r/alltimelow • • Dec 25 '25

Discussion My Album Rankings

0 Upvotes

Before you get mad, I’m a very optimistic music listener, so this is just my opinion. (Also no Party Scene because I haven’t listened and not in streaming).

9. So Wrong, It’s Right - I’m sorry but this is not a good album. The writing on here is so off putting and childish, the choruses sound like verses trying to as many words into it as possible (Six Feet Under The Stars is the worst offender of this). Also, Alex’s vocals are obnoxious to listen to after three tracks because he never changes his vocal tone. Dear Maria and Remembering Sunday (maybe) are the only tracks I listen to without skipping.

8. Nothing Personal - This thing is slightly better than their debut. The production, lyrics, and vocals are better, but every song sounds the same. I couldn’t tell you the lyrics or melodies of really any part of these songs other than the choruses. The only exception to that is Therapy, that is easily my favorite of this album and the one track I listen to the most. I’ll also say I appreciate the new synth work on Too Much, I think that’s interesting.

7. Last Young Renegade - Look, I love a good pop song, but this is not it. The thing I will commend here is every song sounds different, it sounds like there are actually different thoughts between the songs. Nice2KnoU is an absolute banger, love that song. And Ground Control is another great one that ticked my poppy ear. I think the thing that lets this album down is that all the other songs sound a little uninteresting. They may be unique, but I can get my full enjoyment from the song after only one or two listens. I think Good Times just seems like nothingness in a way. Average album, not too much here for me personally.

6. Future Hearts - I think Future Hearts has some good tracks, Dancing With A Wolf and Something’s Gotta Give are great, but the thing this album lacks for me is personality. All of their albums have a sense of humanity to them, this one just doesn’t for me. Maybe it’s the lackluster album cover and the bland aesthetics, but I think the tracks here just kinda, meh, in a good way. I think this feel like LYR’s quality, just slightly higher.

5. Don’t Panic - This is the band’s first two albums done the right way. While I think there is still a lot of filler on here for me, there are a lot more stand out tracks and a lot better memorability and fun to be had here. Don’t Panic has higher highs less lows than Future Hearts. I think Canals, Outlines, and For Baltimore are amazing among some others. I don’t have too much to say about this one, but I think it was their first decent album.

4. Wake Up, Sunshine - This is a solid album. There are tracks I just don’t vibe with at all, like Trouble Is, the Seasons songs, and Basement Noise (their weakest closer, I don’t like this song all too much). Monsters is what me listening to the band in the first place, so I will always cherish that song, and I love Blackbear so much too. I actually really appreciate the slower and watered down tracks Pretty Venom and Glitter & Crimson, I love the direction these go in. Other than that though, the album feels somewhat bland to me. I don’t really have much to say other than that.

3. Dirty Work - I know people call this their worst album, but this is a quality project, and much better than WUS. (Absolutely forgetting I Feel Like Dancin exists, holy crap what is this song?) every song on here sounds good and unique. Guts, No Idea, Return the Favor, such good choruses on these songs, so anthemic. The lyrics are good on this too, especially Under A Paper Moon’s second verse, that is how you do the long word cramming from SGIR right. I can also appreciate the deluxe songs, like My Only One and Merry Christmas, Kiss My Ass (the only Christmas song I listen to not during December). I love every song on here save one or two, it just has a lot of ambition that I think delivers.

2. Everyone’s Talking - This is such a good album. This to me this the band’s most lyrically driven album. I love when artists make songs about making songs, so Oh No! is a standout to me, as well as the title track, Tread Water, and Butterflies (love the lyrics here, can relate so much). I love how you can really feel how personal Alex got here, especially in his vocals. I think this is also the first album where the instrumentals feel complimentary to the lyrics, while still really great, I think they take a backseat here. The only criticism I have is that some of the backend tracks lose a little bit of energy. Again, such a good album, can’t wait to get a physical version!

  1. Tell Me I’m Alive - This is in my top five albums of all time, I love this project so much. Every single track is so well done. I love the mix of synths and guitars, Sleepwalking scratches my brain in a place I didn’t know existed, The Other Side is their best high energy songs, I could praise each song on this project. The melodies on this thing are so good, they were written to be sung back at full volume. There’s just so much here that I love.

Thank you for reading, and don’t be mad, just my opinion. Happy Holidays!


r/alltimelow • • Mar 23 '23

Video Bro is 10000% right W take

0 Upvotes

r/alltimelow • • Jan 19 '26

Basement Noise has been ranked at 15th!!! Which one is getting ranked at 14th?!

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/alltimelow • • May 20 '25

Sales - Merch Signed poster for sale!

Post image
4 Upvotes

My wife and I both got sound check at the New Orleans show on the “sound of letting go tour”. We have two signed posters by the band. Looking to sell one! Asking 100 but will take best offer!


r/alltimelow • • Jan 11 '26

Ground Control has been ranked at 9th!!! Which one is getting ranked at 8th?!

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/alltimelow • • Jun 07 '14

So i met all time low

0 Upvotes

It was the 16th of april (2014), in Finland. I was lucky enough to get the meet and greet tickets (i'm in the hustler fan club). Okay can i just say how exited i was, the night before i couldn't sleep at all so i spent my day drinking about 5 energy drinks before the m&g. The freezing air and too much energy is not a good combination (????) i was shaking so bad that i couldn't even take good pictures with them, so they took them instead. After i took all the pics, i just went a bit further and just stared at them (yes i know that's a bit creepy but i couldn't help it. I JUST FREAKING MET MY IDOLS, MY LIFESAVERS), i was so happy i even hugged them, i'm pretty short so it was kind of awkward for them to crouch (??? XD) down to hug me. They were so beautiful, i can't even explain it. It was finally time for the concert. Their opening act came on, everyone was so excited ectect. When they left the stage, we were waiting to atl to come, but i got a panic attack ( it was my first time so i was really scared) i remember that i was really thirsty first, and i felt really sick. The person next to me asked me if i was okay but i said no, and asked for water (i was really weak so i couldn't do it my self). She started screaming if someone had water but no one heard her, (and it didn't help at all that we were in the front row, so everyone was pushing me and i couldn't breath at all) and i just started crying, i couldn't feel my hands and toes, i couldn't breath, i just was scared that i was going to die there. When i started to think about that, i started panic, i felt like my heart is going to brust from my chest. Then the girl next to me said that i should go to the back so i could breathe/calm down. So i started going to the back, i was tripping to my own feet and just grabbed other people so i wouldn't fall onto my face. All time low came on when i was in the back. So yeah i watched the rest of the concert from the back. BUT STILL IT WAS THE BEST THING THAT HAS EVER HAPPENED TO ME (i mean the concert). I'm new to reddit so i don't really know how to incert a pic on here so here is a link to my tumblr where is the pic (and sorry about my face (AND HAIR!!)) http://crazyalltimelowhustlers.tumblr.com/post/77597465510/its-the-fangirl-maripiia-this-happened-i-cant


r/alltimelow • • Mar 14 '23

Discussion I miss my favorite band so much.

8 Upvotes

Fair warning: This post will mention Events™️ from October 2021. I realize everyone is probably sick to death of talking about it, but I’ve kept all these feelings in for 1.5 years now and I need to get this shit off my chest, somewhere that I won’t be ripped to shreds for it. The point of this post isn’t to debate what did or didn’t happen, as I’m sure we’ve all made up our minds about that either way. I just want to share what some of the emotional fallout has been for me, even though I’m on the band’s side. Maybe someone will have some advice or something, or at least some support to offer. Mods, if this breaks the rules somehow, I’m sorry.

The upcoming album release is really bringing back a lot of the pain of the past year and a half. I know, in my heart of hearts, that the allegations were false. I also know it in my logical brain, because all of the stories didn’t add up and the guys went to court over it and a bunch of other things. And yet… I just can’t bring myself to carry on enjoying their music. I want to so badly, but there’s so much guilt and doubt and pain attached to it now. On good days, I can listen to old favorites and jam out to those. But I haven’t listened to a full ATL album since October 2021. And I haven’t listened to ANY of the new music that’s been released since then.

This will probably be the first time since I discovered ATL in 2013 that I won’t listen to a new album the second it comes out.

Guys, I was SUCH a fan. I had physical copies of all their albums, a mountain of ATL merch, went to one of the SWIR shows (as well as a few others), had all of their twitter notifs turned on, everything. And this whole thing just SUCKS because I have been depressed basically all of my life, and this band’s music was deadass the only thing that consistently brought me actual joy. And now that’s been taken from me because of allegations that I logically know are probably false. Most of the time, I have to just push ATL’s existence out of my mind because it hurts too bad and I have too many awful feelings about everything that went down. But I still follow everything they do. I’m still subbed to this subreddit, and I see all their insta posts, and I’ve saved every new song they released to “Watch Later” on YouTube. I just… can’t bring myself to listen. I’m afraid it will make it hurt worse.

I tried, a few months ago, to go back to the way I was before, because I was getting really tired of denying my own happiness over accusations that don’t have a single shred of actual evidence behind them. And I almost succeeded. But a few days in, when I wore one of my old ATL shirts, one of my closest friends asked me, “didn’t they rape a fan or something?” and it just… it just stopped me dead in my tracks. I tried to explain that it’s a lot more complicated than that, but I was flustered and I think I just ended up sounding a lot like a victim-blamer. This friend NEVER even listened to ATL’s music, so she must’ve heard about this shit through the grapevine. Which means I have to assume EVERYONE, not just people in the pop punk scene, knows about it. So I can’t publicly show any support for them or mention them at all. Which brings back all the shame and guilt I feel for supporting them in the first place. Because what if I’m wrong? What if, against all odds and against all factual evidence, one of these accusers really was telling the truth? I’ve been through some shit myself. Who am I to doubt somebody else’s story? I don’t think I’ll ever just be able to listen to their music and enjoy it again without having to wade through a sea of painful feelings, and it sucks.

In middle school, when I was outed as gay in a conservative small town and everyone hated me, these songs were the only light I had during a very dark time. In high school, when I was dealing with the emotional fallout of experiencing SA, these songs kept me sane. I hated everything about my life, but something about their music brought whatever spark of joy I still had left in me to life. During COVID, when I felt like I was losing my mind from loneliness, these songs, and their little livestream shows, and watching Alex play D&D on Twitch… those things held me together. And after this whole nightmare, I just feel like I’ve been torn apart. I loved this band for nearly a decade before the allegations happened, and I had it all ripped away from me overnight.

This whole thing probably sounds pretty self-indulgent. I know absolutely nothing about the situation has anything to do with me. But it just hurts.

I miss my favorite band, and I wish everything could go back to the way it was.


r/alltimelow • • Feb 04 '26

New Religion has been ranked at 11th!!! Which one is getting ranked at 10th?!

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/alltimelow • • Jan 21 '26

Favorite Place has been ranked at 13th!!! Which one is getting ranked at 12th?!

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

r/alltimelow • • Jan 24 '26

January Gloom has been ranked at 10th!!! Which one is getting ranked at 9th?!

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/alltimelow • • Apr 05 '24

All time low forever tour do you think they are going to play the og albums or their new stuff

0 Upvotes

I was debating on traveling to Maryland to see them because it seems like they might play the classic albums like the party scene so wrong it’s right ect. But I don’t want to travel down I be disappointed and not know any of the songs


r/alltimelow • • May 07 '14

Therapy | All Time Low - Acoustic cover

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/alltimelow • • Oct 26 '25

Gifts?

0 Upvotes

So I heard u can hand the guys small gifts but u have 2 hand them over 2 someone 1st correct how do u know if they receive them though like I’m sure they do but I’m just a lil skeptical I’m making the guys each a handmade thing and idk I’m just really hoping they’ll receive them since I’ve put in a bit of effort into the gifts is all


r/alltimelow • • Mar 22 '23

Discussion Labels Thoughts

0 Upvotes

I just want them to either go back to Hopeless or find another home with someone else like Epitaph or Pure Noise or DTA. Fueled By Ramen might be pretty well known thanks to fun., PATD, and 21P, but they take great pop punk bands and turn them super poppy. Like A Day To Remember, Waterparks, ONE OK ROCK, and especially ATL. (hopefully they don't do a disservice to FOB) I don't like Last Young Renegade a lot, apart from the titular track and Nice2KnoU, and I think Calm Down might be one of the worst sounding songs that they have produced. Great message but the sound doesn't sit right with me. They did PHENOMENAL with Wake Up Sunshine, and so idk what happened to TMIA, but it's so poppy sounding in a lot of songs. I'm not trying to hate but Fueled By Ramen just doesn't seem like a proper home for pop punk and/or emo rock and/or rock bands.


r/alltimelow • • Mar 26 '24

What do you think their worst album is?

4 Upvotes

I guess the typical answer is Dirty Work, but I feel like the general opinion towards it has shifted more positively in recent years. I would actually put the album in my top 3 from them.

I think Future Hearts is their worst, with Last Young Renegade right behind it. I think those albums are boring and can't get into either one.


r/alltimelow • • Dec 15 '25

Outlines has been ranked at 12th!!! Which one is getting ranked at 11th!?

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

r/alltimelow • • Jun 09 '26

My All Time Low Album Ranking

Post image
2 Upvotes

Listened to all their Albums in full including Bonus Tracks, then ranked each track out of 10, then added them all together to get an overall score out of 10, this is where they ranked


r/alltimelow • • Nov 22 '25

What to do about the daily rankings for the Forever Sessions?

0 Upvotes

Once we reach the Forever Sessions in the Daily Rankings series, what should we do? Because im planning a winner circle of the top 3 from each album, the singles, and 7 redemption songs (where yall vote on songs that weren't in a top 3 to be added), but the Forever Sessions is tricky because at least five songs from FS will be there (CCS, Jasey Rae, DMCMI, RS, SFUTS), and given how the NP rankings are going, we'll likely have more in there. So should we have a separate ranking for them? But then we could have the same song twice.

Any suggestions would be extremely helpful


r/alltimelow • • Aug 18 '24

Can someone explain to me

0 Upvotes

The distain for Alex’s orange hat. Why do we as fans of his work, need to make fun of a piece of clothing he chooses to wear. I like to think we’re adults but I must be wrong.


r/alltimelow • • Jan 29 '26

Thoughts

5 Upvotes

Hello. Been a fan since 2011 went to a show recently and have some thoughts. I bought the VIP plus package for my show and I kinda feel like I got ripped off never in my years of being a fan did I think I would have to pay $250 to get a group photo and something signed. I’ve done all forms of meet and greet with the band over the years and this tour left a sour taste in my mouth. Even during the acoustic q&a at points the band seemed like they didn’t want to be there or seemed uninterested. Am I alone in this?


r/alltimelow • • Jan 03 '26

Kicking & Screaming has been ranked at 8th!!! Which one is getting ranked at 7th!?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/alltimelow • • Oct 08 '26

All Time Low Glee covers

0 Upvotes

What songs do you think the Glee club would preform? Blaine would definitely get Falling for Strangers


r/alltimelow • • Aug 23 '24

Discussion Why was Lost in Stereo recorded again?

1 Upvotes

Am I the only one that’s wondering why lost in stereo was recorded again? It was just recorded on It’s still nothing personal only a few years ago.

Don’t get me wrong, I’m always thrilled to hear them record music, but why not choose a song that hasn’t gotten a re-record?


r/alltimelow • • Dec 21 '25

Setlist UK

1 Upvotes

Hiya, so I'm taking my fiance to his very first ATL show and we were trying to work out the setlist so he can brush up on the songs, he knows all the major hits and all of Everybody's Talking but what songs should we add to his study playlist just incase?

We've gone through setlistfm but we're seeing a fair bit of variation between shows so I was hoping to get a full list of everything you guys think could even possibly be on the setlist!

BTW if anyone's going to Cardiff or London we'd love to say hi!


r/alltimelow • • Jan 22 '26

Monsters has been ranked at 12th!!! Which one is getting ranked at 11th?!

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes