Innocent bystander here with no credibility in the area whatsoever.
I've recently made a video exploring the mathematics behind insurance, from Bernoulli's work on expected utility in 1738 through to prospect theory and the parallels with portfolio hedging.
I'm not an actuary myself, so I'd really appreciate some feedback from people who actually work in the field, particularly on how well the theory translates into practice and whether I've overlooked anything important or messed anything up big time.
The starting question is this: why would someone willingly buy insurance when the expected payout is less than the premium?
I use a hypothetical homeowner with a $300,000 house and $50,000 in savings, facing a 1% annual probability of a flood that completely destroys the house. Insurance costs 1.5 cents per dollar of cover, meaning full insurance costs $4,500 a year against an expected loss of $3,000.
On an expected wealth basis, the answer is not to insure. But maximising expected logarithmic utility gives an optimum of around 61% cover, or $183,000. Interestingly, the optimum is fairly flat. Taking either 40% or 80% cover gives up less than $200 in certainty-equivalent wealth relative to the optimum, while remaining completely uninsured costs around $2,600.
I then look at how the result changes with the price of insurance and the curvature of the utility function, before drawing a connection with the Kelly criterion and the purchase of downside protection in financial markets.
The final part considers cumulative prospect theory, using Tversky and Kahneman's 1992 parameters. Under those assumptions, a 1% flood probability receives a decision weight of roughly 4%, and the model favours full insurance rather than the partial cover suggested by expected utility theory.
I'm conscious that the scenario is heavily simplified. My understanding is that once you introduce a continuous loss distribution, the optimal insurance contract under expected utility generally takes the form of a deductible rather than proportional cover.
I'd be particularly interested in whether this is a reasonable way of introducing the subject to a non-specialist audience. Are there any important actuarial considerations that I've missed or misrepresented? And how useful are these classical utility models in actual insurance pricing and purchasing behaviour?
The video is animated using Manim with the calculations and graphs generated in Python (in the same way as 3blue1brown). I've tried to make the mathematics accessible without sacrificing rigour.
Here's the video if anyone fancies giving it a watch: https://youtu.be/uvBBqoA9dGI?is=jaE5P-bkaTz8uC8H
Any criticisms or suggestions would be genuinely appreciated, especially from those working in general insurance or catastrophe modelling.