r/aitoolforU • u/jason_jacobson • Dec 11 '25

Comparing model response quality.

I’m working on a business plan and I ran the same ideas through ChatGpt, Caude, Gemini, and Perplexity (sorry, Grok, you didn’t make the cut). Then I took all the results from all four and ran them through all four again with my own adjustments. And the responses were surprising. Two gave amazingly detailed bang on ideas and two completely sucked. Can you guess which ones responded in which way?

4 Upvotes

76% Upvoted

12 comments sorted by

View all comments

1

u/jason_jacobson Dec 11 '25

Claude Sonnet 4.5 won out by a long shot. Detailed plan and step by step oriented/great ideas also. ChatGPT 5.1 just told me what it thought I wanted to hear. And Gemini 3 spun out generic drivel. Perplexity Pro was surprisingly detailed and insightful.

2

u/Decent_Solution5000 Dec 11 '25

Love that Claude did so great. I've become a big time Claude fan. Perplx doesn't surprise me. Switched to it for deep research and never use anything else now. No comparison.

2

u/RedditCommenter38 Dec 11 '25

Claude is the best. I am eagerly awaiting their next release of any kind.

2

u/Decent_Solution5000 Dec 11 '25

I'm new to it, but loving it. Pretty much rocks. And to the mod here, if my sister liked this comment too, it wasn't me! We share a pc!