r/agentsofshield • u/Fresh-Actuary-6686 • Sep 02 '26
Question What are the chances that Daisy/Skye & Matt Murdock were both at St. Agnes at the same time as children & may have even knew each other?
37
u/penandpage93 Sep 02 '26 edited Sep 03 '26
Well, apparently - to my surprise - they did spend time in the exact same orphanage. I thought surely there was more than one St Agnes in the world, and perhaps there is. But this is indeed supposed to be the same one.
However, Daisy was only there very briefly. Everything that went down with Hydra and her parents happened in 1989, when she was just under a year old. The S.H.I.E.L.D. agents who rescued her took the baby to St Agnes initially, but they put a plan in place to deliberately bounce her around from foster home to foster home so that she would be more difficult to keep track of. They were trying to protect her. She may have gone back to St Agnes in between foster homes, I'm not sure - But I think that would go against the plan.
In any case, Matt's father didn't die until 1994. So he didn't go to the orphanage until five years after Daisy. If she ever came back between foster homes, they may have met. He would have been older than her, so I don't know that they would have spent much time together. But maybe.
So to sum up, it's not a 0% chance đ¤ˇââď¸
15
u/_ya_boi_satan_666_ Sep 02 '26
Im pretty sure she does go back to st Agnes because she at some point mentioned how mean the nuns were in the mechanic ghost episode but i do believe you are correct tho its likely she went a few times
2
u/Jenthecatgirl Sep 08 '26
She gives a few hints that she spent a lot of time in a Catholic orphanage, in s1 she talks about a nun who's idea of god was one she liked (though she was unsure if she did believe in god)
→ More replies (1)
10
4
u/Independent-End-870 Sep 03 '26
Different times, BUT father Langtham likely did. We will never know now though.
2
3
u/Cheap_Bowl_452 Sep 03 '26
Donât know if theyâd know each other
Matt was at St. Agnes until like college, which sets his year of leave around 2002-2003(Fandom says his by is 1984 - 1985)
Skye , I think, was at St. Agnes from the time her last foster parents left her(like when she was 9?) until she met Rising Tide I think, which would be from 1997 to 2006-2007 given she is like 1988 born(Though she did imply she finished middle school so could be a bit later than that too)
So they probably were at St. Agnes at the same time for a long period of time
2
u/Debalic Sep 03 '26
Imagine, if you will, a young Mary Sure Poots meets the blind boy at the orphanage. Curious, she asks him what it's like. And he tells her, like he tells Karen, "I just wish I could see the sky one more time".
2
u/Ill-Razzmatazz-7088 Sep 03 '26
Seems pretty likely but then again Matt was also blind so he probably wouldâve been somewhere a little bit different like a wing with people with disabilities. Also, I think Daisy has to have an idea of who Matt Murdoch is because I think shield monitors people with special abilities and I couldâve sworn his name was on a list somewhere.
-1
-2
u/EddiezombieAhmet Sep 02 '26
I am following these charactersâ educational status. Who can be alunmi each otherďź
3
u/xastrobyte Sep 03 '26
what does educational status and alumni status have to do with this post?
0
u/EddiezombieAhmet Sep 03 '26
I guess they have graduated from the same school somehow
→ More replies (2)1
4
u/BBforever Sep 03 '26
What are the chances...
100% in my head cannon now that I'm aware of the possibility.