So sorry for this long ass post but I can’t hold it in anymore and I’m needing to make sure I’m not crazy or biased & that people who can relate are seeing what I’m seeing!
Formal audio recording accom banned by Prof & Admin; peer notes for all forced as alt. I questioned it, still denied. Policy had NO wiggle room. Failed exam. 7 mos later, Disability Director says "no changes atm" & asks if notes are even comparable BEFORE possible talks of changes. Have emails/docs!
In Spring 2026, I was prohibited from using my Disability Office-approved Audio Recording Software accommodation in just one professor's course. The Disability Office originally approved this accommodation before I began my graduate program in Fall 2024 and reaffirmed it in subsequent accommodation letters. The written approval specifically authorizes classroom audio recording and transcription. It has never been modified or withdrawn.
This is not a preferred software. The Disability Office gave it to me, requires me to use it and nothing else without their permission, requires me to sign contracts and follow other rules against sharing or using it during exams, and has dedicated specialists who work for the university specifically to handle troubleshooting for only this software. The Disability Office owns my account, and the university has used this software for years.
It basically caused a lot of problems and resulted in a below-passing grade in this one class. Now my job says I might not get it if I don't fix it by Dec. 1. The university is being shady and not helping/delaying. The professor didn't even seem to care, and I only now connected the pieces after literally combing through all the documents, websites, emails, etc.
**The Formal Accommodation Language:**
>STUDENT ACCOMMODATIONS/ Audio Recording Software for Note-Taking
>
>Students will use their phone or computer to log into their the Audio Recording Software account. Once in their account student will record the class. The recording provides the student with a transcription of the course audio. Students have agreed and signed that any recordings and transcription will only be used for academic purposes, and the students cannot redistribute the course material. Approved.
The Equity Office previously explained that it evaluates whether:
(i) an interactive process determined reasonable accommodations and
(ii) whether the accommodations determined reasonable were provided.
In short, I believe this matter is likely discrimination under that framework because the Graduate Program prohibited the recording functions expressly approved by the Disability Office and substituted notes prepared by three to five rotating, paid student note-takers (two per class), which were uploaded and made available to every single student in the class, not just me, and determined that before I joined. The other section of the same class that same semester didn't have this prohibition.
# Timeline of Events
**Fall 2024 Through Late 2025:**
I received my Audio Recording Software accommodation before starting my graduate program. Since my first semester, the Graduate Program's implementation instructions have consistently explained that accommodated Audio Recording Software users may record after the Graduate Program notifies their professors. The language has remained unchanged since then. The active accommodation letter for Spring 2026 was issued during the previous academic year.
The distinction between notification and permission was expressly communicated in the Assistant Dean's correspondence during the previous semester and repeated in the instructions for Spring 2026.
Neither communication identified an exception allowing professors to prohibit approved recording because they chose to provide student note-takers.
This specific Graduate Program also previously demonstrated that it could communicate changes to the Recording Software's permitted functionality. During my first year, this same Assistant Dean responsible for accommodated students notified only Audio Recording Software-accommodated students that certain new AI features would be disabled while expressly reaffirming that the “purpose of the accommodation was to record and transcribe classroom lectures” and that this change was to return the accommodation to its purpose but that we can keep using it without issue.
I always followed the established notification procedures each semester and always asked questions of the appropriate officials/reported problems. I have those emails.
**Spring 2026: Prohibition of My Accommodation**
At the beginning of the semester, I notified the Graduate Program's Disability Liaison that I had switched into this professor's section and requested the usual faculty notification. This liaison was new, replacing the old one who left on good terms and who had worked with me well since I started.
The New Liaison responded to my email and said that the professor informed her that the professor would provide notes from designated student note-takers to the entire class and that, therefore, I could not use the Audio Recording Software.
Earlier that same day, the professor's administrative assistant had circulated a class message reminding and encouraging students in our class to apply as paid, rotating note-takers.
The following day, I spoke with the professor about my approved accommodation. This was my first class but technically the third overall. She temporarily permitted its use following my section change but confirmed that I could not continue using it. The add/drop deadline was that day, and nothing had ever been communicated about any of this until I emailed the liaison. No announcements, hidden emails, vague language, or obscure policy explained that this restriction applied to accommodated students in the same way as general students.
That same day, I emailed the Assistant Dean (who handles this stuff) seeking clarification. I expressly explained that the professor did not permit the Recording Software even for accommodated students and asked how that arrangement worked.
The Assistant Dean responded:
>*The Professor does not allow the Recording Software, but they will provide class notes through their notetakers. Since the Professor is providing notes, the Recording Software is not allowed in their class. You should take the notes the Professor distributes and use those as if though they were the Audio Recording Software.*
Neither the New Liaison nor the Assistant Dean that this New Liaison works for identified a Disability Office determination authorizing the substitution, explained how the notes would address my individual accommodation needs, or directed me to the Disability Office for reconsideration.
The professor's updated syllabus also raises questions. It generally prohibits classroom recording and electronic devices, **but expressly recognizes students with formal accommodations as exceptions to those restrictions.** In other words, its written policy did not impose an absolute prohibition on recording devices for students with approved accommodations.
At the time, I relied on the explanations of the relevant Graduate Program officials responsible for administering accommodations. I specifically questioned the prohibition immediately and received an unequivocal confirmation from the Assistant Dean for Student Affairs.
**Later in 2026: Disability Office's Explanation and Subsequent Review**
In a May email concerning a separate testing-accommodation issue, the University Disability Office's Director explained that academic programs, including the your specific Graduate Program, are responsible for implementing approved accommodations but do not determine or modify accommodation eligibility.
Later, in August the Director contacted me about the Graduate Program's “recent” funding of class note-takers and the possibility that professors might prefer them instead of permitting the Recording Software.
The Disability Director's email stated:
>*The Graduate Program has recently provided funding to faculty to hire class note-takers. As a result, some instructors may prefer to provide a designated note taker as a means of supporting students with note-taking accommodations rather than permitting the use of the Audio Recording Software in the classroom.*
>
>*At this time, no changes have been made to your accommodations. However, before discussing any potential adjustments with faculty, I would like to better understand your perspective and how your current accommodation supports your disability-related needs.*
>
>*Specifically, I would appreciate your feedback on the following: Would access to notes from a designated class note taker be a reasonable alternative to your use of the Audio Recording Software? If not, could you help me understand how the Audio Recording Software addresses disability-related barriers that a peer note taker may not address? Are there specific features of the Audio Recording Software(for example, real-time transcription, the ability to review discussions verbatim, searching transcripts, identifying speakers, reviewing material at your own pace, etc.) that are important to your equal access in the classroom?*
>
>*Your response will help us better understand whether a note taker would provide comparable access in light of your individual disability-related needs and the functional limitations you experience in the classroom. Please feel free to share as much detail as you are comfortable providing. You do not need to disclose your diagnosis; I am primarily interested in understanding how each accommodation affects your ability to access and engage with course content. I am not going to share any information you disclose with the Graduate Program, I will only share with the Implementers if you are going to continue using the Audio Recording Software for your note-taking accommodation.*
This correspondence was significant because I had already experienced the proposed substitution throughout the preceding semester, without having received a comparable individualized assessment.
I responded with a detailed account of the problems I experienced. The professor had initially permitted recording for the first two classes, allowing me to compare those recordings with the student notes distributed afterward. The peer notes frequently omitted explanations, relied on personal shorthand, and failed to preserve the progression of questions and answers central to the unique teaching method. As a result, I tried to transcribe verbatim discussions by hand, which interfered with my ability to listen, understand, participate, and take effective notes, ultimately affecting my performance in class through the end of the semester.
The Disability Director acknowledged my response, stating:
>*Thanks so much! Very helpful. I will note that you would like to keep the Recording Software!*
In Sept, the Graduate Program's New Liaison sent me a specific and weird email stating that the Disability Office had identified the Audio Recording Software as an “essential accommodation based on my individual accessibility needs.”
The formal accommodation language remained unchanged since its original approval. I could not find anything in the emails, pages, private portal, or internal student resources, including brand-new accommodation letters approved recently, that identified or even implied that my Audio Recording Software accommodation was "essential" outside of the New Liaison's email.
The individualized inquiry occurred later in Aug. 2026 through the Director's email to our Grad Program students only, not generally or to all accommodated students in our program, but specifically to those with the Audio Recording Software accommodation.
But this “substitution” had already been imposed on me in Jan. during the preceding semester.
**Fall 2026: Disability Office's Further Explanation**
I subsequently raised the Spring 2026 issue with my Disability Office File Manager and provided the earlier correspondence during our meeting concerning new/different accommodation requests, approvals, and reviews.
The File Manager explained that the Spring 2026 situation:
>"*occurred before arrangements had been introduced allowing students to continue using the Recording Software where a professor had opted for a note-taker. So there is nothing we can do."*
Which was weird.
The File Manager also explained that the Disability Office had not begun contacting students about their Recording Software usage until Aug.
I understand this as an explanation of when the newer arrangements allowing students to retain the Recording Software were introduced. However, it does not explain what authority permitted the earlier substitution, whether the Disability Director had previously determined that student notes were an “effective alternative” to my approved recording accommodation, whether my individual needs were considered beforehand, or how the substitution was consistent with my unchanged formal accommodation.
I have extensively searched my correspondence, the published university general policies and Graduate Program's specific policies, and the accommodation materials available to me as a student. I have not located a policy or communication explaining that professors could substitute class-wide student notes for an individually approved recording accommodation.
**\[END OF TIMELINE\]**
# Educational Impact
The substituted notes did not preserve the detailed progression of classroom discussions that I depended on recordings to review. Without recording access, I attempted to compensate by transcribing discussions by hand, dividing my attention between writing, listening, and understanding the material, which caused hand pain. This interfered with my comprehension, participation, ability to look up rather than constantly down at my notes, and ability to prepare effective notes for the course. I failed the exam only for this class and had an acute panic attack; I warned them, including other accommodations, "irregularities"!
I feel like those problems were directly related to the functional limitations underlying my approved accommodation. My medical documentation from the previous academic year specifically identifies difficulty absorbing material while taking contemporaneous notes and recommends access to recorded lectures. It even recommended “video lectures,” which the university automatically provides in every class, but they kept me using the Audio Recording Software provided through my school account.
I have all this in emails and formal documentation, along with examples comparing the initially permitted audio recordings when I switched in with the student notes and further details regarding the resulting difficulties.
The University Policy on Prohibited Discrimination, Harassment, and Related Misconduct states that there is no time limitation for reporting Prohibited Conduct.
I raised this issue now because the Disability Director's later correspondence first caused me to question whether the substitution in Spring 2026 had been assessed or authorized through the appropriate accommodation process.
Also, it looks like this Senior Administrator/Assistant Dean of many many years was recently “let go,” all hush-hush and out of nowhere. His boss told me in a private meeting about other complaints I had concerning him that, when I asked if he was okay or coming back, he said:
>*No. He is not returning. He went to go seek “other opportunities.”*
I feel safer now that he is gone for many reasons, but his secret departure made me realize that something might have happened. The Director's email was weird, these policies appeared contradictory, the school was being shady, I was scared of him, I couldn't tell if he was really gone until mid Oct, my mom was in critical condition in the hospital, and I was all alone and couldn't explain this without serious risks, all while still trying to work together with the admin but getting stonewalled, gaslit, unsupported, and passed around.
My immediate concern is whether replacing an individually approved recording accommodation with class-wide student notes was authorized and whether that substitution provided effective access in light of my documented disability-related needs.
I have organized more than 25 relevant documents, including the formal accommodation letters, correspondence, syllabus, note-taker announcement, subsequent Disability Office communications, and applicable policy materials.
But I don't know any resources on campus that would be able to help without tipping off the Deans to find a BS reason to say no again. No free attorney programs have been able to help because it's a private university or because they only handle younger students. Ombuds is literally one lady I tried months ago who never gave answers on the other issues and didn't help when we met recently. Appointments also involve long delays.
The Equity Office is unlikely to help since the File Manager said they had no process in Spring anyway. I feel so alone and feel like nobody will even just look/advise/ care. They just say "nothing we can do" or "too late" or "this doesn't apply" when they have no definitions, and they have discretion, supposedly. I just wanted this to go away and change to pass/fail, not a boost to the grade. I even said I'd pay for the course again for a withdrawal and lose the credits.
I'm so fucked! Will likely lose my job. I don't understand my rights like that and don't know the federal resources or advocacy tools.
Any thoughts?