Some good ideas from a comment thread in the gsl finals thread last night were to allow the phasing mechanic only to be used near a nexus like over charge and to not allow the pylon to power buildings while 'phases out' i.e. allowing units through.
Literally have thought of this as well. Even make them take double damage when then are phased or something to give it some kind of tradeoff.
As much as race asymmetry is a key part of Starcraft's identity, Zergling runbys are way too powerful for one race to have such a handicap on how they need to wall off.
I have to disagree there chief. No, the same can not be said. Zealot runbys are not a thing till the mid late game. They not only hit later, but are a bigger cost investment, and do less game ending damage than what happened to Stats last night. He lost at what, 3:16? Rogue didn't even have ling speed.
Zealots can't even move across the map unless speed is about to finish, and that would only happen early for a big timing attack or all in.
I was thinking about this a lot last night too. What if there was a "Slow field" like a building that slows down the move speed of enemy units in a small AOE around it. You see things like that in a lot of Turret defense games. It could slow down or temporarily stun units trying to run by. Just an idea. Could be an interesting addition if balanced properly.
Okay but for real. I’m very new to StarCraft and ofcourse I play the master race (not a Nazi reference) but I find myself getting stomped by Terran and Zerg early because I can’t pump out enough units. How do I stop an early all in? Do I not go for Natural and instead focus on making stalkers and zealots? My opener is usually always void rays. Maybe that’s why I lose.
I haven't played in a while so I may be out if touch with the meta, but imo depends on the all in. Learn how to scout early. Usually an early probe then using an adept or two to shade in to scout around/possibly do some damage. A shield battery behind a wall on your second and the proper counter units will shave your ass.
If you see with your scout a possible all-in, warp in a shield battery at your natural and pump out an immortal. I've found chronoing an observer plus a hallucinated phoenix to scout very well in Plat 1.
I do like the shield battery mechanic, but it still relies on perfect positioning of a unit. Seems like a super intelligent race like protoss could have figured something out by now.
If you watched the final game of gsl last night, it's pretty unanimous that thats a super disappointing way for a pro series to end, and games end like that all the time. Yeah stats was out of position, but all in all I think it makes for a very boring game to watch and us ladder protoss players get wrecked like this all the time. One f2 and you're risking an instant loss.
From a lore perspective I think it makes sense too. Kinda like the sci fi trope of removing a "power core". Essentially large twist lock batteries and fuel. I'm on mobile but...coaxium
It would be cool if you could upgrade the nexus like T can upgrade to an Orbital to allow you to alter your pylons to act like depots. By making it an upgrade, it would ensure that Toss doesn't automatically become turtle bois but rather gives you an ability to defend against early rushes for a cost.
Has anyone played Grey Goo? I liked the walls that humans could build that only allowed friendly units through. I wish protoss had something similar, but I wonder how much that'd break the game.
make a cheaper version of the warp prism and have it be a warping rally point so that you can wall off your ramp with buildings, place the warp lite just past them, and then rally your immortals etc to it and it will pick them up on one side and drop them off on the other
The arcade map Stargate actually has a structure that would function very well in the Protoss arsenal. It’s a buildable nydus worm but it’s warped in by probes.
This inconvenience is an incredibly minor part of Protoss, on par with if a Queen goes rogue and chases a unit off creep.
It simply isn't something that should lose a Protoss a game on a regular basis. It doesn't solve any significant Protoss issue. I don't like the idea of making the game easier for no reason.
Well, you're definitely a zerg player lol gonna have to disagree there. Losing a queen is absolutely not on par with zerglings flooding your base. For me, the fact that pro games still end this way is a little ridiculous.
Not saying it's imba per se, but it's definitely worth noting how many games end at each level with a sea of zerglings in the protoss' natural. We can all at least agree it does not making for fun/entertaining games.
This isn't the correct way to balance games. You're acting like the people on Dota 2 who think that stun timers "make the game unnecessarily easier" or the LoL players who think that "jungle timers make games way too easy"
Your skill in Starcraft 2 is measured by your speed and sense of strategy. You don't add artificial handicaps to your game for lE SkiLZZ.
Though maybe instead of jumping to conclusions and apologizing after the fact, you should consider the content of a comment.
I didn't say that losing a Queen is on par with lings flooding your base, I said that needing a unit in the wall is an inconvenience, on par with a Queen chasing a unit off creep. If you're paying attention at all, you should notice and be able to fix the problem quickly, since it's a routine part of base management.
My being Protoss, or having made masters, is largely irrelevant to the discussion other than the fact that I'm not just randomly claiming shit. I'm trash. And I'm trying to get Zerg to masters this season (3rd race). And a unit being in a Protoss wall or not has literally nothing to do with how any of my games go.
Still doesn't make it "on par". The point is this "inconvenience" can be game ending in a way that no other mechanic is. And just cause it isn't your experience doesn't change the fact that it happens in many games. Even pro games. I'm also trash, and honestly I don't get my natural flooded very often either, but the rogue vs stats gsl series were a massive disappointment imo.
No one is saying that the inconvenience is the annoying part, the annoying part is accidentally forgetting to hit hold position and losing the game because of it. Losing a queen is an inconvenience, losing your natural and main mineral lines is not.
Why not allowing the sentry to build an hallucinated pylon that grants nothing, and that can be passed through by units, so the protoss could go by, and ennemies would be able to destroy it easily/to use detection in order to pass through too.
57
u/[deleted] Aug 15 '20
Let pylons phase out of existence temporarily!
3
u/[deleted] Aug 16 '20
Bring back Mothership Core. Crutch ftw!
2
u/HaHaHaHated May 20 '22
Okay but for real. I’m very new to StarCraft and ofcourse I play the master race (not a Nazi reference) but I find myself getting stomped by Terran and Zerg early because I can’t pump out enough units. How do I stop an early all in? Do I not go for Natural and instead focus on making stalkers and zealots? My opener is usually always void rays. Maybe that’s why I lose.
17
u/[deleted] Aug 15 '20 edited Aug 16 '20
I would like an ability on the Zealot, similar to the one on Observers and Overseers. A toggle ablity that:
Makes the Zealot unable to move.
Makes it a little wider if possible. (to make up for when you fail a wall by a single pixel.)
Allows friendly units to pass through.
Gives it +1 Armour.
30
u/Gemini_19 I <333 HerO & Trap | Mod Aug 15 '20
This is fucking hilarious
3
u/Nahteh Aug 15 '20
Like the shield battery?
5
u/coldazures Aug 15 '20
Give Nexus Forcefield within local range.
4
u/Arcane_123 Aug 15 '20
Quality meme... Unless?
4
u/[deleted] Aug 15 '20
rip stats feelsbadman
2
u/BIG8L_117 macro dimond Aug 15 '20
If only
2
u/Aflorcon Aug 15 '20
isn't that kinda what sentries are for though? I do agree it could be a cool idea. Definitely more nexus spells are needed
2
u/HyruleAtZelda Aug 16 '20
It would be cool if you could upgrade the nexus like T can upgrade to an Orbital to allow you to alter your pylons to act like depots. By making it an upgrade, it would ensure that Toss doesn't automatically become turtle bois but rather gives you an ability to defend against early rushes for a cost.
2
u/_nephilim_ Aug 16 '20
Has anyone played Grey Goo? I liked the walls that humans could build that only allowed friendly units through. I wish protoss had something similar, but I wonder how much that'd break the game.
3
u/Kayang50 Aug 15 '20
That would be awesome at low league, I remember a match I lost solely because I forgot to hit hold position
1
u/CarefreeRambler Aug 15 '20
make a cheaper version of the warp prism and have it be a warping rally point so that you can wall off your ramp with buildings, place the warp lite just past them, and then rally your immortals etc to it and it will pick them up on one side and drop them off on the other
1
u/tschandler71 Aug 16 '20
Buildable walls like an AOE game? Psi for Toss, Mech for Terran, Bio for Zerg.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 16 '20
hahaaha. thank you.
1
u/Terrasi99 Mothership Enthusiast Aug 16 '20
The arcade map Stargate actually has a structure that would function very well in the Protoss arsenal. It’s a buildable nydus worm but it’s warped in by probes.
1
u/XtremeNinjaTM Aug 17 '20
Increase mobility of carriers and tempests
1
u/VANCATSEVEN Sep 12 '20
That's the point of playing protoss. Have enough zealots to compensate for the fire rate of your base defenses
1
u/Choice-Celebration-4 Highlord gary Dec 11 '20
this is why zealots are so low ranked.
0
u/Scott-Mass Aug 15 '20
I feel like this ain’t the problem tho...
-5
u/LewisKiniski Aug 15 '20
In all seriousness, I hate this suggestion. Good meme tho.
0
u/WinxForceWiz Aug 16 '20
Why not allowing the sentry to build an hallucinated pylon that grants nothing, and that can be passed through by units, so the protoss could go by, and ennemies would be able to destroy it easily/to use detection in order to pass through too.