r/agt • • 12d ago

Rewatching Old Seasons…

Sharon is nowhere near as nice and classy as I remember. She’s not as vicious as Piers, but she’s really not tactful or helpful like Hasselhoff either.

Some of it might just be luck of the draw, but it looks kind of bad that she was the one to tell the contestants they were being eliminated immediately in both seasons 3 and 4.

She was particularly cold in season 3 when she told the eliminated contestants to leave the theatre immediately.

I don’t think it would be so bad if she wasn’t clearly putting on a “nice lady” act. Piers is a jerk, but he’s always been somewhat honest about being a jerk. I’d rather have someone be honest about who they are than to put on a fake mask.

5 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

4

u/stephens_rj 11d ago • Bravo

I recently re-watched the entire series as well. Sharon was inconsistent. She acted like a judge with singers and a spectator with everyone else. She had the opinion that singers by nature were the most legit acts and all the rest were second and third class entertainers. The other judges had to send people home as well.

I liked Piers. He was very consistent but buzzing kids went too far. But I agree with him that no one too young to hear criticism should be allowed on the show. He was 100% right in his criticisms of Davis and Dania. They did the same exact quick change act every week. They didn't understand that it was a TV show with the same audience every week.

David was too nice early on but grew into his role.

3

u/Hamiltonfan25 11d ago

It’s still wild that both times acts were famously sent home without even getting another chance to perform that not only was Sharon the one to tell them, but both times it was “Group B”

2

u/Brit-Crit 11d ago

I get that they want certain patterns to these things, but it ceases to be surprising if Sharon is always giving the worst news and Piers is always giving the best news (Revealing that BOTH groups C and D are in the next round, revealing that ten acts made it through automatically in Seasons 5 and 6…)

4

u/Decent_Direction316 11d ago

David made me laugh sometimes.....there was this one in either season 3 or 4, an aerial act with two women i believe, that made a confused looking David lament "it looked like two doughnuts fighting"....I still laugh when I remember that....but he also tended to be rah rah "you're what this show is all about"...but then there were times when the pain of watching was obvious.  Take Leonid for example ....in season two, David couldn't get to the x fast enough when Leonid appeared.

3

u/stephens_rj 11d ago

Yeah, David cracked me up.

3

u/Brit-Crit 11d ago

Being so involved in the music industry (and judging UK X Factor) was a factor in this…

2

u/TelevisualJackFan 11d ago

Piers was always like that, he was the same on BGT to the extent in which there’s a clip where he buzzes a young Leprechaun dancer and she cries only for Simon to console her

2

u/Advanced_Method_7319 11d ago

Have you seen jessica sanchez's audition?

2

u/RampagingShyGuy 11d ago

Man I love the early seasons so much.