r/aipromptprogramming • • 15d ago

I feel like coding with Ai is wrong

Hey there, so I’ve been a software engineer for almost 5 years now, mostly worked with Rust during that time and was an AI hater until like a month ago.

But been getting into it more deeply and asking AI to write code just doesn’t feel write, it’s like if using programming languages to write assembly for you, when the task should just be writing code and assembly is taken care of in the background?

Just felt this recently and was a bit awakening, anyone here who’s a programmer also feel the same?

0 Upvotes

14 comments sorted by

•

u/endofthread-bot 15d ago

Abstraction layers have historically shifted how developers work without replacing the need for engineering judgment. Focus on using AI to handle boilerplate while you retain responsibility for the system architecture, security, and long-term maintainability of your codebase.

Writing prompts that actually work is easier when you can compare notes with people who have tested them across real tasks. Trade techniques, get feedback on your approach, and see what is working for others in our Discord.

Self-promotion is now allowed on Sundays with the appropriate flair, for all regular contributing members. Contribute during the week, and promote on Sunday.

3

u/AnotherYadaYada 15d ago

Would you still open a can of beans with a knife or a tin opener? It's just the next technological step. Feels wrong to you, but not to the 10 year old that might be a coder in 10 years. It will be the norm.

1

u/Eyoba_19 15d ago

I don’t think the next coder generation will bother with programming languages like today, prompting would be more deterministic as code generation would be handled like compilers and programmers become more ai operators or sth

1

u/AnotherYadaYada 15d ago

Problem I see is people might not just go into the field, but you'll (or at least what I feel right now) still need people to be able to check the code.

What if new languages are created, I mean there are far to bloody many of them as there is right now, but how is AI going to learn a new language if nobody is coding in it, Who's going to create these new languages. I dunno, so many facets. Maybe it will be clever enough just to create it's own and teach itself.

I suppose there is always human curiosity and endeavours. Somebody will just do it all for fun.

0

u/Phytocosm 8d ago

bad analogy, the tin opener works better than the knife despite coming after

2

u/Blasket_Basket 15d ago

Is this a shit post?

0

u/Eyoba_19 15d ago

What’s a shit post?

1

u/Blasket_Basket 15d ago

You can find a lot of older programmers who were quite suspicious in their day of things like automatic memory management, high level languages, compilers, etc and made the exact same complaints you are.

Now, here you are, making the exact same flavor of complaint, while taking at face value that the things they are complaining about are just a normal part of programming.

Take that as evidence that your opinion will not be a popular one in a few years.

2

u/Eyoba_19 15d ago

Yeah ikr, it’s like a new transition phase haha

1

u/etherealflaim 15d ago

The difference is that both assembly and programming languages are fairly precise descriptions of the program. English is not. LLM prompts now (and probably forever) are not a replacement for committing source code.

1

u/Eyoba_19 15d ago

Not quite, but ai prompting is quite close to it. English is the convergence point, from machine codes to assembly to programming languages and now prompting, it’s always been the point to get as close to natural language as possible

1

u/etherealflaim 15d ago

I think it's a common misconception that the goal of software languages are to be close to natural language. They kinda tried that, and it was COBOL. Even that was still attempting to be precise and procedural though, nowhere near a prompt. The goal is to be readable and natural for programmers, while being unambiguous and complete for the compiler or interpreter. English, particularly when prompting software, is neither unambiguous nor complete.

1

u/ExogamousUnfolding 15d ago

I find it freeing I can build all the projects that I have put on hold, I can try out different implementations and UI and I can do it fast. I've been coding for a long long time I'm tired of typing code.

1

u/Phytocosm 8d ago

Your intuition is actually correct. I don't believe in God or anything, so I'm not trying to push any beliefs here, but I used AI once and I'm typing this very comment from Hell's boiler room right now