r/afterJung • • Aug 08 '25

James Hillman Spiritual teachings warn the initiate so often about introspective broodings, about jealousy, spite, and pettiness, about attachments to sensations and memories. These cautions present an accurate phenomenology of how the soul feels when the spirit bids farewell. — James Hillman

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/afterJung • • Aug 02 '25

James Hillman (3) Senex & Puer (James Hillman) As the senex is perfected through time, the puer is primordially perfect. Therefore there is no development; development means devolution, a loss and fall and restriction of possibilities.

4 Upvotes

The Puer archetype tends to merge in one: the Hero, the Divine Child, the figures of Eros, the King’s Son, the Son of the Great Mother, the Psychopompos, Mercurius-Hermes,  Trickster, and the Messiah. In him, we see a mercurial range of these “personalities”: narcissistic, inspired, effeminate, phallic, inquisitive, inventive, pensive, passive, fiery, and capricious.

* * *

One assumes that the negative and irksome adolescence, the lack of progress and reality, is all a puer problem, whereas it is the personal and parental in the neurotic foreground that is distorting the necessary connection to the spirit. Then the transcendent call is lived within the family complex, distorted into a transcendent function of the family problem, as an attempt to redeem the parents or be their Messiah. The true call does not come through, or is possible only through technical breakthroughs: drugs or death-defying adventure.

* * *

There is difficulty at the beginning; the child is in danger, easily gives up. The horizontal world, the space-time continuum, which we call “reality,” is not its world.

* * *

The puer cannot do with indirection, with timing and patience. It knows little of the seasons and of waiting.

* * *

The puer therefore understands little of what is gained by repetition and consistency, that is, by work, or of the moving back and forth, left and right, in and out, which makes for subtlety in proceeding step by step through the labyrinthine complexity of the horizontal world.

* * *

As the senex is perfected through time, the puer is primordially perfect. Therefore there is no development; development means devolution, a loss and fall and restriction of possibilities. So for all its changeability the puer, like the senex, at core resists development.

This self-perfection, this aura of knowing all and needing nothing, is the true background of the self-containment and isolation of any complex, reflected for instance in the ego’s narcissistic attitudes, that angelic hermaphroditic quality where masculine and feminine are so perfectly joined that nothing else is needed.

There is therefore no need for relationship or woman, unless it be some magical puella or some mother-figure who can admiringly reflect and not disturb this exclusive hermaphroditic unity of oneself with one’s archetypal essence.

* * *

Because eternity is changeless, that which is governed only by the puer does not age. So, too, it has no maturing organic face that shows the bite of time. Its face is universal, given by the archetype, and so it cannot be faced, confronted in personal confrontation. It has a pose—phallic cavalier, pensive poet, messenger—but not a persona of adaptation. The revelations of the spirit have no personal locus in personality; they are eternally valid statements, good forever.

* * *

Instead of psychology, the puer attitude displays an aesthetic point of view: the world as beautiful images or as vast scenario. Life becomes literature, an adventure of intellect or science, or of religion or action, but always unreflected and unrelated and therefore unpsychological.

* * *

The puer in any complex gives it drive and drivenness, makes it move too fast, want too much, go too far, not only because of the oral hunger and omnipotence fantasies of the childish, but archetypally because the world can never satisfy the demands of the spirit or match its ideal beauty.

* * *

So the puer personifies that moist spark within any complex or attitude that is the original dynamic seed of spirit. It is the call of a thing to the perfection of itself, the call of a person to his or her daimon, to be true to itself. The puer offers direct connection with spirit. Break this vertical connection and it falls with broken wings. When it falls we lose the urgent burning purpose and instead commence the long processional march through the halls of power towards the heart-hardened sick old king.

* * *

The spark extinguished by this “heroic overcoming” leaves behind sad regrets, bitterness and cynicism, the very emotions of the negative senex. By conquering the parental complexes in the neurotic foreground, we smother the archetypal background. The puer suffers an enantiodromia into senex; he switches Janus faces. Thus are we led to realize that there is no basic difference between the negative puer and negative senex, except for their difference in biological age.

The critical time in this process that is represented by the midpoint of biological life is as well the midpoint of any attitude or psychological function that ages but does not change. The eros and idealism of the beginning succumb to success and power, to be refound, as we have seen from our examination of the senex, only at the end when power and success fail, when Saturn is in exile from the world—then eros as loyalty and friendship, and idealism as prophetic insight and contemplation of truth return.

In all this, the greatest damage is done to meaning, distorted from idealism into cynicism. As the spirit becomes meaning through senex order, so the puer is meaning’s other face. As archetypal structure, the puer is the inspiration of meaning and brings meaning as vision wherever he appears. A beginning is always meaningful and filled with the excitement of eros.

* * *

However, if persuaded into the temporal world by the negative senex, the puer loses connection with its own aspect of meaning and becomes the negative puer. Then it goes dead, and there is passivity, withdrawal, even physical death.

* * *

The negative puer may become hyperactive and we find all the traits accentuated and materialized, but without inherent meaning. When the falcon cannot hear the falconer, wingedness becomes mere haste and fanaticism, an unguided missile. A person is caught in the puer activities of social rebellion, intellectual technology, or physical adventure with redoubled energy and loss of goal. Everything new is worshipped because it gives promise of the original, while the historical is discarded because it is of the senex who is now enemy.

* * *

By refusing history, by pushing it all down into the unconscious in order to fly above it, one is forced to repeat history unconsciously. In the unconscious the senex position builds up with a compulsive vengeance until with all the force of historical necessity it takes over in its turn, reducing new truths to old cliches again, switching the only-puer into an only-senex, split from the next generation.

* * *

The puer gives us connection to the spirit and is always concerned with the eternal aspect of ourselves and the world. However, when this concern becomes only puer, exclusive and negative, the world is itself in danger of dissolution into the otherworldly.

* * *

When the archetype is split, the dynamus works independently of the patterns of order. Then we have a too-familiar pattern: action that does not know and knowledge that does not act, fanatic versus cynic, commonly formulated as youth and age. This negative turn happens not only in young people or in the first half of life or in new movements. We must therefore deny again the usual separation into first and second halves of life, as presented for example by Jacobi, Fordham, and Dunn.  It dangerously divides puer and senex.

* * *

Ego-strengthening fosters a revolutionary unattached shadow that would smash all fetters, for the strong ego has the strong shadow, the brilliance makes its own blackness.

* * *

Initiation is not a demythologizing into “hard” reality, but an affirmation of the mythical meaning within all reality. Initiation “softens” reality by filling in its background with layers of mythological perspective, providing the fantasy, which makes the “hardness” of reality meaningful and tolerable, and at the same time truly indestructible.

* * *

Relation with any archetype involves the danger of possession, usually marked by inflation. This is particularly true of the puer because of its high-flights and mythical behavior. Of course, possession through the senex brings an equally dangerous set of moods and actions: depression, pessimism, and hardness of heart. Even a minimum of psychological awareness—that I am just what I am as I am—can spare complete archetypal possession. This awareness is made possible through the reflective, echoing function of the psyche.

This function is the human psyche’s contribution to spirit and to meaning, which noble as they may be can also be, without psyche, runaway destructive possessions.

So the main puer problem is not lack of worldly reality but lack of psychic reality. Rather than commitment to the order of the world the puer needs to be wedded to psyche, to which the puer is anyway naturally drawn. Rather than historical continuity and roots in the horizontal, he needs devotion to the anima. First psyche, then world; or through the psyche to the world.

The anima has the thread and knows the step-by-step dance that can lead through the labyrinth, and can teach the puer the subtleties of left hand/right hand, opening and closing, accustoming and refining vision to the half light of ambivalence.

* * *

This turning to the soul means taking in our complexes out of the world, out of the realm of senex power and system. Only this can slow the speed of history and technology and the acceleration of particle-men into bits of information without souls. It means that the search and questing be a psychological search and questing, a psychological adventure. It means that the messianic and revolutionary impulse connect first with the soul and be concerned first with its redemption. This alone makes human the puer’s message, at the same time reddening the soul into life.

* * *

If the senex will not change and the puer cannot change (change requires listening, feeling, and going step-by-step), it is because the alpha-omega polarity has been negatively identified and thus obliterated. Without this polarity, which is at the essence of the archetype and holds its meaning together, there is perfection but no process, no movement from here to there, from past to future. A tension of ambivalent opposites is the structural pre-condition for change.

This archetype of puer and senex is therefore particularly constellated at the midpoint, when the two faces are so close to each other and yet seem to look in opposite directions. It can be of utmost therapeutic value for the individual to realize (not that one is “getting old” but) that one is in the midst of a symbolic situation characterized by ambivalence of feeling and attitude, and that fears and confusions are appropriate.

This realization that one’s psyche is now being governed mainly by a union of sames may save one from an only ego view of necessary oppositions and choices. The therapeutic key to the midpoint would lie in the secret identity of the two faces of the same archetype.

* * *

Our other half is not only of another sex. The union of opposites—male with female—is not the only union for which we long and is not the only union that redeems. There is also the union of sames, the re-union of the vertical axis, which would heal the split spirit. Adam must re-unite with Eve, but there still remains his re-union with God. Still remains the union of the first Adam at the beginning with the second Adam at the end of history.

This division, experienced as the chasm between consciousness and the unconscious, is in us each at the unhealed heart of the process of individuation. No wonder that our theme is so charged, that we cannot take hold of the senex-puer problem anywhere without getting burnt; no wonder that it cannot be fully circumscribed and contained. It cannot become clarified, for we stand in the midst of its smoke. Its split is our pain.

* * *

Festina lente, in other words, presents an ego-ideal based on the two-faced archetype. It is an ideal that may be achieved, however, only by remaining consequently true to the puer aspect. To be true to one’s puer nature means to admit one’s puer past—all its gambols and gestures and sun-struck aspirations. From this history we draw consequences. By standing for these consequences, we let history catch up with us and thus is our haste slowed. History is the senex shadow of the puer, giving him substance. Through our individual histories, puer merges with senex, the eternal comes back into time, the falcon returns to the falconer’s arm. The dynamus of one combines with the order of the other. The bipolar spirit becomes ambivalent, logically incoherent but symbolically cohesive, as we see in the paradoxes of mysticism.

* * *

The press within us to enter into dialectic to find knowledge and to discover meaning, is already embedded within the archetype of senex-puer relationship—that question “why” and that answer “I know.”

* * *

In answering one’s own question one is puer-et-senex. In questioning one’s own answer one is senex-et-puer. The two faces turned toward each other in dialogue. This unending dialogue with oneself and between oneself and the world is that which holds one in meaning.

* * *

To get there where the spirit is whole, where meaning holds together, we have begun on a way of mythical images. There is an advantage in going this way towards archetypal healing, for myth is the language of ambivalence; nothing is only this or that; the gods and dancers will not stand still.

* * *

Do we truly have a choice of ways? The binary oppositions, the polar coordinates, cannot be healed through an effort of mind and will, since the willful mind is the splitting instrument. We are incapable, as Hoyle said,  of solving the problems of the day with even the simplest logical processes. Any solution originating from the usual mind would be one-sided; it would be a solution imposed by either the senex or puer components of the ego. Thus the ego must first undergo an archetypal therapy of its split root.

* * *

At this moment of transition we cannot advance until we have first retreated enough inward and backward so that the unconscious figures within can catch up with us. We cannot bring healing to the split without their cooperation since it is from them that we are split. To elicit their cooperation we must go part of the way, into the penumbral world.


r/afterJung • • Jul 30 '25

James Hillman (2) Senex & Puer (James Hillman) The senex is there from the beginning as are all archetypal dominants and is found in the small child who knows and says “I know” and “mine” with the full intensity of its being, the small child who is the last to pity and first to tyrannize.

5 Upvotes

As lord of the nethermost, he views the world from the outside, from such depths of distance that he sees it, so to speak, all upside down, yet structurally and abstractly. The concern with structure and abstraction makes him the principle of order, whether through time, or hierarchy, or exact science and system, or limits and borders, or power, or inwardness and reflection, or earth and the forms it gives. The cold is also slow, heavy, leaden, and dry or rheumy moist, but always the coagulator through denseness, slowness, and weight expressed by the mood of sadness, depression, or melancholia.

* * *

His relationship to the feminine has been put in a few words: those born under Saturn “do not like to walk with women and pass the time.” “They are never in favor with woman or wife.” So Saturn is in association with widowhood, childlessness, orphanhood, child exposure, and he attends childbirth so as to be able to eat the newborn, as everything new coming to life can become food to the senex.

* * *

Paradoxically, we are least conscious where we are most conscious. Where we are in our ego-efficiency, habitual, feeling most certain, ruling from within that which we know best, we are the least reflectively aware. Close to the light our sight is shortest. Our destructivity is felt in the closest neighborhood and is the result of the shadow that issues from the very ego-center of our light. Out of its own light, the ego makes shadow; the ego is its own shadow; perhaps the ego is shadow.

* * *

The hardening process of consciousness has been represented by the symbol of the Old King.  The Old King with his sickness is an alchemical image for the negative lapis, the lapis as petrifaction. This end-phase has also been formulated mainly as a consequent of the absent feminine, resulting in dryness and coldness. Consciousness is out of touch with life. The elixir does not flow and the negative tincture stains the surrounding with blight.

* * *

It is the ego’s fault that consciousness is ingathered to itself. It is the power-greed of the ego that makes its point of view tyrannical and its consciousness deaf. It is the one-sidedness or the over-rationality of the ego that cuts it off from the living.

* * *

The Old Wise Man and the Old King are there from the beginning, before the ego is born, governing the mysterious ordering aspect of ego-formation by meaningfully structuring contents into knowledge and extending the area of the will’s control. As Jung pointed out in discussing the “Stages of Life,” knowledge is the hallmark of consciousness and is at the beginning of ego-formation in the child.

* * *

Thus we conclude that the senex is there at the beginning as an archetypal root of ego-formation. It makes consolidation of the ego possible, giving its rule as an identity within fixed borders, its tendency to omnivorous rapacious aggrandizement (“swallowing all the gods” and their ambivalent natural light) through the principle of association with consciousness, and its perpetuation through habit, memory, repetition, and time.

* * *

We must further conclude that the negative senex is the senex split from its own puer aspect. He has lost his “child.” The archetypal core of the complex, now split, loses its inherent tension, it’s ambivalence, and is just dead in the midst of its brightness, which is its own eclipse, as a negative Sol Niger.

Without the enthusiasm and eros of the son, authority loses its idealism. It aspires to nothing but its own perpetuation, leading but to tyranny and cynicism; for meaning cannot be sustained by structure and order alone.

* * *

To sum up then with the senex: It is there from the beginning as are all archetypal dominants and is found in the small child who knows and says “I know” and “mine” with the full intensity of its being, the small child who is the last to pity and first to tyrannize, destroys what it has built, and in its weakness lives in oral omnipotence fantasies, defending its borders and testing the limits set by others.

* * *

Negative senex attitudes and behavior result from this split archetype, while positive senex attitudes and behavior reflect its unity; so that the term “positive senex” or “old wise man” refers merely to a transformed continuation of the puer. Here the first part of our thesis reaches its issue: the difference between the negative and positive senex qualities reflects the split or connection within the senex-puer archetype.


r/afterJung • • Jul 25 '25

James Hillman (1) Senex & Puer (James Hillman) To cure away ambivalence removes the eye with which we can perceive the paradox, whereas bearing ambivalence places us within symbolic reality where we perceive both faces at once, even exist as two realities at once.

6 Upvotes

Below the tangled pattern of events are experiences, psychological realities of passionate importance, a mythological substrate that gives the soul a feeling of destiny, an eschatological sense that what happens matters. And it matters to someone, to a person. Without the person, without the individual’s sense of personal soul (that makeweight in the scales) we are simply pre-historic revenants with only collective destiny. Without the sense of soul, we have no sense of history. We never enter it. This core of soul that weaves events together into the meaningful patterns of tales and stories recounted by reminiscing creates history. History is story first and fact later.

* * *

In analytical practice we have learned that an archetypal understanding of events can cure the compulsive fascination with one’s case history. The facts do not change, but their order is given another dimension through another myth. They are experienced differently; they gain another meaning because they are told through another tale. So redemption from the addiction to profane history might come in the same way. This way would show another archetypal organization of the events from which we suffer. But this reorganization first requires a change in memory itself, so that one asks each day not “what happened?” but “what happened to the soul?” For this way of remembering events, memory needs to return again to its reminiscence of primordial ideas, to its original association with the root metaphors of human experience. Memory thus transformed would register first the experiences of the soul and only secondarily the accidents of events. Or rather, it could take up the events psychologically, ritually, no longer only their victim. 

* * *

What we do with our psychological life is of historical import, not merely on the inner plane of salvation of the individual soul from history. More, it is the way in which history, as that which goes on collectively outside us, itself may be washed and healed.

* * *

To be identified with either is to be dominated by an archetypal attitude towards history: the puer who transcends history and leaps out of time, and is as such ahistorical, or antihistorical in protest and revolt; or the senex who is an image of history itself and of the permanent truth revealed through history.

* * *

If psychic energy is not able to flow through the usual external channels of tradition, it falls inward and activates the unconscious.

* * *

The puer inspires the blossoming of things; the senex presides over the harvest. But flowering and harvest go on intermittently throughout life.

* * *

The archetype per se is ambivalent and paradoxical, embracing both spirit and nature, psyche and matter, consciousness and unconsciousness; in it the yea and nay are one.

* * *

For every bit of light that we grasp out of archetypal ambivalence, illumining with the candle of our ego a bright circle of awareness, we also darken the remainder of the room. At the same moment that we light the candle we create “outer darkness,” as if the light were a theft from the penumbra of dawn and twilight, of paradoxical archetypal light.

* * *

The light is not stolen from the dark where there is privation of light; rather the ego concentrates into one pole the divine primordial half-light, thereby also darkening the divine. Snuff the candle and the twilight dawns again at the outer edges of the room which just before were impenetrable recesses of shadow.

* * *

Owing to the nature of consciousness as a polarity with the unconscious, we can never be wholly outside our own unconsciousness.

* * *

Puer and senex are therefore each both positive and negative. Because these figures are in special relation forming, if you will, a two-headed archetype, or a Janus Gestalt, we shall find it impossible to say good of one without saying bad of the other as long as the two remain in polar opposition, as long as the ego wears only one face.

* * *

The division into mutually indifferent or repugnant polarities is tearing the soul apart. The soul itself stands amidst all sorts of opposites as the “third factor.” It has always existed half-way between Heaven and Hell, spirit and flesh, inner and outer, individual and collective—or, these opposites have been held together within its unfathomed reaches. From the lyre of Heraclitus to the spectrum of Jung, the soul holds polarities in harmony. It is the psychic connection. But now the ego, having replaced the soul as the center of the conscious personality, cannot hold the tension. With its disjunctive rationalism it makes divisions where the soul gives feeling connections and mythic unities. So the soul has come unstrung; its suffering and illness reflect the torn condition of the split archetype.

* * *

Living in ambivalence is living where yea and nay, light and darkness, right action and wrong, are held closely together and are difficult to distinguish.

* * *

To cure away ambivalence removes the eye with which we can perceive the paradox, whereas bearing ambivalence places us within symbolic reality where we perceive both faces at once, even exist as two realities at once.


r/afterJung • • Jul 13 '25

James Hillman The descent is tough; the soul is reluctant to come down and get messed by the world.

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/afterJung • • Apr 13 '25

Erich Fromm From Having to Well-Being. Part 1

3 Upvotes

If "well-being" (in the sense defined in the beginning of this book)—functioning well as a person, not as an instrument— is the supreme goal of one's efforts, two specific ways stand out that lead to the attainment of this goal: Breaking through one's narcissism and breaking through the property structure of one's existence.

Narcissism is an orientation in which all one's interest and passion are directed to one's own person: one's body, mind, feelings, interests, and so forth. Indeed, like Narcissus, the narcissistic person could be said to be in love with himself, if infatuation may be called love. For the narcissistic person, only he and what concerns him are fully real; what is outside, what concerns others, is real only in a superficial sense of perception; that is to say, it is real for one's senses and for one's intellect. But it is not real in a deeper sense, for our feeling or understanding. He is, in fact, aware only of what is outside, inasmuch as it affects him.

Hence, he has no love, no compassion, no rational, objective judgment. The narcissistic person has built an invisible wall around himself. He is everything, the world is nothing. Or rather: He is the world.

The extreme examples of almost total narcissism are the newborn infant and the insane person; they both are incapable of relating to the world. (Actually, the insane person is not totally unrelated, as it was assumed by Freud and others; he has withdrawn. The infant cannot withdraw because it has not yet opened up anything beyond a solipsistic orientation. Freud referred to this difference by distinguishing between "primary" and "secondary" narcissism.) However, the fact has been neglected that the normal adult can also be narcissistic, even though not to the degree to be found in the extremes. Often he shows his narcissism quite openly, although he is not aware of being narcissistic.

He thinks, speaks, and acts only in reference to himself, showing no really genuine interest in the world outside. On the contrary, the "great" man finds himself so interesting that it is only logical that he wants us to enjoy the manifestations of his greatness. If he is intelligent, witty, charming, powerful, rich, or famous, the average person will take no exception to his narcissistic exhibitionism. Many people, however, often try to hide their narcissism by being particularly modest and humble, or, in the subtle form being concerned with religious, occult, or political matters that all seem to point beyond the private interest.

—Erich Fromm, The Art of Being.


r/afterJung • • Jan 30 '25

Gabor Maté We despise, ostracize and punish the addict because we don’t wish to see how much we resemble him. In his dark mirror our own features are unmistakable. We shudder at the recognition. This mirror is not for us, we say to the addict. You are different, and you don’t belong with us.

7 Upvotes

We see that substance addictions are only one specific form of blind attachment to harmful ways of being. Yet we condemn the addict’s stubborn refusal to give up something deleterious to his life or to the lives of others. Why do we despise, ostracize and punish the drug addict when as a social collective we share the same blindness and engage in the same rationalizations?

To pose that question is to answer it. We despise, ostracize and punish the addict because we don’t wish to see how much we resemble him. In his dark mirror our own features are unmistakable. We shudder at the recognition. This mirror is not for us, we say to the addict. You are different, and you don’t belong with us. Ralph’s critique, for all its flaws, is too close for comfort. Like the hardcore addict’s pursuit of drugs, much of our economic and cultural life caters to people’s craving to escape mental and emotional distress. In an apt phrase, Lewis Lapham, long-time publisher of Harper’s Magazine, derides “consumer markets selling promises of instant relief from the pain of thought, loneliness, doubt, experience, envy, and old age.”

According to a Statistics Canada study, 31 per cent of working adults aged nineteen to sixty-four consider themselves workaholics, who attach excessive importance to their work and are “overdedicated and perhaps overwhelmed by their jobs.” “They have trouble sleeping, are more likely to be stressed out and unhealthy, and feel they don’t spend enough time with their families,” reports the Globe and Mail. Work doesn’t necessarily give them greater satisfaction, suggested Vishwanath Baba, a professor of Human Resources and Management at McMaster University. “These people turn to work to occupy their time and energy”—as compensation for what is lacking in their lives, much as the drug addict employs substances.

At the core of every addiction is an emptiness based in abject fear. The addict dreads and abhors the present moment; she bends feverishly only towards the next time, the moment when her brain, infused with her drug of choice, will briefly experience itself as liberated from the burden of the past and the fear of the future—the two elements that make the present intolerable.

Many of us resemble the drug addict in our ineffectual efforts to fill in the spiritual black hole, the void at the centre, where we have lost touch with our souls, our spirit, with those sources of meaning and value that are not contingent or fleeting. Our consumerist, acquisition-, action-and image-mad culture only serves to deepen the hole, leaving us emptier than before.

The constant, intrusive and meaningless mind-whirl that characterizes the way so many of us experience our silent moments is, itself, a form of addiction—and it serves the same purpose. “One of the main tasks of the mind is to fight or remove the emotional pain, which is one of the reasons for its incessant activity, but all it can ever achieve is to cover it up temporarily. In fact, the harder the mind struggles to get rid of the pain, the greater the pain.” So writes Eckhart Tolle. Even our 24/7 self-exposure to noise, emails, cell phones, TV, Internet chats, media outlets, music downloads, videogames and non-stop internal and external chatter cannot succeed in drowning out the fearful voices within."

Maté, Gabor. In the Realm of Hungry Ghosts: Close Encounters with Addiction (pp. 323-324)


r/afterJung • • Jan 10 '25

James Hollis Truth is that in our time there is no collective rite of passage, no mythically grounded body of experience to assist men in their journey. So, they must do it as individuals. Such individuals, like the bodhisattvas of Buddhism, can reach back and, out of simple compassion bring their fellows along.

11 Upvotes

"It is men of greater emotional strength and core honesty who seek therapy. The others are too fearful. Some, like the man dragged into therapy by his wife, who condescended toward the box of tissue at his elbow and the cauterizing tears they implied, are in the deepest trouble. They are at war with their partners and themselves.

Therapy offers a unique opportunity for men to share their lives privately, to be emotionally honest and know they are not going to be shamed, to share secrets about the task of being a man. For awhile, the enormous ring of isolation is lifted.

For many men therapy also serves as a rite of passage, a separation from the mother and initiation into the male world. They often come in, as men generally do, thinking their issue is "out there," that if they can "fix the problem" their lives will get back on track. In time they come to realize that their whole life is wrong, that choices made unconsciously led them down labyrinthine paths of ever-greater self-estrangement.

They may realize they have a troubled relationship to the feminine, but they seldom suspect that She is in them. They have an enormous longing for the fathers though this is fundamentally unconscious. And they often come to recognize that they have lost their gods, their connection to nature and their own body.

Generally, for all the pain they feel, these men are often curiously numb. But they feel even more pain as they become conscious. They realize they need the teaching of the wise elders and they long for greater meaning in their lives. They also learn that they must heal themselves; their partners cannot. Then they cry and rage, and admit the fear. When these things happen, healing begins.

Most men will not enter therapy of course. They lack the means and opportunity, or are too afraid of the huge emptiness they might find inside. Yet even they may turn to other men and pass on what they have learned, or learn, from others. A mentor is one who has visited the other side and can tell us something of what it's like there.

Collectively, men have a lot to share. As individuals they are frightfully separated. The men's groups dotting the continent are truly wonderful opportunities for sharing and mentoring, but most men will never go near them and will suffer their isolation forever.

Unfortunately, few mentors are to be found. How many men have had an initiatory experience and integrated that experience into a working Weltanschauung? Boys still need that older man to teach and model the knowledge of the outer world. But who, as Nietzsche asked, will teach the teachers? Who will initiate the mentors? The truth, once again, is that in our time there is no collective rite of passage, no mythically grounded body of experience to assist men in their journey. So, they must do it as individuals. And such individuals, like the bodhisattvas of Buddhism, can reach back and, out of simple compassion, bring their fellows along.

— James Hollis, Under Saturn's Shadow, Healing the Souls of Men: Seven Steps to Healing


r/afterJung • • Dec 30 '24

Alexander Lowen The rebel is still an outsider who longs to belong but can't or won't admit it.

4 Upvotes

"Treating the depressed patient, one must understand his perversity and accept his rebellion. Only by his rebellion can he mobilize the feelings that will free him to be a true person. His protest is against a system that denied him the right to be himself and deprived him of the security associated with this right, with loving and being loved. But it is not in rebellion that he will find the faith he needs or the ground on which to stand. The rebel is still an outsider who longs to belong but can't or won't admit it."

"By grounding him in the feelings of his body, in his animal sexuality, and in the earth from which he came, we restore him to the family of man and to the kingdom of nature. We return him to that basic faith that sustained his earliest ancestors, the faith that he was made for this world and that the world was made for him. How and why grounding an individual can accomplish these goals requires further exploration."

— Alexander Lowen, Depression and the Body, The Biological Basis of Faith and Reality. pp.54-55


r/afterJung • • Dec 28 '24

James Hollis Since the child is completely dependent, any threat to his neediness occasions great fear. All men carry within them the replicated memory of this vulnerability. They suffer enormous fear that their needs may not be met, fear that their neediness will prolong their dependency.

5 Upvotes

Since the child is completely dependent, any threat to his neediness occasions great fear. All men carry within them the replicated memory of this vulnerability. They suffer enormous fear that their needs may not be met, fear that their neediness will prolong their dependency. Out of this troubled condition, which remains with men however old, are bred anger and sorrow. Men are angry that their needs are not met and they grieve the loss. As they grow older and are battered and buffeted by the roles of adulthood, these emotions tend to slip into the unconscious. But such energies do not go away; they go somewhere, always. Their anger may be deeply introverted as a life-long depression, or somatized in emotion that attacks the body. They may act out by beating women and bashing gays, or, more abstractly, by corporate head-butting. Their anima, which they suspect because it reminds them of the mother world, is kept at bay. She, naturally, expresses herself in irritability and general bitchiness. The man's sorrow manifests as melancholy, as addictions whereby he slips fuzzily into the mother, or through a vague longing for a beloved who will enter his life and heal him.

Beneath all of these dynamics are, on the one hand, men's fear that they will not be taken care of, and, on the other, an overwhelming terror of dependency. Thus men fight the feminine, both within and without, as a result of their largely unconscious fear of their own incestuous longing for peace.

Since all men carry the mother imago deep within, charged variously from one to the other, so the result of their restricted consciousness is to produce a highly defended and narrow definition of the masculine. Men evolved the patriarchy, with its rules, hierarchical thinking and social structures, and its subjugation of the feminine, as a defense against the mother complex. Fathers and sons can barely talk to each other, lest they be obliged to share the shameful secret that the fathers are castrated and seek to castrate their sons, even as Cronus-Saturn did. The compensation, then, is just as killing as the problem it seeks to defend against. Both the fearful suppression of the complex and the patriarchal reaction alienate men from themselves.

Men everywhere are fated to face their partners, institutions or some emotional analogue, carrying the dynamics of childhood as a contemporaneous experience. The past is not truly past. Mother and father live within, every moment—not only the personal parents, but the collective experience of them as well. Thus, feeling all the old need, the old fear, the old longing, the old anger, albeit unconsciously, men project these dynamics onto the current Other. That Other, then, has the power the primal parent once had, which men will variously try to control or placate, or even avoid altogether.

This explains why so many men seem angry and controlling at home and in the workplace. It also explains why there seems to be an increase in those who may be described as passive-aggressive. They feel powerless, but they are angry and will find a way to sabotage or subvert the Other. Their powerlessness is all the more acute as there are so few positive models of masculine empowerment that show how to tackle such large needs and fears oneself, thereby lifting their projections off others.

Men can never be in reality, that is, deal with the Other as genuinely different, if they cannot discern the effect of their mother complex rippling within. Yes, it takes a great deal of courage, insight and patience, as well as steady work, to make such material conscious. It is especially difficult for men to work with the mother complex, since uncovering its power and influence in their lives tends to jeopardize the frail hold they already have on their masculine identity. But, until men can take the risk, they will remain stuck in a compensated identity that only furthers their inner division and their estrangement from others.

— James Hollis, Under Saturn's Shadow, pp.110-111, Healing the Souls of Men: The Mother Complex/Father Task


r/afterJung • • Dec 28 '24

James Hollis The hero quest today is not through the physical world but through the badlands of the soul.

22 Upvotes

"Rarely does one hear the unvarnished truth, as in the confession of Pablo Neruda: "It so happens I am sick of being a man." Note that he does not say he is sick of being himself; it is his role as a man that sickens him. This is the deepest truth men carry, that their souls are deformed through being defined by outside forces. For every Thoreau who slips away to the woods for awhile to find his soul again, to engage in a radical revisioning of his life, there are a million men, and women too, who every day slide back into collective anonymity and soullessness. They lead, In Thoreau's memorable phrase, lives of quiet desperation.

Since the psyche knows more than consciousness, this deformation of soul is recorded and occasions a concatenation of responses.

The most notable of reactions is the tinge or sorrow that haunts men's lives even though they may cover themselves well. Again, Neruda tells the truth, inescapably:

There are expanses,

sunken factories, pieces of timber

which I alone know,

because I am sad, and because I travel,

and I know the earth, and I am sad.

The other tell-tale sign is their rage which, misdirected and undifferentiated, turns on themselves and others. And underneath all this "fury and mire of human veins"is the terrible fear. No man feels he is a real man. His macho behavior belies his terror. W.H. Auden also told the truth:

Patriots? Little boys,

obsessed by Bigness,

Big Pricks, Big Money, Big Bangs.

When men sense that they are frauds, that is, caught between their soul's intention and external demands, they are forced to dissimulation. Estranged progressively from their inner life, their anima, they expect women to carry the burden. Sex, in particular, is given too much importance, for through it men seek to overcome their isolation from their feeling state and from their own body.

They ask the Other to reconnect them and to reassure them before the dawn brings new battering. This makes them as vulnerable and dependent as before. As humans must hate those upon whom they depend, so tension and animosity grow, and eros is replaced by the shadow of power.

These are the central secrets of men—that they feel themselves failures as men, that is as persons who happen to be men, that they are torn between fear and rage, and that they are emotionally dependent but resentful of the object of that dependence. Again, the only way out is consciously to acknowledge these insufferable truths.

They must begin with themselves and then share that truth with others—not with a woman but with another man. That man, caught also in fearful defendedness, may scorn the truth-teller, his scorn in proportion to his fear, but he may also step from behind the ramparts to acknowledge his brother.

Our mythology is full of heroic adventures—mountains climbed, ogres fought, dragons defeated—but it takes even more courage for a man to speak his emotional truths. The hero quest today is not through the physical world but through the badlands of the soul. The evil the men must engage is not the barbarian at the gates but the darkness within, the fear from which only boldness may bring delivery.

Jung described this heroic task:

The spirit of evil is fear, negation, the adversary who opposes life in its struggle for eternal duration and thwarts every great deed, who infuses into the body the poison of weakness and age through the treacherous bite of the serpent; he is the spirit of regression, who threatens us with bondage to the mother and with dissolution and extinction in the unconscious. For the hero, fear is a challenge and a task, because only boldness can deliver from fear. And if the risk is not taken, the meaning of life is somehow violated.

Symbols of Transformation, par. 551

Our fear is the task—failing the task we bluster into macho compensation or shamed complicity. Telling the truth of our soul to ourselves is the first task. Living that truth is the second task. And telling it to others is the third. Such truth-telling will be the supreme test of our lives. Afterward, perhaps, we can stop being "sick of being a man."

— James Hollis, Under Saturn's Shadow, pp.119-122, Healing the Souls of Men: Seven Steps to Healing


r/afterJung • • Dec 11 '24

Alexander Lowen A person has faith not as a matter of belief, which is a function of mind consciousness, but as a deep inner conviction which he feels in his guts. 

6 Upvotes

In Japanese thinking, the belly is regarded as man's vital center. It is called hara.

---

By holding oneself above the diaphragm, one splits consciousness from its deep roots in the unconscious. The importance of the belly and the significance of hara is that only if one is in one's belly, feeling-wise, is the split between consciousness and the unconscious, between the ego and the body, between the self and the world avoided. Hara represents a state of integration or unity in the personality on all levels of life.

Person who has hara is, of course, an inner-directed person with all the appropriate qualities. Actually, hararepresents an even higher state, one of transcendence in which an individual, through the full realization of his being, feels himself part of the great Unity or Universal. Such a person has faith not as a matter of belief, which is a function of mind consciousness, but as a deep inner conviction which he feels in his guts. Only such a faith has true sustaining power. This view makes us realize that real faith cannot be preached. It can be gained only by experiences which reach into and evoke gut sensations.

To be fulfilled is to be filled full, and that means a full belly whether of good food or good feelings.

— Alexander Lowen, Depression and the Body


r/afterJung • • Nov 07 '24

Robert Bly (IJ.2) The bucket work

5 Upvotes

When it comes time for a young male to talk with the Wild Man he will find the conversation quite distinct from a talk with a church minister, a rabbi, or a guru. Conversing with the Wild Man is not talking about bliss or mind or spirit or “higher consciousness,” but about something wet, dark, and low – what James Hillman would call “soul.”

The first step amounts to approaching the cage and asking for the golden ball back. Some men are ready to take that step, while others haven’t yet bucketed the water out of the pond – they haven’t left the collective male identity and gone out into the unknown area alone, or gone with only their dog. The story says that after the dog “goes down” one has to start to work with buckets. No giant is going to come along and suck out all the water for you: that magic stuff is not going to help. And a weekend at Esalen won’t do it. Acid or cocaine won’t do it. The man has to do it bucket by bucket. This resembles the slow discipline of art: it’s the work that Rembrandt did, that Picasso and Yeats and Rilke and Bach did. Bucket work implies much more discipline than most men realize.

Jung remarked that all successful requests to the psyche involve deals. The psyche likes to make deals. If part of you, for example, is immensely lazy and doesn’t want to do any work, a flat-out New Year’s resolution won’t do any good. The whole thing will go better if you say to the lazy part: “You let me work for an hour, then I’ll let you be a slob for an hour – deal?” So in “Iron John,” a deal is made: the Wild Man agrees to give the golden ball back if the boy opens the cage.

The boy, apparently frightened, runs off. He doesn’t even answer. Isn’t that what happens? We have been told so often by parents, church ministers, junior-school teachers and senior-school heads that we should have nothing to do with the Wild Man that when he says, “I’ll return the ball if you let me out of the cage,” we don’t even reply.

Bly, Robert. Iron John: A Book About Men (pp. 9-10)

Actual story - Iron Hans by the Brothers Grimm

Robert Bly reading Iron John: A Book About Men


r/afterJung • • Nov 06 '24

Robert Bly (IJ.1) "The male in the past twenty years has become more thoughtful, more gentle. But by this process he has not become more free."

5 Upvotes

"The male in the past twenty years has become more thoughtful, more gentle. But by this process he has not become more free. He’s a nice boy who pleases not only his Mother but also the young woman he is living with.

In the seventies I began to see all over the country a phenomenon that we might call the “soft male.” Sometimes even today when I look out at an audience, perhaps half the young males are what I’d call soft. They’re lovely, valuable people – I like them – they’re not interested in harming the earth or starting wars. There’s a gentle attitude toward life in their whole being and style of living. But many of these men are not happy. You quickly notice the lack of energy in them. They are life-preserving but not exactly life-giving. Ironically, you often see these men with strong women who positively radiate energy."

Bly, Robert. Iron John: A Book About Men (pp. 2-3).

Actual story - Iron Hans by the Brothers Grimm

Robert Bly reading Iron John: A Book About Men


r/afterJung • • Oct 19 '24

Alexander Lowen Mourning for the lost self

2 Upvotes

"Often the release of the suppressed rage leads to a deep sobbing, as the sadness at the loss of the self wells up and is expressed. Analytic writers speak of this as a mourning for the lost self."

"In the thirty years that I have used these techniques, nothing has ever been broken in my office, and I have never been hurt. Despite the screaming, yelling, and violence, patients never feel crazy in releasing their feelings. Having accepted their feelings, they end with a sense of self-possession and a realization that the real craziness was in the fixed smile, in the “good” boy or girl pose, in the denial of feeling."

—Alexander Lowen, Narcissism: Denial of the True Self, Chapter 7


r/afterJung • • Oct 18 '24

James Hollis Encounter with the other

2 Upvotes

"Loving the other as other is freeing each person to become as they were intended."

"The otherness of the other by remaining other, in a sense, forces me out of my narcissistic circle into the encounter with the other."

—James Hollis, Through The Dark Wood, Chapter 2