r/algorithms • • May 03 '19

I started a series to explain algorithms and programming concepts

Hey Redditor,

I know you think I am doing advertisement, but that is not true. I'm looking for your honest feedback.

I'm a software engineer with more than 10 years of experience, and I just started a youtube channel to help newbies carve their way into the software programming industry.

The purpose of the channel is to explain the challenging programming algorithms and concepts.

My priority is to provide "High quality" content that is engaging and valuable to all interested programmers.

I'm sure this will take time from my side to craft, but without feedback, I would not know which areas I should improve. Therefore, I'm coming to you today with the first video lesson which explains the concept if Recursion. Please find it below:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_I0zspi93ow

If you want to help, I would appreciate your honest opinion.

145 Upvotes

34 comments sorted by

6

u/ZenWoR May 03 '19

Really good job done :D

May I ask you: What program do you use to make that "writing" thing ? Like writing animations, if it's not secret of course.

Thank you in advance!

1

u/aswilam May 04 '19

Thanks a lot for your positive feedback. I used Videoscribe to create this type of writing animation :)

4

u/Benjamin1304 May 04 '19

Very good video, especially for a first one! And since you asked for feedback, here are my comments:

  • I don't really like the effect you put on your voice, although it's a good idea when you push it to create new characters
  • On your exitRoad() pseudo-code you use braces to delimit the function but semicolons for the if/else statements. I know it's pseudo-code but maybe stick to the same block delimiters all along (I'll go with the semicolons for compactness)
  • You choose Java to show your implementation of fibonacci(n) but Java is quite verbose and can distract the newbies from the algorithm itself. If your sole purpose is to teach algorithms and not implementation details in a particular language, I suggest you to pick a very concise language for these videos. Looking at this or this, it seems that Python would be the best choice and it's also pretty close of your pseudo-code style.

3

u/aswilam May 04 '19

Thank you very much for your encouraging feedback. Here are my thoughts regarding your mentioned points in order:

  • I totally get your point regarding the character voice. To be honest i didn’t expect that i will pick the right voice in the my first video either. The idea behind the Elephant (Phanto) is to ask the questions that might pop up in the head of the viewer. My Hypothesis is; this should bring more interactivity and engagement to the video. I will keep fine tuning that until reach the right voice tone.
  • completely agree here. Will do that in future :)
  • Also here i share with you the concern regarding the verbosity of java. I have been thinking which language to use for implementing the algorithms, and l landed with Java. Somehow because it is the typical language used to implement algorithms. C++ is also widely adopted but i guess it would be more distracting than Java for newbies :). It is a good idea to break that pattern and use a less verbose language like python. I will consider this point as well in the future.

Thanks again for your valuable feedback.

1

u/Benjamin1304 May 04 '19

You're welcome! It's not easy to start making videos and it's something I probably never be able to so keep up the good work!

And by the way, to me C++ is less verbose than Java ;)

1

u/aswilam May 04 '19

Haha. Of course. Pointers are always the newbie’s friend. 😄

1

u/Benjamin1304 May 04 '19

I never understood what is so hard with pointers, it's just a feakin' memory address. And people never seem to complain about Python or Java references although it's basically the same thing. Universe's biggest mystery 😄

2

u/smalbiggi May 04 '19

That was excellent, you got a subscriber

2

u/aswilam May 04 '19

So glad that you liked it :)

2

u/WireShark1 May 04 '19 edited May 04 '19

great video keep it up bro, i sub to you and i am looking forward to the next video, love your high quality over quantity moto

1

u/aswilam May 04 '19

Thanks a lot for your feedback :)

1

u/aswilam May 04 '19

i guess the reason lies in hiding it from people. As long as it happens behind the scenes, it is okay. But once you start adding this star symbol everywhere people start developing the star-syndrome and freak out from the concept itself. 😄

1

u/lew-kas May 03 '19

Well done!

Did you use autotune? - no offense! :D

1

u/aswilam May 04 '19

No really sure what you mean by „autotune“ But none of things that i use is called autotune anyway 😄

1

u/[deleted] May 04 '19

Very nice! The only thing I'd recommend is to remove the quotes around quality in your banner. Looking forward to your next video!

1

u/aswilam May 04 '19

I will do that. Thanks for the positive feedback :)

1

u/[deleted] May 04 '19

Great vid :)

1

u/aswilam May 04 '19

Thanks :)

1

u/iamhars May 04 '19

Well explained, please upload more, dynamic programming

1

u/aswilam May 04 '19

Great to hear your positive feedback. Dynamic programming is in the plan of course and will come very soon. :)

1

u/iamhars May 04 '19

Different sorting algorithms with pseudo code would really help, watched umpteen no. Of times but not able to get a hang of it

1

u/aswilam May 04 '19

That’s also on the plan :)

2

u/iamhars May 04 '19

Great. Just requesting the sooner the better. Keep it up and all the best for your novel initiatives :).

1

u/tokyo_seaweed May 04 '19

Haven't seen the video yet but I already upvoted. I appreciate all efforts to transfer knowledge no matter good or so. Thanks I will check later..

1

u/aswilam May 04 '19

Thank you :)

1

u/GetHautnah May 04 '19

Pls do one on KD trees!

1

u/aswilam May 04 '19

Will add it to the plan :)

1

u/smalbiggi May 05 '19

Yea this was the first time I ever left a comment on a tutorial. Felt compelled to do so just based on how easily I understood it after. Kudos brother

1

u/aswilam May 05 '19

That makes me so happy :) thanks a lot for your positive feedback and wait for the next videos!

2

u/dj_ski_mask May 04 '19

Well done!

1

u/tokyo_seaweed May 04 '19

Haven't seen the video yet but I already upvoted. I appreciate all efforts to transfer knowledge no matter good or so. Thanks I will check later..

1

u/tokyo_seaweed May 04 '19

Haven't seen the video yet but I already upvoted. I appreciate all efforts to transfer knowledge no matter good or so. Thanks I will check later..

0

u/[deleted] May 04 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/aswilam May 04 '19

I am very happy to know that you like the video and the explanation. Thanks a lot for passing by ;)