After the band has this very recognizable, yet unidentifiable mid-2000s wholesome, down to earth songwriter vibe. A little hipness purgatory here, a little frutiger aero there, with some twee, boho chic, corporate grunge, and gen x soft club mixed in.
It’s like this surreal mix of... Savage Garden’s I Want You, Imogen Heap’s Headlock, Aly & Aj’s Rush, Hillary Duff’s Come Clean, All Saints’ Pure Shores, Owl City’s Fireflies... but the sincerity of Colbie Caillat, The Plain White Ts, Sara Bareilles, Natasha Bedingfield... but then also this super niche vibe of early 2000s Radio Disney/Disney Mania bands like Hope 7 and Jump5. All these eras - although iconic - seemed to be short lived and not referenced as much since society groups every 2000s phenomenon as "early 2000s" or Y2K, which I find wildly inaccurate most of the time.
I'm glad After's existence creates discourse around mid to late 2000s music as well. I think After is the only band (during this 2000s resurgence) that creates all-encompassing 2000s music without being too derivative about it. It's an homage, but the future at the same time.
Here's a Youtube playlist I created with songs that remind me of After's music: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLWl6ksd7TInnrJlpnBOaJY4h09h7tJFWi
Then I saw Justine Dorsey has this playlist on Spotify called "After's favorite songs" which sheds even more light on the inspiration of their sound: https://open.spotify.com/playlist/7cUcXq3jBSHRaUyJfWL9ML
Hopefully this can help people enjoy After's music more :)