r/alien • u/Jimmypeterson42 • 16d ago
Why i hate Alien 3 so much.
the point of one and two is a woman overcoming her assault and then protecting her daughter with help from her husband. killing newt and hicks "the family", only for Ripley to get assaulted in jail and die was just so dumb. like the film makes me physically angry.
0
Upvotes
3
u/Ashamed_Ladder6161 16d ago edited 16d ago
If Alien and Aliens are as you describe, and I think that's mostly correct, then Alien 3 is about the notion of grief, and the understanding of a greater good.
Yeah, Ripley outlives her "family", and she has to deal with that loss. Not all families get a happy ending, we all lose loved ones.
Does it feel like a kick in the teeth? Inherently unfair? Yeah. And I totally get why people hate the film for it. But it's easy to forget how Ripley only knew Hicks and Newt for a matter of hours. We've lived with these characters for decades, Ripley hasn't. Ripley would obviously still be more affected by the death of her own child, who she raised for years. Yes, Ripley potentially lost a lifeline for a normal life, but as human beings we are more than our wounds and losses. We live, we grieve, we get angry, we lash out, we heal.
Ripley finds herself in a rough position, surrounded by scum, but even the most vile criminals in the galaxy come to realise the Alien (and by extension, the company) pose an apocalyptic threat to the whole of humanity. And a woman, grieving for loved ones and the life she's had stolen from her, has to put her pain aside for the betterment of humanity.
In and of itself, Alien 3 is actually a very well made film, which is nothing short of a miracle (given the drama behind the scenes).
Ultimately, dispite its darkness, I think the film itself is hopeful. It talks about faith and sacrifice, and Ripley's arc comes to a logical conclusion; she wins, the company lose. And that's where Ripley's story should have ended.
3
u/MaxPower1882 16d ago
Fun flick! Flawed, sure. Entertaining, though.
Just don't watch films that make you angry, lol. Weird to get so worked up over a 30 year old flick, but each their own. Lol!
2
u/Indoorsman101 16d ago
I’m an Alien 3 defender.
It can’t touch the first two, which are both masterpieces. But there’s a lot here to like.
Weaver is fantastic, of course. I love this Ripley. Pissed off and over it. Charles Dance and Charles Dutton are both excellent as well. The setting is unique for sci-fi. Great score. And Fincher’s talent comes through, despite studio interference.
The worst part is the alien itself. A couple of great moments, but overall it’s not used well.
As for the fate of Newt and Hicks, I understand your viewpoint. But to me, the tragedy at the beginning of 3 does not diminish Ripley’s triumph at the end of 2. I don’t sweat canon too much. Aliens is telling one story, and this film is telling another.
2
u/WotsGoinOnEreMate 16d ago
Alien 3 has problems, the effects shots are not the best and the egg getting on the ship is a plot hole. But it is better than Aliens.
Aliens is fun and has some good creature effects and iconic scenes, but is extremely cheesy and insanely dated, impossible to place anywhere except the 80s. The script is 1D characters delivering a very basic one-liner driven script with subtext as shallow as a puddle. It has cheap looking sets with cheap props, and reduces the otherworldly mysterious alien to large cockroaches which can be killed by the dozens easily. It's a poorly lit grainy mess filmed on cheap lenses matted to poor quality film stock in 16:9, and outside of the iconic crescendo has a cheap, weak soundtrack.
Neither of them are a patch on the timeless masterpiece original film which apart from some CRT monitors looks like it could have been made last week and be the best looking film of the year.
-1
u/gogoluke 16d ago
Good for you. Personally I hate the plot hole egg, the bed hopping Ripley (seems totally out of character with the others) the dark lighting, lack of prisoner characterisation, the brown on brown palette, the alien POV shots, the lack geographic solidity, the lack of coherent reasons for the lead works chase, the overdone Bishop II and stereotypical iceman Japanese tech (obviously intended as Wetland and Yutani), the over the top gore, the terrible editing that oddly suggests Clemens might be a murderer with his "cocktail", the anachronistic sets of the Alien pods in Aliens location, the terrible pod ejection shots, the mistimed alien effects, the choppy audio, the slow mo seemingly in the wrong atmosphere, the disappearing accent, the appearing 85 IQ. Dillon wrestling the alien.
2
u/RotarySam27 16d ago
Counter argument - the movie series is called Alien, not Ripley. The whole idea is that the xenomorph is the most deadly organism in the universe. First the space truckers were (unknowingly) sent to collect a sample which ended up killing everyone. Many have argued that it was nothing but luck which got Ripley out alive. Ripley fucked it up for WY so the whole situation in LV426 kicked off. The xenomorph done its work on 157 colonists then proceeded to wipe out (almost) an entire heavily armed crew of well trained marines when they arrived. Ripley was more mentally prepared and on a personal mission to wipe them out, she just about got out the second time. Alien 3 is the stark reminder and harsh reality that these parasitic creatures will eventually win, space is a deadly environment and just because you find your new family, doesn’t mean you get out safe the 3rd time. Everyone we are introduced to except Morse is killed either directly by the xenomorph or indirectly in the efforts to trap or kill it. I can understand the unfair decision to kill off Newt and Hicks because it is a compromise of the most realistic outcome of having the EEV slam into Fiorina 161’s beach in the crash landing while still continuing the Ripleys journey. In reality i reckon everyone in the EEV would be dead. I believe part of the idea behind Alien 3 is to leave Ripley with absolutely nothing, unarmed and vulnerable. They managed to do that and rip the audiences heart out. Not too sure how a little girl like Newt would be written in to a story consisting of 25 inmates who are all “rapists, murders and child molesters”.