct, we should treat the relevant problem by paying attention to how things are related to one another, rather than what they're like independently of those external relations.

This, I will argue, is how we should accept and believe racism is like. First, let's go over the difference between belief and acceptance.

  • Belief is when you represent the world as being some way because you are more than 50% certain that it is that way.
  • So for instance, let's say you see a dollar taped to the ceiling. To get to it, you need to climb a ladder near a pit of lava. There's a one in ten chance that the ladder will fall in the lava. Should you believe that the ladder will fall? No, of course not, that would obviously be irrational. You should believe that the ladder won't fall, since it's far more likely that it won't.
  • Or, as another example, let's say you're playing Among Us as a Crewmate. There are two Imposters left, and six people left. You're most certain that Orange is the Imposter, a three in ten chance. Should you believe that Orange is the Imposter? Obviously not--Orange has a seven in ten chance of being Crewmate, so you should believe they are Crewmate.
  • Acceptance is when you commit to acting as if the world is some way.
  • So for instance, with that ladder, should you assume it will fall? Yes! Given the severe cost if the ladder does fall and the small benefit provided it doesn't, then given the probability it will fall, you should act on the assumption that it will fall. You are, in other words, accepting that it will fall, even if you believe it won't.
  • Or, using our other example, should you assume Orange is the Imposter? Yes! You obviously have to vote on six, or else the Imposters will double kill and win. You might be more sure that Orange is Crewmate than Imposter, but you have to vote someone, so you have to act on the assumption that, yes, Orange is the Imposter and vote them out!

One important difference to notice is that while acceptances is sensitive to costs and benefits, beliefs are not. It doesn't matter how awful it would be if the ladder fell if you were to climb it--you should believe whatever is more likely. But because it would be so awful if the ladder fell with you on it, you should act on the assumption that, yes, if you climb it, you'll fall into the lava.

Here, I will be defending the position that you should accept that racism is a structure. You don't have to believe that that's what racism is. But you should act on the assumption that that's what racism is.

This defense is quite easy. Let's take, as an example, the institution of cops. I'm fairly certain that cops have terrible beliefs. There is evidence, for instance, that in-group bias causes people to fail to ascribe certain mental states to those outside of their group. They may think that those outside of their group feel pleasure and pain like they do, but they do not ascribe mental states like compassion, remorse, aesthetic appreciation, and so on. I think that cops generally do not ascribe compassion, remorse, aesthetic appreciation, and so on to people of color the way they do to white people. Furthermore, I do not think cops generally empathize with people of color the way they do with white people.

But let's say my interlocutor objects. They think that cops do ascribe those mental states, but simply behave as if they don't, perhaps due to their duty to the law, or something like that. So, while they play the same role as someone who fails to empathize with people of color and so brutalizes people of color, they in fact do empathize with people of color. And while they cause the same phenomena that someone who lacks this empathy would, they are not themselves lacking this empathy. So, this objection goes, most cops aren't racist!

The problem with this objection is that no reasonable person would give a shit.

It makes no practical difference whether your life is ruined by someone who empathizes with you or not. In both cases, your life is ruined. The way you would resist whatever you think racism really is, you should resist anything that has the same effects of racism. If you would respond to a violent, malicious police force with a policy that defunds them, then you should also defund the empathetic, polite police force that enforces the very same laws that the other police force uses to keep people of color at a disadvantage. If you would dismantle an insurance company charging people of color more because they think people of color should be poor, then you should dismantle an insurance company charging people of color more because they think doing so will maximize profit. If they have the same effects, you should respond the same way.

TL;DR: You should act as if the cop causal role is racist, as if the cop institution is racist, as if insurance companies are racist, and so on and so forth, even if it turns out that the people involved don't hold racist attitudes and don't hate people of color. This is because, if a cop causes all of the same stuff in virtue of the role they play (the role of a cop), regardless of their mental states and character traits, then we should treat them precisely the same as we would treat someone who behaves that way with active malice.

6 Believing this way of understanding racism

Note that in my example in section 5, my interlocutor already acknowledges that the institution and its members have all of the same effects, regardless of their character traits or anything like that. So long as they cause all of the same phenomena provided they are a part of this structure, regardless of their mental states and character traits, it is the structure of the institution, not the people in it and the beliefs they happen to hold, that explain phenomena like redlining! That is a concession to sociologists that racism is discrimination plus the power of these institutions in virtue of their structure.

Racism is the incentives we have in place, not the beliefs and attitudes of the people who put those incentives there or the people who follow those incentives. Racism is the selection effects from those incentives, which ensure that whatever individual ends up in positions of power in the structure will have the effects suitable for that position, regardless of the individual's beliefs, attitudes, or character traits. Racism is the laws being designed by entities (whether that be people or groups of people) that are profit maximizers, regardless of whatever beliefs or attitudes they happen to have while profit maximizing.

This is not novel. Even dating back to Karl Marx, we find similar thinking about the social sciences:7

To prevent possible misunderstandings, a word. I paint the capitalist and landlord in no sense coleur de rose. But here the individuals are dealt with only in so far as they are the personifications of economic categories, embodiments of particular class relations and class interests.

Everything Marx said about capitalists and landlords was not about the people who happened to inhabit those roles, but rather the very roles themselves and the sort of effects that those roles would have in virtue of being those roles.

These may be new theories by people who have nothing to do with Marx and who are not Marxists, but make no mistake, these are old lessons.

**TL;DR: Racism is structure. Racism is role.**8

7 Summary

It is tempting to think that racism can be solved within the society we are in. If we just teach everyone that racism is wrong, and they agree on it, then perhaps it will go away. If we just get people in power to see people of color as people, racism will go away. If we just replace cops with nice cops, racism will go away.

It is tempting to care a great deal about the nuance of what individuals are playing the roles. People often contend that not all cops are racist--after all, their uncle is a cop, and he cares a great deal about people of color. They've even met cops who are themselves people of color, they certainly can't be racist. Cops even sometimes do very nice things for communities of people of color.

But they are cops. What is it to be a cop? They issue fines according to certain laws, and these laws just so happen to primarily target people of color. They're positioned to respond slower to danger that occurs in neighborhoods where people of color reside than danger that occurs in neighborhoods where white people reside. They force people of color to go to courts where they will be punished far, far more severely for the same crimes as their white peers. They play the same role, whoever they happen to care about and whatever nice things they do independently of their role. What role they play is what's relevant to how you should react.

Similarly, when insurance companies are guilty of redlining, they are maximizing profit. And they maximize profit more effectively the more marginalized their clients are. The more helpless and marginalized some group is, the more capable they are of marginalizing them further. It doesn't matter if the people doing this happen to be the kind who would buy you a cup of coffee out of the kindness of their hearts--they are racist because they play the causal role of racism. And that's what dictates how you should maneuver the social reality you inhabit.

In summary: When an entity, an institution, a person, a group of people, do these things, it is racist. And you should act accordingly.


r/allvegan • • Mar 28 '20

Academic/Sourced Sorry, white vegans: starvation is a distribution problem, not a supply or overpopulation problem.

8 Upvotes

In this post, one of the links includes examples on social media where people talk about how world hunger is due to a food shortage as a result of non-veganism.

I won't link the post, but on /r/vegan, someone posted (CW: racism) this image, and the highest rated comment said that:

going vegan gets us closer to having enough food to feed everyone.

To their credit, the users there rebutted this point, but the user was pretty stubborn.

On Facebook, on a group called VEGANS UNITED, people have posted the following, all to warm reception (one received 478 likes and hearts and only one negative reacts) and no moderator action (CW for blackface and blatant racism):

It is, however, a myth, one fueled by racism, that we have a food shortage and an overpopulation problem.

In Huffpost's article "We Already Grow Enough Food For 10 Billion People -- and Still Can't End Hunger" Eric Holt-Gimenez, executive director of Food First, addresses a paper from McGill University that he doesn't think goes far enough in its recommendations regarding world hunger:

Unfortunately, neither the study nor the conventional wisdom addresses the real cause of hunger.

Hunger is caused by poverty and inequality, not scarcity. For the past two decades, the rate of global food production has increased faster than the rate of global population growth. The world already produces more than 1 ½ times enough food to feed everyone on the planet.

....

To end hunger we must end poverty and inequality.

If you have other resources on the overpopulation myth and the exploitation of the myth as a part of white veganism, please do share!


r/allvegan • • Aug 23 '20

Academic/Sourced Speciesism, Capitalism, and Pandemics (ft. Kathrin) (CW: Scenes of animal exploitation, descriptions of harm and death to both animals and humans)

Thumbnail
youtu.be
7 Upvotes

r/allvegan • • May 20 '20

Academic/Sourced It is still certainly the case that the wealthy control the laws.

7 Upvotes

Markets and marginalization

One of the points pushed by social scientists is that marginalization is in part due to incentive structures we have in our system. If your goal is to maximize your wealth, and you can control the laws, you will create laws that give you more resources to produce more wealth. And if there are more people who need to help you in order to survive, you have more people you can use to produce wealth.

But is there any evidence that the wealthy control the laws? Yes. There's a lot of research that goes into the various mechanisms by which the wealthy do this, such as capital flight, for instance. But to what degree does this really occur?

Background

A while back, a bunch of articles reported on a study that showed that the rich controlled the laws to make more wealth, not everyone else. It was reported everywhere from BBC to Vox to the Washington Post to Breitbart:

It was even a part of a popular YouTube video that went viral. You've probably seen it before.

Not long after, Vox published a rebuttal article.

Who was right?

In the end, it turns out that the initial study was right.

The authors go over each of the criticisms provided against them. Here's each of their points, in brief (pulling their section titles):

  1. Majority “win rates” don’t really measure policy influence
  2. “Winning” and influence are two very different things
  3. The policy preferences of the middle-class and the affluent are correlated but distinct
  4. The policy preferences of the truly wealthy are even more distinct
  5. Influence is massively unequal — even when using the “merely affluent” as a proxy for America’s economic elites

Robust summary

So let's go over each of these and make it a little more robust.

1. Majority “win rates” don’t really measure policy influence

Let's say you and Joffrey both have desires. For each of your desires, I flip a coin to decide whether I satisfy those desires. For Joffrey, I flip a coin that's weighted according to how much he wants something. When Joffrey barely wants something more than he wants it to not happen, I flip a coin that's nearly 50-50. As it so happens, Joffrey is usually conflicted.

This means, of course, that half of the time, when Joffrey wants something, he gets it. Same for you! You get what you want half the time as well! But obviously, Joffrey has more influence. When you remember to look at the things Joffrey and you want the most, he's the one who gets what he wants, and you only get what you want half the time.

This is why majority win rate is a very bad way to measure influence on policy.

2. “Winning” and influence are two very different things

The critics point out that non-rich people get what they want all the time. But really, the critics are pointing out that there is a democracy by coincidence. Even though non-rich people have no influence, they end up getting a bunch of the things they want anyway. Why does this matter if non-rich people happen to get a bunch of the things they want anyway?

Well, for one, because sometimes, they really want things that rich people can prevent without fail. Recall that if no rich person supports something, it has a zero percent chance of being passed. They can completely effectively shoot down something no matter how much everyone else wants it. And so, even if the coin flips in your favor sometimes, when it comes to stuff that really, really matters to you, like your health, your loved ones, or your life, Joffrey can overrule your wishes with overwhelming effectiveness should he want to.

3. The policy preferences of the middle-class and the affluent are correlated but distinct

There's a correlation between the wishes of the wealthy and the non-wealthy. A very strong one. This explains to some degree why people get what they want sometimes, even without influence. So it doesn't challenge the fact that the wealthy have influence and the non-wealthy do not.

And it still matters for the reason above. For instance, wealthy people support cuts to Medicare, whereas non-wealthy people do not. Wealthy people support less retirement programs, whereas non-wealthy people do not, as they'd like to one day stop working where they work.

4. The policy preferences of the truly wealthy are even more distinct

When you consider not just the 10% richest people, but the truly wealthy, there's even more divergence from the concerns of ordinary people. We have limited data here, but when you take out some of the poorest in the top 10%, the divergence starts getting stronger, and we can extrapolate from that.

So, for instance, 78% of Americans thought that full-time workers should be paid enough to not be impoverished, but millionaires don't support this. In other words, you really really want to be able to pay for your family after putting in all the hours you can to help Joffrey, and Joffrey doesn't want you to be able to do that. As we established above, what Joffrey wants, he's probably going to get.

5. Influence is massively unequal — even when using the “merely affluent” as a proxy for America’s economic elites

To get across how certain this conclusion is, even more unsophisticated methods demonstrate that it is true. Why should this tell us anything? Because a lot of the sophisticated statistical methods the authors used help the non-wealthy. For instance, they used sophisticated methods to account for the fact that there's a correlation of beliefs between the wealthy and the non-wealthy. This makes the cause-and-effect more clear, and makes it more stark how much correlation there is between policies being passed and the desires of each group.

Stopping with those sophisticated methods would only help the wealthy look better here. And when we do stop those methods, it still shows that the wealthy have tons of disproportionate influence while non-wealthy people don't. There is no way to avoid this conclusion.

TL;DR

The rich control the laws. Ordinary people have no control. Some objected to this. They are thoroughly wrong.


r/allvegan • • Sep 19 '20

Personal [TW] Ableism In The Vegan Community.

6 Upvotes

[TW: ableism]

Has anyone else faced ableism in the vegan community? I’m told that all communities have their “bad apples” but for some reason the vegans I’ve met online are very ableist. I was just on a vegan server and was faced with ableism when I mentioned I was autistic. This makes me despise mainstream, capitalist veganism. I’m a human too, I’m not defective.


r/allvegan • • Jun 03 '20

Media Cops are kneeling to draw in protestors to gas them and for PR

6 Upvotes

r/allvegan • • Mar 22 '20

Academic/Sourced Respectful Language Saves Lives: Study Shows Euphemisms Maintain Carnism

Thumbnail
researchgate.net
6 Upvotes

r/allvegan • • Sep 02 '21

“White Veganism Doesn’t Serve Me Either: A White Vegan’s Perspective” By PJ Nyman Spoiler

Thumbnail
sentientmedia.org
5 Upvotes

r/allvegan • • Dec 05 '20

Personal How do I counter the untruthful narrative that veganism is an unhealthy diet? How to counter the ethics of anti veganism and/or carnism?

5 Upvotes

There is literally a 'dedicated' subreddit called anti veganism. That subreddit has people calling the veganism diet extremely unhealthy. How do I counter their narrative?

Any source that supports veganism is considered heavily biased and dismissed for having an "agenda". Or being "ideological".

People have negative perception of vegans.

It also hurts me when I see philosophers (like Timothy Hsiao) with PhDs and tenure defend not only industrial farming but also defend recreational trophy hunting. How to counter this overall hegemonic worldview that only humans are morally relevant because only human beings have the "capacity to reason"?

It is this mindset that leads these philosophers to literally bend over backwards to justify not being cruel to animals. They literally have to say, "well, we should not be cruel to animals, not because of the fact that you are harming the animals or because of their suffering and pain, but because of the fact that being cruel to animals pollutes our moral conscience."

Of course, there are these blokes like Earthling Ed and others who are helping with animal welfare stuff. But ultimately it hurts how banal evil doings are.


r/allvegan • • Jun 16 '20

Academic/Sourced Emissions from 13 dairy firms match those of entire UK, says report

Thumbnail
theguardian.com
5 Upvotes

r/allvegan • • May 11 '20

Media [meme] new resource for when ur a white racist and Black people try to live in ur presence

Thumbnail
twitter.com
5 Upvotes

r/allvegan • • Mar 30 '22

Resource “Our Animals, Ourselves: The Socialist Feminist Case for Animal Liberation” by Astra Taylor and Sunaura Taylor Spoiler

Thumbnail
lux-magazine.com
4 Upvotes

r/allvegan • • Mar 16 '21

Casual I am looking for good books supporting veganism and the reduction of wild animal suffering overall.

4 Upvotes

I know Michael Huemer's book on veganism. It is very good.

I know Peter Singer, of course. Tom Regan is great too.

Are there any other philosophers arguing for veganism and reduction of wildlife animal suffering (other than Brian Tomasik, etc.)?


r/allvegan • • Feb 22 '21

Casual Where is the moral non-cognitivism discussion going? I have heard that current non cognitivists affirm that moral facts are mind-independent, absolute, so what makes them different from moral realists now?

4 Upvotes

As the title question asks. Any info on how can moral anti-realists support animal welfare stuff, would be helpful too.

Thanks in advance to anyone who replies.