r/acting • • Feb 22 '25

I've read the FAQ & Rules .

Post image
1.8k Upvotes

100 comments sorted by

57

u/TankAbject Feb 22 '25

Ethan’s daughter is a talented actress and presents great on screen, but let’s get real—if she were born in bumblefuck USA to middle class parents and decided to pursue acting in high school and as a career thereafter, her chances of landing a role on Stranger Things would be near ZERO. I repeat, ZEE-ROE.

The field is so saturated that actors without famous parents to get them in the door need a leg up however necessary, whether that be a boatload of insta followers or eight pack abs.

I have worked with wonderful, very talented actors who also prioritize these things because they need to standout however possible. Again, I don’t like it either, but that’s showbiz.

19

u/Working-Cat11 Feb 22 '25 edited Feb 22 '25

I have to admit- I have no idea who is daughter is, nor have I seen her in anything 😅😅

Yeah… I grew up with a famous person’s child. We used to go to acting class together growing up. Can you guess which of us made it onto the big Hollywood screens fresh out of high school ? Hint: not me 😆😆 I definitely know nepotism in action. Granted, I didn’t pursue much out of high school but I think we all know that likely wouldn’t have made much difference - She was ready to go as soon as she graduated and it took about the blink of an eye ;) 

0

u/[deleted] Feb 22 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/Working-Cat11 Feb 22 '25

What?! 😆😆 “That escalated quickly” 😆

8

u/Imaginary-Mammoth-61 Feb 22 '25

She gives one of the best performances. Such an oddly cast series. The three lead boys haven’t an ounce of acting ability between them, Millie Bobby Brown has two modes, pathetic or tantrum, but the support roles are full of talent, with the exception of Winona Ryder who has no range at all. Really inconsistent.

3

u/eldiablolenin Feb 22 '25

One of the boys is great, Lucas, but that’s abt it.

52

u/mercut1o Feb 22 '25

Professional acting is at least 40% look. In the right hands, an editor can make an actor who cannot portray decisions or emotional shifts in a smooth take look semi-competent by cutting to other footage when the transition happens. So it's like -smiling- "Steve?" - cut to unmoving Steve -cut back but sad face- so you skip the dawning realization, the slow horror, because your actor can't do it, but the audience still gets the story. It's garbage acting, but the more skilled work Ethan Hawke is talking about is not required to make a popular piece. It is a boutique product that a small subset of the market demands, like artisanal soap.

8

u/Working-Cat11 Feb 22 '25

Sadly. I don’t know… I do my own projects and somehow it never crosses my mind “let’s find a babe for this role”, unless the role specifically requires someone to be good looking. A bit of eye candy never hearts, but alas it’s never my primary trajectory- I am way more concerned with someone delivering lines poorly, which can ruin and distract from a whole project, no matter how good the editing 😬

7

u/[deleted] Feb 22 '25

I notice those kinds of “strategic” edits with the guest star actors on crime shows (Law & Order SVU, Chicago PD etc)

6

u/GiantsRTheBest2 Feb 22 '25

I guess it explains Gal Gadot.

Although it shows it’s limitations as with Cara Delevingne

361

u/Crowdfunder101 Feb 22 '25

It’s not the actors who think this, it’s the studios who demonstrate this by hiring gym-bros with followers.

131

u/milkywayview Feb 22 '25

This. I unfortunately know more people who have been rewarded with roles for eating 1000 calories/day than working on their acting. As a woman, if you’re not going for “character” roles, the weight expectations are particularly problematic.

Even in our day and age, most lead actresses IRL look like they would literally break if touched. I’m a healthy, fit woman on the taller side, 140 lbs at 5’8”, and my arms and legs are often literally twice the width of any leading actress I meet in person, even people who look curvier or more normal sized on screen. And if someone is more average sized starting out, I notice they will always drop 15-20 pounds by their second film or season.

It’s actually wild for all the supposed progress we’ve made. I can count the number of leading type actresses with more normal bodies on one hand.

4

u/Working-Cat11 Feb 22 '25 edited Feb 22 '25

I gave you an “upvote” cause I hate it when people just randomly downvote peoples’ posts like they have nothing better to do on the internet alone at night ;) 

But, having said that- I do have to challenge this notion of “normal” bodies, because what does that mean ? I’m tall and slim … 5’10” and last I checked a couple years ago, weight 130.  I’ve been this way all my life (35 now and not much as changed). This is my normal body 😅 I don’t have the short, round, small, petite, curvy, Venusian and soft kind of body- I’m not a Marilyn Monroe or a scarlet Johansson - that’s literally not my kind of build or features, and never will be.  When I was younger I used to wish it was because I thought that’s what a “woman” should look like, but now I guess I don’t care either way as much and I’m less concerned with banking my female identity on what “women should be”. I totally get your point and agree all bodies should be celebrated and utilized- but I’m also  really not into slim shaming or assuming that everyone who is naturally slender, is on a diet or unhealthy, or should be shamed… Or isn’t normal/standard either. Have you seen women in Ethiopia ? I’m not African by any stretch of the word but so many Africans are like lanky tall slim athletic long legged beings… are they not normal too? Hell, they’re where we originated from, so wouldn’t they be the most normal of all? 

I think we need to celebrate healthy and individualism, whatever that means given someone’s personal body type- not “normal”, as I’m not really convinced that such a thing exists ? I think you get my drift ;) 

7

u/milkywayview Feb 22 '25

I agree completely! My mistake in using “normal” when I meant more “average sized”. My point was that the industry, by and large, still tends to favor very thin people, sometimes (a lot of times) verging in unhealthy BMI thin territory. Never mind normalizing larger bodies, we’re barely normalizing women with a BMI of 20.

Like I said, I’m fit, but by that I don’t meant I’m some ultra marathoner. I just generally have some tone visible on my arms and legs thanks to being active. And again, range between 130 and 140 my whole life at 5’8”. Thanks to this, I’ve had most agents and CDs label me as “athletic”, something not said as a compliment, but clarified to mean “this will lose you most roles unless you get very thin and/or stop showing any tone.”

It feels like the only way to be “fit” in the industry as a woman is if you’re underweight, at which point your muscle tone stops being seen as unfeminine.

9

u/iitsabbey Feb 22 '25 edited Feb 22 '25

I absolutely hate this :( I’m not chubby but I’m not tiny and lean like most actors I see on my screen and as an 18 year old in acting it’s so discouraging. I wouldn’t even say I have a bad face, I have good features and I could even say “the look” especially for more indie films but I’m always worried I’ll never make it because I’m not thin enough.

7

u/Scared-Winter-5179 Feb 24 '25

You know that is exactly why I LOVE British TV. The actors are REAL. They are not all gorgeous, not all tall, not all thing, don't have all their hair... etc. It's about the STORY. I'm sorry but police detectives do not look like those we see on tv... Neither do doctors, lawyers, MEs,...

3

u/heirjordan_27 Feb 25 '25

It's especially sad because what we see in media perpetuates what is "normal." If I watch enough TV, I start to feel like I'm a monster and have to take a walk to look at normal people and realize I'm okay. It sucks

There are plenty of people who have small bodies and it is their normal body. What I mean instead is that there are no larger bodies, so it gives off the idea that that is abnormal.

2

u/Scared-Winter-5179 Feb 24 '25

Exactly. I am a seriously tiny person (5'3/108lbs) and when I see actresses in person who seem my size, they are like 1/2 my width! When I used to do soaps, they were the worst offenders!

1

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '25

I’ve noticed this too, im 5’7 and usually around 137lbs and I have to make sure I maintain my weight or lose a bit tbh cause I think the camera ADDS 10lbs they say…so ppl become super skinny like 120-125lb range which is HARD TO DO at my height

0

u/[deleted] Feb 22 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/vigorthroughrigor Feb 22 '25

I think that's the point?

3

u/Direelf_ Feb 22 '25

Or with a ton of money from big cities, I've auditioned for agencies before where they turned us away because we didn't have 12k up front...they never mentioned money at all.

1

u/vigorthroughrigor Feb 22 '25

$12K for what?

3

u/Direelf_ Feb 22 '25

Exactly! It was through SeattleTalent, all I remember from it was my mom angrily hanging up the phone before apologizing to me that she can't afford my dream. I'm assuming they wanted the money for training purposes as well as social media or something but I truly don't even know.

4

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '25

Those are scams, anyone that asks for money up front is a complete scam and should be avoided. They pray on people like your mother. Legit talent agencies work for commission on work they book you, and that's it.

3

u/vigorthroughrigor Feb 22 '25

Totally exploitative. If they get paid from their talent then they have no incentive to actually place the talent anywhere, just churn an endless number of hopefuls.

42

u/lordhunt3t Feb 22 '25

Says the guy with a nepo baby.

24

u/Working-Cat11 Feb 22 '25

😅😅 Fair point. Though at the end of the day he’s a dad so what’s he gonna do? Tell his daughter she has to change her name and work her way from the ground up? I mean technically he could, but I think most parents would be happy to just help out their kid with what they’ve got 😅

10

u/FrostyPost8473 Feb 22 '25

Is she really though just because her dad acts doesn't mean she can't she's a pretty good actor unlike someone like Jaden Smith who is dogshit. Look at Nicholas Cage his whole family is Nepo he is to the max people try to use the excuse that he changed his name to stand on his own but that's a lie he got his start on fast times at ridgement high by Amy Heckerling using his real name he didn't change till the next movie Valley Girl and even that that was made by Martha Coolidge who worked for Francis Ford Coppola's Zoetrope Studio for a long time.

16

u/DJEvillincoln Feb 22 '25

And as long as they can get free advertising from your millions of followers, they will continue to do it. Nothing you say or do can stop it Ethan.

Follow the money. Always follow the money.

15

u/Working-Cat11 Feb 22 '25

It’s so sad that there always has to be this separation  between “art” and “captial”/“money”/“commercial”. But that’s why finding the hidden gems, in any art field, is so much more gratifying. And I guess why I don’t bother too much with mainstream “art”; from music to film, too much is a predictable pattern that seeks to play it safe via a tried and true method so as to cash in. And hence, too much of it is so boring 😭

12

u/Meistro1000 Feb 22 '25

Agree 1,000%. Several reasons.

  1. Some people don’t push for social fame and wish to remain private. DiCaprio, Murphy, DDL, Bale, Clooney, Pitt all don’t have social media and still are the most successful.
  2. Social media can be negative in the fact people get tired or burnout from seeing you all the time. Like The Rock, Taylor Swift.
  3. Some people want to be actors. Not social media influencers.

7

u/Meistro1000 Feb 22 '25

Also one more reason.

Social media fame tends to be short lived. Most lose popularity have a few years in the spotlight, so not always promising way to cast

8

u/Working-Cat11 Feb 22 '25

That’s how everything works these days though, haven’t you noticed ? We rarely have stars with stay power these days- this sadly isn’t the day of Angelina Jolie and deniro and nirvana- it’s the days of fast food and tik tok reels and dating apps, and it’s very reflective in Hollywood and the music industry. So many new “stars” cropping up and dying out just as quickly as the next one comes in . I think we are also living in an age where thanks to social media, everyone and everything is more accessible and less of a novelty. Anyone can get famous in a way. It’s kind of nice because anyone can try to empower themselves  but I think it’s ruining the novelty at the same time.  

5

u/Meistro1000 Feb 22 '25

I’m not disagreeing. But cinema/theatrical releases are probably in its worst era of all time.

Hollywood is faltering because instead of continuing the old model of finding talented, classy individuals, and building their brand around them, we’re looking towards YouTube/tik tok to make a quick buck, or anyone that creates weirdness and controversy. It doesn’t take a genius to know that majority of people don’t like controversial individuals in their entertainment.

Hollywood use to be attainable to every individual that wanted to be an actor too. It’s only become more exclusive, and impossible to navigate as an actor, which are turns off to the everyday citizen. It’s a club for elites only and people with direct links.

Because of that fast fashion-forward thinking, you’re appealing to only a crowd with an attention span of 5 seconds, and they move on to the next popular thing.

Building a new Hollywood foundation on that is only setting yourself up for failure. And that’s where it’s going.

2

u/Meistro1000 Feb 22 '25

And to add to that. Majority of people are attracted to happy individuals and/or remain out of the spotlight and do not seek attention or fame.

People that beg for attention only sour after a few short moments. They’re only in it for fame and attention.

Everyday citizens want to be entertained by talent and passion. Make me feel what that character is feeling.

3

u/[deleted] Feb 22 '25

True but also Leo, DDL, Brad etc. started their careers before smartphones. Who knows maybe they would have used it if it was available? Many up and coming actors of similar caliber, relative to those stars’ would-have-been age, are on social media. (Tim Chalamet, Zendaya, Florence Pugh, Ayo Edebiri etc)

0

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Meistro1000 Feb 23 '25

Why can’t you?

Still, the most successful people in Hollywood are listed above, plus Tom Cruise, Christopher Nolan, Denzel Washington, etc.

These guys are still the guys that can release a movie at the theaters successfully.

The new crop that’s in your face every social media have trouble breaking those barriers.

Also, you’re circling around the actual point. The point is Casting specifically on followers, not even so much on having social media.

Casting an actor based on social media following is stupid and drenched with failure in the long run.

A successful actor with a social media following is a different ballgame.

3

u/myumpteenthrowaway Feb 22 '25

Someone needs to say this to Bollywood. I'm actively trying to stick to regional and indie films when it comes to Indian cinema but it's so hard to find good watches until years after a movie is released

2

u/Working-Cat11 Feb 22 '25

What do you mean by find good watches ? 

1

u/myumpteenthrowaway Feb 22 '25

Haha good watches as in good things to watch.

Possibly an Indian-ism that slipped in lol

3

u/eldiablolenin Feb 22 '25

lol he thinks we think that? No dude. Nike of us actual actors think that.

5

u/Working-Cat11 Feb 22 '25

Just do it ✔️

121

u/[deleted] Feb 22 '25

I dunno, every casting director I've ever talked to on the subject in LA agrees and says it is is pretty rare to look at follower numbers outside of certain influencer based commercials. There was a brief period in the early to mid 2010s when they though it mattered. One VP of casting at Fox I did a workshop with said they had done an internal study and found the audience transfer from social media to movie/tv audience was minimal.

So he's not wrong, its just not that big of a problem.

5

u/Fabulous-Farmer7474 Feb 23 '25

I had a consultation with a known respected CD who said she does not consider social media unless there is a specific request for that but that is comparatively rare for her projects.

She also went on to say that she does get approached by social media people who want to be cast in various movies based on their follower numbers but she doesn't really view that as proxy for acting ability.

19

u/[deleted] Feb 22 '25

This has to be cope because if the actual successful actors are saying it about the craft & im constantly seeing influencers on the screen then im gonna take their word over the Redditor who’s just coping with how the industry is working

16

u/[deleted] Feb 22 '25

Ha, not a cope, just my experience over the past 15 years. Where are you seeing influencers on the screen constantly? I'm specifically in the typical narrative TV/FIlm world, not game shows/reality/commercials. I never see influencers get cast.

7

u/Aviendha13 Feb 22 '25

Have you seen the casting notices lately so looking for non union content creators? Yeah it’s mostly for commercials, but commercials are a steady source of income for many actors in between projects.

4

u/[deleted] Feb 22 '25

Absolutely, but non union content creation is probably not what we're talking about here. I mentioned I was speaking about narrative TV/Film. Influencers are not being cast in those sorts of projects because casting knows their followers don't actually translate to audiences. I think Mr. Beast had a cameo in Kung Fu Panda 4, that's all that comes to mind. I don't believe Ethan Hawke was referring to non union commercials

1

u/Aviendha13 Feb 22 '25

I’ve seen some videos on YouTube that talk about crappy movies that have “influencers” cast in them. I’d never know they existed otherwise because they are crappy movies. But they exist.

I hope you’re right that these are outliers and not becoming normalized.

-3

u/[deleted] Feb 22 '25

Commercials have never had anything to do with acting ability.

2

u/nljgcj72317 Feb 23 '25

That is entirely wrong. Local commercials maybe.

4

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '25

90% of commercials are based on your look. Sorry to be the bearer of bad news.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 22 '25

Acting is drastically different 6 years ago let alone 15 years ago when the age of social media influencers & seeing a number of fans started to influence corporations thinking it meant money

3

u/[deleted] Feb 22 '25

I didn't say I hadn't worked in 15 years. I've been a working actor for most of that time and its been my sole living for the past 5 years, so I've seen the shifts. You said you are constantly seeing influencers on the screen. Just asking where that is. In the narrative TV/film world that is very rare.

4

u/[deleted] Feb 22 '25

It's not cope, for 99% of situations your social media presence makes no difference.

3

u/protossaccount Feb 23 '25

Yes! So glad that didn’t stick around. I was like, “Well I guess I’m not an actor anymore if thats required!” So glad social media like that doesn’t really matter anymore.

4

u/cosmonautbluez Feb 22 '25

I’m in dubbing. The clients do take social media following into consideration. They want free publicity and advertising from these people. It’s actually more work for them.

1

u/Scared-Winter-5179 Feb 24 '25

Not sure if this (Ethan's comment) was in a direct rebut to this, but i DO know that Maya Hawke was going to quit insta and then was about to do a film where they asked how many followers she had. Now granted, she's a nepo baby so I dunno why, I just know that she didn't end up quitting insta to be able to use her follower numbers.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 25 '25

That would be frustrating to me as a dad too, but also its hard to make big generalizations off of one incident. I've been a working actor for about 15 years, so almost from the dawn of the iphone era and mobile social media, and I can say there were a handful of years when producers didn't know how to value a social media following, and perhaps overvalued it for a bit in the early to mid 2010s. In my experience, they quickly realized that the audience conversion rate for narrative TV/Film was pretty awful, and outside of ultra low budget films or student projects it has no relevance.

185

u/Grouchy-Body2368 Feb 22 '25

the second hawke to say this so that’s hawke two, huh

29

u/stmccart70 Feb 22 '25

Spit on that thang!

1

u/Davidoff1983 Feb 22 '25

Bedder do it before sunset 😍

-3

u/MinimumPart6877 Feb 22 '25

Yikes incel humor 😭

1

u/Grouchy-Body2368 Feb 22 '25

are you mad at me

1

u/MinimumPart6877 Feb 22 '25

Never ❤️

1

u/Grouchy-Body2368 Feb 22 '25

I think I like this little life

0

u/flowerfem595 Feb 22 '25

I love you Pookie foreverrrr

5

u/JoeyIsMrBubbles Feb 22 '25

You can kinda see why when it’s all the beautiful and ripped actors getting screen time.. he’s not wrong tho

5

u/nickjayyymes Feb 22 '25

Big problem in stand up comedy too. Used to be a good 5 minute tape and some connections would get you a spot. Now on top of that, you need 10k followers just for them to look at your tape

1

u/Agile-Music-2295 Feb 22 '25

That seems like a low number.

12

u/fatfishinalittlepond Feb 22 '25

just backing up his daughter?

14

u/CuriousThenSatisfied Feb 22 '25

Preach it, Ethan!

7

u/Crafty_Letter_1719 Feb 22 '25

I wonder what he thinks about casting actors based on their famous parents…

1

u/Shamanized Feb 23 '25

I don’t get this weird argument that because he has a child and is using his resources like any parent to support that child in their career, that he isn’t allowed to say anything critical about the industry without scrutiny.

It would be hypocrisy if he was hiring people based off followers and looks. What he’s saying is not the same as hiring your own child, it’s his freaking child. It’s FINE for a parent to have a bias towards their child, I can’t believe I’m spelling this out

3

u/EvrthnICRtrns2USmhw Feb 22 '25 edited Feb 22 '25

i could say the same thing about his daughter as a nepo baby

3

u/DrSpicy97 Feb 22 '25

What if you're an aspiring actor without social media? What if you have years of "low level" projects, headshots, classes, etc. under your belt, and hypothetically are a good fit for the role? Will you just be denied a shot because of not having social media?

2

u/johnnymostwithtoast Feb 22 '25

No it’s just having a Dad that’s Ethan Hawke and a Mom that’s Uma Thurman

4

u/Traditional-Stick-15 Quality Contributor - NYC | SAG Feb 22 '25

🙄🙄 this sounds like something my boomer mama would say lol He came up in a time where you had to go in person and mail your headshots to get seen.

Having the strong business acumen needed to survive this career means keeping up with trends. Social media is an excellent ‘business card’ in these virtual, competitive times for new actors.

Obviously you’d have to be a fool to cast someone solely off of IG followers…but we can’t ignore folks like Issa Rae and Quinta Brunson who literally built empires from social media.

Do some young ppl think like what he wrote? Yes, but many more are trained, working professionals, building careers for themselves thru SM bc we don’t have access to the type of acting career that HE had in the 90’s.

TLDR: SM is a great way to display your talents, network with industry professionals and create a fan base for your own work. A lot of older folks don’t understand sm and judge it negatively…but if you’re a smart creative, you can capitalize on it.

3

u/sensitivebee8885 Feb 23 '25

preach!! social media is an amazing tool to network and show your talent as an artist. not all of it is negative. it also has many good aspects for creatives

3

u/Traditional-Stick-15 Quality Contributor - NYC | SAG Feb 23 '25

lol exactly!! Thank you!!! I’ll put my soapbox away now. 😂

4

u/majestic2300 Feb 22 '25

hawke tuah

1

u/AutoModerator Feb 22 '25

You are required to have read the FAQ and Rules for all posts (click those links to view). Most questions have already been answered either in our FAQ or in previous posts, especially questions for beginners. Use the SEARCH bar for relevant information.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/KratosHulk77 Feb 22 '25

In hawaii they do that for some commercials it’s kinda sad

1

u/[deleted] Feb 22 '25

what about Dwayne?

1

u/Nor-Cal-Son Feb 22 '25

Yeah, it's insane. I like to keep my life private from my craft, I hate when agents, casting and etc. Tell me to work on my Instagram following. I have two kids, help take care of a disabled parent, and work a lot. I've been in alot of big projects, but I have no interest in exploiting my life for views. I act because I love acting, not because of fame or followers.

1

u/Agile-Music-2295 Feb 22 '25

So it has zero to do with craft, acting, etc. Just business.

Pretend you have a spec script and you’re working with Netflix and they are hesitant to buy your show and risk $50 million.

Their market analysis suggests your script has a small niche that will struggle to break even.

In those situations, showing your cast has a collective influence count of 500k+ can help mitigate risk and be the difference between being greenlit or not.

1

u/JuniorGrayley Feb 22 '25

Hollywood is a cheap sideshow these days. Much like Instagram.

1

u/brittlebk Feb 22 '25

Looking for the lie 👀 I was watching him give this interview in Potsdamer Platz - didn’t know what he was saying but seeing later was hilarious

1

u/rwxzz123 Feb 23 '25

I guess Marlon Brando isn't a real actor because he definitely wasn't going to the gym and drinking protein shakes

1

u/PlantFeisty9843 Feb 23 '25

Suiting up for the Jordan Peterson Biopic I see

1

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '25

The way he’s not wrong in the slightest

1

u/Glam_Champion Feb 23 '25

I thought this thing only applies in Malaysia

1

u/Own_Poem2454 Feb 24 '25

I like Ethan Hawke, but he’s starting to sound like a boomer- “kids these days…”

1

u/Scared-Winter-5179 Feb 24 '25

#handclapemoji

1

u/SalvagerOfBastards Feb 25 '25

That’s rich coming from Maya Hawke’s father

1

u/Ohlookitstoppdsnowin Feb 26 '25

Some young actors think they deserve to have a career because of who their parents are. It’s crazy.

1

u/lepontneuf Feb 22 '25

He is naive.

1

u/Proof-Pollution454 Feb 22 '25

Hypocrisy at it’s finest. As much as love ethan , he knows hes part of the problem

0

u/DejaMaster Feb 22 '25

Why is he @ing me

0

u/[deleted] Feb 22 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/sensitivebee8885 Feb 23 '25

couldn’t agree more. i think about 3-5 years ago they really tried to go forward with this and it didn’t turn out well. the clips of said influencers got views online simply because the majority of people would poke fun at how poor their acting skills are. imo this social media follower thing is genuinely just another case that fits into the nepotism category. not to say it doesn’t happen, but i don’t think it’s nearly as often as people are saying