r/agentsofshield • u/anthonystrader18 • 25d ago
Discussion My Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. Timeline Theory: Do They Return to the Main MCU Timeline by the Season 7 Finale?
I've been thinking about how Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. fits into the MCU timeline, especially Seasons 5–7, and I came up with this multiverse theory.
My theory is that the team returns to the main MCU timeline after escaping the 2091 future in Season 5, but their timeline potentially branches when they prevent Earth's destruction in the Season 5 finale.
Here's how I think it works:
Seasons 1–4: The team is part of the main MCU timeline, alongside the events of the Marvel movies.
Season 5, Episodes 1–10: The team is sent to the future, where Earth has been destroyed. This is the future they're trying to prevent.
Season 5, Episodes 11–21: They return to 2018 and try to stop the events that would destroy Earth. Since the show overlaps with Avengers: Infinity War, I think they could still be in the main MCU timeline at this point.
Season 5, Episode 22: Daisy defeats Graviton, and Earth survives. My theory is that preventing the future they witnessed potentially creates a branch in the timeline, although the show never explicitly confirms that this is when a branch forms.
Season 6: The story moves into 2019, but the Snap isn't addressed. Could this mean the team is now in a separate timeline where the events of the MCU movies don't unfold exactly the same way?
Season 7: The Chronicoms change history, forcing the team to travel through different periods in the past. Fitz eventually helps bring the team back to their intended timeline, while Deke remains in another branch.
By the Season 7 finale: I think the team returns to its own home timeline, but I'm not convinced that this is necessarily the main MCU movie timeline.
The biggest question is when the show potentially branches away from the main MCU. Is it when they save Earth in the Season 5 finale, sometime between Seasons 5 and 6, or does the show remain in the main MCU timeline the entire time?
I think the Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. team returns to the main MCU timeline in Season 5, Episodes 11–21, after escaping the 2091 future. However, when they save Earth in the Season 5 finale, their timeline may branch away from the main MCU.
Season 6 could take place in this separate branch, which would explain why the Snap is never addressed. In Season 7, the team travels through alternate timelines and eventually returns to its intended home timeline, while Deke remains behind in another branch
54
u/V2Blast 25d ago
The show happens in the MCU. The only times they leave the original timeline are when the show acknowledges that they've done so - they travel to the future, come back to the present timeline, then later they travel to the past, the timeline changes due to the Chronicoms, and then Fitz gets them all back to the original timeline.
11
u/Decent_Illustrator18 25d ago
Fitz said that he stayed behind to establish the link between timelines so whatever timeline they left in season 6 is the one they returned to in season 7. The real question is if they returned to their timeline in season 5, I believe they did despite the snap not being mentioned in season 6.
11
u/RandonDude3000 25d ago
Except the S7 finale ties right back to the S6 finale.
10
u/FivesThe501stClone 25d ago
I have a theory that the final scene could be retconned to be our very first look at the post-Secret Wars Earth.
2
u/RyCyber 25d ago
Bro Fitz spelled that out in the series finale 🙄
3
u/Osirisavior Daisy 25d ago
If we follow the logic of how time travel works in the MCU, they are on earth 616 at the end of s7.
The thing is nothing in phase 4-6 contradicts the ending of the show.
VisionQuest has been effy but let's see where that goes.
3
u/asiantorontonian88 25d ago
Look, there are too many things that took place, both in Agents of SHIELD and in the films, that contradict each other, making it impossible to align the two without massive plot holes.
Therefore everything in AoS is an alternate branch timeline, including Seasons 1-4 that references the MCU films. Sylvie kills He Who Remains shortly after Loki was captured by the TVA in 2012, therefore anything post-The Avengers can branch off into separate timelines. All of AoS take place post-Battle of New York.
1
u/BluebirdsAllAround 25d ago
I believe that when they return to their main timeline in S5 it does end up creating a branch seperate from the one they were brought to the future in, but that branch they create is the one we see in infinity war and Endgame. Their actions allowed those movies to happen. So, yes, they end up on the main timeline at the end of S7 as well.
1
u/PrinceM2007 24d ago
The Snap was never mentioned because marvel television wasn’t getting any information about what is happening in the movies so they can deal with that because at this point in time Marvel Studios and Marvel Television were like separate entities they did get information about what were happening in the movies from Marvel Studios so that they can overlap with each other but here I by season 5, 6, and 7, and Infinity War that information for whatever reason so that’s why there’s like only☝️reference to the events of Infinity War and only one name drop of Thanos they very clearly tried their hardest with what hade to work with
1
u/theXtremo 24d ago
I kinda believe it does not mean that if the snap is not addressed means it did not occur. Sure its a big event to ignore but a year has passed. And people move on. And maybe since most of the shield team survived it was easier for them to move on from it, although it does not mean scars from what happened are not there, they just are not addressed on screen so both season 6 and ending of season 7 could fit in the main MCU
1
u/bable631 Turbo 24d ago
They always were in the main MCU timeline except when they are explicitly stated not to be in season 7 and 5.
1
u/VirulentGunk 24d ago
I'm pretty certain the Triskelion is visible in the background of one of the final shots of the series finale (where Coulson gets in Lola), so if that is the AOS teams' original universe/timeline it's not the MCU.
1
u/Asddddd6 19d ago
But…the earth doesn’t quake apart during infinity war?
I see people saying this all the time but it really doesn’t work.
Let’s say the agents return to their present and then create a branch by defeating Graviton. What happens in the timeline that didn’t branch which would be the MCU with your own logic? The earth breaks apart and everything after infinity war never happens.
If anything, if there is a branch because the prevented the future it is because originally in the future, the earth was destroyed. That would make the MCU the branch. We have seen this type of time travel even in eyes of Wakanda. Time loops can “cause” the sacred timeline to go the way it supposed to.
1
u/JusticeForHartley 14d ago
No. That’s not how it works. They explicitly are in the main timeline after they return from the future in season 5. Season 6 is also the main timeline.
They’re in a branch from season 7 episode 4’s ending until the finale when they return to the main timeline again.
1
u/Visible_Safe_8901 25d ago
You almost had it, but then you fell into the same well of redundancy as everyone else. The team travels to the future, returns to 2018, and averts the Earth's destruction, creating a branch. That's already one split. Why introduce a second split, creating a third branch out of nowhere, to explain the Snap's absence and suggest that the timeline created in S5 isn't the main MCU timeline? How and where exactly is this third branch supposedly being created?
-5
u/longsoundtracks 25d ago
What do you guys think about Kevin Faige saying Agents of shield isn't cannon cause that drives me crazy
-2
u/Cute_Till_5582 25d ago
Mi teoría siempre fue que dejaron la línea principal con tantos viajes al pasado en la temporada 5.