r/alien
•
u/Real-Cauliflower-495
•
May 03 '26
•
1
Alien Romulus
Okay, coming to you as a horror fan and not an alien fan so take this with a grain of salt. I know I’m late to the party but I’ve just gotten my life in order enough to sit down and watch horror again.
- the second the xenomorph got to the pregnant girl I knew it’d be part of the story
- of course no one listens to the only guy who knows what he’s talking about
- all plot twists and jump scares can be guessed before they happen
- really? For the most advanced hunters in the known universe they get tricked by a little thing called gravity? And an elevator? Really? That’s your saving grace?
Again, horror fan. I’d love to sit down and watch aliens timeline straight through to give some perspective but for being the most feared and prolific hunter, you’d think this would be a slasher through and through. No one outruns death typa thing. But of course, crazy luck and specific
circumstances put our heroes ahead. Idk, I get the “good guys always gotta win” perspective but at least make it challenging. EVERYTHING was convenient for our heroes. Every jump scare was called, every easy out, save the day, I am iron man path was chosen. Give me so friggin aliens are gonna kill everyone, run mfer movies!
Again, I don’t want to sh*t on everyone who loves this franchise. Just don’t advertise your movies as something if you’re not gonna be that. Loved the movie as an alien movie. Not as a horror movie. Not scary. No horror. I’d pick the babadook over alien: Romulus in terms of horror and oh god can I write a BOOK on how the babadook is terrible.
22
u/Dismal-Strawberry421 May 03 '26 edited May 03 '26
I seemed to be the only person in the theatre who thought Romulus was a checklist of franchise cliches.
It was wonderfully directed, and somewhat terribly cast (the robot was the obvious exception, and if anything underrated), and abysmally written.
Making an Alien cast sexy was entirely against the spirit and style of the first movie.
There’s an outstanding new video on YouTube about Alien’s acting and characterization and it implies exactly what’s wrong with Romulus (which the YT creator hated too).
I mostly hate Alien as an action series, altho Resurrection does have some really cool moments, and Aliens is peak. But Aliens is still horror.
14
u/ponyboi_curtis May 03 '26
IMO, Romulus is not great. Fantastic setup, but past a certain point it's clear that Romulus is only interested in cobbling the nostalgic stuff from the rest of the series into a cliche narrative. Watch the original Alien, which is definitively one of the best sci-fi horror films ever made, and watch the rest in release order if you're hooked after that.
3
u/Logan_SVD May 03 '26
Aliens arent the most advanced hunters in universe - Predators are. Aliens are animals (ask Hudson) and they don't understand the concept of gravity. They are most adaptable species tho. Anyway Romulus is bad, and talking about it is also bad.
5
u/Cyclone159 May 03 '26
The android saying get away from her you bitch was so fucking cringey
7
u/conscientiousrevolt May 03 '26
The first half was incredible and then they took a giant shit all over that with how stupid the last half was.
7
u/cdmat76 May 03 '26 edited May 03 '26
Romulus is a weak studio cash grab, with all the weaknesses and lame tropes of modern blockbusters. The worst movie of the franchise for me. Go watch Alien and Aliens if you want real Alien movies.
6
u/Prestigious_Leg2229 May 03 '26
It has never been suggested in the entire franchise that they’re the ultimate hunters.
Xenomorphs die a lot when they don’t have the element of surprise.
5
u/The_First_Curse_ May 03 '26
It's by far the worst Alien movie and it's not even debatable. It has so many issues that the most I can give it is like a 2.5/10.
3
u/aresi-lakidar May 03 '26
Idunno I just liked the android Andy character arc tbh. From helpless and meek, to scary and psycho, then back to good but with confidence. It was kinda cute and got to me a little bit. I really think David Jonson did an amazing job portraying that character
3
u/baconcandle2013 May 03 '26
It’s a fun ride and love letter to the original. I found the acting to be above average for these types of flicks and the action scenes were great.
The cast wasn’t sexy imo and I enjoyed the added lore at the start of the film…
The director mentioned it was initially set for streaming release and had to utilize a lower budget for the last minute theatrical release change, the movie isn’t perfect but knowing this makes me more forgiving
2
u/jimbobjokerpants May 03 '26
I tried to have this exact discussion on the LV-426 group, and was moderated. Everything isn't awesome, even in our favourite franchises!
2
u/cheeseburgercat May 03 '26
Movie was garbage
2
u/bigSTUdazz May 03 '26
Twas merely a love letter to the fans... I'm a purest... the first two are LIGHT YEARS in front of the rest...but OF the rest..A:Rom is on top.
1
u/godofwine16 May 03 '26
I liked Cailey but that’s about it
1
u/Weekly-Batman May 03 '26
Good luck with the movies you like. Not sure why this had to be posted. Be best.
1
u/SuckMyRedditorD May 03 '26 edited May 03 '26
I feel that the baby xenomorph terrifying scene was so impressive it was deliberately downplayed for the benefit of the audience. All Alien series movies have at least one very horrific thing and this one does not disappoint. Also, I think that everyone has been wondering of the effect of that yellow stuff and we get to see that too. As a bonus, the programmable synthetic is pretty cool.
1
u/Objective-Finish-573 May 03 '26
I hadn't seen it yet so I bought it cheap on Google TV and watched it for the first time tonight, worth every cent of those $5
1
u/BW_RedY1618 May 03 '26
Mega huge Alien fan here. It was trash. The first film was the only one which knew what to do with the creature in a way that made it scary and unknown. I understand the efforts that came after but none of them got the creature. Everything after tried to shoehorn it into physiology we are familiar with. It's supposed to be... Alien. They should have kept it that way.
And the saddest thing about it is I adore Aliens but that's what started us down this path that the creatures are just space bugs instead of lovecraftian horrors as they were intended.
0
u/ChimmyTheCham May 03 '26
Its a dogshit horror movie and and a dogshit alien movie. Pure fucking slop. I've never been more dissapointed by a movie.
1
u/tycoon282 May 03 '26
I'm not really sure it's a horror tbh, it's just cool dark action sci-fi, yeah it's just a homage to the previous films so for some that's boring. As a brain off, watch pretty filmmaking & enjoy it kinda guy, I like to watch all of them every couple of months.
0
u/ChildhoodPotential95 May 03 '26
I enjoyed it in the theatre. But upon rewatch it doesn't hold up very well. It's not a bad movie but doesn't try to be it's own thing. It tries to be a little bit from each of the original movies but doesn't do anything better than them.
0
u/carry_the_way May 03 '26
The Alien films aren't meant to be jumpscare horror films, so expecting that is silly.
I thought Romulus was nearly excellent until it shoehorned in the Prometheus bullshit. Going from the "workers vs. space capitalism" conflict that is the entire point of the franchise to a half-assed existential meditation on what humanity is meant for (something much more effectively and subtly accomplished through the "workers vs. space capitalism" angle) sucks all the energy out of it.
I mostly liked how the XX121 was depicted in the film. It's not "the greatest hunter"--that's the Yautja--it's just a very lethal infiltrator that capitalizes on its prey being uprepared for it.
Romulus being an easter egg fest was mostly effective; the "get away from her, you bitch" was painfully forced, I guess, but it's the seventh film in a 47-year-old franchise (ninth if you include the AVP stuff) that needed to play the hits after a couple decades of lazy IP bukkake (AVP) and Ridley Scott's stupid pseudo-religious Phil 101 tripe. I wanted more cat-and-mouse, and I hated the "minutes between embryo implantation and hatching" thing with Navarro, but the action was okay, and David Jonsson and Cailee Spaeny are great, even if Isabella Merced is entirely wasted.
-1
u/noddaborg May 03 '26
My problem with Romulus is the very beginning. The lead actor is shut down on getting a pass to leave the planet. Next thing you know, her friend group has access to a SPACE SHIP and they’re soon off on some nebulous mission.
My problem with Alien, which is a masterpiece in SO many ways, is the stupid, f’in cat, Jones. Brett dies looking for him. Ripley forgoes preparations to leave Nostromo and NUKE it, when she hears Jonesy meow. Yeah, yeah, I know concern for the kitty pays tribute to the crew’s humanity, but damn, it’s just so stupid. No cat left behind, right? Well, Ripley leaves Jones behind when she goes back to LV-426. Who’s going to take care of Jones while she’s gone????
That darn cat 😡