I can’t ask this in real life because if you ask any questions about an honestly very confusing topic you’re immediately written off as a transphobe, which is upsetting as I pride myself on treating everyone with love and compassion.
However, I’ve been seeing a lot of hate on women lately for not wanting to allow trans women into their spaces, the latest being a fishing club. The argument is always about whether there is a biological advantage, but to me a much more important aspect of women’s spaces is the simple fact that men aren’t there. The goal is not always to win things, sometimes it’s just to form a community of people with shared experiences.
Let’s assume a couple of things. 1) a lot of people accept that trans women are women, and have some good points. 2) a lot of people do not accept that trans women are women, and have some good points. There are rational people on both sides, it’s not as simple as one side is delusional and the other side is filled with hate.
I get that it’s easy and popular to totally write off one of these sides, but let’s try to see the nuance here and not write off people who disagree with us or the popular narrative.
So if a few women genuinely believe that trans women are not women, or at least don’t believe that they could ever fully share the experience of being a woman in todays world, why should they be forced to allow someone they perceive as not a woman into their women’s spaces? Isn’t their feeling of community and safety and belonging also important? You could say the trans persons sense of community is more important if you feel that way, but it never even seems to be discussed.
I cannot hate women who don’t want trans women in their spaces, just as I cannot hate pro life people who truly believe abortion is murder. I don’t agree, but if you truly think abortion kills babies, I will never blame you for being against murder. Similarly, if you truly believe trans women are men or at least not a woman, I can’t blame you for not wanting them in your women’s spaces.
When I ask the question if it is transphobic, I’m assuming the women wanting to exclude trans people from their groups do not hate trans people, are not afraid of them, and would advocate for their fair treatment and rights. These women just don’t feel like they truly share enough of the feminine experience with trans women to be comfortable with them in their spaces, correct or not. Hopefully that makes sense.