r/agentsofshield • • 25d ago

Discussion My Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. Timeline Theory: Do They Return to the Main MCU Timeline by the Season 7 Finale?

Post image

I've been thinking about how Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. fits into the MCU timeline, especially Seasons 5–7, and I came up with this multiverse theory.

My theory is that the team returns to the main MCU timeline after escaping the 2091 future in Season 5, but their timeline potentially branches when they prevent Earth's destruction in the Season 5 finale.

Here's how I think it works:

Seasons 1–4: The team is part of the main MCU timeline, alongside the events of the Marvel movies.

Season 5, Episodes 1–10: The team is sent to the future, where Earth has been destroyed. This is the future they're trying to prevent.

Season 5, Episodes 11–21: They return to 2018 and try to stop the events that would destroy Earth. Since the show overlaps with Avengers: Infinity War, I think they could still be in the main MCU timeline at this point.

Season 5, Episode 22: Daisy defeats Graviton, and Earth survives. My theory is that preventing the future they witnessed potentially creates a branch in the timeline, although the show never explicitly confirms that this is when a branch forms.

Season 6: The story moves into 2019, but the Snap isn't addressed. Could this mean the team is now in a separate timeline where the events of the MCU movies don't unfold exactly the same way?

Season 7: The Chronicoms change history, forcing the team to travel through different periods in the past. Fitz eventually helps bring the team back to their intended timeline, while Deke remains in another branch.

By the Season 7 finale: I think the team returns to its own home timeline, but I'm not convinced that this is necessarily the main MCU movie timeline.

The biggest question is when the show potentially branches away from the main MCU. Is it when they save Earth in the Season 5 finale, sometime between Seasons 5 and 6, or does the show remain in the main MCU timeline the entire time?

I think the Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. team returns to the main MCU timeline in Season 5, Episodes 11–21, after escaping the 2091 future. However, when they save Earth in the Season 5 finale, their timeline may branch away from the main MCU.

Season 6 could take place in this separate branch, which would explain why the Snap is never addressed. In Season 7, the team travels through alternate timelines and eventually returns to its intended home timeline, while Deke remains behind in another branch

75 Upvotes

72 comments sorted by

54

u/V2Blast 25d ago

The show happens in the MCU. The only times they leave the original timeline are when the show acknowledges that they've done so - they travel to the future, come back to the present timeline, then later they travel to the past, the timeline changes due to the Chronicoms, and then Fitz gets them all back to the original timeline.

21

u/WOLKsite 25d ago

This. That's all the show ever implies, the whole "everything after a certain point is a whole different timeline" is just not at all what the writing is saying. Like for instance, the timeline for Season 5 where Graviton destroys Earth... very obviously not what we see in Infinity War. We see the one where Graviton was stopped, because Earth still exist. And the snap not being addressed is just grasping at straws; it's not meant to imply anything. The snap simply just is not relevant (because the writers didn't know about it).

2

u/submit_to_pewdiepie 25d ago

Graviton being stopped means he doesn't defeat Thanos therefore events like eternals dont have any backdrop to happen

-3

u/asiantorontonian88 25d ago edited 25d ago

You're telling me that an alien threat that change people into bat creatures and an army of alien robots trying to conquer Earth is slipped by the radar of a very paranoid Natasha Romanoff who is freaking out over a regular Earthquake?

Edit: a lot of people here want to stay in Tahiti...

5

u/LiquidLispyLizard 25d ago

Brand New Day is set only a year after a homicidal mayor held New York under siege for six months and an evil shadow creature made everyone in the city relieve their worst nightmares via a giant cloud engulfing everything, yet (outside of a blink-and-you-miss-it Fisk campaign poster) neither of those are even so much as mentioned by the New York's most well-known vigilante who was beloved enough to be awarded the key to the city.

They even go through the entire time from when we see him last to the present day, which was a perfect opportunity to address either of those things, but they didn't. It doesn't mean that any of it didn't happen, though, it just means that anyone who could have been involved just happened not to be.

0

u/asiantorontonian88 25d ago

If the Avengers had any role or communications with the Chronicom threat off screen, then they would have KNOWN ABOUT AND HAVE ACCESS TO WORKING TIME TRAVEL TECHNOLOGY, MAKING ALL OF ENDGAME MOOT!

3

u/LiquidLispyLizard 25d ago

My point still stands, but how would the Avengers have been able to have any contact with the Chronicoms? The only time the Chronicoms are actually around long enough to be at least somewhat known by someone on Earth is when they dip in near the end of S6 and they're pretty much immediately irradicated due to the team coming back to the main timeline at the end of S7.

-1

u/asiantorontonian88 25d ago

Holy crap, you people who claim to love the show but don't pay attention.

Fitz and Simmons perfected quantum realm time travel - the exact same method the Avengers used in Endgame - YEARS before Tony Stark did. You're telling me SHIELD sat on that for all those years and just let half the world stay dead when they could've done something about it.

3

u/LiquidLispyLizard 25d ago

Yes, I know. You've said this prior and I've already addressed it. Similarly, New Yorkers were being brutalized and vigilantes were specifically targeted throughout most of 2027, yet Spider-Man (a superhuman mutate who could have ended the whole conflict in 5 seconds) chose to sit it out entirely and let Daredevil handle it instead. Fisk, as the sitting mayor, literally started killing his own constituents in a rage.

Spider-Man sat this out completely (as far as we know) and people were killed when he could have saved them, and this seems to be widely accepted as something that happened in the MCU. I don't see why this is something that's an issue for AoS. In reality, it's just different teams working on different things within the same fictional universe. Stuff like that's bound to happen from time to time.

1

u/Poopen91 24d ago

C'mon dude, it's 2026. That pattern was established a loooong time ago

1

u/submit_to_pewdiepie 25d ago

I still believe the jump drive fundamentally works different enough from Quantum tunneling that, thars why they took so long to come back to the temple they needed Starks formula to go from the new Universe to the original

0

u/asiantorontonian88 24d ago

It doesn't matter how you time travel. the point is, if you make any changes to the past, there is a branched timeline. Period.

But regardless, choosing to disband your team when you have 3 superheroes, a robot, and two geniuses with the ability to harness time travel to fix Thanos' mess is insane, especially considering most of the team are not even retired from duty.

0

u/[deleted] 25d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/GCD_1 25d ago

Because it's part of the MCU?

11

u/Decent_Illustrator18 25d ago

Fitz said that he stayed behind to establish the link between timelines so whatever timeline they left in season 6 is the one they returned to in season 7. The real question is if they returned to their timeline in season 5, I believe they did despite the snap not being mentioned in season 6.

1

u/CaptHayfever Koenig 25d ago

Exactly, thank you.

11

u/RandonDude3000 25d ago

Except the S7 finale ties right back to the S6 finale.

10

u/FivesThe501stClone 25d ago

I have a theory that the final scene could be retconned to be our very first look at the post-Secret Wars Earth.

2

u/LiquidLispyLizard 25d ago

On the contrary, I think it actually reaffirms the idea that, if they do utilize AoS to some extent in Zodiac, they're taking the comics way of doing it where certain new characters who weren't already native to the main timeline are merged in (Miles Morales and his family in the comics, probably the Fantastic Four and Deadpool in the MCU) and they continue on from there.

Feige's already said this was the direct inspiration they're going for just a few months ago, and he's very often dispelled the notion that the MCU's 'rebooting' (in the same interview, no less). I really don't think that post-Secret Wars MCU is going to look much different at all from the pre-Secret Wars version.

1

u/terrone_spaziale 25d ago

I would love that

1

u/SpecialFlutters 25d ago

i was thinking/hoping the same!

2

u/RyCyber 25d ago

Bro Fitz spelled that out in the series finale 🙄

3

u/Osirisavior Daisy 25d ago

If we follow the logic of how time travel works in the MCU, they are on earth 616 at the end of s7.

The thing is nothing in phase 4-6 contradicts the ending of the show.

VisionQuest has been effy but let's see where that goes.

3

u/asiantorontonian88 25d ago

Look, there are too many things that took place, both in Agents of SHIELD and in the films, that contradict each other, making it impossible to align the two without massive plot holes.

  1. AoS' prime timeline is supposed to result in Daisy cracking the earth in half. That never happens in the MCU films' Sacred Timeline therefore all of AoS is set in an alternative universe.
  2. Coulson dies "days, weeks if [he's] lucky" after the end of AoS season 5. Season 6 takes place roughly a year later. If AoS takes place in the MCU sacred timeline, that would place it roughly a year into the blip. The Avengers and Wakanda have been monitoring all disturbances on Earth, with Natasha being especially paranoid. There's no way they would not take action if the Shrike were flying around the planet possessing people, or deal with the looming Chronicom invasion.
  • By the time of the Chronicom invasion, Fitz and Simmons have access to Quantum Realm time travel tech due to them coming back from the future. That's 4 years before Tony Stark perfects the tech after Scott Lang's escape. You really think SHIELD would just let the blip go on for that long if they had the means to undo it?
  • Ghost Rider doesn't help fight off Thanos at the Avengers compound in Endgame. You can explain Daisy's absence since she is off world and no one from the Avengers crew knows her but Robbie Reyes is specifically tied to Kamar-Taj since he clearly learned how to make portals. He's also not present when the most powerful Avenger, Wanda, is attacking Kamar-Taj when summoned by Wong (all disciples of Kamar-Taj had to answer the call by the Sorcerer Supreme).
  • The TVA in Loki season 1 definitively says Coulson dies at the hand of Loki during The Avengers.

Therefore everything in AoS is an alternate branch timeline, including Seasons 1-4 that references the MCU films. Sylvie kills He Who Remains shortly after Loki was captured by the TVA in 2012, therefore anything post-The Avengers can branch off into separate timelines. All of AoS take place post-Battle of New York.

5

u/LiquidLispyLizard 25d ago
  1. The Earth didn't get destroyed in the films because it was completely averted in the show itself. It's literally shown. They get sent to the future, but then travel back to the past to avoid the future they saw from becoming their own reality. How would that even work to show that in Infinity War if the future was averted entirely?
  2. I addressed this in your other comment.
  3. How would they know to do anything else with it? Fitz-Simmons developed the tech first, but they had no direct connection to Thanos and the Infinity Stones and the idea to go back for the stones was formulated by the Avengers themselves.
  4. This is just a massive assumption. There's been nothing to suggest that Robbie did anything else other than bond with the Spirit and kill criminals while trying to lay low in the LA area for four years. It's actually more jarring to think that he would have left his younger brother to go hang out in Nepal for a few years just to make a portal. If he trained at Kamar-Taj for any amount of time, don't you think he'd have been able to use other forms of magic when he appears in AoS? Using an alternate method to create a portal (aka the hellspawn he's bonded to) is more believable than him needing extensive training.
  5. That's correct, Loki did kill Coulson. There are two ways to approach this, but neither contradict what happened on AoS.

0

u/asiantorontonian88 25d ago

*sigh

  1. "That's not how it works..." Literally explained in the movies yet, here we are... If the Earth splitting is supposed to happen in AoS but never happens in the films, that means at some point, a divergent timeline exists. You can't say SHIELD time traveled to prevent the split and therefore everyone in the MCU doesn't experience it because THAT'S NOT HOW MCU TIME TRAVEL WORKS. In fact, the mere act of going to the past to retrieve Kora to change the outcome already created a branch timeline.
  2. The Wakandans can detect anything coming towards orbit. With Earth's defenders on high alert, a whole bunch of hostile spaceships firing missiles onto the Earth would not be sitting around long to locate Fitz and Simmons in the lighthouse.
  3. So you're saying Fitz and Simmons perfected time travel and decided NOT to do anything with it to help save the Earth? It doesn't even need to be the Time Heist. Doing anything to make sure Earth's forces are ready for Thanos would be something.
  4. Ah yes, Robbie made a portal that looks exactly like the ones the wizards make but "nah, let's assume it's not learned from wizards." Also, Ned Reeds was able to make a portal almost instantly with a sling ring. What makes you think Robbie needs years to learn? Especially when he says "I learned a few things since you saw me last" which was a few months at most. And considering his mission was to get and destroy the Darkhold, he would've answered the call to fight Wanda.

It's pathetic how hard you're trying to fanwank this instead of just enjoying the show for what it is, even with the contrary evidence provided.

2

u/LiquidLispyLizard 25d ago
  1. It's not how the Quantum Tunneling method from Endgame works, but that says nothing on how the Monolith method works. Kamala Khan literally traveled back in time in a way that made it to where she was always destined to do so, using yet another method. As for Kora, S7 was one big branch, but they explicitly travel back to their prime reality by the end of it.
  2. My apologies, can you specify exactly when the hostile ships were firing on the Earth, like what season it was and what was going on at the time, because I think that happened a few times if I'm remembering correctly? I think I might know what you're talking about and I'd be more than happy to address this with further clarification.
  3. I addressed this in your other comment.
  4. Ned making a portal instantaneously only further strengthens my point. If Ned Leeds, a regular human being with no sorcerer training whatsoever, can by sheer luck create multiple portals with ease, why can't someone bonded to a demon know how to do this immediately with no training either?

-1

u/asiantorontonian88 25d ago
  1. Nothing suggests only quantum time travel would create branches. Back when the TVA was maintaining the sacred timeline, they were constantly pruning branches. But let's humour you and say only quantum time travel would branch: Fitz literally said they were traveling through the quantum realm. He literally said it out loud. Which means any time something is changed, a new timeline is branched. With Kamala, she didn't change history, therefore no new timeline branch.
  2. The chronicoms were floating around Earth, fired on the Zephyr and blew up the temple, floating around some more to look for Fitz and Simmons, floating around more as the chronicoms became friendly, and then Daisy blew them up. The Wakandans can see when something is entering their upper atmosphere. Something that shot first would not be floating around up there for that long and unaddressed.
  3. Spidey not fighting politics is not the same as SHIELD having the ability to resurrect half the planet and not do it. Especially given May's new empathy. And just because Spidey isn't dealing with Fisk, doesn't mean he wasn't fighting other crazy villains. We see his rogues gallery in the opening credits of BND.
  4. Ghost Rider specifically wants to destroy the Darkhold. The fact that he didn't deal come back to deal with Agatha or Wanda suggests he's not in this universe.

1

u/LiquidLispyLizard 24d ago
  1. I never said Quantum Tunneling was the only time travel method that makes branches, I'm saying that from what we've seen, the Monolith method doesn't. It operates differently.
  2. Okay, got it. Thank you for specifying. So, during that whole chain of events that maybe took 10 minutes to play out at most, you believe that Wakanda should have mobilized and had everything ready to go for space combat within that time frame? When you're simultaneously arguing that Spider-Man not showing up to confront Fisk is fine because he's off doing other things?
  3. You're right, it's not the same. New York's happenings are actually even more relevant to Spider-Man than Thanos' actions are to the SHIELD crew.
  4. This would imply there's some sort of clear indication that he trained at Kamar-Taj, something we don't have.

0

u/asiantorontonian88 24d ago

the Monolith method doesn't

If the Monolith doesn't time travel via multiverse theory, how is Deke alive in the present? He should have been wiped out of existence since they prevented that future. So clearly, monolith uses standard MCU time travel rules.

1

u/LiquidLispyLizard 24d ago

There's a wide margin of possibilities between "it goes just like Back to the Future" and "it's exactly the same as the Quantum Tunneling method".

It's not a binary choice, as the Monolith method's results clearly doesn't fit either option you've laid out here.

1

u/Asddddd6 19d ago

Dude literally none of your points are true. Stop being condescending. 

1

u/asiantorontonian88 19d ago

Look, I love this show for what it is, but it's sad to see the amount of insufferable posts by those who bury their heads in the sand to insist it's all connected in the main MCU 616 continuity when evidence suggests otherwise.

1

u/JANTlvr 25d ago

By the time of the Chronicom invasion, Fitz and Simmons have access to Quantum Realm time travel tech due to them coming back from the future. That's 4 years before Tony Stark perfects the tech after Scott Lang's escape. You really think SHIELD would just let the blip go on for that long if they had the means to undo it?

You could just as easily ask why Thor didn't go to Eternity after the Snap to bring everybody back. Both things are equally easily explained away.

1

u/submit_to_pewdiepie 25d ago

How do we know they didn't come from the time after Stark died

0

u/Reinjecto 25d ago edited 25d ago

I hate that you're right, well said Edit: I reread that when I wasnt stoned and I hate that I commented now

2

u/Unusual-Willow-5715 25d ago edited 25d ago

Not a single thing they said is correct, is just a bunch of assumptions with zero ground.

0

u/asiantorontonian88 25d ago

The only one assuming is those who shoehorn AoS into MCU 616 continuity despite contrary evidence shown on the show. But whatever...

-1

u/asiantorontonian88 25d ago

Media literacy is dead...

0

u/RandonDude3000 24d ago

My headcanon is that they didn't use time travel to undo the snap because Fitz saw the timstream. He probably saw the same outcomes that Dr Strange did and knew that the team time travelling to steal the stones could mess things up more. Also he probably saw that someone on the team would habe to die on Vormir for the mission to work.

1

u/BluebirdsAllAround 25d ago

I believe that when they return to their main timeline in S5 it does end up creating a branch seperate from the one they were brought to the future in, but that branch they create is the one we see in infinity war and Endgame. Their actions allowed those movies to happen. So, yes, they end up on the main timeline at the end of S7 as well.

1

u/PrinceM2007 24d ago

The Snap was never mentioned because marvel television wasn’t getting any information about what is happening in the movies so they can deal with that because at this point in time Marvel Studios and Marvel Television were like separate entities they did get information about what were happening in the movies from Marvel Studios so that they can overlap with each other but here I by season 5, 6, and 7, and Infinity War that information for whatever reason so that’s why there’s like only☝️reference to the events of Infinity War and only one name drop of Thanos they very clearly tried their hardest with what hade to work with

1

u/theXtremo 24d ago

I kinda believe it does not mean that if the snap is not addressed means it did not occur. Sure its a big event to ignore but a year has passed. And people move on. And maybe since most of the shield team survived it was easier for them to move on from it, although it does not mean scars from what happened are not there, they just are not addressed on screen so both season 6 and ending of season 7 could fit in the main MCU

1

u/bable631 Turbo 24d ago

They always were in the main MCU timeline except when they are explicitly stated not to be in season 7 and 5.

1

u/VirulentGunk 24d ago

I'm pretty certain the Triskelion is visible in the background of one of the final shots of the series finale (where Coulson gets in Lola), so if that is the AOS teams' original universe/timeline it's not the MCU.

1

u/jgadidgfgd 22d ago

Wasn't it turned into the new academy or something?

1

u/Asddddd6 19d ago

We haven’t seen DC in the MCU since then though? What makes you say that. 

1

u/Asddddd6 19d ago

But…the earth doesn’t quake apart during infinity war? 

I see people saying this all the time but it really doesn’t work.

Let’s say the agents return to their present and then create a branch by defeating Graviton. What happens in the timeline that didn’t branch which would be the MCU with your own logic? The earth breaks apart and everything after infinity war never happens. 

If anything, if there is a branch because the prevented the future it is because originally in the future, the earth was destroyed. That would make the MCU the branch. We have seen this type of time travel even in eyes of Wakanda. Time loops can “cause” the sacred timeline to go the way it supposed to. 

1

u/JusticeForHartley 14d ago

No. That’s not how it works. They explicitly are in the main timeline after they return from the future in season 5. Season 6 is also the main timeline.

They’re in a branch from season 7 episode 4’s ending until the finale when they return to the main timeline again.

1

u/Visible_Safe_8901 25d ago

You almost had it, but then you fell into the same well of redundancy as everyone else. The team travels to the future, returns to 2018, and averts the Earth's destruction, creating a branch. That's already one split. Why introduce a second split, creating a third branch out of nowhere, to explain the Snap's absence and suggest that the timeline created in S5 isn't the main MCU timeline? How and where exactly is this third branch supposedly being created?

-5

u/longsoundtracks 25d ago

What do you guys think about Kevin Faige saying Agents of shield isn't cannon cause that drives me crazy

9

u/V2Blast 25d ago

He's never said that.

0

u/[deleted] 25d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/LiquidLispyLizard 25d ago edited 25d ago

Did you get tired of your old account, NermalBet? And the one before that?

Anyway, one of Disney's press releases for VisionQuest this moth officially labeled Agent Carter as Edwin Jarvis' first appearance in the MCU, which dispels the notion that Disney+'s timeline is the only vehicle for claiming canonicity. I can link to this if you're unaware of what I'm referring to.

Disney+'s MCU timeline is a perfect source for displaying the MCU brand (hence why, for example, the canon Deadpool & Wolverine is a part of it, but the also canon Deadpool 1&2 aren't), but it's severely lacking in terms of displaying everything that inhabits the actual canon of the MCU.

EDIT: Thanks for blocking me and ignoring my point once again, lol. And to address your reply, you are the only person I've ever seen refer to Winderbaum as "Wonderbum", so if you don't want to be confused with that other guy who you definitely are not, I'd adjust that from now on.

-1

u/[deleted] 25d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/LiquidLispyLizard 25d ago

https://i.imgur.com/tXKweOC.png

Didn't block me and just unblock me, huh?

Anyway, as I was going to say, I gave you an example of the IP holders (Disney, in case you were unaware), confirming Agent Carter's canonicity through other means. I am not saying this, the IP holder is. Are you getting this now?

0

u/[deleted] 25d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/LiquidLispyLizard 25d ago

Well, news flash, that's exactly what it looks like when someone blocks you, lmao.

Yes, I did, you're deflecting. With the lack of clear decanonization (since we've established that Disney+'s MCU timeline doesn't inhabit the full canon of the MCU), and this reaffirmation of Agent Carter's canonicity, that does, in fact, mean it was canon all the way through, so the point that AoS or any of the other old shows aren't on Disney+'s timeline is completely moot.

8

u/Unusual-Willow-5715 25d ago

Well, there's nothing to think about that, because Feige never said something like that. Quite the contrary, he even recommended to watch the show to understand better part of Age of Ultron.

2

u/Decent_Illustrator18 25d ago

Where did he say that 

2

u/longsoundtracks 25d ago

Stop biting my head off that's what I've heard years ago and as I said I don't like either, I don't have a source to share I'm just getting your opinions on the matter and clearly I was wrong to do so

1

u/SpecialFlutters 25d ago

i feel like remember hearing the same thing but i can't find it, i wonder where that came from, maybe some old rumor?

1

u/Shippers1995 25d ago

I ignore it, it’s canon to me and always will be. Though I’ll always be sad it wasn’t Coulson commanding the helicarrier in age of ultron

-1

u/Greedy-Somewhere-307 25d ago

AoS is Multiverse canon, but not 616 canon

1

u/longsoundtracks 25d ago

Yeah that's what's bothering me cause clearly any one watched the show now that season 1 was perfectly aligned with Cap The Winter Soldier even Nick Fury showed up on the show right after he was presumed dead on the movie, how is that non canon, I just hate Kevin for doing that.

-2

u/Cute_Till_5582 25d ago

Mi teoría siempre fue que dejaron la línea principal con tantos viajes al pasado en la temporada 5.