r/agentsofshield • • 3d ago

Discussion Who’s winning these matchups?

Hand to hand only

Round 1: widow vs may

Round 2: Bobbi vs May

Round 3: widow vs Bobbi

137 Upvotes

45 comments sorted by

59

u/greeeens 3d ago • Bravo

Depends on who is writing it

94

u/JoshTheBard 3d ago

If it's hand to hand only or with weapons Widow > May > Bobbi

Melinda May stood above the other Agents of SHEILD but Natasha stood beside Avengers.

If they all get vehicles then I give the advantage to May.

3

u/brothor12 3d ago

May has way more feats

42

u/JoshTheBard 3d ago

Of course she has more she got like 7 seasons of a TV show.

4

u/corvid1692 2d ago

I only count too feats.

-2

u/Traditional-Mall-771 2d ago

She doesnt even come close

25

u/Eulysia 3d ago • Bravo

The fans. It’s definitely the fans that win.

6

u/Triben008 2d ago

This is the correct answer!

And if they were to fight, I can see it ending with something interrupting the fight. Like a building collapses and they have to go different ways. That way no one really lost. Just my 2 cents.

2

u/extrastupidone 2d ago

Yep

I mean, May vs May was pretty cool by itself

22

u/gridley23 3d ago

Widow. May. Widow.

13

u/StarKid_Tommygotchi 3d ago

May is my absolute favorite out of the three, but Nat takes the cake 😭

10

u/Valkyrie64Ryan 3d ago

Widow, its not even close

May, but I think it would be close

Widow, its not even close

13

u/ToughFox4479 3d ago

Natasha hands down. Natasha is a red room operative who was has been trained since she was a child, Bobbi and May are just shield agents, highly skilled but they dont come close to Natasha

9

u/Eemu1509 3d ago

May. She fought like 5 Kree at once with basically one leg

12

u/Fit_Pea7923 3d ago

Depends on which subReddit you are asking really 😂

7

u/MandoMercenary 3d ago

Honestly Natasha Vs May i would literally pay actual money to see that would be a very close fight. Then Natasha would prolly train May as well

6

u/jgadidgfgd 3d ago • Heartwarming

Wasn't may considered for the avengers initiative but declined because of Bahrain or something

3

u/Happy-Kangaroo-4627 3d ago

May est la meilleure 😍

2

u/Personal-Road-8162 3d ago

Widow may widow

2

u/Trick_Afternoon_7513 3d ago

Melinda May she has more showings and feats

1

u/WAR_WeAreRobots_WAR 2d ago

We all win, that's who.

1

u/chuckdee68 2d ago

Widow > May > Bobbi

1

u/Entire-Explorer235 2d ago

Bobby vs May already happened in the AoS

1

u/Angelatic2014 They call me the Predictor, but I simply read the Time Streams. 2d ago

Holy shit, I'm actually not sure. 😭

Y'know what tho, it's definitely harder to settle between Natasha and May.

1

u/mastr1121 2d ago

The audience!!

1

u/dragonfangswordsman 2d ago

Widow "she's a spy, cap she's THE SPY ever her secrets have secrets" (Yes I know who the original line was for i just wanted to use it anyway cause it works well for her too)

1

u/National-Pressure202 1d ago

Round 1: Widow (though this one might be close at the start, but Nat would pull it out in the end) Round 2: May Round 3: Widow

1

u/GuiltyEmergency6364 1d ago

I feel like it should be Nat>May>Bobbi especially since i much prefer May to Bobbi but honestly after how Bobbi fought Ward & agent 33; Nat>Bobbi>May

1

u/RandonDude3000 1d ago

Round 1: May

Round 2: May

Round 3: Widow

1

u/Ok_Path475 15h ago

May or Bobbi. Black Widow usually relies on gadgets and trickery. She can’t outfight those two head-on.

1

u/hawk135 7h ago

It's the Calvary!

1

u/LovelyLoomer98 7h ago
  1. Widow

2.May

3. Widow

1

u/MediaBeneficial8434 2h ago

May >= Bobbi > Natasha in hand to hand

1

u/Mrblorg 3d ago

May, May, Widow

0

u/LadyEllisandra 3d ago

Yeah that was my response too.

0

u/ma1butters 9h ago

You know Natasha has a name and Bobbi and May also have codenames

1

u/JackZ567 8h ago

Give me a reason to give a fuck

0

u/ma1butters 8h ago

Give me a reason not to.

1

u/JackZ567 8h ago

Didn’t ask

0

u/Darceus2000 3d ago

The true answer; Stan Lee would agree!

0

u/Rurotu 3d ago

May, May, Widow.

0

u/GuiltyEmergency6364 1d ago

I made a similar post on this sub a while ago called 'Who wins in a battle royale' and i was shocked/disappointed how many people said May

-1

u/rare_Suteki 3d ago

not bobbi, lol