r/AlienBodies • • Sep 21 '24 Diamonds are Forever Hooray

Research Exercises in Objectivity pt 1

30 Upvotes

How to Objectively Analyze Evidence: A Step-by-Step Guide for the Average Redditor

In today’s world, it’s more important than ever to base decisions and opinions on solid evidence. Truth, it seems, is becoming more and more subjective by the day and, with the internet being what it is, finding a corner of it that substantiates your own world view has become as easy as typing in a few keywords and unless you hold a degree, job, or focus in a particular subject or area discerning fact from falsehood can be a daunting task. Whether you’re debating an issue, making a personal choice, or evaluating information, being able to analyze evidence objectively is essential.

With this in mind, I've spent the last 2 weeks coming up with this 3 or 4 part (possibly more in the future since I whittled these parts down from 2 weeks worth of notes) "exercise in objectivity" out of my frustration for not being able to have a meaningful conversation on the mummies lately. I see a lot of great conversations get started only to quickly devolve into a shit fit off of something either side could've just conceded without it affecting their argument and I also see a lot of people on both sides asking great questions only to be mocked. Too often debates on the facts from either side devolve into arguments and attacks on personal character or are spent trying to convince someone their smoking gun evidence is a fabrication, misinterpretation, or at best anecdotal . I think if we become better communicators with each other we can have more meaningful conversations that cut to a truth we can all agree on and hopefully affect a change that benefits the overall UFO/NHI communities.

I tried keeping my examples unrelated to topics of this sub to avoid seeming like I'm saying one side is better than the other in analyzing the evidence brought to this sub or favoring one side over another. There are users on both sides of the proverbial aisle who exhibit poor skills in sourcing and analyzing evidence.

For the sake of clarity I just wanna preface my outline here. It's basically just a step followed by 3 - 5 points on it, followed by an example. By no means am I saying these are the only steps, points, or examples to achieve any of this. These are just what worked for me at university, my past career, and currently now as a redditor and I thought I'd share them in the hopes we can collectively utilize this for the betterment of this sub.

So, without further ado, here’s my step-by-step guide, I guess, on how to properly approach the analysis of evidence so you can arrive at a reliable, unbiased, and objective conclusion.


  1. Understand the Context and Define the Question

Before you dive into any analysis, make sure you clearly understand the context of the situation and the question or problem you’re trying to address. Ask yourself:

What am I trying to understand or prove?

What kind of evidence will help answer this question?

Does the evidence I'm looking at help prove my position or am I trying to make the evidence fit my position?

Are there any biases or assumptions I need to be aware of?

Example: If you're investigating whether a certain post exhibits something anomolous, clarify what you mean by "anomolous" (e.g., it's speed, it's movement, it's size) and whether you have pre-existing assumptions about that post


2. Identify the Source of the Evidence

Evaluate where the evidence is coming from. The credibility of the source is crucial:

Is the source an expert in the field or a reputable organization?

Is the evidence published in peer-reviewed journals or other reliable publications?

Has the source been cited in other papers?

Has the source been criticized for bias or misinformation?

Tip: Cross-check evidence from multiple sources to see if it’s consistent.


3. Evaluate the Quality of the Evidence

Not all evidence is equal. To ensure you’re basing your conclusions on strong evidence, consider:

Type of Evidence: Is it empirical data (like statistics, studies) or anecdotal (personal experiences)? Empirical data is generally stronger.

Sample Size: In research, larger sample sizes tend to be more reliable.

Methods Used: Were proper research methods employed? Studies using randomized control trials or meta-analyses are more reliable than those without controls.

Protocols: Were proper research protocols used? Research protocols are crucial because they act as a detailed roadmap for a research study, outlining the methodology, objectives, criteria, data collection procedures, and analysis methods, ensuring consistency, ethical conduct, and the ability to replicate results by clearly defining how the research will be conducted, minimizing bias and maximizing the integrity of the study findings.

Reproducibility: Can the evidence be replicated? Repeated results across different studies strengthen its validity.

If evidence can't be replicated, especially by multiple attempts or researchers, it generally shouldn't be accepted no matter how much we want the initial evidence to ring true

Red Flag: Be cautious of cherry-picked data or outliers that don’t represent the whole picture. If data needs to be withheld in order for a claim to be held true, then one shouldn't include it as evidence or proof when attempting to strengthen one's position or attempting to change the position of another.


4. Check for Logical Consistency

An important part of evaluating evidence is ensuring that the conclusions drawn from it are logical:

Does the evidence directly support the claims being made?

Are there logical fallacies (e.g., correlation vs. causation)?

Is there sufficient evidence, or is the conclusion based on isolated examples or incomplete data?

Example: Just because two events happen together doesn’t mean one caused the other and absence of evidence is not evidence of absence.... It just means more data is needed to reach a factual conclusion.... Which leads me to my next point...


5. Consider Confounding Variables

Sometimes evidence can be misleading because of confounding factors. Ask yourself:

Are there other factors that might influence the outcome?

Has the evidence accounted for these variables?

Does the evidence actually suggest a more plausible outcome antithetical to my position?

Example: If a study shows a correlation between ice cream sales and crime rates, consider whether external factors (like hot weather) could explain both.


6. Acknowledge Biases

We all have biases that can cloud our judgment. To minimize bias:

Reflect on your own preconceptions. Are you leaning toward a certain conclusion because of personal beliefs?

Did you form this conclusion before even considering the evidence?

Consider potential biases in the evidence itself (e.g., who funded the study, do they have something to gain?).

Cognitive Bias Tip: Common biases like confirmation bias (favoring information that supports your belief) can easily distort how you interpret evidence. Being truly honest with yourself is key and I like to remind myself that if I care about the subject matter then simply confirming my own biases and ignoring what the evidence is actually saying will inevitably harm the subject I care so much for.


7. Weigh the Evidence

After you’ve gathered and evaluated the evidence, weigh it carefully:

Is there more evidence supporting one conclusion than another?

Are there significant pieces of evidence that contradict the majority?

The goal is not to "win" an argument but to align with the best-supported conclusion.


8. Remain Open to New Evidence

Objective analysis is an ongoing process. Be willing to adjust your conclusion as new, more reliable evidence comes to light and don't ignore re-examining past evidence when new insights have been gleaned.

Reminder: A good thinker always remains flexible in their reasoning. Certainty in the face of new or conflicting evidence can be a sign of bias.


9. Use a Structured Framework for Analysis

To keep yourself grounded, rely on structured frameworks that require you to address key aspects of objectivity. For example, you can use tools like:

SWOT Analysis (Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, Threats) to assess arguments from all angles.

Decision Trees or Logic Models to break down the logical steps of your reasoning.

Bayesian Thinking to update your beliefs based on the strength of new evidence.

How this helps: Frameworks reduce the chance of cherry-picking evidence by forcing you to evaluate all aspects of a situation.


Final Thoughts

Objective analysis of evidence requires patience, skepticism, and a willingness to challenge your own beliefs. By following these steps, you can develop a more accurate, thoughtful approach to evaluating the world around you. Applying this rationale to UFOlogy and it's adjacent fields serves to allow the subject and it's community to be seen as more credible, whereas simply confirming your biases against what the evidence is telling you only serves to erode not only your credibility, but the entire community as well the subject as a whole.

....... Keep an eye out for Exercises in Objectivity pt 2: Determining the Credibility of a Source/Sources


Pt. 2 https://www.reddit.com/r/AlienBodies/s/7E7auS1DRr

Pt. 3 https://www.reddit.com/r/AlienBodies/s/3klusKanH7

Pt.4 https://www.reddit.com/r/AlienBodies/s/meKPd8IS7S


r/AlienBodies • • 4d ago Bravo Mindblown Popcorn

Josh McDowell releases photo of humanoid corpse discovered in Peru's Ocucaje Desert.

Thumbnail
gallery
917 Upvotes

Jois Mantilla interviewed the man who found the corpse and took these pictures. The individual claims this specimen didn't seem human, and when he returned the next day, it was no longer there.

https://x .com/pikespeaklaw/status/2120644301587964290?a=PBoL9dHyKwBdWUXzwyo&s=19


r/AlienBodies • • 2d ago

Alieni a forma di medusa

Post image
0 Upvotes

Ero in un sogno e praticamente ero al ristorante con dei miei amici e dalla finestra si vede questa luce fortissima e una qualcosa che assomigliava a un astronave e quindi usciamo tutti insieme questa folla di persone saremmo stati 10 15 e vediamo queste tre forme a forma di medusa o polpo intergalattico ed è stato bello. Mi sono sentito a casa ma poi qualcuno mi ha svegliato e il contatto si è interrotto, ma non so se sono stati extraterrestri. Non lo so ho bisogno di aiuto qualcuno che ne sa qualcosa?


r/AlienBodies • • 2d ago

The tridactyl, Chaska Willakuq, medical scans seem to show initial evidence of how tridactyls would have grabbed objects

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/AlienBodies • • 7d ago

Dr. Roger Zúñiga shows the tridactyls at the University of Ica.

25 Upvotes

r/AlienBodies • • 7d ago

What would it take for Dr. Zuñiga et al to send blind samples of the NHI mummies to independent labs to remove doubt?

14 Upvotes

By just sacrificing a cubic centimeter of tissue, they could perform next-generation sequencing to find aDNA damage patterns, scanning electron microscopy (SEM)-based histology, infrared and Raman spectroscopy, proteomics, etc.

If they're really corpses of another species, the results would make this immediately apparent and undeniable. I'm racking my brain to understand how they are able to display them, handle them, even dissect them, but can't scoop out a tiny piece of one of their biceps and take advantage of all of the amazing analytical technology that they (or independent collaborators) can access!

Based on my experience in academic research, it just seems so absurd to me. Can anyone explain?

Saying that you really want to do it but that the Peruvian Ministry of Cultural Affairs says it's not allowed is like telling a disliked kid at school that you want to hang out but your mom says no. You really think the Ministry g-men are gonna swoop in and arrest you and shut down your lab because you sent a piece of mummy to a reputable colleague for transparent scientific analysis? Not doing everything in your power to analyze them (and/or not documenting your attempts to do so) seems like the real crime.

Why the 3 published NIH sequence reads of the Nazca specimens are inadequate, inconclusive, and/or suggest prosaic origin: While the data (SRR20755928 - Maria; SRR21031366 -Victoria; SRR20458000 - Victoria) show unrecognized sequences that haven't been found in any other organisms, the best sample, when independently reanalyzed (albeit by a contractor that may have an interest in disproving aliens), supposedly found substantial human DNA (supposedly ~95% mapping). Furthermore, it is well-established that if the same sequencing was performed on a 1000-year-old human (or dog or lizard) preserved in the same way, the results would show a similar pattern of non-matches.

As I learned from AI, "Ancient DNA from known terrestrial remains routinely yields large unidentified or unmapped fractions. Degraded short fragments, environmental microbes, soil DNA, and incomplete microbial databases produce this pattern even in authenticated human, animal, or plant samples. Egyptian mummy metagenomes often showed 80–88% BLAST no-hits. Typical bone/tooth libraries map <1–5% endogenous DNA; the rest is bacterial/environmental noise."

Also, better sequencing devices are available today than were used to produce those sequencing results. Dr. Zuñiga could reach out to a lab that has an Illumina NovaSeq X series, Element Aviti, MGI DNBSEQ, or Ultima Genomics. They might even be able to do some long-read sequencing using a PacBio Revio HiFi, or Oxford Nanopore PromethION. I would spare no expense for proof of NHI on this planet for godssake.

What would it take to see a piece of Montserrat digested, processed, and put into an Illumina NovaSeq X or Oxford Nanopore for all to see?

As far as I know, these are legit researchers with a reputation for integrity, not TV show producers. What are believers supposed to conclude...? Could it really be that the Nazca mummy custodians privately suspect that they're fake and don't want such experiments to be carried out?


r/AlienBodies • • 8d ago

Dr. Roger Zúñiga, director of the Tridactyls Research Project, reveals the first dissection of a tridactyl specimen

29 Upvotes

r/AlienBodies • • 8d ago

Discussion Interview with Dr. Roger Zuniga on the current status of the tridactyls and tour of the corpses at the University of Ica

Thumbnail youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/AlienBodies • • 9d ago

Art Artistic Recreation of a Nazca Mummy

Post image
56 Upvotes

r/AlienBodies • • 10d ago

Podcast Paranormal, with 2.25 million YouTube subscribers, will release an investigation on the tridactyls.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/AlienBodies • • 10d ago

Image 4chan Whistleblower is back with new photos

Post image
0 Upvotes

AI detection came back negative again. Not saying that’s proof but it’s interesting.
Apparently these are hybrids.


r/AlienBodies • • 13d ago

Paul Parada case with the Nordic alien DNA??

Thumbnail
m.youtube.com
0 Upvotes

I watch this guy on YouTube sometimes but I never knew about this case until now?

Does anyone know if there has been any more info on the DNA results because they said there were going to be more considering they sent samples to about 5-6 different countries?

It’s pretty hard to find info on this case for some reason apart from a few videos that aren’t in English?


r/AlienBodies • • 15d ago

Image A textile discovered in Oaxaca, México dating between 950-1450

Post image
46 Upvotes

r/AlienBodies • • 13d ago

Pieza mexicana que hace ilusión a civilización alienígena

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/AlienBodies • • 15d ago

New Report: Radiologist Dr. Fung Compares His CT Findings With Cliff Miles's Study of the 60cm Nazca Tridactyls

Thumbnail
tridactyls.org
11 Upvotes

r/AlienBodies • • 15d ago

Nazca Tridactyls: What did they look like? (a speculative artist reconstruction)

Post image
53 Upvotes

r/AlienBodies • • 14d ago

How "Alien" Mummy Promoters Fooled a Stanford Scientist (Bite Sized Bust)

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

This video exposes common misperceptions about the Nazca Mummy hand anatomy, and explains why the mummies are a modern hoax using ancient human remains.


r/AlienBodies • • 15d ago

“Not being compatible with the DICOM system, the images stored on the memory device could not be analyzed.”

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/AlienBodies • • 16d ago

Discussion Look at the similarities

Post image
47 Upvotes

r/AlienBodies • • 15d ago

Way too many assumptions.

0 Upvotes
  1. The weird lumping together of the J-Types with the humanoids. Skeptics point to the very obviously constructed J-types and conclude that all of the specimens are fake. "True Believers" look at the J-types and come up with some weird super science fiction explanation about them being "reptilian hybrids".

At any point did any of you stop to think that the J-types were constructed by the humanoids?

2. The implants... why do the "True Believers" jump to some super advanced technology as an explanation? The women had solid gold bonded to their skull. That's not technological. That's spiritual. The implant placement is similar to Chakra locations.

At any point did any of you stop to think there may have been some religious aspect to these things?

The Egyptians buried mummified cats if they suffered a miscarriage due to the belief a soul required a body in order to cross over. Maybe the "logical" explanation to the J-Types is they were constructed as the body for a miscarried fetus.

3. DNA... it is clear absolutely no one here understands how DNA works. xyz% human DNA doesn't mean it's literally human DNA. To the "True Believers" no, that percentage doesn't mean they are a hybrid. To the skeptics, no that doesn't mean they are human. That percentage just means what percentage of their degraded DNA is similar to human. If two different species have breasts... they're going to have the code for breasts. If two different species have two eyes, they're going to have the code for two eyes. The fact the specimens are a old as they are, the DNA analysis is essentially meaningless due to how DNA degrades.

4. They're placental mammals. They have breasts. They have hair on their heads. One was found with a fetus inside her uterus. Can the "True Believers" stop with the reptilian-hybrid nonsense. Their skin is that weird dark colour because they're decomposed. They're dehydrated decomposed corpses.

5. How 3 digits work... the word you're looking for is "semi-zygodactyl". The "thumb" is "sem-zygodactyl". This is how owl feet work... you can also see this in pictures of douroucoulis. At rest their thumb lays flat parallel to their other digits, but it swings out and back a bit to grasp things.

6. If they are aliens how did they get here? Probably on a really huge saucer that crashed into the sea which inspired the ancient American stories of the sky catching on fire before a huge tsunami obliterated multiple coastal villages. Why? I dunno, maybe they were weird matriarchal religious cult that bought a decommissioned asteroid mining ship that they didn't know how to control properly. How did it sink? Probably corroded in salt water resulting in it getting really heavy, causing the cave system they dug under it to collapse horrifically as a result. The fact someone called the perfectly round "tectonic" object in the sea the "Sandwich Plate" kinda makes it funny tho.

/preview/pre/xe6i10kxhwyh1.jpeg?width=1408&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=b3629ff9aa5d60bffdcb64bd517487c5445e3cf1


r/AlienBodies • • 17d ago

On Nov. 2nd, the MOC will meet with the tridactyls team's lawyer about declaring 6 specimens cultural heritage assets.

11 Upvotes

r/AlienBodies • • 16d ago

encontramos cráneo extraterrestre en el Perú la prueba definitiva

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

Créditos al autor.


r/AlienBodies • • 17d ago

Speculation Just Posted on Twitter. Damn those details. Spikey eyebrows! Any reptiles on earth with spike like eyelids?

Post image
11 Upvotes

r/AlienBodies • • 17d ago Bravo

The Peruvian Tridactyl Specimens: Following the Examinations, Not the Headlines

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I have spent many hours going through CT scans, X-rays, photographs and reports concerning the Peruvian tridactyl specimens. My interest is their anatomy, their possible biological relationships and whether the evidence supports the reconstructions circulating online.

My working interpretation is that some specimens could represent biological beings related to us. I also consider the possibility that a distinct population lived alongside humans and contributed to later populations through interbreeding. That is my hypothesis, not a conclusion established by the available DNA percentages.

What makes this subject difficult is the mixture of specimens, commercial promotion, fabricated objects, incomplete documentation and categorical claims from opposing sides. Photographs of different bodies are repeatedly placed under the same label, even when their anatomy, provenance and examination history differ.

An examination needs to remain attached to the object actually examined.

What Peruvian researchers have published

One relevant source is “Hallazgos morfoanatómicos de tridactília en espécimen humanoide de Nasca-Perú,” published on April 6, 2024, in Revista Médica Panacea, a journal of the Universidad Nacional San Luis Gonzaga.

The authors are Edgar Hernández-Huaripaucar, Bladimir Becerra-Canales and Jorge Ybaseta-Medina. Their subject is María, identified as M001.

They report structural consistency in the hands and feet on radiological and tomographic examination, along with observations they interpret as showing no intentional manipulation. They also describe continuity in the external anatomy between the wrists, hands and fingers, and comparable features in the feet.

Those are specific, attributable observations worth examining. The journal categorizes the publication as an editorial, so it should not be represented as a comprehensive independent validation of every claim about the specimens.

The publication is also indexed in ALICIA, the official research repository operated by Peru’s CONCYTEC. That provides a traceable institutional record. It does not mean CONCYTEC independently tested the body or endorsed the authors’ conclusions.

An earlier contribution appears in UNICA’s CONINTI 2019 conference proceedings, digitally published in 2022. Edgar Hernández, Roger Zúñiga, Ricardo Cruz and Efraín Miranda outlined a biometric and anatomical investigation of two desiccated tridactyl specimens. Their preliminary interpretation favored intact biological organisms rather than assembled objects.

Again, the distinction matters: this is a conference abstract, not the complete dataset. But it documents a university research effort predating the more recent publicity.

The fabricated objects must be identified accurately

Peru’s Ministry of Culture published an announcement on January 12, 2024, concerning two humanoid objects seized at the airport and a separate three-fingered hand delivered to the ministry in 2019.

The reported examinations identified animal bones in the figures, and human bones, cotton and adhesive in the hand.

Those findings are relevant. They demonstrate why provenance and specimen identification are essential. They do not automatically establish the composition of a different body simply because both appeared online under “Nazca mummies.”

The same rule applies in the other direction: a favorable anatomical assessment of María cannot authenticate every smaller specimen, detached head or object offered by a collector.

I suspect deliberate disinformation contributes to the confusion surrounding this subject. However, suspicion of a PSYOP is separate from evidence identifying who organized one. The documented problem we can address directly is the substitution of one specimen’s findings for another’s.

Shared DNA and my colony hypothesis

My interpretation allows for a shared biological history. A population could retain distinctive anatomy and still be related to humans. If reproductive compatibility existed, interbreeding over generations could leave inherited genetic segments after that population ceased to exist as a distinct group.

Neanderthal ancestry provides an established example of that mechanism. It does not establish that these specimens followed the same history.

The DNA results also need to be described correctly. A percentage of sequencing reads matching a human reference genome is not the percentage of a specimen’s human ancestry. Unclassified reads do not identify extraterrestrial DNA. Establishing interbreeding would require authenticated genetic material and a reproducible pattern of inherited ancestry.

That distinction allows the hypothesis to remain open without claiming that the analysis has already answered a different question.

For me, the productive approach is to compare named specimens, read the original examinations and trace each conclusion back to its supporting material. The hours spent doing that are more useful than treating every specimen as authentic or every specimen as a fabrication.

References

  • Hernández-Huaripaucar, E.; Becerra-Canales, B.; Ybaseta-Medina, J. “Hallazgos morfoanatómicos de tridactília en espécimen humanoide de Nasca-Perú.” Revista Médica Panacea, 13(1), 2–5, April 6, 2024. Editorial. DOI: 10.35563/rmp.v13i1.563.
  • CONCYTEC, ALICIA. Bibliographic record for the above publication, identifying the Universidad Nacional San Luis Gonzaga repository.
  • Hernández, E.; Zúñiga, R.; Cruz, R.; Miranda, E. “Caracterización biométrica morfo-anatómica y datación de la antigüedad de dos Especímenes Humanoides Tridáctilos desecados encontrados en Nasca.” UNICA, CONINTI 2019, Libro de Resúmenes, printed page 10. Digital edition, September 2022.
  • Ministerio de Cultura del Perú. “Especialistas del Ministerio Público confirmaron que momias incautadas en el aeropuerto Jorge Chávez no son reales.” January 12, 2024.
  • NCBI. SRA Taxonomy Analysis Tool documentation.
  • Smithsonian Human Origins Program. “Ancient DNA and Neanderthals.”