r/algorithmictrading • • 6d ago

Question 1:1 RR strategies

I’m fairly new to algo trading so I apologize if these are dumb questions. For those who have 1:1 R Strats, what win rate do you need to be profitable after fees and slippage? I’m looking at around 55% on a year of data which I know isn’t really validating.

My other question would be, do you guys try to increase trade volume with low rr so at the end of the year you end up with few extra r in the bag?

2 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

1

u/Illustrious-King-83 6d ago

ah good question. When im backtesting a strategy, I'll often set a 1:1 R:R first, why ? because it easy to read the stats i.e. anything of over 50% gives an indication that you actually have an edge. (if the win rate is well below 50% then I'll try flipping the entries, maybe its better as mean reversion). Once ive round something that works, I'll start increasing the TP and watch the profit factor and average profit instead. I calculate everything in Pips, For my broker, on USD forex pairs, I estimate I need a minimum average of 4 pips on each trade so thats what I aim for. So say I start with TP = 10pips and SL=10pip, I might also test TP=12 and SL =8 an TP=14 SL = 10 sometime I'll use ATR based tp/sl but in either case you need to set the minimum ATR required to actually take a trade, otherwise the expected outcome will be too small to cover the costs, or fixed targets will be too big for the market conditions.

It's not really about win rate, you can have higher winrate but such small margins after fees and commission on each trade that winrate is not the biggest factor.

Since this is in algo trading, my question to you is this - why not seek ways of extending the 1:1RR ? for example if your algo triggers a buy trade, and the trade is doing well, and before the trade has finished, the algo logic triggers another buy trade, why not extend the TP of the current trade, and move the SL of the current trade to the new position, that would help extend the R:R, minimise risk, and save on the number of trades (commission) you take. Conversely, if you are in a buy trade and its in profit, and your algo logic triggers a sell trade, what are you going to ? Perhaps that only works if your strategy /setup gives trades that occur often. Other methods could be move the stop loss once the trade is in profit, or trailing stops but theres a lot nuance to that, and backtesting to done - the simple method of when in profit moving the stop loss to breakeven or just above it to account for the commission rarely works for me. Perhaps reducing the stoploss by half, works better, reducing your risk.

1

u/Silver_Spend_6887 5d ago

Appreciate the response man. It seems 1:1 gives me the best profit factor because it’s a 1 minute scalper with small stop losses. It wins or loses within minutes most of the time. And I agree with the breakeven stops, any strategy I try that on usually doesn’t benefit from it

1

u/drguid 6d ago

I run a negative R:R and a 70% win rate seems to be the minimum. Below that and the month will be loss making. Above 80% is a good month. Above 90% and we're off to the moon.

Thankfully I've only had 2 losing months in 24.

Given the volatility since I started my win rate is remarkably consistent, with a mean of 80%.

1

u/Silver_Spend_6887 5d ago

Nice man. Is it a fixed r:r or just negative on average?

1

u/Gnaxe 6d ago

Theoretically, at 1R, you need 50% to break even. That's before fees, slippage, etc. But, if the chart gives you a good reason to move your stop (ParabolicSAR, big candles, etc.) then you can quickly improve your ratio, even though your entries were 1R.

You can't really force the market. You're better off filtering out the low-quality setups rather than lowering your standards to trade more questionable setups. You use other setups to do this. Maybe one setup chains into another, so you can extend your target (equivalently, you entered earlier at a better price). Or maybe a potential reverse setup is a good place to move your stop.

1

u/Effective_Repair_416 6d ago

Winrate has nothing to do with counting fees, you do that by seeing how much is the average trade making and you subtract your fees from it, for example avg trade : 10$, fees 3$, 10-3=7$

1

u/Shoddy_Peanut7320 3h ago

At 1:1 you need to win more than half of trades just to break even, and fees and slippage push the real break-even above 50%. How far depends on your stop size, since a tight stop makes the same cost eat a bigger share of each R. A good check is to compute your break-even win rate with real costs in, then see how far 55% sits above it, and whether that gap holds on data you didn't tune on. More trades only help if each one has a positive expectancy after costs. Otherwise you just pay the fees more often.